When will the Federal Reserve get back to normal?

US Federal Reserve exterior For the past five years, officials at the Fed have been operating under abnormal circumstances

Read any article about the US Federal Reserve in the past year and the same phrase appears over and over again: "extraordinary stimulus measures".

While that is partially due to a lack of imagination on the part of me and my fellow business journalists, the reality is that the extraordinary has become, much to the Fed's dismay, ordinary.

Since 2012, the US central bank has engaged in an $85bn (£52bn) a month bond-buying programme in order to lower interest rates and encourage spending.

This effort - known as "quantitative easing" (QE), a phrase for which I'd also like to apologise on behalf of journalists and economists - was meant to prop up a weak US economy at a time of sluggish job growth and depressed spending.

Start Quote

It's really where the art rather than the science of central banking comes in”

End Quote Randall Kroszner Former Federal Reserve governor

It followed two earlier efforts - QE1, in 2008, and QE2, in 2010, for the jargon obsessed - to boost US growth.

While some have doubted the efficacy of QE to spur economic activity, no one questions the size.

In total, these efforts have expanded the Fed's balance sheet (essentially, the amount of new money the central bank has printed and now holds as debt) to close to $4 trillion - more than the economic output of Germany, the world's fourth biggest economy.

Now, the question is how the Fed will begin its rebalancing act.

A tightrope walk

To take a step back, remember the "ordinary measures" of central banks around the world are to raise and lower short-term interest rates.

$100 bills As part of its "extraordinary measures" the Fed has printed close to $4 trillion

This is something the Fed has been unable to do since 2008, when it lowered the main federal funds rate to between zero and 0.25% (in economist speak, it is when the Fed hit the "zero lower bound").

Remember, the Fed funds rate is the benchmark rate from which all other rates - like mortgage rates and car loans and even global lending rates - are derived. Since the Fed hasn't been able to lower short-term interest rates, it has resorted to bond buying to lower long-term rates.

The art of timing

Cas Shiver

The Fed has got the timing of its pullback wrong before.

"The Fed has been overly optimistic every year," says former Federal Reserve economist Joseph Gagnon.

"They see green shoots every spring and then the green shoots wither."

This optimism was what led the bank to start and stop, and then start and stop, the various QE efforts over the years.

But many economists now agree that while the US economy is far from perfect, it's certainly not in danger of withering once more.

Take the case of Cas Shiver.

Mr Shiver (pictured) is the founder and owner of Sundog Productions, a textile manufacturing firm that specializes in custom dyeing, embroidery and screen printing.

After taking advantage of several government programmes to stimulate business in the wake of the 2008 recession, Mr Shiver broke ground on a new factory in 2011.

"We are noticing a recovery in the last few months," he says now, noting he's already hired one new employee and has plans to bring on more staff in January.

Stories like Mr Shiver's imply that "2014 will be the one year in which the Fed will be right," says Mr Gagnon.

The Fed took its first step on 18 December in its quest to re-normalise policy by engaging in a move known as a "taper". (If you're looking around for a Fed to English dictionary, I'm sorry to say it's still at the printers.)

Tapering is slowing down the $85bn a month bond-buying programme. In this case, the Fed said it would only buy $75bn worth of bonds each month going forward.

But this doesn't mean this will be the case for long.

"Note that [Chairman Ben Bernanke] has never used 'taper' - the word taper implies that once you start you go on a straight line down," says Fed "translator" Randall Kroszner, a former governor of the central bank who served from 2006 to 2009.

"I don't think that's how the Fed is thinking about it. I think they'll have a step down and then see what the impact is on markets and the economy and then decide what the next steps will be."

Mr Kroszner says that subsequently working out when to completely remove all stimulus efforts - not when to start the process - is perhaps the most difficult decision facing the Fed.

"One of the key questions will be the timing of the exit, making sure that the economy is on a robust and sustainable recovery path - that's very difficult to predict, and it's really where the art rather than the science of central banking comes in," he says.

Getting back to normal

But even when QE3 is done and dusted, it will take some time for the Fed to offload some of the trillions of dollars on its balance sheet.

The assumption is that instead of trying to sell the various bonds it has purchased over the years, the Fed will instead let them "mature" - that is, become due.

But this will take some time: one forecast by economists at the bank found that it could return to normal sometime between mid-2019 and mid-2021.

Start Quote

We're not going to go back to the old world - it's just not going to happen”

End Quote Joseph Gagnon Peterson Intitute for International Economics

There is also the matter of the other "extraordinary measure" being used: forward guidance.

"Forward guidance" refers to the Fed's effort to manage expectations by communicating expectations about interest rates and the economy in press conferences and written statements.

It is meant to help investors, and markets as a whole, better plan for the Fed's policies.

"Communications have become just as crucial a tool of monetary policy as any other traditional strategy," says Mr Kroszner.

But again, it is a tool that is not as effective as simply lowering interest rates, and many observers assume the Fed will rely on it less as a tool once monetary policy gets back to normal.

'Recipe for turbulence'

The Fed has said it will start raising interest rates sometime in 2015, once the unemployment rate falls below 6.5% and inflation remains within the bank's 2% target.

Alan Greenspan and Ben Bernanke Alan Greenspan (l) & Ben Bernanke benefited from taking over during "normal" times

But even once the Fed can return to its preferred tool, there are some who doubt that things will ever return to their pre-recession status.

"We're not going to go back to the old world - it's just not going to happen," argues former Fed economist Joseph Gagnon.

In the old world, the Federal Reserve targeted a federal funds rate of 4% - or a "real" rate of 2%, when inflation, ideally at 2%, is taken into account.

But Mr Gagnon and others, including former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers, argue that these targets might no longer be relevant.

As the US population ages, the labour force participation rate declines, and trade deficits remain high, it could be that expectations need to be recalibrated. The "natural rate" of interest might be lower, particularly as the working age population in the US is only expected to grow 0.2% between 2015 and 2025.

Some economists, like Princeton's Alan Blinder, have argued that due to these factors, it might be prudent for the Fed to never abandon, to return to the theme, its "extraordinary measures".

Whatever happens, Mr Gagnon says that the next few years will be "a recipe for turbulence".

More on This Story

US Economy

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories


BBC Business Live

    RBS BONUSES 10:18: Via Email Kamal Ahmed BBC Business editor

    "There has clearly been a major clash behind the scenes between the government and RBS. It is unclear as yet where the idea to end annual bonuses for the chief executive and the chief financial officer came from - but it looks like a highly political move. After the departure of the former chief executive, Stephen Hester, over a clash on the future of RBS's investment bank, it is clear that the Treasury is still calling the shots."

    RUSSIA RATING 10:06:

    More on that Russia debt rating, which comes from Standard & Poor's. It says further downgrades are possible if the situation in Ukraine worsens. Russia's BBB- rating puts it on a par with Azerbaijan, Bloomberg reports.

    HONDA RESULTS 09:56:
    Honda logo

    Honda has reported its latest quarterly results. Net income more than doubled to 170bn yen, ($1.67bn; £1bn). Rising sales helped, but the results were also flattered by a weaker yen. Honda sold 1.2 million cars during the quarter.

    RETAIL SALES Via Twitter Nick Bubb, retail analyst

    tweets: "Yet again, the ONS Retail Sales figures for March are inflated by mystifyingly high sales growth for "Small Businesses"... #ThePlanetONS"

    RETAIL SALES 09:35:

    Retail sales rose by 0.1% in March, compared to February, according to the Office for National Statistics. Non-food stores saw the highest year-on-year increase since April 2002 up 9.6%. But the ONS thinks that reflects a very cold March last year.

    ALSTOM 09:30:

    The French government is concerned about the prospect of a takeover of engineering firm Alstom. In an interview with Le Monde, economy minister Arnaud Montebourg said: "the government expresses patriotic concern and watchfulness with regard to Alstom". The minister said he and the prime minister will meet the president of General Electric to discuss their concerns. There is still no confirmation of the takeover talks from either firm.

    RUSSIA RATING Via Twitter Victoria Fritz Business reporter, BBC News

    tweets: "Russia suffers its first ratings downgrade in five years. Just one notch above "junk" status. Money pouring out of the country and investment stifled"

    PEUGEOT 09:19:

    PSA Peugeot Citroen shares are up more than 1% in Paris. The car maker reported a 1.9% increase in revenue for the first quarter. Unit sales (the number of cars and trucks) were up 7.7%. Earlier this month Peugeot's chief executive Carlos Tavares announced an ambitious recovery plan.


    Europe's major markets are lower this morning. In London the FTSE 100 is down 0.28, the Dax in Frankfurt is 0.74% lower and the Cac 40 os down 0.33%. The biggest loser on the FTSE is Tullow Oil, down 3% after one of its exploratory wells, off the coast Mauritania, found no oil and is being abandoned.

    ALSTOM 08:58:
    V150 TGV train

    Trading in Alstom shares have been suspended by French market regulators. On Thursday shares surged after a report said that General Electric was preparing a takeover bid for the maker of TGV high-speed trains.

    RBS BONUSES 08:50:
    RBS HQ

    RBS says that 77 people earn more than £1m a year at the bank, that's down from 95 in 2012. By comparison it also says that Barclays has 481 staff that earn more than £1m. At RBS "code staff", which are those who take or manage risk on behalf of the bank, earn on average £624m.

    BAIDU RESULTS 08:38:
    Baidu website

    Baidu, which operates China's most popular internet search engine, has reported a 24% jump in quarterly profit to 2.5bn yuan ($408m; £242m). Sales soared by almost 60%. The company has been spending heavily to promote its products on mobile devices. As a result expenses jumped by 137% from the same period in 2013.

    RBS BONUSES 08:27: BBC Radio 4

    BBC business editor Kamal Ahmed is on the Today programme. "It looks like RBS directors will be paid a third less than competitors and we will see if this affects the way the bank operates," he says. RBS, like other banks in the UK and Europe, wanted to raise the cap on bonuses. But when it approached UKFI, which holds the government's stake in the bank, it was turned down. The bank is also stopping annual bonuses for top executives.

    INTEREST RATES 08:13: BBC Radio 4

    On Today, Andrew Sentence, former member of the Bank of England's Monetary Policy Committee, raises concerns over rising house prices: "We are getting near the point where we should be seeing a gradual rise in interest rates," he says. He's worried if the policy of rising interest rates is left too late "then homeowners will struggle".

    RBS BONUSES 08:06: Breaking News
    RBS HQ

    More news from RBS this morning. It is scrapping annual bonuses for its chief executive and chief financial officer from 2014. They will still receive "long-term incentive rewards", entirely in shares and linked to performance criteria, but these will be given over a period of five years. The bank says the move is an effort to reward "long-term performance".


    WPP chief executive Sir Martin Sorrell is on Today. He quotes some interesting figures on digital advertising. His company spends $75bn a year on it for their clients. Ads on Google account for $2.5bn of that. But Facebook is growing fast, he thinks adverts placed on Facebook could grow by 50% this year, to perhaps as much as $700m.

    RBS BONUSES 07:45:
    RBS HQ

    The Royal Bank of Scotland has given up on an attempt to get a 2:1 pay ratio voted through at its next AGM, which would have meant it could pay employees 200% of their salary as a bonus. In a statement in the company's annual report, the RBS board says it expected UK Financial Investments, which owns RBS shares on behalf of the Treasury, to block the decision, so they will try and pass a 1:1 ratio instead.

    MORTGAGE RULES 07:37: BBC Radio 4

    Martin Wheatley, chief executive of the Financial Conduct Authority, is on Today, explaining his agency's new rules for lenders. He expects some "outlandish" questions to be be asked while banks get used to the new system. "Every bank is designing their own system" and "it might take time to settle down", he says. "The point is to lend what people can afford to repay."

    TICKET TOUTS 07:29: BBC Radio 4

    MPs are proposing new measures to deal with ticket touts. Sharon Hodgeson, MP, says there is "industrial scale touting". "Huge quantities of tickets are harvested and then sold on secondary platforms," she says. Oliver Wheeler from the online ticket exchange Viagogo says the government should not intervene in a "voluntary transaction between two parties".

    PARANOID PUTIN? 07:19:
    Vladimir Putin

    According to the Moscow Times, Russian president Vladimir Putin told an audience on Thursday the internet is a "special project" by the CIA. He also claimed the country's most popular search engine, Yandex, was under Western influence.

    WILLIAM HILL 07:12:
    Gambling machine

    William Hill will close 109 shops this year. It blames the government's increase in the Machine Games Duty to 25%. As a result of the closures 420 staff are at risk of redundancy. William Hill says it will make "every effort" to redeploy the staff affected.

    PHARMA STOCKS 07:08: Radio 5 live

    The pharmaceuticals market has been a hive of activity this week. GSK and Novartis swapped assets, and there are rumoured mergers, including a Pfizer buyout of AstraZeneca. Jo Walton, pharmaceuticals analyst at Credit Suisse, tells Wake Up to Money drug companies are facing pressure on prices, as governments try and buy more cheaply, and they are having trouble developing new products. The "easiest thing to do is to take capacity out," she says.


    Labour leader Ed Miliband will unveil plans to tackle the "epidemic" of zero-hours contracts in a speech in Scotland later. Shadow business secretary Chuka Umunna tells Today there has been a "rising tide of insecurity". He says that very often people are employed on zero hours contracts without even realising it.

    FRIDAY BOSS 06:51: BBC Radio 4

    The Friday boss on Today is Thea Green, founder of Nails Inc. The nail bar chain turns over £22m a year. The average spend is around £35 and women refer to it as "their little bit of luxury", which is why the business was not particularly hurt by the downturn, Ms Green says. She thinks of Nails Inc as a fashion company. This year's nail colour is floral, she tells Simon Jack.


    The Gherkin is in a bit of a pickle (credit to Mickey Clarke). The London skyscraper, designed by Lord Norman Foster's company, has been forced into administration. That's because the strength of the Swiss franc left the building's owners unable to pay debts secured against the building (which were loaned in that currency).

    MORTGAGE RULES 06:36: BBC Radio 4

    More from Peter Hill. He says mortgage lenders will want information on three areas: Committed expenditure, like other loan repayments. Basic expenditure - utility bills etc. The final area is more "grey". It is "basic quality of living expenditure" which could include broadband expenses. He does not think gym membership would fall into that. Only 2% are expected to fail the test - in good times.

    MORTGAGE RULES 06:32: BBC Radio 4

    Peter Hill, chief executive of Leeds Building Society, is back. On Today, he says: "If a customer is reasonably well prepared, the mortgage interview should take less than two hours". Lenders are also expected to assess if a borrower could still afford mortgage payments if interest rates were to rise. But lenders are unlikely to test if borrowers can afford rates as high as 7%, as some have reported.

    STARBUCKS RESULTS 06:28: Radio 5 live
    Starbucks logo

    Last night, Starbucks posted a loss of pre-tax loss of £20m in the UK. "No they didn't, of course," says Mr Urquhart Stewart on Wake Up to Money. "What they've actually been doing is funnelling revenues offshore back through the Netherlands again". The good news, he says, is that there are a lot of other places to get your coffee these days.

    TOP MANUFACTURERS 06:23: BBC World News

    More from Boston Consulting Group's Hal Sirkin: "Low cost countries are not always low cost. Western countries are becoming much more competitive," he says. Mexico and the US are "rising stars". The UK, Netherlands, India, Indonesia are holding steady. But Sweden, Belgium and France are becoming less competitive. "Brazil is actually one of the highest cost countries on the list," he says.

    TOP MANUFACTURERS 06:10: BBC World News
    Mini assembly plant

    The UK is the cheapest western European country for manufacturing - overtaking Spain. That's according to new research by the Boston Consulting Group (BCG). It looked at energy costs, wages, currency fluctuations and productivity among the 25 leading exporting nations. On World Business Report, BCG's Hal Sirkin says Mexico has lower manufacturing costs than China.

    BARCLAYS 06:05: Radio 5 live

    Wake Up to Money discusses yesterday's Barclays AGM. The bank withstood a shareholder revolt on the size of its bonus pool, but the outcry from investors is "not very good news" for the company, says market commentator, Justin Urquhart Stewart. "The shock was that you had the likes of Standard Life saying we're not going along with this," he says. "At some point they [Barclays] are going to want to come back to the markets, and they'll need these shareholders to support them."

    MORTGAGE RULES 06:00: Radio 5 live

    Tougher rules for potential mortgage borrowers come into force tomorrow. The Mortgage Market Review is designed to protect consumers from the kind of reckless mortgage lending that would leave them unable to make repayments. On Wake Up to Money, chief executive at Leeds Building Society, Peter Hill, says the rules will help ensure people borrow affordably, and that they can endure "a few bumps in the road".

    06:00: Ben Morris Business Reporter

    Mortgage lenders will be obliged to ask tougher questions about applicants for mortgages from Saturday. More on that coming up, on the Business Live page.

    06:00: Joe Miller Business Reporter

    Good morning. We'll have results from several carmakers later, but meanwhile, stay with us. You can contact us throughout the morning by tweeting @BBCBusiness or emailing bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk



From BBC Capital


  • A microphoneClick Watch

    The app that turns your voice into a musical instrument

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.