Congress tells Hayward BP ignored oil well dangers

During the course of the day, Mr Hayward faced attacks from both politicians and the audience

BP chief executive Tony Hayward has been told by an angry US Congressional panel his firm ignored dangers when drilling in the Gulf of Mexico.

House committee on energy and commerce chairman Henry Waxman said BP's "complacency" before the 20 April rig explosion had been "astonishing".

He accused Mr Hayward of "stonewalling" for failing to answer his questions.

As a public relations exercise for BP, the hearing was a disaster, a BBC correspondent says.


Maybe it was President Obama's decision to dispatch the Attorney General - Eric Holder - to the Gulf Of Mexico a few weeks back to look into the possibility of criminal charges against BP that made the company's CEO so cautious as he gave testimony.

Time after time, to their growing frustration, Tony Hayward told members of Congress that it would be "premature" to prejudge the outcome of investigations into the explosion on the Deepwater Horizon well nearly two months ago.

Mr Hayward's reticence to be drawn further into the causes of the disaster led to growing frustration on the part of committee members, one of whom accused him of "stonewalling".

Another recurring theme of Mr Hayward's testimony was that he wasn't personally involved in decisions relating to the construction of the well which could have impacted on safety.

Committee members had accused BP of cutting corners in order to get the well into operation, but Mr Hayward professed himself out of the loop on those matters.

""With respect, sir, we drill hundreds of wells a year around the world," he informed Republican committee member Michael Burgess.

"Yes I know, Mr Burgess replied dryly, "That's what's scaring me right now."

Over and over, the BP chief refused to agree with the conclusions of a group of angry, hostile Congressmen and women who seemed in no doubt, after their own lengthy enquiries, that BP had shown a reckless lack of attention to safety, Paul Adams reports.

Infuriated by Mr Hayward's inability or unwillingness to answer their questions, committee members resorted to expressing their disgust, more than one saying he felt insulted.

Eleven people died in the Deepwater Horizon drill rig accident, which left a ruptured well spewing hundreds of thousands of barrels of oil into the Gulf of Mexico.

Despite BP efforts to contain the leak, oil continues to enter the sea, threatening states along the Gulf coast.

BP says it will withhold dividends until the end of the year as part of its response to the spill.

The long-term hope for ending the spill rests with two relief wells now being drilled, one of which has reached two miles (3km) below the seabed, or about two-thirds of its way to its target, US disaster coordinator Admiral Thad Allen reported on Thursday.

It is planned is to seal the leak with concrete but that is not likely to happen until August at the earliest.

'Tremendous risks'

BP's shares rose more than 6% after it agreed to put $20bn (£13.5bn) in a fund to compensate victims of the spill.

The increase halted falls that had led to the company's stock value halving in recent weeks.

Congressman Waxman said in his opening remarks that BP had "cut corner after corner" in order to save money, which led to the explosion and fire on board the Deepwater Horizon.

"We could find no evidence that you paid any attention to the tremendous risks BP was taking," he went on.


Mark Mardell

Start Quote

This is going very badly for Mr Hayward and for BP”

End Quote Mark Mardell BBC North America editor

"We reviewed 30,000 pages of documents from BP, including your e-mails. There is not a single e-mail or document that shows you paid even the slightest attention to the dangers at this well."

He told Mr Hayward: "You're not taking responsibility, you're kicking the can down the road."

One by one, other Congressmen, both Democrats and Republicans, questioned BP's activities in America in a hearing which lasted some seven hours.

"We are not small people but we wish to get our lives back," said Bart Stupak, playing on a comment made the day before by BP chairman Carl-Henric Svanberg about how BP sympathised with the "small people" of the Gulf, and a recent remark by Mr Hayward about wanting his "life back".

Representative Steve Scalise holds photo of an oiled bird Congressmen were angry at the effects of the oil spill

Texan Republican Michael Burgess expressed surprise when the BP chief said he had not known anything about the well in question until he was told in April that drilling had confirmed an oil discovery.

"But you're the CEO of the company," Congressman Burgess said.

"With due respect," Mr Hayward replied, "we drill hundreds of wells around the world."

"Yeah, that's what scares me right now," said Mr Burgess.

A row erupted within Republican ranks after another Texan Republican, Joe Barton, suggested BP had been subjected to a "$20bn shakedown" by the Obama administration.

Mr Barton, the senior Republican on Mr Waxman's committee, was rebuked by his own party leaders and retracted his words, the Associated Press reports.

"I regret the impact that my statement this morning implied that BP should not pay for the consequences of their decisions and actions in this incident," he said in a statement.

BP pledge

Earlier, as Mr Hayward prepared to testify, a protester briefly disrupted the hearing, shouting that he should be "charged with a crime" before she was removed.

BBC special coverage graphic

This week, the BBC is assessing the impact of the Louisiana oil spill. Correspondents in the US, the Gulf of Mexico, Brazil, Nigeria and London are reporting for the BBC World Service, World News TV and the BBC News website.

She was identified as Diane Wilson, a fisherwoman from Seadrift, Texas, near the Gulf Coast.

Expressing his "deep regret" for the spill, Mr Hayward repeatedly stressed he was constrained in what he could say by the fact that a number of investigations into the explosion had yet to finish.

"There is nothing I have seen so far that suggests that anyone put costs ahead of safety," he said at one point. "If there are, then we'll take action."

He said he had focused on improving safety for the three years he had been in his post and his priority was ending the spill and clearing up the oil.

"I give my pledge as the leader of BP that we will not rest until we make this right," he said.

Mr Hayward's inability to answer specific technical questions about the situation on the rig angered the panel particularly.

Start Quote

We are not small people but we wish to get our lives back”

End Quote Bart Stupak US Congressman

BP's chief executive said answers would be supplied by his firm when they were ready.

The questions, set out in a letter to Mr Hayward on Sunday by Mr Waxman and fellow committee member Bart Stupak, include allegations that BP:

  • Went against the advice of its own plan review regarding the well's design and chose a riskier, cheaper and quicker casing option
  • Used only six centralisers to make sure the casing ran down the centre of the well bore, rather than the 21 recommended by sub-contractor Halliburton
  • Rejected warnings by its own plan review and Halliburton in preparations for a cementing job
  • Decided to forego a recommended safety step in the circulation of drilling mud
  • Did not deploy a "lockdown sleeve" that would have prevented the seal from being blown out from below

More on This Story

US Oil Spill

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More US & Canada stories


Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • TravelAround the world

    BBC Travel takes a look at the most striking images from the past seven days


  • A bicycle with a Copenhagen WheelClick Watch

    The wheel giving push bikes an extra boost by turning them into smart electric hybrids

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.