Bowe Bergdahl: A never-ending state of war?

A soldier is silhouetted against the sky on the Guantanamo Bay detention facility. Ending the war against al-Qaeda would directly affect the legal status of detainees at Guantanamo Bay

Related Stories

After a bruising week where the Obama administration found itself on the defensive over a cover-up within the Department of Veterans Affairs, the White House thought it had some good news to announce.

In a Rose Garden ceremony, President Barack Obama welcomed the release of Sgt Bowe Bergdahl after five years of captivity, exchanged with help from the Qatari government for five Taliban prisoners held at Guantanamo.

It was good news, but political hell broke loose anyway. The criticism came from all directions:

Congress was not consulted, a necessary legal hurdle for the Taliban prisoners' release. The price was too high, since these senior Taliban commanders could rejoin the fight and threaten American lives in the future. Mr Bergdahl may have walked away from his post, which calls into question not the rescue but rather the high-profile announcement.

Ending three wars

All that said, the furore is not so much about Mr Bergdahl than the future of the war against political extremism. Twelve years after 9/11, there are still major strategic disagreements over who the enemy is, how to defeat them and what success (or victory) looks like.

Mr Obama is positioning himself to end the three wars he inherited by the time he leaves office. The last American soldier left Iraq in 2011. The combat mission will end in Afghanistan at the end of this year, with all US and NATO soldiers out by the end of 2016. Regarding the war on al Qaeda - what former President George W Bush initially termed the 'war on terror' - President Obama said in a speech last year at the National Defense University: "This war, like all wars, must end."

While true, if the Bergdahl controversy is any indication, Congress is not prepared to do that any time soon.

Mr Obama said a year ago that he intends to engage Congress regarding the Authorization for the Use of Military Force (AUMF), the declaration of war that justifies US operations against core al Qaeda - those responsible for the attacks of 9/11 - and its affiliates and allies. It has been the basis for not just the war in Afghanistan, but other mostly covert operations against al Qaeda in places like Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia and Libya, and related intelligence and legal actions.

The primary concern about the AUMF is its age. There is little question the broad extremist threat to the United States and its key allies is greatly reduced. Osama bin Laden is dead. Al Qaeda's core leadership has been "decimated", as Mr Obama said at West Point last month. But the residual threat is not zero.

Al Qaeda's new generation

A new generation of al Qaeda operatives is now emerging - groups and individuals that identify with the al Qaeda brand but had no connection with 9/11. Their defining struggle is not Afghanistan, but may well be Syria. New networks are focused more on local, not global, issues.

Al Qaeda is attracting a broad range of combatants to the ongoing civil war, including an estimated 70 Americans. A young Florida man recently blew himself up in Syria. What the other Americans and Western citizens do with the military experience they gain there is anyone's guess.

The central question going forward is whether the long-term residual threat from such political extremists can be handled by a combination of intelligence, military and law enforcement action below the threshold of "war". For example, the US and other countries have taken action against Boko Haram, which identifies with al Qaeda, after it abducted some 200 schoolgirls. Washington has gone to great lengths to distinguish this response as support and not combat.

If the AUMF is repealed, the greatest impact would be on the Guantanamo Bay detention facility. It would remove the legal justification for the prison and the military tribunals being conducted there.

In 2009 Obama pledged to close Guantanamo within a year. Congress blocked that initiative. Since then, the administration has been able to reduce the size of the population, now down to fewer than 150 detainees, but not put it out of business.

The prison population includes a handful of genuinely dangerous people who cannot be tried in a civilian court, including 9/11 planner Khalid Sheikh Mohammed. Few military tribunals have been completed. Mohammed's has been going on for two years with no end in sight. Few members of Congress are enthusiastic about transferring detainees to American soil and within reach of the US civilian court system.

While the AUMF could be modified, it's more likely Congress will, by inertia, simply keep it on the books, extending the state of war indefinitely. Mr Obama has consistently maintained this is unsustainable both politically and legally, a point on which he and Edward Snowden completely agree.

Four days before he announced Mr Bergdahl's return, the president was also in the Rose Garden to discuss the American transition out of Afghanistan. He said: "It is harder to end wars than it is to begin them."

He meant these words to be rhetorical. They could end up being prophetic.

PJ Crowley is a former US assistant secretary of state and now a professor of practice and fellow at the George Washington University's Institute for Public Diplomacy and Global Communication.


More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 26.

    My guess is the war will just drone on

  • rate this

    Comment number 25.

    Thank you, Jane. Yes, it is beyond repulsive how his family is being threatened. Disgusting, arrogant, hypocritical bigots with no amount of decency.

    Lucy: technically you didn't "say" anything. Just as an FYI, you WROTE something.

    David (not 23): No, she has no shame as she cannot fathom being wrong (god told her so = no questions asked!). And yes: the media should be ashamed too.

  • rate this

    Comment number 24.

    21: Yes, an unfortunate thing. Those fighting the British were essentially a militia. And the same goes for the original IRA, doesn't it? Yet what are they considered? They maybe started with good intentions but - as an Irish mate put it - they turned in to thugs. But it is an interesting double standard. Militia = bad, military = good (black & white). What are colours? There's no such thing!

  • rate this

    Comment number 23.

    It's good to be assured that the broad extremist threat to the US and its allies has been greatly reduced, although perhaps women in Nigeria or the citizens of Mosul might have trouble believing that. But it is helpful to have the Obama administration's utterly delusional worldview exposed for all to see. The president really believes that if he gives up then attacks on the US will stop.

  • rate this

    Comment number 22.

    Mussolini, the Father of Modern American Politics, said that to control the masses you need never-ending wars and an uneducated civilian population to tap into. He claimed that it would kill off the unlucky and the incompetent, as well as be great for the corporations who own the government. 100% of the US policies are fascist in nature. This is a fact and far too many Americans don't know it.


Comments 5 of 26


Elsewhere on the BBC

  • StudentsBull market

    Employers are snapping up students with this desirable degree


  • 3D model of Christ the Redeemer statueClick Watch

    Using drones to 3D map the famous Brazilian landmark Christ the Redeemer

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.