'The best engineers come from Germany'

Is Germany's 'earn as you learn' model an election winning factor? Tanya Beckett finds out.

Related Stories

"I think the apprentices will be guaranteed a job when we go back, so I think we'll be OK," said Rhys from Bristol.

He and his fellow fresh-faced apprentices are huddled around a noisy workbench in Berlin. At just 19, he is one of the youngest in his group at this training centre.

Rhys, a keen rugby player, says he is settling into the German lifestyle and has even found a rugby club nearby.

He is one of just 2,200 young workers chosen from some 45,000 applicants by the electronics and electrical engineering giant Siemens for its pan-European training scheme.

Another apprentice, 21-year-old Gabriel from Northampton, says he came to Berlin to learn the German way.

"They are much more precise, they go into detail a lot more," he says.

"It helps you understand why all the best engineers and creatives come from here."

Start Quote

They are all expected to go home still working for Siemens - but in their homeland”

End Quote Martin Stoeckmann Head of training, Siemens

It is a point that was recently made by the British business lobby group, the CBI.

It warned that the UK's traditional educational route, of A-levels followed by a university degree, was not the only path to a good job and could help deepen a skills crisis in the UK.

The CBI called for more earn-as-you-learn schemes, supported by companies, alongside traditional degrees - and cited Germany as one of the leaders in vocational education.

'Excellent chance'

Siemens's trainees have come from all over Europe for the company's three-year programme, that will give them an income while they learn the art of German engineering.

"I know that right now, it's not the best time to find a job. It's why I'm doing this in Germany," says 20-year old Miguel from Madrid.

He hopes to return to Spain, despite dire employment prospects at home, where one in two young people is out of work.

Rhys, a British apprentice with Siemens British apprentice Rhys says he is confident his training will help him get a job

"Everybody knows what the label 'Made in Germany' means," says 22-year-old Vainius from Lithuania.

"This is a perfect example of how they do it. It is an excellent chance for everyone here."

In Spain, says Miguel, "we don't have opportunity to study practical and theory at same time."

Start Quote

It's a very practical, applied approach”

End Quote Nora Hesse Open Europe

In another classroom at the firm's vast training centre, a British girl stumbles over German grammar. Learning to speak German is part of the deal.

Apprentices here are encouraged to immerse themselves in the culture, offered help in opening a bank account and in other aspects of living abroad: it is a very German approach.

Germany's vocational system has been around for decades and is deeply embedded in society. A university degree does not have quite the same cachet here that it does in many other developed countries.

Youngsters who are not qualified for or interested in going to university can join a programme in which they work part of the week for a firm that pays them and teaches them relevant skills.

The rest of the time they spend in school.

Chambers of commerce and industry bodies are involved, to ensure that the work and the teaching are matched.

After their apprenticeships, the trainees often have jobs to walk into, in sectors including electrical engineering, sales and marketing, shipping and agriculture.

Roughly two out of three young Germans go through this system.

'They are loyal and proud'
Martin Stoeckmann, head of training for Siemens, Berlin Apprenticeships are goods for trainees and companies, says Martin Stoeckmann

"It's a very practical, applied approach, where young people are partly hired, partly subsidised in this dual education system," says Nora Hesse, a Berlin-based economist at the Open Europe think tank.

"They do receive some money but not too much, and their education is covered by the company that hires them," she says.

Martin Stoeckmann, who runs Siemens's training centre, says that the apprenticeships are a good investment for both the young people and the companies involved.

"Around 90% of them stay at Siemens after they finish their education. They are loyal and proud to be at the company," he says.

The company denies claims that schemes like this represent a brain drain, as Germany sucks in the brightest and best youngsters from all over Europe.

"They are all expected to go home - still working for Siemens - but in their homeland," says Mr Stoeckmann.

Advocates of Germany's vocational training point to the fact that despite the global recession, the number of young Germans out of work remains low.

An apprentice at Siemens's training centre, Berlin Germany has the lowest youth unemployment rate in Europe

Youth unemployment in Germany is under 8%, compared with 56% in Spain and 38% in Italy.

Since the 2008 financial crisis, the number of 15- to 29-year-olds not in education, employment or training has risen in most OECD countries - except in Germany.

Limited knowledge

However, some argue that there are drawbacks to this vocational bias.

Countries that combine school and work-based education, such as Germany, Austria, Denmark and Switzerland, may help young people into jobs, but in older age, these workers' skills can become obsolete, says the influential Munich-based Ifo Institute.

Knowledge is also limited to the operations of the company that trains them.

Yet with a crisis that has hit growth and the job prospects of many young people across Europe, for the apprentices at Siemens, this system offers hope.

Rhys says he is confident of his own future, thanks to the technical training he is getting.

But he says that back in Britain - where 960,000 people aged 16 to 24 are jobless - many of his friends face an uncertain future.

"I am worried for a lot of other people," he says.

More on This Story

Related Stories

More Business stories

RSS

BBC Business Live

  1.  
    RUSSIA SANCTIONS 12:40:
    apples

    Poland is the world's largest producer of apples and it was the biggest supplier to Russia before the ban on EU food was imposed on 7 August. Polish family apple farms accounted for 90% of those sales and now they face the choice of trying to apply for EU emergency aid or finding another market for their crops outside of the EU. The BBC's Nigel Cassidy has more here.

     
  2.  
    FERGUSON SHIPBUILDERS 12:24:
    Ferguson Shipbuilders

    Administrators have received four bids for Ferguson Shipbuilders in Port Glasgow. The shipyard fell into administration last week with the loss of 70 jobs. The administrators did not reveal the bidders' identities, but Clyde Blowers chairman Jim McColl and McGill's Buses owners James and Sandy Easdale have said they are interested in the business.

     
  3.  
    WATER METERS Via Twitter Simon Gompertz Personal finance correspondent, BBC News

    tweets: Compulsory water meters - maybe you save money, maybe you see your bill double

     
  4.  
    MANE EVENT 11:55:
    Show jumping

    The seventh World Equestrian Games gets under way in Normandy, northern France, this weekend. Making a profit is not the primary target for the organisers, Federation Equestre Internationale secretary general Ingmar De Vos tells the BBC. "For them it is important to have the legacy, and... promote the equestrian industry in the region."

     
  5.  
    RSA INSURANCE 11:40:

    RSA Insurance - the firm behind the More Than brand in the UK - has agreed to sell its insurance business in Singapore and Hong Kong to Allied World Assurance for £130m. New RSA chief executive Stephen Hester has been trying to revamp the business after it ran into problems, including the discovery of a hole in the finances of its Irish business last year.

     
  6.  
    JACKSON HOLE 11:25: BBC World News
    Justin Urquhart Stewart

    Central bankers are very wary of taking any precipitative action that might endanger the economic recovery, analyst Justin Urquhart Stewart - sporting a particularly fine bow tie and braces combination - tells World Business Report. All eyes are on the gathering of central bankers at Jackson Hole to see if they give any clues as to when rates might rise.

     
  7.  
    SAT NAV 11:10:
    Galileo

    With the planned launch of two satellites aboard a Soyuz rocket from French Guiana later this month, Europe is pushing ahead with its own satellite navigation system, known as Galileo. How will it change our lives? A fascinating insight here from BBC reporters Tim Bowler and Matthew Wall.

     
  8.  
    Via Email Ilya Spivak Currency Strategist at DailyFX

    "A lull in fundamental event risk in Asia and Europe has left currency markets rudderless, with investors looking ahead to the Kansas City Federal Reserve Economic Symposium. A gathering of so many policy heavy-hitters in one place all but guarantees that someone will invariably say something market-moving at some point before the affair is through. Needless to say, traders will be all ears."

     
  9.  
    HOUSE PRICES 10:41:
    Houses

    Asking prices for homes across Wales and parts of the North of England are still significantly lower than before the financial crisis, according to property website Rightmove. Prices in County Durham are still more than 13% below levels seen at the pre-crisis peak of May 2008. No prizes for guessing that the biggest price increase in the period was seen in central London - a rise of 41.9%

     
  10.  
    SCOTTISH VOTE 10:29:
    Douglas Flint

    A vote in favour of Scottish independence could lead to "capital flight" from the country, HSBC chairman Douglas Flint has told the Daily Telegraph. He said this could leave Scotland's financial system in a "parlous state". Writing in the paper, Mr Flint says the sterling currency union has been an "anchor of financial stability" for Scotland.

     
  11.  
    AGA RESULTS 10:16:
    aga

    Aga, the oven maker, has said revenues for the first half of the year were up 3.3% to £123.5m. Operating profits were up 60% to £2.4m. "Our markets have picked up but remain inconsistent and variable. Uncertainties around mortgage availability and interest rates are a contributing factor," it said.

     
  12.  
    MARKET UPDATE 10:03:

    Shares in Vodafone have risen 0.8% this morning following a report that it could be a bid target for US telecoms firm AT&T. AstraZeneca shares are up a further 0.7% so far today. Shares in Astra jumped 3% yesterday on speculation that US rival Pfizer could be preparing another bid for the pharmaceutical firm, following its failed takeover attempt earlier this year.

     
  13.  
    ADVERTISING 09:49: BBC Radio 4

    Kate Robertson, co-global president and UK chairman of Havas Worldwide - one of the world's largest marketing communications agencies, was the Friday boss on the Today programme. She says her industry is a barometer of economic conditions - in 2009 its UK business saw revenues drop 9% from the year before, but this year UK revenues are up about 12% so far.

     
  14.  
    YELLEN SPEECH 09:34: BBC Radio 4
    Janet Yellen

    All eyes will be on US Federal Reserve chair Janet Yellen later when she addresses a gathering of central bankers and other policymakers at Jackson Hole, Wyoming. Analysts will be studying the speech for clues as to when the US might raise rates. James Bevan at CCLA Investment Management tells Today that she wants to see wage inflation picking up before taking action.

     
  15.  
    LONDON STOCK EXCHANGE 09:19:

    In addition to setting out plans for a rights issue, the London Stock Exchange has also announced a big rise in quarterly profits following a "resurgence in the IPO market". The surge in the number of firms floating shares on the market helped to push pre-tax profits for the three months to June to £83.6m, up 40% from a year earlier.

     
  16.  
    AIRPORT SURVEY 09:05: BBC Breakfast
    BBC Breakfast

    Some of Britain's biggest and busiest airports have been named as the worst for customer satisfaction by the consumer group Which?. Smaller airports did much better, including Doncaster Sheffield airport, where Dominic Laurie is for BBC Breakfast. Aviation analyst Laurie Price says smaller airports have a great opportunity but are hard pressed to compete with bigger airports which have the greater volume of flights.

     
  17.  
    MARKET UPDATE 08:50:

    European stocks are largely up before a key speech from US Federal Reserve chief Janet Yellen. She is due to speak at a gathering of central bankers in Jackson Hole, Wyoming, as investors continue to speculate on the direction of US interest rates.

    • London's benchmark FTSE 100 index rose 0.04% to 6,780.08 points
    • Frankfurt's Dax gained 0.12% to 9,390.29
    • The CAC 40 index in Paris fell 0.04% to 4,291.06
     
  18.  
    EDF ENERGY 08:36:
    Gas rings

    "We recognise that for a period of time the service to our customers was not up to the standards they deserve," says Beatrice Bigois from EDF Energy following this morning's announcement from Ofgem that it will pay out £3m. "We apologise to those customers who were impacted during this period. We have co-operated fully with Ofgem and have taken this matter very seriously."

     
  19.  
    MARKET UPDATE 08:17:

    After nine consecutive days of gains, Japan's Nikkei share index has closed lower. The benchmark index ended the day down 47.01 points at 15,539.19. In Hong Kong, the Hang Seng is up 104.96 points at 25,099.06.

     
  20.  
    CO-OP BANK RESULTS 08:08: Radio 5 live

    Chris Wheeler, a banking analyst at Mediobanca, is on 5 live talking about the Co-op Bank results. He says "there are signs of progress" but still "problems they have to deal with," including a drop in deposits. A reduction in money set aside for bad debts "flattered" the profit figures, he said.

     
  21.  
    BANK OF AMERICA 08:01: Radio 5 live

    Bank of America can easily afford the record $16.7bn (£10bn) settlement with US authorities for misleading investors about the quality of loans it sold, US investment expert George Conboy tells Radio 5 live. He says the bank is likely to make $10-15bn over the next 12 months.

     
  22.  
    CO-OP BANK RESULTS 07:54:

    An offer of shares to the public via a stock market listing is "logistically unlikely" before the end of 2014, the Co-op Bank says. It is setting up a committee to work out when it will do that. The Prudential Regulation Authority "has indicated it would be concerned if an IPO were to distract focus from the primary goal of delivering the Bank's Turnaround Plan," it said.

     
  23.  
    ARGENTINA DEBT 07:46: BBC Radio 4

    Argentina risks becoming an "international financial pariah" again over its latest debt row, James Bevan, chief investment officer at CCLA Investment Management tells the Today programme. "The problem is that investors won't trust them, [so] they won't provide money," he says.

     
  24.  
     
  25.  
    LSE RIGHTS ISSUE 07:35:
    LSE sign

    The London Stock Exchange has said it plans to raise £938m through a rights issue. The money is to be used to part-fund the acquisition of Frank Russell Company. The LSE announced in June it was buying the US asset manager for $2.7bn (£1.6bn).

     
  26.  
    PPI SPENDING 07:25: Radio 5 live

    Consumers have about £23bn of payment protection insurance redress from banks, says James Bevan, Chief Investment Officer at CCLA Investment Management on Wake Up to Money. When that dries up, it may have an effect on spending, he says.

     
  27.  
    EDF ENERGY PENALTY 07:15:

    Ofgem said it found that between May 2011 and January 2012, "EDF Energy did not have appropriate procedures in place to properly receive, record and process all customers' complaints in accordance with complaints handling rules". However, it adds EDF took action quickly to rectify the problems. It also says EDF "has acknowledged that their customers were caused significant disruption" and has apologised.

     
  28.  
    CO-OP BANK RESULTS 07:09:
    bank

    Co-operative Bank has reported a loss of £75.8m for the six months to the end of June. That compares with a loss of £845m the year earlier. The bank says it has cut staff numbers by 21% from a year earlier to 5,860.

     
  29.  
    EDF ENERGY PENALTY Breaking News
    EDF bill

    EDF Energy is to pay £3m after an investigation by energy regulator Ofgem found that the company breached complaint-handling rules. The company will pay the money "to benefit vulnerable customers", Ofgem says.

     
  30.  
    BANK OF AMERICA 06:55: BBC Radio 4

    Chris Wheeler, an analyst at Mediobanca, has been discussing Bank of America's massive $16.7bn settlement with US authorities. He told the Today programme that while banks were at fault, investors were also "in a hurry" at the time, and failed to carry out proper credit analysis of what they were buying.

     
  31.  
    EUROZONE 06:44: Radio 5 live
    ECB headquarters

    James Bevan is chief investment officer at CCLA Investment Management and he's on Wake Up to Money talking about the eurozone's performance. "Interest rates are so low" in some of the countries that when you factor in the risk of investing the rates are negative, he says. Sustainable growth in the UK hasn't yet been seen either, he says. with house price growth and PPI repayments from banks driving consumer spending.

     
  32.  
    GAP IN INDIA 06:30:
    Gap logo

    US clothing store Gap is bringing its brand to India, aiming to open 40 outlets. It will launch its first two stores there early next year in Mumbai and the capital Delhi - India's biggest and busiest cities.

     
  33.  
    BANK OF AMERICA 06:20: Radio 5 live
    Bank of America

    Chris Orndorff, a fund manager at Western Asset Management is on Wake Up to Money talking about Bank of America's record $16.7bn settlement. The penalty dates back to the behaviour of a company it purchased, Countrywide. "The timing of the Countrywide purchase has to be one of the worst in history," he says. The fine wipes out the cumulative net income of the bank for the last three years. The bank is very safe though, he says.

     
  34.  
    ARGENTINA DEBT 06:06:

    Argentina's plan to exit its debt default by asking investors holding defaulted bonds to swap them for new locally issued debt has been ruled "illegal" by a US court. New York Judge Thomas Griesa said the plan was "lawless". Argentina was trying to get around an earlier court ruling banning it from paying interest to investors who had accepted restructured bonds.

     
  35.  
    OIL PRICE 06:00: Radio 5 live
    Oil barrels

    After rising sharply in June, oil prices have now slipped back to 14-month lows. Amrita Sen from Energy Aspects tells Wake Up to Money. She says that "the initial price rise was on the back of the fears should any disruptions come at peak demand". However, despite geopolitical risks, supply has remained undisrupted while demand has fallen.

     
  36.  
    06:00: Nick Edser, Business reporter

    Good morning. Get in touch with us via email: bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or on twitter @BBCBusiness.

     
  37.  
    06:00: Howard Mustoe, Business Reporter

    Hello! We'll be bringing you all the latest business news, data and analysis. Stay with us.

     

Features

From BBC Capital

Programmes

  • Hitch-hiking robot HitchBOTClick Watch

    Hitch-hiking robot HitchBOT completes a 6,000km (3,700-mile) trip plus other tech news

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.