An unholy pension hole

The Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby

The Archbishop of Canterbury, who has taken upon himself the role of scourge of big opaque banks and profiteering payday loan companies, is today accused of ignoring a financial sleight of hand on his own doorstep.

John Ralfe, who would be seen by many as the bane of allegedly reckless pension funds, has written to Archbishop Welby to warn him that the deficit of the Clergy Pension Scheme may have been seriously understated.

Ralfe also complains that he was refused access to the data, and had to obtain it through a backdoor route, which he says is "not a good example of the Church's transparency and openness".

Black hole

The Clergy Pension Scheme has 16,400 members, including 5,800 pensioners, and its latest valuation showed a £293m deficit, which seems big, but was only modestly higher than the £263m deficit of 2009.

Ralfe points out that the increase in the scheme's hole would have been much higher - to a substantial £391m - if it had not been for a jump in the discount rate used for calculating the scheme's liabilities.

The important point is that the higher the discount rate, the smaller the liabilities. And the Clergy Pension Scheme increased this rate by 0.5% without - according to Ralfe - giving an explanation for why this was appropriate.


Ralfe calculates that if the deficit had been recognised at that higher £391m, cash-strapped dioceses and parishes would be forced to shell out £90m a year to provide vicars and other church officers with pensions, compared with the 2012 outlay of £69.4m.

He complains that at the synod in November, there was no discussion of the pension hole, because the official view was that the deficit had hardly increased and contributions would therefore rise by less than £3m.

Ralfe says: "If this £21m a year increase had been tabled at the Synod, it seems likely dioceses would have pushed to close the scheme... The Archbishops' advisory group reported in 2010 that only 18 of the 42 dioceses supported sticking with DB [final salary] pensions".

Robert Peston Article written by Robert Peston Robert Peston Economics editor

How Labour pays for student fee cut

Labour would reduce tax relief for those earning £150,000 or more a year, shrink maximum pension pots to £1m and cut maximum annual pension contributions to £30,000 to pay for a cut to £6,000 in student fees.

Read full article

More on This Story

More from Robert


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 184.

    "I can generate more income than an annuity"
    With the greatest of respect, it'd be pretty appalling if you couldn't, wouldn't it?

    Politicians are just waking up to the fact, that the people have rumbled that one. The fact that even the Tories have increased the capped drawdown limit to 120% of the GAD annuity rate shows that.

  • rate this

    Comment number 183.

    @100Anthony Rat "I stopped paying into any personal pensions 10 years ago

    I never started 40 years ago
    This whole pay now and get a bucket of promises at 60 or 65or70??
    is a con waiting to happen

    With tax free investments, personal allowances and capital gains allowances I can generate more income than an annuity and still have earnings growth and capital growth with a limited tax bill

  • rate this

    Comment number 182.

    "Gordon Brown institutionalised the state theft of private sector pension funds"
    Tax on dividends held by funds in both sectors is all it did, as in many countries. It's made little difference to mine: a small increase in contributions covered it.

    If it's as awful as you claim, why haven't the Tories reversed it?

    Management fees are what you mean, and 0% interest.

  • rate this

    Comment number 181.

    The second coming has been postponed after a fact finding mission found out there was nothing worth saving.

  • rate this

    Comment number 180.

    100.Anthony Rat "I stopped paying into any personal pensions 10 years ago, when even though I was paying in, the pension amount actually went down"

    Very wise. Gordon Brown institutionalised the state theft of private sector pension funds in Labour's 1997 Finance Act, and it continues to this day.


Comments 5 of 184


Features & Analysis

  • BeefaloBeefalo hunt

    The hybrid animal causing havoc in the Grand Canyon

  • Actor Jackie Chan gestures as he stands on the set of his new movie 'Around the World in 80 Days' on 6 May, 2003 in Berlin, GermanyDuang duang duang

    How a new word 'broke the Chinese internet'

  • Sound of Music PosterFar from a flop

    Even Sound of Music film crew surprised by success

  • Don Roberto Placa Quiet Don

    The world's worst interview - with one of the loneliest men on Earth

From BBC Capital


  • 3D model of Christ the Redeemer statueClick Watch

    Using drones to 3D map the famous Brazilian landmark Christ the Redeemer

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.