The case for making Hebden Bridge the UK's second city

 
Hebden Bridge street

Related Stories

Birmingham and Manchester are usually mentioned when the subject of Britain's second city comes up. But is Hebden Bridge - population 4,200 - the rightful owner of the title?

Pretty much everyone in the world knows which is Britain's biggest city, but who can name the second?

It is a trick question, of course. Britain does not have a second city. Instead, it has a first city and a couple of thirds.

The 2011 census figures for Britain's broadly defined built-up areas, ranked by population, show that Greater London comes first with 9.8 million.

That makes it as big as the next six urban areas put together - Greater Manchester (2.5m), the West Midlands (2.4m), West Yorkshire (1.8m), Greater Glasgow and Clyde (1.2m), Liverpool (0.9m) and South Hampshire (0.9m).

Drawing on that list, Manchester and Birmingham offer the best candidates for second city status, but each is still only a quarter of the size of the capital and its sprawling urban area.

Now, if Britain was a typical country, you might expect it to have a second city of about five million, which is twice the size of Greater Manchester or the area around Birmingham.

London skyline London is the size of the six next biggest urban areas combined

I say this because it has been observed - very loosely it should be said - that the size distribution of cities within countries tends to follow a pattern in which the biggest city is about twice the size of the second city, three times the size of the third city, four times the size of the fourth and so on.

It is named Zipf's Law after the American linguist George Zipf, who noticed that the frequency distribution of words in many languages followed that pattern.

For the UK, the implication is stark.

Start Quote

It is as though Britain has a great world city but lacks a great national one”

End Quote

As the eminent economic geographer from the London School of Economics, Henry Overman, puts it: "These kind of arguments imply that the problem with Britain's urban system is not that London is too big. Instead, if anything, it's that our cities are too small."

Our second tier cities in particular.

Having cities that are too small is potentially an economic problem because we know that big cities act as hubs which boost whole regions.

We know that cities are where a disproportionate amount of business gets done. And we know that, typically, bigger cities are more productive than smaller ones.

One World Bank report summarised it thus: "The large and growing academic literature suggests that doubling city size increases productivity by 3% to 8%."

In other words, if you could make Manchester the size of London (by doubling it and doubling it again) you would expect it to be about 6% to 16% richer.

Manchester Manchester's population has grown rapidly over the past decade

Those who hate Britain's lopsided London-centricity might want to think about the idea of promoting the creation of a far bigger second city - one of several million people, which could serve as a counterweight to the mighty force that is the capital.

Hitherto, one might say that the lack of a proper second city has allowed London to divide and rule the rest of the nation. And the argument is even more powerful now that London has become such an obvious global centre.

It is as though Britain has a great world city but lacks a great national one.

Find out more

So, if you believe this analysis, which second city offers the most hope for taking on the might of London?

Manchester or Birmingham are usually put forward, and the data suggests there is a logic to those two being on the shortlist.

Most people who have thought carefully about it veer towards Manchester, which has had a faster growing population in the last decade and enjoys more of an international reputation based on its two football teams. (Not to mention the US exposure it has gained from the character Daphne in Frasier).

And, in a GfK opinion poll for the BBC, the city was a clear but not runaway winner. When asked which of six cities they would like to be the UK's capital if it were not London, 31% of people chose Manchester, against 25% for Birmingham. (The list also included Edinburgh, Belfast, Cardiff and Bristol.)

Birmingham city centre Birmingham is often put forward as the UK's second city

However, there is an interesting alternative suggestion - Hebden Bridge. It is not a suggestion to take literally, but it does make an important point.

Hebden Bridge, nestling in the Pennines between Manchester and Leeds, is certainly one of the most interesting and flourishing towns in the UK. It was once declared the "fourth funkiest town in the world" (whatever that means) and is often said to be the lesbian capital of the UK.

Zipf's Law applied to world cities

Germany

  • Berlin 3,375,222
  • Hamburg 1,734,272

Brazil

  • São Paulo 11,125,243
  • Rio de Janeiro 6,323,037

Canada

  • Toronto 5,583,064
  • Montréal 3,824,221

South Africa

  • Johannesburg 7,860,7812
  • Cape Town 3,430,99

Source: National statistics agencies

The suggestion that it is Britain's second city came from resident David Fletcher, who was active in the 80s saving the town's old mills and converting them to modern use.

His point is that Hebden Bridge is an inverted city with a greenbelt centre and suburbs called Manchester, Leeds and Liverpool.

His point was that the real second city of the UK is a trans-Pennine strip that extends the relatively short distance across northern England, joining the built-up areas that lie second, fourth and sixth in the UK ranking.

Certainly, Hebden Bridge has attracted a lot of professional couples who are split commuters, one heading towards Manchester and one towards Leeds each morning. It is a place that allows both those cities to be treated as next door.

And maybe therein lies some kind of answer to the critical mass of London. It's not a second city called Hebden Bridge, but a super-city that tries to turn the great cities of northern England into one large travel-to-work area.

It would require a lot of physical infrastructure to improve links between the different centres.

And there would doubtless be rivalry and tension. The fact that Manchester is at its centre may not delight those who enjoy the football rivalries that are well known in that neighbourhood.

But there is no need to combine the teams, or to combine the names.

There would simply be a need to build on the success the bigger cities of Britain have been enjoying in recent years.

Watch Mind The Gap: London Vs The Rest on BBC Two at 21:00 on Monday, 10 March. Or catch it later on the BBC iPlayer.

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 730.

    May be UK has only one large city because of it's physical size. All the other countries mentioned are all much larger than the UK. Some counties' conurbations are farther apart than those in the UK . Some countries also have historical reasons for their large concentractions e.g. Canada - English or French language divide, South Africa - the divide between Dutch and British settlers

  • rate this
    +34

    Comment number 661.

    I don't care where the 2nd city is located, as long as it kick-starts growth and investment in some area of this country other than London! How can a country feasible compete with only one geographical region? Would Germany be the power base of growth and development it is today if every decision made was to protect Berlin. Who cares where they locate it just diversify

  • rate this
    +11

    Comment number 655.

    As someone who lives near Hebden Bridge but commutes to Manchester, and with a partner who commutes to Huddersfield, I quite like this idea.

    Sadly there is little investment in the idea with the current rail provider in the area (Northern Rail) using old buses on train bogeys on the Manchester to Leeds line. The trains are usually late, always overcrowded, and often cancelled/over-filled.

  • rate this
    +24

    Comment number 574.

    That's final then - scrap HS2 & concentrate on infrastructure between the northern cities. How about a motorway that goes all the way to Scotland - or are we holding off, waiting for them to leave? I don't condone the idea of increasing the populations of these areas but if we can better connect them then that would be hugely productive - M62 from Liverpool to Leeds is in desperate need of upgrade

  • rate this
    +4

    Comment number 533.

    The second city for the UK should be one of the other capitals - Edinburgh, Cardiff or Belfast. For England's second city I think we should have a balance to the South so it should be in the North - Leeds, Liverpool, Sheffield or Manchester. This woud take investment away from London though so it will never happen. I wonder when Yorkshire will get a referendum on independence?!

 

Comments 5 of 13

 

More Business stories

RSS

Business Live

  1.  
    10:41: Pork pie probe
    A picture of a Sainsbury's Melton Mowbray Pork Pie

    The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has launched an investigation into the merger of two pork pie makers. Pork Farms' plans to buy Kerry Foods' chilled savoury pastry (CSP) business, which includes pork pies, sausage rolls, pasties and slices, quiches and scotch eggs. The market is worth about £1bn a year. The CMA is worried the business will be too big will face competition from only 1 or 2 other suppliers.

     
  2.  
    10:23: Swiss interest rates turn negative

    Switzerland doesn't want your money. That was the message earlier this morning when the Swiss central bank cut interest rates to minus 0.25%, cutting the value of large sums of money left on deposit in the country. The negative interest rate is being applied to "sight deposits" - a form of instant access account - of more than 10m Swiss francs (£6.5m).

     
  3.  
    10:08: Russia crisis

    A thinly veiled threat for the European Union from President Putin. "Do they the [EU] want a stable guaranteed supply of energy resources from Russia that they desperately need?" he asks. "If they don't want it, well, then it's not going to happen. There are no other energy sources other than from Russia," he warns.

     
  4.  
    Black Friday bonanza Via Email Maeve Johnston UK Economist, Capital Economics

    While the effects from Black Friday should prove to be temporary, it is clear that the underlying picture is very strong. With consumers' discretionary spending power likely to be boosted by the drop in the oil price, confidence strong, and real incomes set to record their strongest growth in more than a decade in 2015, we remain optimistic on the prospects for retail sales over the next year.

     
  5.  
    Via Twitter Office for National Statistics

    "'Black Friday' helped boost household electrical goods by 32% in Nov 14 compared to Nov 13"

     
  6.  
    09:55: Russia crisis

    Mr Putin starts using hunting metaphors: "There are some people that want the Russian bear to lie down and eat berries," Mr Putin says. That way they can chain him and remove his "teeth and nails." The crisis should be an opportunity to change the structure of the economy otherwise Russia could end up "skinned and hanging from a wall" Mr Putin says.

     
  7.  
    09:52: Russia crisis

    If you think the Russian government is bureaucratic you should see the bureaucracy of the European Union, says Mr Putin. Even the Russian president has started making jokes about the EU now. Nigel Farage will be delighted.

     
  8.  
    09:47: Rouble remains volatile
    Rouble dollar

    The rouble has been bouncing around while President Putin has been speaking. It is trading around the lows for the session with a dollar buying more than 62 roubles, but earlier the rouble had strengthened to 58 to the dollar.

     
  9.  
    09:39: Russia crisis

    Mr Putin's press conference continues. He says the country will be back on its feet within two years. Growth will be inevitable, he says. Growth in the world economy will increase the need for energy resources, he says. But Mr Purtin says the economy still needs to be more diverse. $419bn of reserves will not be wasted he says. The government will fulfil its social obligations, he adds.

     
  10.  
    09:33: Black Friday bonanza
    John Lewis shop window

    Retail sales surged at their fastest rate in more than a decade in November, according to the Office for National Statistics. Retail sales volumes grew 1.6% from October and showed annual growth of 6.4%, the fastest annual pace since May 2004. Those figures were helped by the popularity of Black Friday this year.

     
  11.  
    09:23: Russia crisis

    Mr Putin says he hopes to see some strengthening of the rouble over the next few days. What happens if oil prices fall further? He says the government will focus its attention on those people that really need its help. He's guaranteeing to pay pensions and social security but he has just opened the door to "reduce some social spending".

     
  12.  
    09:21: Russia crisis
    President Vladimir Putin

    "I think everybody understands the most important situation of the day is that of the national currency," Mr Putin says. He blames "outside factors" for the fall in the rouble. Mr Putin says: "We have also failed to do a lot of what we had planned in terms of diversification over the last 20 years". "I think the central bank and the government are taking adequate measures to deal with the situation," he adds.

     
  13.  
    09:19: Russia crisis

    President Putin's annual press conference has begun and he's getting straight to the point and talking about the economy. So far it's just the numbers, unemployment is low, he says, below 5% and Russia's industrial complex should have grown by 3% by the end of the year. The government budget is running a surplus of 1.9%, he adds.

     
  14.  
    09:07: Russia crisis BBC Radio 4
    Vladimir Putin

    Russian president Vladimir Putin holds his end-of-year news conference this morning. Anne Applebaum, a former editor of the Economist, says Mr Putin's legitimacy as leader is based on a pact with the Russia people that he will bring them stability and rising living standards. In return the Russian people will live with the fact they don't really have democracy and will tolerate a great deal of corruption by him and the people around him, she says.

     
  15.  
    09:04: Russia crisis BBC Radio 4

    Anne Applebaum suggests the Russian people are likely to begin to question whether Mr Putin should stay in power if they are not getting anything in return, such as rising living standards. But there is no mechanism to remove him, she says. The test is whether he can keep the economy going over the next couple of months, in the meantime he can blame the West for the problems, or elements within Russia says Ms Applebaum.

     
  16.  
    08:56: GM suspends Russian sales
    GM logo

    GM has suspended sales of cars to Russian dealers, blaming the the "volatility of the rouble exchange rate", Bloomberg reports. Cadillacs, Opels and Chevrolets already ordered will be delivered at the agreed price, the reports says.

     
  17.  
    08:44: Newspaper review
    Business pages

    Let's have a quick look at the business pages. The Financial Times leads with that thawing of relations between Cuba and the US. It also says plummeting oil prices have hit renewable energy firms. The Telegraph says that BT is looking to raise £2bn by selling shares to fund its purchase of EE. The Times says that investors have been spooked by Russia's crisis and are abandoning emerging market debt.

     
  18.  
    08:28: North Sea oil crisis
    North Sea Oil platform

    North Sea oil firms and service providers are cutting staff and investment to save money and the industry is "close to collapse" the independent explorers' association Brindex has said. Falling oil prices are now beginning to make North Sea oil production too costly it suggests. Brent Crude has now fallen below $60 per barrel and has fallen nearly 50% since the summer.

     
  19.  
    08:10: Sony cancels The Interview

    A cinema in Texas is replacing The Interview with "Team America: World Police" says Radio 5 live presenter Rachel Burden. That might make Texans feel a bit better about the hacking of Sony Pictures, which North Korea is thought to be involved in. As well as satirising gung-ho Americans Team America World Police ridicules Kim Jong-il, the father of North Korea's current leader Kim Jong-un. Take that North Korea!

     
  20.  
    07:56: Royal Mail privatisation Radio 5 live

    "There's a huge opportunity for financial institutions to game the system," Lord Myners tells Radio 5 live. He's talking about the process of "book building" whereby big investors like pension firms and insurers are approached and asked what they think a firm is worth. Transparent digital auctions would be a better way of fixing a price. says Lord Myners.

     
  21.  
    07:42: Royal Mail privatisation BBC Radio 4

    "I think actually the sale of Royal Mail was a well-balanced complex exercise and the government managed to achieve its objective, Lord Myners tells Today. When asked why UBS forecast a price of 450p for Royal Mail shares, around the time the 330p a share price was set, Lord Myners argues that is an example of the so-called "Chinese Walls" within investment banks working.

     
  22.  
    07:23: Sony cancels The Interview
    Movie poster for The Interview

    Jon Taplin who produced Martin Scorsese's Mean Streets and The Last Waltz makes some interesting points on Radio 5 live about Sony's withdrawing The Interview. He points out that the biggest US movie chain AMC is owned by a Chinese firm. Many movie theatres are in shopping centres and AMC says it was under pressure from those shopping centres who were worried that shoppers would stay away if The Interview was playing. (The hackers had warned of 911-style attacks).

     
  23.  
    07:08: Mobile phone coverage Radio 5 live
    mobile phone user

    There's been a "huge row" between mobile operators and companies says BBC technology correspondent Rory Cellan-Jones on Radio 5 live. The result is today's announcement that firms will invest £5bn in mobile kit to achieve 90% geographic coverage by 2017. That £5bn was going to be spent anyway says Rory, the companies wanted the government to abandon a "national roaming" scheme that they hated.

     
  24.  
    06:52: Local government pensions BBC Radio 4

    Local government pensions schemes are "staggeringly inefficient and a national embarrassment", according to the right leaning think-tank, the Centre for Policy Studies which has published a report calling for a radical overhaul of them. Currently 89 separate schemes in England and Wales are £47bn in deficit, it says. The report comes on the same day as the local government finance settlement.

     
  25.  
    06:48: Local council spending Radio 5 live

    Later this morning, councils in England will find out how much money they are likely to get from the government for the next financial year. Councils are expecting a 12% cut in their budgets. They are saying that the situation is "virtually unsustainable and services will start buckling under the strain", according to BBC political correspondent, Iain Watson. The government argues that councils have coped well with cuts so far, Iain says on Radio 5 live.

     
  26.  
    06:39: Royal Mail privatisation BBC Radio 4
    Royal Mail Glasgow

    The big problem for the government was judging the price and ensuring interest from institutional investors in Royal Mail, CCLA Investment Management's James Bevan tells Today. If shares were priced too high Royal Mail might not have attracted enough interest from institutional investors. That would have meant the shares would have lost value when they debuted on the stock market, and the government "gets accused of being greedy," Mr Bevan adds.

     
  27.  
    06:33: Royal Mail privatisation BBC Radio 4

    So the report into the stock market flotation of Royal Mail has been released but James Bevan, from CCLA Investment Management tells the Today programme the report tells us "very little about what actually happened. It's more of blueprint for what should happen in the future." He says the report seems to focus more on how to deal with institutional investors in any future privatisations.

     
  28.  
    06:27: Sony cancels The Interview Radio 5 live
    A banner for "The Interview"is posted outside Arclight Cinemas

    Sony Pictures has now cancelled the release of the film that provoked a cyber attack on the company. On Radio 5 live Steve Futterman, Los Angeles reporter for CBS Radio News, says it was primarily a business decision as five major theatre chains had abandoned the comedy (called The Interview), after the hackers made references to 911-style attacks. But Mr Futterman asks: Will the film have a video release or appear on a streaming service when the situation calms down?

     
  29.  
    06:19: US interest rates Radio 5 live

    "Markets are hugely relieved that the Fed will not be tightening rates any time soon," says James Bevan, from CCLA Investment Management. On Radio 5 live Mr Bevan says the markets are now betting there will not be a rise in interest rates during the next calendar year.

     
  30.  
    06:12: Cuba new era Radio 5 live
    Havana

    "It's quite a dramatic and unexpected step," says Phillip Oppenheim, managing director of coffee company, Alma de Cuba. That's after President Barack Obama announced moves to normalise diplomatic and economic ties. Mr Oppenheim thinks that announcement could make a real difference in two or three years time. He says that Cuba is very slowly being liberalised. It's become easier to set up small businesses, for example.

     
  31.  
    06:09: Royal Mail privatisation Radio 5 live

    Peter Hahn from Cass Business School explains that big institutional investors were approached in what's known as a "pilot fishing" exercise to ascertain a price Royal Mail. They, of course, were incentivised to quote a low price. Mr Hahn says that's a slightly simplified scenario - but was basically what happened. "IPOs (initial public offerings) are always more of an art than a science," Mr Hahn says on Radio 5 live.

     
  32.  
    06:07: Royal Mail privatisation
    Royal Mail"s Glasgow mail centre at St Rollox

    The government made £180m less from the £2bn sale of Royal Mail than it could have, a report commissioned by Business Secretary Vince Cable has said. It says shares could have been valued up to 30p more than the flotation price of 330p because of the high level of demand from banks and individuals. It said future government share sales should be more transparent and the pricing could be set at a later stage.

     
  33.  
    06:03: Markets boosted by US Fed

    US Federal Reserve chair Janet Yellen had some Christmas cheer for investors and borrowers on Wednesday when she signalled the central bank planned to be "patient" before raising interest rates. Most analysts had expected the Fed to signal its willingness to raise interest rates early next year but Ms Yellen's comments suggest the bank it wiling to wait a little longer. That's given markets a boost so far today.

     
  34.  
    06:02: Ben Morris Business Reporter

    If you want to get in touch you can email bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or tweet us @bbcbusiness.

     
  35.  
    06:00: Matthew West Business Reporter

    Morning folks. It's going to be another busy morning by the looks of things. Yesterday's reassurance from the US Federal Reserve has cheered markets in Asia and even lifted the Russia rouble. Meanwhile, Royal Mail was "underpriced" by £180m, a report into its stock market flotation has found. There's lots more to come, so stay with us.

     

Features

From BBC Capital

Programmes

  • An ECG (electrocardiogram)Click Watch

    The wearable technology which could allow you to pay for goods with your heartbeat

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.