Call for major record labels to change for digital age

Billy Bragg performing at Glastonbury Billy Bragg thinks streaming services are the future of the music industry

Over the past 20 years the music industry has had to deal with plummeting CD sales, online piracy and new ways of listening to music via the internet.

Now the industry is being polarised by music streaming services.

Companies such as Spotify and Deezer provide vast catalogues of tunes which users can stream for free, interspersed with advertising.

To get rid of the adverts you can pay a subscription of around £10 ($16) a month.

But a number of musicians have criticised the size of the payments that artists receive for their songs being streamed on these services.

Radiohead singer Thom Yorke withdrew his solo music from Spotify in October, calling the service "the last fart of a dying corpse".

But others, such as English singer songwriter Billy Bragg, see Spotify as the future of the music industry.

"I think railing against Spotify would be like railing against cassettes. Saying I don't want my music on cassette [because] it's not 12 inches by 12 inches.

"It's another method by which people get access to music. It's the beginning of a new music industry."

Find out more

Peter Day reports on the music industry for In Business on BBC Radio 4 at 20:30 GMT on Thursday 2 January

Spotify says it has 24 million active users, 6 million of whom are paying subscribers.

Mark Williamson, director of artist services at Spotify, said that the company has paid $1bn (£611m) to the rights holders of songs in the past five years.

"What is even more incredible is between 2009 and 2012 we paid out $500m to the industry and in 2013 alone we paid out another $500m.

"The amount of money we're paying out to the industry is by no means small," he says.

But Billy Bragg points out that services like Spotify are not the reason musicians are receiving small cheques in exchange for streams of their songs.

"If there is a problem in the whole Spotify situation it's the analogue royalty rate that the majors insist on retaining for digital plays and digital streaming."

'Soul searching'

There are three major labels now - Sony Music, Universal and Warner.

A Spotify employee walks out of a news conference in New York The money musicians get from Spotify depends on their contracts with labels

Billy Bragg thinks that the reason musicians are not seeing good returns from Spotify and other streaming services is because these labels are signing deals with musicians that are stuck in the past.

"The recording industry is still fixed on what we call an analogue model - that's a reference to the way we used to record."

He agrees that to physically produce a record the labels did a lot of work and in exchange took between 85-92% of the royalties.

The artists would get 8-15% of the wholesale price.

"Digital sales aren't based on physical production, but unfortunately the analogue royalties that the record labels offer bands still reflect the old physical production model rather than the digital model," he says.

Fred Bolza, Sony's director of innovation and strategy, told the BBC that the image of a record company is outdated.

"There is a disconnect between an external perception which is still [us as] a cartoonish baddy, versus what we have done over the last 10 years.

Start Quote

Big record companies… are trying to milk every last dollar or pound from the musicians on their label”

End Quote Moby Musician

"We have really matured, grown as a business, we have added skill sets from outside. All this soul searching, all this disruption has had a positive upside."

He admits that the royalty rates in the digital age are "difficult".

"It's something we're working on and that we're conscious of. It takes some time for these things to flow through.

"Of course, things are never a problem until they reach a certain scale.

"Now they're reaching a certain scale - we are hitting a point where we have to address and look at how all that works."

When asked whether Sony was signing deals with new artists that gave them more money for different things like streaming, Mr Bolza says: "the nature of certain deals is that they are starting to change."

"While I accept that there is still road to be travelled down that route, I think things are changing," he adds.

'Do it yourself'

The American musician Moby agrees that record labels will have to change.

"If we go back 50 years the recording contracts that musicians were signing were horrifying. A lot of musicians were getting 2% royalty rates.

"In the 1980s and 1990s royalty rates became pretty fantastic, moving up to 15-20%.

"Now big record companies… are trying to justify their survival and keep their lights on.

"They're trying to milk every last dollar or pound from the musicians on their label."

But he adds that ultimately musicians do have a choice.

"If [you] don't like the big record companies, go and do it yourself. There is a lot of precedent of musicians having success with that now."

Peter Day reports on the music industry for In Business on BBC Radio 4 at 20:30 GMT on Thursday, 2 January.

More on This Story

Music Retailing

Related Stories

More Business stories


BBC Business Live

    08:02: RBS RESULTS BBC Breakfast

    Kevin Doran, fund manager at Brown Shipley, says we could see the government sell some of its 80% stake in RBS within the next 12 months. The bank's current value is "very close to fair value", he says, so maybe a sale before the general election?

    Via Twitter Jamie McGeever, markets correspondent at Reuters

    tweets: "One of the BOJ side-effects - gold falls to a 4-year low of $1,168"


    Bank of Japan Governor Haruhiko Kuroda says Japan is at a "critical moment" in its bid to conquer years of falling prices. "We can say the Japanese economy is now at a critical moment in its process of getting out of deflation," he told reporters in Tokyo. "The (easing) measures this time show the Bank of Japan's unwavering determination to exit deflation."

    07:43: WWI DEBTS

    We've put a call in to the Treasury, asking them to whom the WWI repayments are being made. Do you know anyone who holds National War Bonds (or 4% Consols, as they were called after a refinancing)? Get in touch by emailing or tweeting @BBCBusiness.

    07:40: SONY SLUMPS

    Another important fact from Sony's results. The company is packing up its smartphone business in China.

    07:35: WWI DEBTS
    South Sea Bubble

    Some of the debt being refinanced by the Treasury dates back to the 18th century, including the "capital stock of the South Sea Company originating in 1711", the collapse of which led to the South Sea Bubble financial crisis of 1720 - depicted by William Hogarth in above print. It's also paying for bonds issued in 1752 and used to finance the Napoleonic and Crimean Wars, the Slavery Abolition Act (1835) and the Irish Distress Loan (1847).

    RBS RESULTS Via Twitter Douglas Fraser Business and economy editor, Scotland

    tweets: "RBS CEO Ross McEwan: "Still have a long list of conduct + litigation issues + much, much more to do to restore customers' trust"

    07:27: WWI DEBTS BBC Radio 4

    Simon Jack on Today says paying off the WWI bonds will allow the chancellor to say he's paying off some of the UK's debt, but its pretty insignificant in terms of the overall debt pile. "It's looks good and sounds good," he says.

    07:23: WWI DEBTS

    The Treasury has announced it is paying off some long-standing debts - dating from WWI, no less. It will redeem £218m of National War Bonds, issued in 1917, with a 5% interest rate. Around £2bn worth of the WWI debt will remain, but the government says it is "looking into the practicalities" of repaying it all.

    07:17: RBS RESULTS

    RBS warns that much more money could be paid out to cover things like the foreign exchange scandal: "Ongoing conduct and regulatory investigations and litigation continue to present challenges" it says, "and are expected to be a material drag on both earnings and capital generation over the coming quarters". It adds that the timing of further settlements or redress "remain uncertain and could be significant".

    07:09: RBS RESULTS

    RBS has set aside £400m to cover potential fines for manipulating foreign exchange markets, and a further £100m to cover more PPI compensation claims.

    Via Twitter Joel Hills, business editor at ITV News

    tweets: "Treasury to repay £218m of war debt + look at 'redeeming the entirety of...£2bn of outstanding First World War debts, in due course'."

    07:05: RBS RESULTS

    RBS also confirms it plans to keep its Irish subsidiary, Ulster Bank. There had been speculation that the company was seeking a buyer for the division.

    RBS RESULTS 07:02: Breaking News

    RBS reports pre-tax profits of £1.27bn for the three months to the end of September. It has also set aside £780m for litigation costs, including costs related to the foreign exchange rate scandal still being investigated by regulators.

    06:57: DONUTS BBC Radio 4

    Dunkin' Donuts is back in the UK after a 20-year break, Today reports, with five outlets opened this year. The chief executive Nigel Travis tells Simon Jack that its donuts are an "affordable indulgence". He says they offer things like low-fat ice cream and coffees for those who don't want the high-calorie stuff, but most people don't go for it.

    06:52: SONY SLUMPS

    Despite a whopping net loss, there's one bright spot for Sony: Sales of gaming devices are up 83% compared to last year, driven by the popularity of the PS4 console.

    06:46: SONY SLUMPS

    Amid all the jubilancy on the Asian markets, one Japanese company continues to have a rough ride. Sony reported a net loss of 136bn yen (£800m) for for the past quarter, up from a loss of 19.6bn yen (£110m) in the same period last year. The struggling electronic giant says this was largely down to an "impairment of goodwill" in its mobile communications division - that is a decline in the value of intangible assets, such as brand recognition, reputation and intellectual property.


    Martin Shulz, a Japan analyst from Fujitsu Research, tells World Business Report that "Abenomics" - the economic policies of prime minister Shinzo Abe - isn't working. "Abenomics is in trouble, the economy isn't improving enough," he says.

    06:40: RBS BBC Radio 4

    Simon Jack's back presenting the news on the Today programme this morning, looking ahead to the RBS results later. Filippo Alloatti from Hermes Investment Management says the bank will probably announce more money set aside to cover PPI claims plus something like £300m-350m to cover fines or expenses relating to the foreign exchange trading scandal.

    06:24: HALLOWEEN BBC World News
    Rico Hizon

    The Live Page's favourite business reporter Rico Hizon is sporting a black-on-black jacket and shirt combo with an orange tie this morning to celebrate Halloween. "Nothing is spooking the markets", he quipped on Radio 5 Live earlier.

    06:22: ASIAN MARKETS

    The markets in Japan have now closed, and investors are grinning from ear-to-ear.

    • The Nikkei 225 index surged 4.9% to 16427.06 (highest since November 2007)
    • In Hong Kong, the Hang Seng rose 1.2%, ending at 23990.24

    Stocks in mainland China, India and South East Asia are also up.


    Here is how the yen reacted to the news from the Bank of Japan - down against the dollar to a six-year low.

    06:07: JAPAN BOOSTS STIMULUS Radio 5 live

    The Bank of Japan's decision is an attempt to "recharge a fragile economic recovery" and it seems like Prime Minister Shinzo Abe "is getting desperate", our very own Rico Hizon tells Wake Up to Money. He adds that the move "weakened the Japanese Yen against the US Dollar to a level not seen for six years".

    Bank of Japan

    This will give you a sense of how surprising the Bank of Japan's decision to pump more money into the economy was. Bloomberg reports that only three of the 32 economists it had surveyed expected the Bank to ramp up its stimulus programme. In its statement, the BoJ says it was worried about "downward pressure on prices" - or lacklustre inflation, to you and me.

    06:00: Edwin Lane Business reporter, BBC News

    We're also looking forward to results from Royal Bank of Scotland at 07:00. In May the bank - still 80% owned by us taxpayers - reported profits of £1.6bn, but warned of a tough year ahead. Get in touch with us on or tweet us @BBCBusiness. You email it, we'll publish it. Probably.

    06:00: Joe Miller Business Reporter

    Good morning. The Bank of Japan has unexpectedly announced a boost to its monetary stimulus programme, in an effort to revive the country's flagging economy. The decision caused Asian markets to soar, with the Nikkei reaching a 7-year high. More on that, and the rest of the morning's business headlines, to follow.



From BBC Capital


  • Francis Rossi, co-founder of band Status QuoHARDtalk Watch

    Status Quo's Francis Rossi explains how alcohol led him to take cocaine

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.