Gem-encrusted mooncakes, corruption, and the law


Linda Yueh explains why traditional mooncake gifts have become controversial

In business, you sometimes hear that it's not what you know, but who you know.

At the risk of depressing parents about the tens of thousands spent on their children's education, connections are important in business.

Well, going to a good school probably raises the chances of meeting other well-connected people.

But, where is the line between making connections and crossing over into corruption?

It is a particular challenge for business in China due to the cultural importance of having good inter-personal relationships.

I wrote about the concept of Chinese guanxi a little while ago when I expected that the GSK troubles with the Chinese authorities would not be an isolated case.

Under the new Chinese leaders' anti-corruption drive, numerous big companies and Chinese officials have fallen afoul of that line.

Earlier this summer, the Chinese authorities launched investigations against British firm GSK and other Western pharmaceutical companies (Eli Lilly, Sanofi, Novartis) for alleged bribery of doctors to prescribe their drugs.

Then, JP Morgan's hiring practices in China came under investigation by the US government. It was over their employment of the children of powerful Chinese officials, known as "princelings", and whether they were linked to specific deals in China as reportedly seen in an internal spreadsheet of their "Sons and Daughters" department.

Some 200 hires are being scrutinised by the SEC, including the daughter of Zhang Shugang, a powerful railway ministry official, who is himself under investigation by the Chinese government for corruption.

Recently, we have seen the most high-profile dismissal so far under the new Chinese leaders: Jiang Jiemin, the head of the body that oversees all of China's large state-owned enterprises, known as SASAC (State-owned Assets Supervision and Administration Commission). And of course, Bo Xilai, who is awaiting his verdict.

Looking back, for companies working in China during the 1990s when it was just opening up its consumer market, having good connections with the Chinese government facilitated doing business in an environment where state-owned enterprises dominated.

With greater opening of the market, perhaps it's become less important. But, relationships remain an essential part of doing business in China as elsewhere.

Nepotism and the hiring of relatives are not unheard of in Western firms. The issue, though, for JP Morgan and others under the US Foreign Corrupt Practices Act is whether there was a quid pro quo for a specific deal in return.

Enforcing the rule of law

For China, enforcing its laws is seemingly a priority for the new president and premier. Premier Li Keqiang in his speech today at the World Economic Forum in Dalian, China, aimed to reassure the assembled foreign businesses that there is a level playing field for them vis-a-vis state-owned enterprises.

The perceived lack of one has been a source of complaint for much of the past decade since China agreed to give multinational companies more market access when it joined the World Trade Organisation in December 2001.

So, improving the effectiveness of laws and driving out corruption are seemingly high on the government's agenda.

But, questions remain over whether the anti-corruption drive to enforce the law is a serious effort or tokenism.

One of the reasons for the recent fervour is that once a country gets richer and develops a large middle class, that middle class would like to have its rights safeguarded.

In a one-party state where there are no democratic safety valves, it is hard to have that assurance.

So, what China has done is to reinforce the rule of law, almost as a substitute for lagging political reform.

Chinese citizens rely on the legal system to protect their property. And combating corruption whether it's foreign companies or government officials reinforces the rule of law.

A key problem though is that China doesn't have an independent judiciary. The courts are an administrative arm of that one-party state run by the Communist Party.

The real test for the rule of law isn't the Bo Xilai trial, despite the publicity. Perhaps it will be when an ordinary citizen wants to enforce the rule of law against a high-ranking official.

If the rule of law comes up against the interest of the rule of Party, then that would be an indication as to whether China's anti-corruption drive and indeed the effectiveness of the legal system, which is fundamental to a stable market economy, can succeed.

Shoppers inspect boxes of "mooncakes" Shoppers inspect boxes of "mooncakes"

Coming back to that line between corruption and guanxi.

The latest ban is using government money to buy gem-encrusted mooncakes, a Chinese speciality cake that is similar to the British fruitcake in that it is eaten during special occasions.

The value and the sales of mooncakes have apparently fallen noticeably, probably because those costing 1,000 RMB (over £100) have disappeared from the shelves.

This really didn't sound like such a good idea in the first place. Gem-encrusted mooncakes, corruption, and the law.

Linda Yueh Article written by Linda Yueh Linda Yueh Chief business correspondent

The Bank of England's theory of everything

Setting interest rates is not the only thing the Bank of England focuses on anymore. But what does the newly expanded powers of the central bank mean for rates?

Read full article

More on This Story

More from Linda


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 37.

    This Blog has been online for 2 days-and there are about 30 postings! It shows,in my view,not only the disinterest in the subject matter but also the poor reporting of this correspondent ( who has more blogs than any reporter). I'm afraid Ms Yueh's work makes very poor reading, it rambles and it hides the real China : where no elections, no freedom,genocide in Tibet,Murders in TianSq,squalor,etc

  • rate this

    Comment number 36.

    what it actually sounds like is not to place your business in china- eventually you will need to play the game and eventually during a corruption roundup your business will be run through the mud.

    not a good thing- so stay out of the country until they get things fixed-- probably a long time with a 1 party government

  • rate this

    Comment number 35.

    A former CEO of a major UK business fined $1Billion for widespead criminality dealing with drug dealers, rogue states and international criminals of every description did not come under any meaningful UK scrutiny.
    He was appointed to 'Dodgy Dave's' government.
    Do you think Linda, it would be a good idea to put our own house in order before we get too concerned with China?

  • rate this

    Comment number 34.

    Gem encrusted mooncake? Sounds as tricky as an old fashioned Christmas pudding, with silver sixpences in it. You're not sure you want to lose a tooth finding one!

  • rate this

    Comment number 33.

    Great article, Linda - you highlight the importance of favoritism & patronage, especially in socially stratified societies like China. Also, India and most of the 3rd world operates this way. And, of course, the UK's narrow & mediocre Oxbridge circles are arranged similarly (and perhaps explain the UK's slow, painful decline). & it prevails to a large degree in the Ivy League circles in the US.


Comments 5 of 37


Features & Analysis

From BBC Capital


  • A robot holding a table legClick Watch

    The robots who build flat-pack furniture - teaching machines to work collaboratively

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.