Are conservatives deserting Sarah Palin?

Sarah Palin speaks at the Conservative Political Action Conference in Washington, DC, on 8 March, 2014. Sarah Palin is facing a backlash over a joke about waterboarding baptisms

Related Stories

Sarah Palin has long been a bete noire of the left, but she has always been able to count support from grass-roots conservatives. At least, until now.

During a speech to members of the National Rifle Association this weekend, Ms Palin cracked a joke that - while being well-received by the crowd - didn't go over as well with many Christian commentators, many of whom considered her an ally.

"They obviously have information on plots to carry out jihad," she said, referring to prisoners. "Oh, but you can't offend them, can't make them feel uncomfortable, not even a smidgen. Well, if I were in charge, they would know that waterboarding is how we baptise terrorists."

For The American Conservative's Rod Dreher, Ms Palin's statement is "sacrilegious". He says that those who laughed at the joke should be ashamed of themselves. Baptism, he says, should be about starting a new life, not celebrating torture.

Start Quote

Joking about baptism in the context of this aggressive action suggests that we don't think baptism is as life-giving or important as it is”

End Quote Mollie Hemingway The Federalist

"If I thought that kind of hateful declaration and abuse of the Christian religion was what conservatism stood for, I wouldn't be able to call myself a conservative," he writes.

Dreher isn't the only religious conservative unhappy with Ms Palin's jibe.

Joe Carter of the Gospel Coalition says that while it is "suicidal" to try to find tolerance and understanding within those who want to destroy the US, dehumanising the country's enemies is just as bad.

"Like us, our enemies need to accept Jesus and to be baptised by water and the Spirit," he writes. "That is the Christian way, not as Palin would have it, to have our enemies fear a pagan god and have their spirit broken by water."

The Federalist's Mollie Hemingway agrees.

"Joking about baptism in the context of this aggressive action suggests that we don't think baptism is as life-giving or important as it is," she writes.

Hemingway says that while she is a longtime supporter of Ms Palin, these latest remarks cross the line. In her eyes, Ms Palin is using religion for a political endgame, and while this type of "civil religion" definitely unites people politically, it comes at the expense of the church.

Start Quote

The media is finally catching on that it is time to ignore Sarah Palin”

End Quote Jason Easley Politicus USA

The Wonkette's Doktor Zoom lampooned Hemingway's criticisms, poking fun at her for missing the mark on exactly why Ms Palin's comments were inappropriate.

"You just see here, now, Ms Palin, we don't so much mind you sticking it to the godless heathen Muslims, but don't you go joking about the sacraments," he writes.

In fact, he says, it can be difficult to pin down just what is so out of line about Ms Palin's statement.

"We're not sure what the most hilarious part of this line is - the desire to live out [conservative commentator] Ann Coulter's dream of victory through forced conversion, the mistaken belief that torture gets reliable intelligence or the very notion that Sarah Palin will ever be in charge of anything but a third-rate cable TV show," he concludes.

While it is well known that Ms Palin is no longer a real politician, writes Patrick Brennan for National Review, she still stands for a group of people who are serious about the ideas of faith and freedom. He asks why any of her supporters would continue to back her after what she said.

"Torture - waterboarding being something reasonable people may consider to constitute it - is and should be a question of grave moral consequence for Christians, and is for any Catholic familiar with the Catechism," he writes.

By some coincidence, Palin's remarks came just hours before Robert Costa of the Washington Post published an article that outlines the former governor's political decline and the diminishing power her endorsements hold.

"Even as she travels to Iowa and elsewhere to bolster her handpicked candidates," he writes, "her influence in these midterm elections has been eclipsed by a new class of stars and her circle has narrowed, with a handful of aides guiding her and a few allies in Washington beyond a group of backbench troublemakers in Congress."

Ms Palin was part of the trendy 2010 Tea Party movement, he says, but increasingly among her friends in Washington she finds herself in a supporting role.

And for some, including Politicus USA's Jason Easley, it's about time.

"Sarah Palin is the one hit wonder who started out playing arenas, then moved down to the clubs, then moved further down to the county fair circuit," he writes.

"When you stop drawing a crowd on the county fair circuit, it's over. The media is finally catching on that it is time to ignore Sarah Palin."

By Kierran Petersen


More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 339.

    337. Follow up - Wayne LaPierre (NRA) 'also redirected' to blaming the US mental health industry inadequacy in dealing with the SH armed crazy - 50 million without health insurance (15% of the population) and those with health insurance having to contend with a range of exclusions, co-pays and extra fees that would choke a horse do you think that anyone with a military arsenal would seek help?

  • rate this

    Comment number 338.

    337. Gabby was shot by a guy with 32 in the clip and was stopped when he had to reload (and was overcome). The NRA, assault weapons ban repeal, and generally crazy people who own high capacity firearms are the Second Amendment landscape - calling Gabby's attacker crazy was a given. Crazy people were responsible for Sandy Hook and Aurora also - the common thread: all were armed to the teeth!

  • rate this

    Comment number 337.

    @336.Chris A ,
    You know, I thought I remember reading that the mentally unbalanced young man who shot Ms. Giffords was unaware of that political ad. I'm more concerned about our mental health policies & treatment in the US. That has been at the heart of many recent tragedies.

  • rate this

    Comment number 336.

    334. Sarah remains a Republican graffiti artist ('Don't retreat, reload"), however, her guerrilla charm got thin with the Gabby Gifford's 'crosshairs': Graffiti has consequences!

  • rate this

    Comment number 335.

    When you start talking about religion then everyone comes out and either says your not a "good" christian/ muslim/ jew/ baptist/ whatever if you don't follow thier form of that religion. Stop being a hypocrit! People have thier opinion, you don't have to like it or listen to it. I also find it interesting that Joe Carter says his own god is a pagan. So Christianity is now a pagan religion??


Comments 5 of 339


Elsewhere on the BBC


  • Former al-Qaeda double agent Aimen DeanHARDtalk Watch

    Islamic State is about revenge says former al-Qaeda member turned spy Aimen Dean

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.