Move over, GDP: How should you measure a country's value?


Related Stories

Poor GDP.

Everyone seems to be rounding on the once highly regarded economic measure.

Gross domestic product - a measure of the value of goods and services a country produces - is perhaps the most powerful statistical indicator in history, and has a huge influence on global policy.

Yet the main criticism of GDP, raised by none other than Bobby Kennedy back in 1968, is that it "measures everything... except that which makes life worthwhile".

Top 10 socially progressive countries

New Zealand flags
  • New Zealand
  • Switzerland
  • Iceland
  • Netherlands
  • Norway
  • Sweden
  • Canada
  • Finland
  • Denmark
  • Australia

Source: Social Progress Imperative

In other words, it is hopelessly flawed as a yardstick of human welfare.

Bottom 10 socially progressive countries

Pakistan flag
  • Nigeria
  • Pakistan
  • Yemen
  • Niger
  • Angola
  • Sudan
  • Guinea
  • Burundi
  • Central African Republic
  • Chad

Source: Social Progress Imperative

Indeed, as far back as the 1930s, Simon Kuznets, an early pioneer of GDP, warned that "the welfare of a nation can scarcely be inferred from a measure of national income".

But despite several attempts at dethroning GDP, which rose out of the Great Depression and World War Two as an attempt to stabilise economic forecasting, the indicator remains the central measure of a country's success.

Ignoring economics

Enter the Social Progress Imperative, an organisation led by Harvard economist Michael Porter. It exists neither to bury nor praise GDP, but to complement it - by compiling an index which measures everything but economic output.

"If you strip out economic indicators," says Michael Green, the group's executive director, "[you can] look at the relationship between economic and social progress and understand it much better."

Mr Green, who worked in international development for many years, proposed the index together with the Economist's New York bureau chief, Matthew Bishop, at a World Economic Forum meeting.

The Social Progress Index (SPI) began by gathering data on 54 distinct welfare indicators, all of which broadly fell under three questions:

  • Does a country provide for its people's most essential needs?
  • Are the building blocks in place for individuals and communities to enhance and sustain wellbeing?
  • Is there opportunity for all individuals to reach their full potential?

The resulting table, of the 132 countries from which robust data could be sourced, is perhaps least surprising at the top.

All the Nordic countries are in the top 10, along with advanced liberal democracies such as New Zealand, Australia and Canada.

Arab Spring Events like the unrest in Egypt could be easier to predict with the SPI

The second tier is much more interesting. It includes five members of the G7 - Germany, the UK, Japan, the US and France.

Japan's strength, for example, is in the area of basic human needs, but it fares below average on wellbeing and opportunity, and particularly low on tolerance and inclusion.

By contrast, the US scores low on basic human needs - it is 23rd in the world - but is fifth best at providing opportunity. And for a country that spends the most in the world on healthcare, the US performs badly on life expectancy.

Map Countries with the darkest colours on this map performed best on social progress
Arab Spring

Although much of the data gathered by the organisation has yet to be processed into meaningful conclusions, the index is providing some interesting lessons about the distinction between economic and social structures.

"Take the Arab Spring," says Mr Green. "You had a bunch of countries who were performing really well economically, and then suddenly this social collapse.

"Clearly a policy based simply on economic growth wasn't working for social harmony."

But a quick glance at the SPI shows the unrest might have been predictable.

Bobby Kennedy Bobby Kennedy said GDP "does not allow for the health of our children... or the joy of their play"

"The north African countries all do worst on opportunity," Mr Green added.

"It wasn't necessarily material needs that weren't being met, it was the chance to take your life forward - rights, freedoms, choices, tolerance and inclusion."

GDP 'not destiny'

"Freedom," the famous Labour figure Nye Bevan once said, "is the by-product of economic surplus", but the SPI partly contradicts his theory.

While the index does show that extreme poverty and poor social performance go hand-in-hand, the correlation stops once countries reach a certain level of prosperity.

The bottom of the index is the preserve of struggling economies, but oil-rich countries such as Russia and Saudi Arabia also do very badly on social progress.

And New Zealand and Italy, who are very close in terms of GDP, are 29 places apart on the SPI table.

In other words, as Mr Green puts it, "GDP is not destiny."

There have been several other attempts at complementing or replacing GDP.

Sir Gus O'Donnell explains the impact wellbeing research is having on policy.

The UN implemented the human development index, the OECD has a "better life index" and even the UK's own Office for National Statistics measures national wellbeing.

Recently, Sir Gus O'Donnell, a former senior civil servant in the UK, published a wellbeing and policy report, which investigated the main economic, social and personal drivers of happiness.

But the key strength of the SPI, Mr Green claims, is the number of different indicators it measures, and the fact that they can all - from religious tolerance to electricity supplies - be compared with GDP growth.

Take political economist Francis Fukuyama's famous problem of "getting to Denmark", by which he meant creating societies which mirrored the supposedly peaceful and prosperous Nordic states.

"You can say Denmark is happier than Britain, but what does that mean?" says Mr Green. "Do I have to speak Danish? Do I have to watch more episodes of Borgen?"

Crisis jargon buster
Use the dropdown for easy-to-understand explanations of key financial terms:
The best credit rating that can be given to a borrower's debts, indicating that the risk of borrowing defaulting is minuscule.

Analysing which SPI indicators correlate with a rise in happiness could help answer such questions.

But there are those who resist the idea that GDP cannot map welfare. Nick Oulton, of the London School of Economics, argues that economic growth can be a good measure of a country's wellbeing.

"It won't solve all problems, but a rise in wealth can lead to declines in infant mortality, increased life expectancy, and people getting healthier because they can afford to eat more food," he says.

The anti-GDP camp, he adds, are "in danger of prompting intrusive policies". It is almost as if they are saying "you might think you know what's good for you, but we know better", he contends.

Contrast and compare

Ultimately, the success of the SPI will be measured by one indicator - its effect on policy decisions.

Some countries are already taking notice. In July last year, Paraguay became the first country to officially start using the SPI as a basis for policy decisions.

Professor Michael E. Porter and Roberto Artavia of the Social Progress Imperative, and Raul Gauto of Fundacion Avina meet with Paraguayan President Horacio Cartes and cabinet members in Paraguay. September 5, 2013. Representatives from the Social Progress Imperative met Paraguay's president last year; the country has officially adopted the SPI

But the real utility of the index will come with comparisons to other data.

Plotting the SPI against government expenditure, for example, may help to finally settle the big versus small government debate.

Another test would measure income inequality against social progress, to test the "spirit level hypothesis" - does greater income equality foster health and happiness?

Meanwhile, experimenting with the data is something the Social Progress Imperative is very keen on indeed.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories


BBC Business Live

    09:26: Breaking News

    The arbitration court in The Hague tells Russia to pay Yukos shareholders $50bn in compensation, says main shareholder GML. Russia forced Yukos into bankruptcy and sold its assets to state-owned businesses for political purposes, says GML's lawyer.

    Commuters at Kings Cross Railway Station

    Here's an interesting tip off from the Guardian about Labour's election pledge to let cooperatives and mutually-owned companies run Britain's rail services. The party's pledge to give public sector bidders the same rights as private companies to bid for rail franchises will be outlined on a visit to Glasgow later today. Labour will say that employees and passengers could take a far greater role in running the railways.

    FRACKING LICENCES 09:14: BBC Radio 4
    Balcombe fracking

    More from Mr Hancoc, who tells the Today programme that "of course" there is some local opposition to fracking but the public in general understands the need for energy security and largely agrees with fracking. He couldn't name a local community pleased about the prospect of fracking, but points out there is a £100,000 grant for local communities and says they will benefit from the proceeds of fracking as well.

    YUKOS AWARD 09:04:

    More from Reuters on compensation for Yukos shareholders. There's another case going on in the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) in Strasbourg on behalf of all Yukos shareholders. That is expected to announce its decision on Thursday. They're claiming Yukos was unlawfully deprived of its possessions by the imposition of bogus taxes and a sham auction of its main asset.

    Mothercare share graph

    Mothercare shares have fallen sharply - 11% - after the company released a statement saying it had had no contact with potential US bidder Destination Maternity since early June. It said firmly it wants an independent future. Shareholders can't be said to be universally delighted about that prospect.

    MARKET UPDATE 08:36:

    European markets have started the day steadily enough. There was some positive data from China with industrial profits growing at a stronger pace in the first half of 2014 than a year earlier. The biggest rise on the FTSE 100 so far is Reckitt Benckiser - up nearly 3% to 5220p - following its positive trading update.

    • The FTSE 100 is 0.17% higher at 6802.99
    • Germany's Dax is lower by 0.05% at 9639.04
    • France's Cac-40 is 0.30% higher at 4343.41
    FRACKING LICENCES 08:29: BBC Radio 4

    Energy minister Matthew Hancock tells the Today programme there is "potentially" quite a bit of shale gas under the ground. That would be good news for our energy security, he adds. Areas need to be explored to see if there is shale gas in the ground first. Companies currently exploring for shale gas will then automatically be allowed to exploit it.


    Ryanair shares have jumped 5% in the wake of its statement earlier this morning, predicting higher profits.

    MARKET UPDATE 08:10:

    Asian stock markets are hovering near three-year highs, with China taking the lead after data showed a robust rise in profits earned by industrial firms. Japan's Nikkei 225 rose 0.46% to 15529.4, while Hong Kong's Hang Seng is up 1% to 24,456.5.

    YUKOS AWARD 08:04:

    Yukos was run by what was then Russia's richest man, Mikhail Khodorkovsky. The $50bn (£29.4bn) the Hague court is said by Reuters to be awarding the shareholders is half the $100bn they were asking for. The claim is from subsidiaries of Gibraltar-based Group Menatep. Menatep now exists as holding company GML and Khodorkovskyis no longer a shareholder either entity.

    ARGENTINA DEBT 07:56: BBC Radio 4

    One more from Mr Caicedo on Argentina's debt woes. He says default will be very damaging for the country because it has been trying to normalise its relationships with capital markets and that will go out the window. He adds that will also mean Argentine provinces won't be able to go to the markets to raise cash by issuing bonds of their own - and that will start to feed into their ability to pay wages to government employees, among other things.

    YUKOS AWARD 07:45:

    Reuters has a report - citing unnamed sources - that the Hague's arbitration court has ruled in favour of a group of shareholders in former oil giant Yukos against Russia, awarding compensation of around $50bn. That's half the amount originally claimed.

    A shelf full of Reckitt Benckiser products

    Reckitt Benckiser - which does a host of branded goods from condoms to cleaning fluid Cillit Bang - reports a 4% rise in sales for the past six months. Profits rose 16% to £1bn. The company has also decided to spin off its Suboxone pharmaceuticals business in the next 12 months, ending months of speculation over the shrinking division's future.

    OVERPRICED HEALTHCARE 07:36: Radio 5 live

    Private healthcare is 15% overpriced, estimates Bupa. The healthcare group itself has been criticised in the past by regulators for lack of clarity around its policies. Bupa boss Damien Marmion says they're working on that: "We have addressed it substantially, but will continue [to deal with the matter]."

    FRACKING LICENCES 07:27: Radio 5 live

    More on Fracking. David Hunter tells Wake up to Money the industry will obviously will need to regulated properly. "It is right that we are clear on how tight regulation should be," he says, but "it's also clear we should be spending more time assessing the potential of fracking" given energy security concerns, he adds.

    Pushchairs on sale at a Mothercare store

    Mothercare has responded to the news US rival Destination Maternity has gone off the idea of bidding for it with a corporate shrug. A statement says it "notes" the offer withdrawal and also "notes" it has had no contact with Destination Maternity for about six weeks. It says under new boss Mark Newton-Jones it is now "fully focused" on its turnaround plan.

    OVERPRICED HEALTHCARE 07:13: Radio 5 live
    Bupa sign

    Private healthcare is overpriced, says ... private healthcare provider Bupa. Damien Marmion, its managing director of UK Insurance. He says the whole industry is to blame, especially the price charged by hospitals. He says prices need to go down by about 15%.

    Ryanair plane landing

    Irish airline Ryanair reports better than expected first quarter earnings. Pre-tax profits rose to 223.6m euros (I£176.8m) in the three months to 30 June up from 88.5m euros a year earlier. Full-year profit guidance is up, too, to between 620m euros and 650m euros for the full year.

    FRACKING LICENCES 06:49: Radio 5 live

    Fracking will not necessarily lead to lower energy prices, David Hunter from Schneider Electric tells Wake Up to Money. It is important that the UK assess the potential of fracking, especially given Europe's currently fractious [a-hem] relationship with Russia. It's more about energy security than lower prices, Mr Hunter says.

    GSK BREAK-UP? 06:40:
    Horlicks jars

    The Financial Times goes with the boss of drugs giant GSK is considering breaking up the company, should its consumer healthcare division be worth more as a standalone company. And yes, that division owns Horlicks, as well as mega-brands like Aquafresh and Corsodyl.

    ARGENTINA DEBT 06:32: BBC Radio 4

    More on Argentina's debt woes. It is risking falling into default for the second time in 12 years, says Carlos Caicedo, senior principal analyst on country risk at IHS Global Insight. In fact, this looks like the most likely outcome after the Argentine economic minister failed to arrive in New York for talks on Friday. Leading Hedge Fund NML Capital believes Argentina will definitely default on its loans, he adds, and the government's refusal to meet and talk with its creditors isn't helping matters.

    ARGENTINA DEBT 06:23: Radio 5 live

    It is more than 10 years since Argentina announced it couldn't pay back its debts. Most bondholders accepted a deal to get back a small percentage in exchange for writing off those debt. But some bonds are owned by US hedge funds who want full repayment. Argentina says no, but there's a court deadline on Wednesday. Deborah Zandstra, a specialist in debt restructuring at Clifford Chance, tells Wake Up to Money the move will have wider repercussions: "Essentially Argentina is being put into a position of defaulting on its bonds. That will trigger cross defaults on its other debts."

    FRACKING LICENCES 06:09: BBC World News
    Brenda Kelly

    Brenda Kelly from IG Index is reviewing the newspapers on World News. "It is interesting to compare the Guardian's coverage with the Telegraph. The Guardian says there will be drilling but the Telegraph says it won't. There are a huge amount of environmental issues - the amount of water used, the risk of small earthquakes, for example. All energy firms will have to provide an environmental statement if they are going to drill near sites of natural beauty."

    FRACKING LICENCES 06:03: Radio 5 live
    Barton Moss Results from test drilling for shale gas at Barton Moss, Salford are being analysed

    Energy companies are being invited to bid for licences to extract oil and gas from large areas of Britain, using the controversial process known as fracking. The technique will be all but banned from national parks and other environmentally sensitive areas. Mike Bradshaw, professor of Global Energy at Warwick Business School, tells Radio 5 live people are concerned: "We've got very limited experience of fracking in the UK. So we don't know the answer to many of the questions that people have about what fracking will look like under UK and EU regulations which are very different from those that exist in the United States."

    06:01: Matthew West Business Reporter

    Morning folks, as ever you can get in touch with us by email at and on twitter @bbcbusiness.

    06:00: Rebecca Marston Business reporter, BBC News

    Monday morning. Here we are. Fracking is under the spotlight as companies start to bid for licences to drill for shale gas. Stay with us for the pick of the business news from the BBC and elsewhere.



From BBC Capital


  • A sun bearThe Travel Show Watch

    The Borneo sanctuary coming to rescue of the world’s smallest bear

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.