Junior Isas: Is confusion still putting parents off?

Iris and Tilly Tilly (right) is already learning about the value of money with friend Iris

Two years ago this month, the government's tax-free savings plan for youngsters - the Junior Isa - opened for business.

But has the decision over which Isa (Individual Savings Account) to invest in got any easier?

The Isa allows parents, grandparents or family friends to invest in cash or stocks and shares for their children's future.

Six million children are eligible for Junior Isas, but only around 300,000 parents are actually choosing to invest. Many are still confused about what type of Junior Isa is right for them.

'Confusing'

Junior Isas come in two forms - a cash Isa or a stocks and shares Isa.

Research from Isa provider Family Investments shows only a small proportion of those who have chosen to open a Junior Isa have decided to invest in stocks and shares.

This is despite the fact that stocks tend to outperform cash, meaning the returns you get if your Isa is invested in the stock market could be much higher.

Yet, there is also risk that the investment can fall further in value than cash.

Start Quote

The problem with investing in stocks and shares is that there isn't just one fund available”

End Quote Sarah Pennells Savvywoman

Carolyn Moore is a professional caterer and mother to one-year-old Tilly. She says she wants to save for her daughter's future but is confused about which option is best for her.

"There are so many Junior Isas out there," says Carolyn. "The cash one and the shares one, and there is not a lot of time to go and investigate all those, especially with my daughter around, so it gets really confusing where to start and you end up doing nothing."

Carolyn says she is planning to look into Isas for Tilly because she wants to help when she becomes an adult.

"It's good for them to have a good start when they turn 18," she says. "Although I think a lot of parents also worry that they do all the saving and then their children spend it all, but I suppose that's where you try and teach them the value of money, we hope!"

Risky returns

The research from Family Investments shows over the 12 months to October, money invested in certain stocks and shares would have offered a return of more than 15%, whereas the same amount of money invested in the best buy cash Isa would provide a return of just over 3%.

Babies Parents can save through a tax-free Junior Isa to provide a nest-egg for their children

Christine Ross, head of wealth planning at SGPB Hambros, believes stocks and shares are a better bet for someone investing for the long haul.

"If someone is going to invest for the very long term, and by that I mean more than 10 years, in cash in real terms, the money is probably going to lose its buying power," she says.

"Interest rates are very low at the moment and inflation, the rate at which prices increase, is growing faster than the amount you get in interest.

"Over the long term, and for a child that could be the next 17 or 18 years until they get the money, that money could buy a very small proportion of what it can buy today."

Spreading money around

However, not everyone agrees that taking a risk is the best idea for parents.

"I think it can be a bit confusing for parents trying to work out which Junior Isa to choose," says financial expert Sarah Pennells, founder of Savvywoman.

"If they go down the stocks and shares route they should, over the longer term, do better.

"The problem with investing in stocks and shares is that there isn't just one fund available so you've got to pick your fund first of all and secondly you've got to look at the charges because they can make quite a difference, especially over the longer term."

A fifth of parents say they do not understand enough about investments and the stock market, according to the research from Family Investments, and more than 40% of those questioned do not want to take risks with their child's money.

"Stocks and shares are risky but there are different ways of making your investments less risky," says Christine Ross. "One way of doing that is to invest over a longer term, another way is to spread your money well - they call it diversification but all it means is spreading your money around, not having all your eggs in one basket."

It seems parents feel more of a responsibility when it comes to their children's savings than with their own and can be more risk averse.

The advice from experts is to have a look at what is available and choose something that suits you and your child - to provide a nest-egg in years to come.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories

RSS

BBC Business Live

  1.  
    DEUTSCHE BANK FINED 10:50:

    The FCA is very cheesed off indeed with Deutsche Bank. The bank failed properly to report 29 million, yes 29 million, of these deals. "There is simply no excuse for Deutsche's failure to get this right," thunders the FCA.

     
  2.  
    DEUTSCHE BANK FINED 10:47:

    Another day, another bank fine. Deutsche Bank in London has been fined £4.7m by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). It's crime was to incorrectly report transactions between November 2007 and April 2013 involving "contracts for difference" - a derivative that lets people bet on share price movements.

     
  3.  
    KITTY NOT CAT 10:20:
    Kitty visa card

    With something of a jolt, Business Live stumbles on this story from our youthful colleagues at Newsbeat. Japanese top icon Hello Kitty is not a cat. An anthropologist from the University of Hawaii who is organising an exhibition about the cartoon character, says owners Sanrio got in touch: "That's one correction Sanrio made for my script for the show. Hello Kitty is not a cat. She is a little girl." And, incidentally, an English one, she was told.

     
  4.  
    FUNDING FOR LENDING 10:06:

    It is worth noting that the raison d'etre of the FLS scheme may have expired. As the bank pointed out earlier this month, overall bank lending to non-financial businesses rose slightly in the second quarter of the year. That was the first such increase since 2009 and the bank expects it to keep on improving.

     
  5.  
    FUNDING FOR LENDING 09:49:
    Money

    Figures from the Bank of England show that its Funding for Lending Scheme, which has revived the mortgage industry, has still not increased lending by participating banks to small, medium sized, or large businesses. The Bank says in the second quarter of this year, banks and building societies borrowed a further £3.2bn from it under the scheme. But in fact lending by those banks to their business customers shrank again, by a further £3.9bn.

     
  6.  
    FRACKING CASE 09:29:

    Frackers have some backers. A court will hear a case later from farmers and landowners trying to evict anti-fracking protestors from sites in Lancashire. The group of 10 landowners say the protests on sites at Little Plumpton and Rosacre Wood have been affecting business. Their legal action is being supported by the shale gas company Cuadrilla.

     
  7.  
    MARKETS UPDATE 09:09:

    European shares have opened lower. The FTSE 100 is down 15 at 6,815. Frankfurt's Dax is 64 lower at 9,505 and Paris's Cac 40 is down 17 at 4,378. London shares are lower after key mining companies' shares fell in response to a fall in the price of iron ore in China. The pound is not much changed at $1.6585 and at 1 euro 25.56.

     
  8.  
    RUSSIAN HACKING? 08:50:

    Our World Service colleagues are reporting that the FBI is investigating reports that Russian-backed hackers are suspected of launching a co-ordinated attack on American banks' computer networks. The FBI says it is trying to find out whether the attack on JP Morgan, one of the biggest US banks, along with four other financial institutions, was in retaliation for sanctions against Russia. The hacking is reported to have involved the theft of sensitive customer data.

     
  9.  
    PADDY POWER 08:29:
    David Moyes statue outside Anfield

    The betting business says it has experienced a record 35% rise in the number of new customers at 795,000 more punters. It says it has done this without increasing spending on marketing. Spending on stunts, however, included these: "We put an 'In case of emergency break glass' encased Alex Ferguson wax model outside Old Trafford... and erected a giant bronze statue of Moyes for services rendered - outside Anfield before the Liverpool versus Chelsea showdown."

     
  10.  
    AEROFLOT RESULTS 08:18:
    Aeroflot

    More airline news. Russia's state-controlled Aeroflot reports a loss of 1.9bn roubles (£35m) for the first half of 2014. That compares to a 45m rouble profit a year ago. The slowdown in the economy and a fall in the value of the rouble against other world currencies are among the reasons.

     
  11.  
    QANTAS 08:03:
    Kangaroo

    Shares in the Flying Kangaroo are up 7.3% at A$139 in the wake of its hefty loss. "We are focused now in the short to medium term on the transformation program," said chief executive Alan Joyce. "We are not actively out there looking for an airline investor." Investors are actively buying its shares though - a new law is opening the doors to foreign investment in the international arm of the airline.

     
  12.  
    AA RESIGNATIONS 07:48:
    AA logo

    There seems to be some upheaval at the top of the AA. Its chief executive Chris Jansen is resigning immediately. The chief financial officer Andy Boland is leaving too.

     
  13.  
    ICE SALES 07:39: Radio 5 live
    Alex Brown of Exeter Chiefs takes part in the Ice Bucket Challenge

    The charity ice bucket challenge appears to be boosting the sale of ice cubes. Tesco says they're up 20%. Paul Doughty, managing director of The Ice Company told Wake up to Money his firm had been busy restocking supermarkets - which saw big sales last weekend. But he explained that this was a bit of a challenge. "At this time of year, we are actually ramping down production, sales get run down over the summer, and we start to reduce our staffing levels in our factories through August."

     
  14.  
    LIVING WAGE 07:31:

    What is is? It is set at £8.80 an hour for London and £7.65 for the rest of the UK. Find out here. The minimum wage - the government's base line, is £6.31.

     
  15.  
    PADDY POWER 07:26:
    Paddy Power pic from website

    Betting giant Paddy Power says pre-tax profits are down 13% at £62m for the first half of the year. The company says many football punters had "dream weekends" in January and March, with 16 and then 17 teams of the 21 most backed winning. "This proved costlier than John Cleese's divorce", says Paddy.

     
  16.  
    HAYS RESULTS 07:16:

    Profits have risen at the recruitment business Hays, which operates in 33 countries. Profits rose 12% in the past year to £132m. Dividends are up 5%. "In many of our global markets, the vast majority of professional and skilled recruitment is still done in-house, with minimal outsourcing to recruitment agencies which presents substantial long-term structural growth opportunities," the company said.

     
  17.  
    LIVING WAGE 07:05: BBC Radio 4

    On the TUC Living Wage story: TUC general secretary Frances O'Grady tells Today that women come off worse because there is low value attached to the jobs women tend to do, such as care working and shop work.

     
  18.  
    LIVING WAGE 06:53: BBC Radio 4
    Care worker

    Today is discussing the Living Wage concept. In many parts of Britain, women working part-time earn less than the Living Wage, says the TUC. Three quarters of part-time women workers in Lancashire do, as do two thirds of part-time women workers in West Somerset. TUC chief Frances O'Grady explains: "The minimum wage is an absolute floor, the Living Wage is the level that means you can take your children on holiday for a week - nothing fancy." The minimum wage is £6.31.

     
  19.  
    QANTAS 06:42:

    Can Qantas solve its huge financial problems? The BBC's Phil Mercer in Sydney says: "The airline's annual accounts have become a horror story of decline as it tries to chart a path back to profit and sustainability". Read more.

     
  20.  
    MALAYSIA AIRLINES 06:32: BBC Radio 4

    Can an airline survive two major plane disasters in a single year? Today says that's the question for Malaysia Airlines. Those who have flown on the airline recently report near empty cabins. Can Malaysian Airlines survive? David Learmount from Flightglobal thinks so. "Malaysia will be given a chance by the government and it will be given some money. People don't like seeing airlines go bust," he told Today listeners.

     
  21.  
    BUSINESS LENDING 06:22: Radio 5 live

    Wake Up to Money looks forward to later this morning when the Bank of England will give us an update on its Funding for Lending scheme - introduced two years ago to encourage banks to lend to small businesses. It's not been a rip-roaring success: a previous report said, despite all that help, the amount of money being lent was down £2.7bn over the first three months of this year.

     
  22.  
    QANTAS 06:12:
    A Qantas Airline plane gets takes off at Sydney Airport in Sydney on August 28, 2014

    Overnight Australia's national airline Qantas reported a huge loss of A$2.8bn for the past year - its biggest ever. That was partly due to writing down the value of its planes by A$2.6bn. Qantas added weak domestic demand, poor consumer spending and rising fuel costs also contributed. Chief executive Alan Joyce tried to put some gloss on the figures: "There is no doubt today's numbers are confronting... but they represent the year that is past".

     
  23.  
    SCOTTISH INDEPENDENCE 06:03:
    Saltire

    Pro-independence business people in Scotland have hit back. 200 of them have signed a letter, appearing in the Herald online, saying that the business case for independence "has been made - and it's strong and ambitious". They add: "The real threat to Scotland is the real possibility of a British exit from the European common market".

     
  24.  
    Rebecca Marston Business reporter, BBC News

    The monitor has been fitted and off we go. You can plug in to us bizlive@bbc.co.uk or @bbcbusiness. Here until 13:00.

     
  25.  
    06:00: Ian Pollock Business reporter, BBC News

    Good morning, the Business Live page will have its finger on the business pulse, just for you.

     

Features

From BBC Capital

Programmes

  • Going through ice across the Northwest PassageThe Travel Show Watch

    Navigating the treacherous Northwest Passage through ice and Arctic storms

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.