Google+

BBC Future

Medical Myths

Does CPR usually bring people around?

About the author

Claudia is a writer, broadcaster and lecturer in psychology. She presents Health Check on BBC World Service every Wednesday and her new book is titled Time Warped: Unlocking the Mysteries of Time Perception.

If there are myths you’d like Claudia to bust in future columns, she’s on Twitter @claudiahammond.

Does CPR usually bring people around?

(Thinkstock)

The number of lives saved by CPR isn't as many as films and TV dramas would have you believe. Why is this the case, and what is the best way to do it?

How many times do films or TV dramas feature someone kneeling over their collapsed friend, desperately pumping up and down on their chest, breathing into their mouth and begging them to wake up? After a few tense moments, there’s some coughing and spluttering from the person on the ground, they open their eyes and their life has been saved. We can all rest easy.

But is it like that in the real world? Cardiopulmonary resuscitation, or CPR, is designed to help someone who’s had an unexpected cardiac arrest – in other words their heart has stopped beating strongly enough to pump blood around the body, depriving the brain of blood flow. The idea of CPR is not to start the heart beating again, but to get oxygen into a person’s lungs to prevent brain damage. To restart the heart would usually require an electric shock.

This is why it’s essential not to give up on CPR before medical help arrives. It buys you time, but it needs to be done hard and fast, which soon tires you out, so you need to get yourself into a position where you can continue for a long time, or ideally take turns with someone else. If someone without a pulse appears to recover and regain a pulse through CPR then the chances are that their heart was still beating faintly all along.

So don’t be surprised if someone doesn’t immediately come back to life. It doesn’t mean you’re doing it wrong; it’s rare for CPR to rouse someone from unconsciousness straight away.

You wouldn’t get that impression from fiction, though. In studies of medical dramas, resuscitation was shown to be successful 75% of the time on US television, whereas there was a more realistic 25% success rate in British dramas. Even that 25% rate is higher than many places actually achieve. The success of CPR depends a lot on where you live and how fast you can get medical help. A review of studies across many countries found a survival rate of just 5.35% in New York compared with 37% in the German city of Heidelberg.

Hold your breath?

Over the years there’s been a lot of debate over the best way of doing CPR. For a long time most guidelines recommended 15 compressions on the chest, followed by two breaths into the person’s mouth, followed by 15 compressions again, repeating this sequence until medical help arrives. In 2005, many organisations including the American Heart Association, changed their recommendations to 30 compressions followed by two breaths. But now there’s research suggesting the breaths might not even be needed at all, a finding which might well encourage more people to come to the aid of a stranger in the street. At the University of Arizona, Professor Gordon A Ewy and his team demonstrated in laboratory studies using animals that compressions alone were just as effective as compressions with breaths.

But what would happen with people in real-life emergencies? It’s not easy studying this – since you don’t know who’s going to collapse and where, it’s impossible to randomise passers-by to do CPR with or without breathing into the person’s mouth. However, in 2004 Arizona began a public information campaign explaining that people didn’t have to give breaths in order to attempt CPR with a video showing you how to do it (see below). The result was a dramatic increase in the number of bystanders prepared to have a go, leading to an increase in survival rates from 18-34%, Not only did just as many people survive even with no breaths, but giving compressions without interruption in this study protected against damage to the brain.

This is still a matter of debate, especially in Europe. The American Heart Association recommends that in the event of an unexpected cardiac arrest untrained people should use what’s known as “Hands Only” CPR, though its latest consensus statement says there’s still not enough evidence to discourage those who’ve had training from giving breathing. These results only apply to adults. In children under the age of 12 it’s still recommended breathing into their mouths as well.

Perfect beat

Then there’s the question of speed. The 2010 US guidelines suggest a rate of at least a hundred compressions a minute. Humming a tune can help you to get the right pace: the Bee Gees 1977 hit Stayin’ Alive, or perhaps Half a Pound of Tuppenny Rice, if you happen to know it. Research from 2012 that sought to find the ideal speed for survival found that it wasn’t a case of the faster the better; there were decreasing returns once they reached a speed of 125 compressions a minute.

Sometimes people are nervous about whether or not CPR is needed. It’s not dangerous to do it to someone who turns out to be conscious after all. If they open their eyes and start pushing you away then you can stop. The greater risk is that people mistake a person’s final gasps for breath as a sign of consciousness and then decide not to do CPR. In fact this so-called agonal respiration can mean they’re dying in front of you.

One thing I discovered when I learned CPR in London, trying it out on the mannequin or Resusci Annie as she’s better known, was how hard you have to press. Although the ribs and the breastbone flex to an extent, it’s not surprising that it can result in a sore chest and even a broken rib or two. It’s worth it though. Although you’re not bringing someone back to life, you’re giving them the chance for someone else to save them. The result can still be the same – you save a life.

If you would like to comment on this, or anything else you have seen on Future, head over to our Facebook or Google+ page, or message us on Twitter.

You can hear more Medical Myths on Health Check on the BBC World Service.

Disclaimer
All content within this column is provided for general information only, and should not be treated as a substitute for the medical advice of your own doctor or any other health care professional. The BBC is not responsible or liable for any diagnosis made by a user based on the content of this site. The BBC is not liable for the contents of any external internet sites listed, nor does it endorse any commercial product or service mentioned or advised on any of the sites. Always consult your own GP if you're in any way concerned about your health.

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.