BBC HomeExplore the BBC

11 October 2008
Accessibility help
Text only
World Wars - World War Twobbc.co.uk/history

BBC Homepage

Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 

Spinning Dunkirk

By Professor Duncan Anderson
Welcoming the troops back home
Welcoming the troops back home ©

Could it have been government news management that conjured the Dunkirk 'miracle' from the disaster of the Fall of France? Duncan Anderson investigates.

Bad news

Over the last ten years new terms have entered the English language. We have 'spin doctors' who, on a 'bad news day', manipulate information to protect their government's 'media flank.' Terminology of this sort is particularly common on military operations, where 'media minders' supervise 'pools' of those journalists who have not been 'embedded', so that their reports can be 'shaped' to conform to the dictates of an all embracing information strategy.

Many deplore the news management of the current age, hearkening back to earlier periods, when fearlessly independent reporters exposed wickedness and brought governments down.

' ... the British government manipulated information to increase the chances of national survival.'

Of course, there never was such a time. Beginning with the emergence of the Greek city states in the fifth century BC, all governments have attempted to manipulate information to their advantage, and have often suppressed those who have sought to tell a different story. This tendency is most apparent when the very existence of the state is under threat. In extreme situations governments can interpret chance events - storms, fortuitous deaths, and so on - as evidence of the intervention of an external agency (often supernatural) working on their behalf.

Such agencies can come in the form of fate (Athens 480BC), a divine wind (Japan 1281), a protestant God (England 1588), a special providence (Prussia 1762) - example could be piled upon example. In the early summer of 1940 Britain's very existence was threatened, and unsurprisingly, the British government manipulated information to increase the chances of national survival.

Published: 2004-02-06

Bookmark with:

What are these?

Articles

WW2 People's War

Interactive Content

Historic Figures

Timelines

BBC Links

External Web Links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external websites.



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy
Advertise with us