Energy bills driven up by battle for gas

A LNG tanker The Japan nuclear disaster caused some LNG ships to be re-routed

In March 2011, an explosion at the Fukushima nuclear plant in Japan pushed up gas prices in the UK.

As nuclear power plants were taken offline, Japan chose to generate more of its electricity from imported gas.

Traders worried that cargoes of Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) headed for Europe would be diverted to Japan - where higher prices were being offered.

This pushed up the price that energy firms had to pay to buy gas in the UK, a cost that may have driven up bills this winter.

Gas and bills

The main thing that currently drives UK bills is the changing price of gas.

Increases in the wholesale price of natural gas will not only drive up the cost of a household's heating, it will also increase the cost of its electricity.

That is because the price of electricity generated from gas power-stations tends to set the wholesale cost of power paid to all generators.

The more expensive the gas bought by power companies, the more expensive the electricity they produce and the more we pay in our bills.

What pushes up annual bills?
  • 1 Annualised household bill Wholesale energy accounts for 45% of household bills which also include tax, company profit, transmission costs and rising clean energy investment.
  • 2 Wholesale energy cost The wholesale energy cost for a dual fuel bill includes the cost of gas and the cost of generating electricity.
  • 3 Wholesale cost of gas The wholesale, on the day, cost of the gas or gas equivalent consumed by the average household over a year.
  • 4 Fukushima nuclear accident The Fukushima accident and subsequent conflict in Libya both helped to push up the cost of gas to UK consumers

The link isn't that exact though.

Like airlines with fuel, energy companies buy much of their gas in advance.

If they buy a lot when the price is cheap, then they won't necessarily need to push up the price to us when it becomes more expensive.

"It's quite misleading when gas companies say we see the wholesale price is increasing so we're going to have put up our prices. It's quite a convenient justification for something far more complicated," says James Allpress from ICIS Heren, which monitors the gas market.

However, over the longer term, even buying in advance can't prevent higher prices feeding through into bills.

Gas rises with oil

The biggest thing that drives the cost of imported gas is the cost of oil.

Many countries buy their gas on long-term contracts from one or two major suppliers.

Germany, for example, buys much of its gas from Russia and recently completed a new pipeline, the Nordstream, to make more available.

And many suppliers, especially countries that also produce oil, such as Russia, tend to tie the price they charge for these contracts to the oil price.

Start Quote

It is the oil price that has propped up the spot price [of gas]”

End Quote Professor Jonathan Stern Oxford Institute for Energy Studies

The UK has few long term contracts, but because so much gas is tied into them, the UK price tends to change with the oil price.

So when oil spiked in 2008, so did the cost of gas in the UK, and so did consumer bills.

Most recently, the conflict in Libya reduced exports of Libyan oil and gas.

Not only did this put up the price of gas in regions that bought from Libya, it also increased the oil and gas price worldwide, potentially driving price rises in the UK over the summer.

"It is the oil price that has propped up the spot price and very strong demand for LNG in Asia, post Fukushima," says Professor Stern from the Oxford Institute for Energy Studies.

The spot price refers to the price paid for gas bought immediately.

Nuclear fallout

But, unlike oil, gas is also heavily influenced by local supply and demand.

During the 2009 recession, gas prices were broadly the same around the world, at around $4-5 per million British thermal units (MMBTU), according to figures from Platts.

But by 26 October this year, gas in the US was down to $3.6, in the UK it had reached $9.9 and in Asia it reached $17.5 - more than three times its 2009 price.

In Asia, rising demand from fast-growing economies, such as China, has driven up the price dramatically.

Start Quote

As the earthquake hit, the UK gas price was trending down, and then it started trending up”

End Quote James Allpress ICIS Heren

The March Fukushima disaster, which increased demand from Japan, only made the situation worse.

In the US, by contrast, the discovery of vast shale gas deposits (gas trapped in rocks) has driven the price down.

New technology allowed gas to be extracted, where before it would remain underground.

The UK is somewhere in-between. It does need to import gas from global markets, including Qatar, which means global demand pushes up local prices.

"Just as the earthquake hit, the UK gas price was trending down, and then it started trending up, purely on trader sentiment," says Mr Allpress.

The UK and Northern Europe have local gas supplies and relatively slow economic growth, so they seem to be holding back prices compared with Asia.

Future uncertainty

The International Energy Agency (IEA) has predicted a golden age for gas in the next decade, driven by new supply from unconventional shale gas around the world and rising demand in Asia.

German President Angela Merkel and Russian President Dmitry Medvedev start the Nordstream pipeline New pipelines such as the Russia-Germany Nordstream could keep prices in check

But what that means for the price in the UK is uncertain.

The IEA's world energy outlook predicted that UK gas production from the North Sea would fall by over 50% during the next 25 years.

This means the UK will be more dependent than ever on imported gas, and competing for it with Asia and the rest of Europe.

In the wake of Fukushima, Germany has abandoned its nuclear programme, potentially increasing its demand for gas in Europe.

Norwegian firm Statoil, which provides much of the gas to the UK, says this means we should make a long term deal or risk higher prices.

They say the government's current policy relies on gas as a backup to new wind and nuclear generation.

"The likelihood is that much of the gas will go elsewhere, or that the price tag of having that gas as backup fuel is going to be extremely expensive," warns Rune Bjornson, senior vice president for natural gas at Statoil.

There are also concerns about shale gas outside the US.

France has already banned shale exploration and it is suspended in the UK due to tremors linked to drilling.

"If unconventional gas does get produced in Europe, it will cost a lot more than it does in the States," says Mr Allpress.

But there is a chance the price could stabilise, or even fall.

Gas from the US could be exported - BG group recently signed a deal with US firm Cheniere energy to do just that.

That would help bring global prices more into line with each other.

And UK energy bills may come to be more reliant on the cost of building nuclear power stations and wind turbines than the gas price.

Ultimately though, events, such as earthquakes, wars, technological breakthroughs and changes in economic fortunes will continue to have a bigger impact on the changing cost of power than anything else.

More on This Story

Business of Energy

More Business stories


Business Live

    07:59: North Sea oil outlook BBC Radio 4

    Ian Theophilus an oil and gas consultant tells Today he expects a number of North Sea oil projects - planned with a higher oil price in mind - may be reduced or cut altogether. He says he is very worried about the prospect for North Sea oil in 2015. He says he and colleagues "remember the late 1980s and 1990s" when the oil price was between $9 and $11 per barrel and "everything was stuck". "The chances are that could happen again," he adds.

    07:51: Keeping the lights on

    Reacting to the completion of the energy auction Energy Secretary Ed Davey, said: "This is fantastic news for bill-payers and businesses. We are guaranteeing security at the lowest cost for consumers. We've done this by ensuring that we get the best out of our existing power stations and unlocking new investment in flexible plant."

    07:41: Keeping the lights on

    Companies will be paid £19.40 per kilowatt by the government to provide backup power following an auction process that has been going on all week. The new scheme is designed to ensure the nation has a sufficient energy buffer to cope with peak demand - usually over the winter.

    07:32: Premier League TV review
    Premier League logo on a football

    Ofcom has launched a consultation on its view that the current division of Premier League and Champions League football between Sky and BT harms competition between pay TV retailers. Back in 2010 Ofcom ordered Sky to offer its sports channels to rivals at a price set by the regulator. It is now reviewing whether that has helped competition and "remains appropriate". There will be a second phase of the review in 2015.

    07:20: North Sea oil outlook Radio 5 live
    North Sea oil platform

    It's extremely difficult to tell if the North Sea oil business is heading into the same kind of crisis that it saw in 1986, says Aberdeen businessman Charles Skene on Radio 5 live. Kenny Anderson the boss of an Aberdeen construction firm remembers the "strife" caused in 1986 when oil fell to $36 per barrel. But predicting oil prices is an "impossible game" he points out.

    07:10: Samsung shareholder payout

    Samsung Electronics is considering increasing its dividend payout this year by between 30% and 50% compared to 2013.

    06:56: Nigerian currency crisis BBC Radio 4

    Phillip Walker of the Economist Intelligence Unit, tells Today the crisis facing Nigeria is far bigger than the one facing Russia. Nigeria's currency the naira has fallen 15% against the US dollar this year forcing the country's central bank to impose foreign currency trading controls. "Nigeria has a bigger population than Russia, its economy relies on oil exports more than Russia, so it's a big problem," Mr Walker says.

    06:48: Gas prices BBC Radio 4

    Professor Green says energy suppliers have an eye on politics at the moment. He says Labour leader Ed Miliband's promise to freeze energy prices for 20 months if his party wins next year's election may mean suppliers will keep prices artificially high despite currently benefitting from lower gas costs.

    06:34: Gas prices BBC Radio 4

    While falling oil prices have recently caught the attention of many, the cost of gas has also been coming down. That's because demand in Europe has been falling due to a relatively warm winter so far. Richard Green professor of sustainable energy business at Imperial College London tells Today we shouldn't expect lower energy bills are a result. That's because energy suppliers are selling us gas they bought at last year's prices.

    06:32: Asian markets

    Asian stock markets have had a mixed session. They Nikkei 225 is up more than 2%. Hong Kong's Hang Seng is up 1.4%. Shares in Shanghai have fallen back after hitting a four-year high in early trading. The Shanghai composite is down 0.1%.

    06:21: China recalculates growth
    Chinese flag

    China's economy is bigger than originally thought. The government has revised up the size of the economy in 2013 by 3.4% to 58.8 trillion yuan ($9.5 trillion). The increase was mainly accounted for by a greater contribution from the services sector. In comparison, the US economy was worth almost $17 trillion in 2013.

    06:14: IAG bid for Aer Lingus Radio 5 live
    Dublin Airport

    British Airways owner, IAG is "good at integrating new airlines" says Richard Hunter, head of equities at Hargreaves Lansdown. He is explaining why IAG made a bid for Aer Lingus. The Irish airline is attractive because it has lots of landing slots at Heathrow, says Mr Hunter. IAG may also have a bit more spending power because of the lower oil price, he adds.

    06:06: North Sea oil jobs Radio 5 live
    Oil worker

    North Sea oil companies are cutting wages, rather than jobs at the moment, says Alan Savage chairman of recruitment company Orion Group on Radio 5 live. For agency workers wages have already been cut by up to 20%. He says that the British oil industry is highly taxed and the "government has a lot to answer for".

    06:02: Russian crisis Radio 5 live
    Russian President, Vladimir Putin

    Next year is going to be grim for the Russian economy, says Craig Botham, emerging markets economist at Schroders on Radio 5 live. The economy is likely to contract 4.5%, inflation is forecast to be betweem 11% and 12%. The rouble could keep on weakening, "it's hard to see a particular floor for the currency" Mr Botham says.

    05:59: Ben Morris Business Reporter

    Do get in touch. Email or tweet @bbcbusiness.

    05:59: Matthew West Business Reporter

    Morning folks. The news the US Federal Reserve is in no hurry to raise interest rates boosted shares on Wall Street and in Asia to new highs. Meanwhile the Bank of Japan maintained its commitment to government bond buying at its last meeting of the year. And we'll be keeping an eye on the Russia rouble and oil price again today and there may be more on IAG's bid for Aer Lingus. Stay with us.



From BBC Capital


  • An ECG (electrocardiogram)Click Watch

    The wearable technology which could allow you to pay for goods with your heartbeat

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.