Corruption and bribery in the classroom

Corruption The global survey warns of the corrosive impact of corruption in education

Corruption in education is a serious blight that undermines the quality and availability of schools and universities around the world, according to an international report.

Anti-corruption campaigners Transparency International have published a global survey showing that about one in six students has had to pay a bribe for education services.

In parts of sub-Saharan Africa and Asia this might be requiring parents to pay a fee for a school place that should be free.

In Eastern Europe, it might be paying to gain an advantage in university admissions.

The Berlin-based campaign group is best known for its annual "global corruption barometer", which measures levels of dishonest payments in more than 100 countries, based on more than 114,000 household interviews.

This year's survey also asked questions about people's first-hand experiences and perceptions of dishonesty in education.

'Shadow schools'

In some countries these perceptions are distinctively negative. The report says that almost three-quarters of people in Cameroon and Russia see their education systems as "corrupt or highly corrupt".

Teacher protest in Brazil Accusations of corruption have fuelled teachers' protests in Brazil

The findings show a huge range of malpractice.

In Pakistan, there are warnings of thousands of "shadow schools" without any real students, but drawing public funding to pay for "ghost teachers".

"Leakages" in the funding of schools in Kenya had the equivalent value of losing more than 11 million text books, says the report. A study of 180 schools in Tanzania showed that more than a third of intended funds had failed to reach the school.

In Greece there are warnings about nepotism in jobs and promotions in higher education.

In Vietnam there is a problem with bribery for places in the most sought-after schools.

The report quotes figures from the United Nations showing 110 countries where fees are levied, despite in theory having free education enshrined in law. The report describes "myriad pretexts" to impose charges on parents.

Degrees of dishonesty

So why should education be so vulnerable to corruption?

Parents want the best for their children, says the report, and they can be exploited by unscrupulous officials controlling access to places.

African school There is still a struggle to provide enough school places in Africa

It also involves a great deal of public money filtering down from central government to local school authorities. In Nigeria, the report says, $21m (£13m) intended for schools was lost in two years.

But it's not only a problem for the developing world or those providing the basics of schooling.

The massive expansion in demand for university education has created rich opportunities for illicit charges.

Students need degree-level qualifications more than ever and are under great pressure to get university places and to leave with good grades, opening up fertile territory for corruption and cheating.

Eastern European and former Soviet states are highlighted as having had particular difficulties.

In Georgia, there have been reforms to stop corruption in university admissions. This hadn't simply been "cash-filled envelopes", but included a complex system of having to buy tutoring, Transparency International found.

There could also be more practical types of illicit charges, with suggestions that in Romania access to university accommodation depended on bribery.

Graduate tail

The demand for qualifications has also generated its own industry in fake universities.

In the United States, the report estimates, there are about a thousand "degree mills" in operation, selling bogus qualifications.

Anti-corruption rally in Philippines An anti-corruption rally in the Philippines against "pork barrel" politics

This isn't only harmless self-delusion, says the report, as these bought qualifications are used to gain graduate jobs, including in one case working in a nuclear power plant.

It also highlights the case of Colby Nolan, a student who ostensibly gained an MBA degree in 2004, until his owner revealed that the graduate was a six-year-old cat. He had gained the equivalent of an upper second class degree.

The growth of higher education as a globalised, multi-billion dollar business has also spawned a parallel opportunity for fraud, says Philip Altbach, director of the Center for International Higher Education in the Lynch School of Education at Boston College.

He has described the "spectre of corruption haunting" the move towards a more internationalised higher education system.

And he has called for more co-ordinated international efforts to set standards and share information.

'Integrity pledge'

The Transparency International study says that corruption has a corrosive effect on education, raising the cost and lowering the quality.

"Many people wouldn't realise the extent of corruption in education, right through from the financing of education through to academic corruption," says report editor, Gareth Sweeney.

School in Lahore A school in Lahore, Pakistan - but there are other "ghost schools" without pupils

"In some countries it's such a serious problem that it could undermine the credibility of their education systems."

There is some good news as the report highlights efforts to tackle bribery.

In Chile, anti-corruption lessons have been introduced to the school curriculum and in Bangladesh there is an "integrity pledge" taken by officials.

The proliferation of mobile phones in Africa is being used to allow people to expose concerns about bribery in schools.

Legal advice centres have also been developed in a number of countries to help community groups make legal challenges against school corruption.

There are also international efforts to improve the monitoring and tracking of education funds.

Human right

But corruption is still there leaching away education budgets. It's a particularly bleak problem when there are still tens of millions of children without any access to school.

"Corruption is an obstacle to a fundamental human right to education," says Mr Sweeney.

While there are campaigners calling for education for all, such as Malala Yousafzai in Pakistan, this report also warns of the barriers being created for the poorest communities by demands for corrupt payments.

Teachers take bribes to offset poor wages or irregular payments and that in turn raises questions about the lack of funding coming from higher up the chain.

Mr Sweeney says that there should be a way of measuring good governance in any future global education targets.

"Even when formal school fees are abolished, many households are still being forced to pay informal fees. How is a family supposed to be able to afford these costs, when they cannot afford their daily meals?," says Pauline Rose, director of Unesco's Global Monitoring Report, which tracks progress towards primary education for all.

"Until these hidden costs are eradicated, we will not be able to call education free, and universal primary education will continue to remain a distant goal for the poorest."

Is corruption a problem for education systems around the world? What can be done to prevent it? Is it being taken seriously enough?

I taught as a public lecturer in Pakistan. Teaching is considered to be one of the most respectable professions but it's rampant with corruption. It's all about who you are and what your background is in terms of political contacts. Many teachers can play the 'ghost' but not with the tacit approval and some kind of backing by higher authorities. In short, teaching is based upon hierarchies and so has become the acquisition of education, especially amongst the elite class which has access to a form of knowledge which is, I would say, purchasable. Sadly enough, this class will go abroad and buy internationally recognized degrees in order to occupy top positions back home while someone else is paid to write their assignments and secure them the necessary grades . (This is a very common practice amongst international students studying in universities in England).Their is no criteria to check the merit of teachers but a piece of paper.

Jaleel, Calgary

Overpopulation, insufficient number of schools, government failure to fund education properly, poor remuneration of teachers are some of the main factors aiding corruption in the education sector. Once the public education sector has been destroyed, the private sector-driven education becomes so expensive only the elites can afford it. The solution is to enforce existing legislation to strengthen quality in public schools, build more schools, train more teachers. When supplies outstrip demand corruption can be kicked out.

Omole, Abuja, Nigeria

Corruption and bribery perhaps exists indirectly in the United Kingdom in relation to its education policies, in terms of catchment areas seeing that many children are placed at a disadvantage in terms of their parents socio-economic status. This often affects where they can and cannot go to school which in the long term affects their future life chances. Perhaps we need to focus on dealing with the discrepancies at home rather than concerning ourselves with issues abroad.

Shade, Essex

If you are happy to be contacted by a BBC journalist please leave a telephone number that we can contact you on. In some cases a selection of your comments will be published, displaying your name as you provide it and location, unless you state otherwise. Your contact details will never be published. When sending us pictures, video or eyewitness accounts at no time should you endanger yourself or others, take any unnecessary risks or infringe any laws. Please ensure you have read the terms and conditions.

Terms and conditions

More on This Story

More Business stories

RSS

BBC Business Live

  1.  
    LISTEN AGAIN 12:15: World Service
    Russia

    The conflict in Ukraine is intensifying and the EU is preparing a new wave of sanctions against Russia, but what leverage does it have left? Business Daily talks to Lilit Gevorgyan, senior Russian analyst at IHS, who says Europe's dependence on Russian gas will limit their room to move.

     
  2.  
    GERMAN SURPLUS 12:00:

    Germany posted a surplus in its public finances for the first six months of 2014, while economic growth faltered. The country's local and national budgets had a surplus of 16.1bn euros (£12.7bn), helped by high employment.

     
  3.  
    TRUCK WARNING 11:40:
    Trucks

    The Daily Mail reports that lorry drivers are being ordered to avoid the French port of Calais, because of confrontations with migrants - some of them armed - who are trying to get to Britain. The Times says Britons returning from summer holidays with caravans and motor-homes are also being targeted by groups of migrants trying to break into their vehicles.

     
  4.  
    UK MANUFACTURING Via Email Robin Johnson head of diversified industrials at law firm Eversheds

    "Everything still points to a strong and sustainable recovery in manufacturing in the UK. The weakness of the eurozone is a negative impact as is the strength of sterling. Long term investment in training and research and development must also be maintained... While today's numbers may show a slight dip, the overall long term prognosis is very positive."

     
  5.  
    RAIL OVERTIME BAN 11:12:

    Rail managers plan a three-week ban on weekend overtime which they say may disrupt travel across the network. More than 2,000 members of the Transport Salaried Staffs Association (TSSA) are protesting at a below-inflation pay offer and will begin industrial action on Friday.

     
  6.  
    RUSSIAN SANCTIONS 10:55:
    Russian President Vladimir Putin

    Russian President Vladimir Putin said he hopes "common sense" will win the day concerning the prospect of more sanctions, according to Russian news agency Interfax. "I hope that common sense will prevail and we will work in a normal modern way, and that neither we nor our partners will bear the costs of these mutual jabs," the agency reported him as saying.

     
  7.  
    SCHOOL COMPUTING Via Twitter Rory Cellan-Jones Technology correspondent

    tweets: New computing curriculum in England comes in this term and will mean children as young as 5 will learn about algorithms - blog from me later

     
  8.  
    NATO COMES TO NEWPORT 10:25:
    Celtic Manor Resort, Newport

    "Every hotel between Swansea and Swindon" will be fully booked as a result of the Nato summit coming to Newport in Wales. That's according to Simon Gibson, director of the Celtic Manor resort, where the event will take place on Thursday. He added there could be "lucrative benefits if Wales showcases itself correctly" and that the summit was a "massive opportunity" for the Welsh economy.

     
  9.  
    EUROZONE MANUFACTURING 10:10:
    Flags

    News from the Eurozone is no better, alas. Manufacturing growth slowed to a 13-month low in August, as the PMI reading dipped to 50.7 - down from 51.8 in July. New orders dwindled and factories suffered amid rising tensions between the EU and Russia over Ukraine.

     
  10.  
    HEADLINES
    • UK and EU manufacturing growth slows
    • Fund manager abandons HSBC over fines
    • Mortgage approvals fall in UK
     
  11.  
    UK MANUFACTURING 09:56:

    The UK's manufacturing industry grew at the slowest rate in 14 months in August, following a drop in new orders. The Manufacturing Purchasing Managers' Index, or PMI, fell to 52.5, the lowest since June last year. A reading above 50 indicates growth.

     
  12.  
    WOODFORD ABANDONS HSBC 09:39:
    HSBC

    Neil Woodford, one of the UK's most well-known fund managers, has sold his stake in HSBC. "I am worried that the ongoing investigation into the historic manipulation of Libor and foreign exchange markets could expose HSBC to significant financial penalties," he said on his website. Mr Woodford had 2.68% of his fund's assets invested in HSBC, a package worth £64m at the time of sale.

     
  13.  
    UK MORTGAGES 09:33:

    The Bank of England says British mortgage approvals fell slightly in July compared with the previous month, to 66,569. In January, the measure reached 76,000, but has been wavering as the housing market shows some signs of cooling.

     
  14.  
    MARKET REPORT 09:26:

    The major European stock markets have had a muted start this morning.

    • The FTSE 100 is down 0.12% at 6811.88
    • The Dax is up 0.02% at 9472.17
    • The Cac 40 is down 0.12% at 4375.75

    BAE Systems is the biggest winner in London, up almost 3%, while Morrison Supermarkets has dropped 2.25%.

     
  15.  
    ISLAND FLING 09:11:
    Apia

    Some conferences are more appealing than others. The third UN Conference on Small Island Developing States begins in Apia, Samoa today. Some 50 countries are invited, and the agenda covers a wide-range of topics, including sustainable energy, water and sanitation, and biodiversity.

     
  16.  
    Via Twitter Jamie McGeever, chief markets correspondent for Europe, Reuters

    tweets: "Italian manufacturing sector contracts for first time in over a year. PMI falls to 49.8 in Aug from 51.9 in July, expected 50.8."

     
  17.  
    PERFORM BUYOUT 08:50:

    Perform Group, which owns the Omnisport sport news agency, rose 26% to 256.7 pence in London after Access Industries Group said it would buy the company. It already owns 42.5%.

     
  18.  
    SAMSUNG EXPANDS 08:35:
    Samsung

    South Korean giant Samsung Group is to become even bigger, Bloomberg reports, after merging its shipbuilding and engineering units. Shares in both firms rose as a result of the announcement.

     
  19.  
    ECUADOR'S BITCOIN 08:19:

    Ecuador says its new digital currency will begin circulating in December. The electronic money will be the first backed by a central bank, and will work alongside the country's current currency - the US dollar. The president says it will help poorer people gain access to banking.

     
  20.  
    MICROSOFT ULTIMATUM 08:06:
    Microsoft China

    The clock is ticking for Microsoft in China. Competition authorities have given the firm 20 days to reply to questions over the compatibility of some of its software, Reuters reports. Microsoft is one of several foreign companies that have come under scrutiny in the country in recent weeks.

     
  21.  
    PUTIN SEEKS PARTITION 07:51:
    Putin

    The Financial Times leads with Vladimir Putin's call for talks on "statehood" for south-east Ukraine. The paper calls it a provocative comment, which will heighten fears that Moscow is seeking partition for Ukraine. The Daily Telegraph says David Cameron and Barack Obama are to respond to the Russian president by urging NATO allies to increase defence spending. In a leader article the paper also recommends fresh sanctions.

     
  22.  
    BERKELEY PERFORMANCE 07:37:

    Berkeley Group, the home builder, is having its annual meeting today. The firm is "well positioned to continue to invest in the business and deliver returns to shareholders. Earnings this year are anticipated to be in line with current market expectations," chairman Tony Pidgley will say.

     
  23.  
    KIER CONTRACT 07:23:

    Kier Group, the builder, says it is the preferred bidder to design and build a new £50m residential tower in London. The company says it will "design and construct 224 luxury apartments arranged in four blocks".

     
  24.  
    GOING SOUTH 07:11:
    St Andrews

    The Guardian reports that Scotland's top universities are bracing themselves for a "brain drain" of their most talented scientists if there's a "yes" vote for independence. The paper says senior figures believe Scotland's best known universities would lose access to billions of pounds of funding - the subjects most at risk are said to include advanced computing and genetic research. However a source close to the Scottish government says the concerns are misplaced and research funding will be maintained.

     
  25.  
    CUBAN IMPORTS 06:57:

    New rules are coming into force in Cuba, limiting the amount of goods people can take into the country in their luggage. For example, Cubans will be allowed only 10 kilos of detergent rather than 40, 24 bras rather than 48, and just two flat screen televisions. Many Cubans see the new restrictions as throttling one of the few sources of high-quality consumer goods.

     
  26.  
    RAC LISTING 06:47: Radio 5 live
    RAC rescue vehicle

    Holly Cook, of Morningstar, was on 5 live too, talking about the car breakdown specialists RAC, who are said to be considering a stock market flotation. How come? It shows "more confidence in the market" and may be seen as a good investment as its business is easily understood, she says.

     
  27.  
    FINANCE LITERACY 06:41: Radio 5 live

    Tracey Bleakley adds that the first rule of money management is "knowing the difference between something you need and something you want." Think about that in the lunch queue.

     
  28.  
    FINANCE LITERACY 06:35: Radio 5 live
    Classroom

    Tracey Bleakley, chief executive of the Personal Finance Education Group is talking about the government's new plan to provide education on financial planning. "We've all got to talk about it," she says, adding that children could educate their parents. That way people can see through "the marketing" that lots of debt is a good idea.

     
  29.  
    TESCO PERFORMANCE 06:30: Radio 5 live

    Tesco is struggling to compete with the likes of Aldi and Lidl because the smaller supermarkets stock fewer lines and focus on keeping prices low. "Tesco are giving people far too many reasons to go elsewhere," Steve Dresser, retail analyst, tells Wake up to Money.

     
  30.  
    TESCO'S NEXT MOVE 06:27: BBC Radio 4

    Tesco's new boss, Dave Lewis, starts work today at the beleaguered supermarket chain, and Holly Cook, of the investment site Morningstar, tells Today that his first move may be to slash prices. Tesco, she says, "used to be a value proposition," but is now "not that much cheaper" than its rivals.

     
  31.  
    EU REVOLT 06:20:
    Cameron

    In its main front page story, the Independent says David Cameron is facing a damaging new revolt over Europe. It says up to 100 Conservative MPs are planning to defy him by declaring that they'll vote to leave the EU - regardless of what concessions he wins for Britain.

     
  32.  
    NETWORK RAIL 06:17: Radio 5 live

    Philip Haigh, railway writer, is still on Wake up to Money. Why is Network Rail in £33bn of debt? It's been spending lots of late, he says. Railway stations, for example, have never looked better. "You just have to look at King's Cross and see what they've done there," he says.

     
  33.  
    BORIS TAKES OFF 06:14:

    Boris's comments come as we await news on whether the Airports Commission will put his favoured plan for a Thames estuary airport back onto its shortlist of options. Incidentally, Mr Johnson is seeking nomination as the Conservative parliamentary candidate in Uxbridge and South Ruislip - where Heathrow expansion is widely opposed.

     
  34.  
    BORIS TAKES OFF 06:07:
    Plane over Heathrow

    The Telegraph carries a piece by the Mayor of London, Boris Johnson, in which he warns that expanding Heathrow, and ditching his plan for a new airport in the Thames estuary, would be a "disaster". But Mr Johnson, who has previously called for the closure of Heathrow, now suggests it could remain open as a secondary airport.

     
  35.  
    NETWORK RAIL 06:03: Radio 5 live

    Philip Haigh, railway writer, is on Wake up to Money, talking about Network Rail's move to the government's balance sheet. On the one hand, he says, it means the state-owned company can borrow more cheaply from the government, but the government will also be able to appoint directors and intervene in things like executive pay.

     
  36.  
    06:01: Howard Mustoe Business reporter

    Morning! Get in touch via email bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or via Twitter @BBCBusiness

     
  37.  
    06:00: Joe Miller Business Reporter

    Good morning. It's a good day for current account holders - particularly those who have experienced the maddening misfortune of being charged for going overdrawn by a few pennies. Banks will now have to give customers until 2pm to cover funds before slapping on a levy. Stay tuned for reaction to that news, and the rest of the business headlines.

     

Features

  • Polish and British flags alongside British roadsideWar debt

    Does the UK still feel a sense of obligation towards Poles?


  • Alana Saarinen at pianoMum Dad and Mum

    The girl who has three biological parents


  • Islamic State fighters parade in Raqqa, Syria (30 June 2014)Who backs IS?

    Where Islamic State finds support to become a formidable force


  • Spanish volunteer Rafa Munoz Perez practising with a rifle in Donetsk, 7 August Motley crew

    The Europeans who pitch up in Ukraine to join the fight


From BBC Capital

Programmes

  • Volcanic eruptionThe Travel Show Watch

    Uncovering the secrets of the Icelandic island buried by a volcanic eruption

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.