'Big six' energy firms face competition inquiry


Dermot Nolan, Ofgem: "No evidence of cartel, but weak competition"

Regulators will investigate whether the "big six" UK energy suppliers prevent effective competition in the UK energy market.

A report by regulator Ofgem has called for an investigation by the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) which could take 18 months.

Centrica boss Sam Laidlaw said it would cause delays to investment and "an increasing risk" of blackouts.

The Ofgem report has criticised the effectiveness of competition.

It finds "possible tacit co-ordination" on the size and timing of price rises, but does not accuse the major energy firms of colluding over prices.

Start Quote

Now consumers are protected by our simpler, clearer and fairer reforms, we think a market investigation is in their long-term interests”

End Quote Dermot Nolan Ofgem chief executive

The BBC's Industry Correspondent John Moylan said the report also cited low levels of switching by consumers and the fact that the market shares of the big six suppliers had not changed significantly over time.

Richard Lloyd, executive director of the consumer group Which, said the regulator's report was effectively admitting that it had not done enough to regulate the market.

'Clear the air'

The big six - SSE, Scottish Power, Centrica, RWE Npower, E.On and EDF Energy - account for about 95% of the UK's energy supply market.

Ofgem is now referring the market to the CMA - the new competition body - "to consider once and for all whether there are further barriers to effective competition".

All the major energy companies have welcomed the referral.

But Sam Laidlaw, Centrica chief executive, said he hoped "a lengthy review process will not damage confidence in the market, when over £100bn of investment in new infrastructure is needed".

When questioned on the BBC Radio 4's Today programme over whether it would mean power outages he said: "There is an increasing risk. A lot can be done in terms of demand management, but actually building a new gas power station does take four years.

"So that's the kind of time pressure we are up against, by adding another two years that makes it six years."

Energy Secretary Ed Davey: "This review will help clear the air"

However, the Energy Secretary, Ed Davey said: "He is absolutely, totally wrong and I can prove it. We have 14 contracts for power generation [in the pipeline] over the next 15 years.

"What we are seeing in Britain is a big investment in energy.

"It is true that companies like Centrica are not investing as much as we might like them to but we are seeing independent energy generation firms like Siemens coming in in their place."

Today Centrica confirmed it would not proceed with plans for a new gas-fired plant, due in large part to today's investigation being triggered.

Profit increases

Ofgem's report also says profit increases and recent price rises have intensified public distrust of suppliers and have also highlighted the need for a market investigation "to clear the air".

How much have energy bills ended up rising?

Supplier 2013 average bill cost 2014 average bill cost Average price increase

Source: Uswitch based on 3,200kwh of electricity consumption, and 13,500 kwh of gas. Dual fuel standard tariffs. Payment by cash or cheque on quarterly basis.













Scottish Power




British Gas












Dermot Nolan, Ofgem chief executive, said: "The CMA has powers, not available to Ofgem, to address any structural barriers that would undermine competition.

"Now consumers are protected by our simpler, clearer and fairer reforms, we think a market investigation is in their long-term interests. "

When asked on the Today Programme whether there would be a breakup of the six largest suppliers Mr Nolan said: "It's possible, (but) I couldn't guess what the Competition and Markets Authority will do".

Tim Yeo, Chairman of the Energy Select Committee said he thought a breakup of the companies was the most likely conclusion of the investigation. He said: "You could cut to the chase and say let's get on with it now.

Centrica boss Sam Laidlaw (l) and SSE boss Alistair Phillips-Davies give their views

"I think that would be the quickest way to restore confidence of consumers in the industry.

"I also think it would remove some of the risks of the lights going out, because investment could take place now."

The report comes a day after supplier SSE announced it was freezing prices until January 2016, putting pressure on rivals to do the same.

SSE whose companies include Swalec said the freeze would lower profits, but that it would "streamline" its business to cover the shortfall.

'Restore confidence'

The energy sector has been at the centre of strident political debate since last summer.

This began with Labour leader Ed Miliband's party conference speech, in which he pledged to freeze energy prices for 20 months if Labour were elected.

He also vowed to abolish the current energy regulator, Ofgem, and replace it with a new regulatory regime that ensured consumers got a "fair deal".

Caroline Flint fears inquiry will delay tougher action against energy firms

Caroline Flint, Labour's shadow energy secretary, asked for the investigation to include Ofgem itself and said: "Isn't today's decision a clear admission that Ofgem has failed to protect consumers?"

The road towards a full inquiry into competition in the market was announced by Ed Davey, the energy secretary, in February.

He wrote to regulators to say that the profit margins made by the six major energy suppliers in the UK were higher than previously thought.

E.On UK chief executive Tony Cocker has now said an investigation was the only way "to restore full public confidence to the energy sector and depoliticise the whole issue".


More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 60.

    and just how many people will have frozen or starved to death due to high energy bills by the time this report comes out and will it be like the Hutton report varied to suit the Tory Grandees. Don't hold your breath people customers like voters only matter at election time!

  • rate this

    Comment number 59.

    It's pretty obvious what the report findings will be:

    The big 6 put their prices up or down at the same time and at around the same rates while charging exorbitant rates and making obscene profits but - strangely enough - there's no collusion or any reason to change the system.

    There you go, Ofgem, I'll only charge you 50% of whatever your designated agency is charging for that one.

  • rate this

    Comment number 58.

    What is the point of a competition enquiry that will take 2 years ?

    We need cheaper energy NOW.

  • rate this

    Comment number 57.

    Have to agree with others' comments; this is more likely just for show.

    If the powers that be can tolerate the pay day lending which is illegal in most other nations, zero hour contracts, Atos..I hardly think profiteering power companies are much of an issue to them, even if it's blatant theft to the rest of us.

    But, to keep the minions happy in our "democracy", a show trial, then business a.u.

  • rate this

    Comment number 56.

    This has been such a blatant example of profiteering it beggars belief that anyone can claim they are not rigging the market with a straight face. Still, I suppose all the big pay cheques help.

  • rate this

    Comment number 55.

    33. Cheddar George
    That costs money, what we need is to start a publically owned power company run as not for profit and watch the for profit companies wither and die when they can't compete"

    While that wouldn't be a bad idea, I think it's a huge assumption that it would be cheaper than the private companies and that the customer service would be better. History tends to suggest otherwise.

  • rate this

    Comment number 54.

    Britain has some of the cheapest energy in Europe, just as well...

    "Britain has among the worst-insulated homes in Europe. This country is second only to Estonia for fuel poverty due to appalling standards of energy efficiency.
    A third of all UK homes (6.7 million) are rated E or worse on their energy performance certificate, meaning they have a poor standard of energy efficiency."

  • rate this

    Comment number 53.

    place a generator above / within parliament there is plenty of hot air spouted there, which is currently wasted.

    Also why would the government challenge the energy companies? After-all, they are owned by the institutions/banks that at the same time lend money to the government & offer jobs to the boys once they leave govt & and were/continue to be bailed out by the taxpayer.

  • rate this

    Comment number 52.

    6th October 2008 report from OFGEM stated 'The Big 6
    suppliers are acting competitively and we have found no evidence of cartels'. Let's go round again!

  • rate this

    Comment number 51.

    Energy should be run so that it breaks even and deilvers value to consumers not allow people to be connedsumers by force.

    The 'big 6' or rather the 'crooked 6' should be run in the interests of their customers, not their shareholders. The government should set aside money for investing in the infrastructure and development of the industry through cutting overseas aid. That's my view.

  • rate this

    Comment number 50.

    Pure public relations. There are more energy companies than supermarkets, mobile phone providers, or banks.

    The real issue is being able to compare prices easily and realistically. That should start with fixed dates for all to set prices per year or half year.

    Energy is not that expensive, and best of all you can control how much you use. It is no big issue.

  • rate this

    Comment number 49.

    This enquiry will not be complete until Jan 2016.

    Typical, just typical.

  • rate this

    Comment number 48.

    19 Choobs
    "Every other company makes a profit. Why not them?
    It is not a discretionary product.
    Compare their increases over a ten year period with earnings.
    You can die if your not warm enough due to being poor.
    25 Arcane
    "Buy solar panels and let the big 6 buy from you"
    Most people who have solar are not poor,so can afford to pay for installation and play the long game,quite often the rich save

  • rate this

    Comment number 47.


    Is there any once state owned industry that, having been privatised, hasn't involved all of the following:

    Higher bills for comsumers...

    Higher bills for the tax payer...

    Reduced quality of service...

    More billing "mistakes"...

    Fat payouts for shareholders & directors...

    Ineffective regulators...

    Large payments by owners/directors to Tory Party funds...

  • rate this

    Comment number 46.

    Quelle suprise...first thing that happens is one of them pops up hinting at power cuts..They do and have taken us for a ride but we arn`t stupid and recognise a vested interest when we see it. Obviously this enquiry is both needed and overdue

  • rate this

    Comment number 45.

    In order to give customers true choice, a not for profit government supplier should also be set up to provide energy. I would buy my energy from it knowing I wasn’t paying shareholder dividends or fat cat boardroom salaries. And I would hope that the people who actually delivered the service got decent pay.

    Give us the freedom of choice!!

  • rate this

    Comment number 44.

    “Regulators will investigate whether the "big six" UK energy suppliers prevent effective competition in the UK energy market.”
    ………And, following this, they will launch a detailed enquiry as to whether bears poo in the woods.

  • rate this

    Comment number 43.

    Why has it taken so long? Is there a cartel? Its like asking if a certain large furry animal does its business in the woods! If price fixing is found then will the government launch a "if you see Sid, tell him to sue them" advert?

  • rate this

    Comment number 42.

    The threat that they will not build necessary power stations shows just have badly these companies are managing things.

  • rate this

    Comment number 41.

    Why isn't there an equivalent regulatory body (i.e., something which has teeth) for investment bankers?



Page 39 of 41


More Business stories


BBC Business Live

    Via Twitter Lauren Davidson, business reporter at The Telegraph

    tweets: "From Times Mag profile last month: CEO Harriet Green fixed Thomas Cook, earned less than her male predecessor."

    07:40: Thomas Cook

    A little more on Harriet Green's departure from Thomas Cook. "I always said that I would move on to another company with fresh challenges once my work was complete," she says. "That time is now." The statement adds that when Ms Green joined, the company's share price was 14p. Today, it is 137.9p.

    Via Twitter Simon Jack Business correspondent, BBC News

    tweets: "Harriet Green steps down as CEO of Thomas Cook after only 2 years. She once told me she never stays anywhere for long but this is very brief."

    07:30: Thomas Cook
    Thomas Cook

    Overall, Thomas Cook, which has been struggling to compete with the rise of internet travel agents, made a statutory pre-tax loss of £114m for the year to the end of September. It's an improvement on the year before, when it made a £163m loss.

    07:24: Compass profits
    Students receive their lunch at Salusbury Primary School in northwest London

    Global catering and support services firm Compass group - if you have never eaten their food, there is a very strong chance your children will have eaten it at school - has reported a 5.4% rise in pre-tax profits to £1.16bn for the year to the end of September. "Food is and will remain our core competence and is backed with some strong support service businesses," the company says.

    07:18: SAS enlists Flybe

    British low-cost airline Flybe has announced it has signed an agreement with Scandinavian carrier SAS, to operate some of its short haul services. It's a white-label deal, meaning SAS insignia will be displayed on the planes, and the flights will seem to the outsider like a regular SAS service.

    07:08: Thomas Cook

    Holiday travel company Thomas Cook has announced that its boss, Harriet Green, is to step down. She will be replaced by Peter Fankhauser, currently the chief operating officer. Ms Green only joined the firm two years ago.

    07:04: Royal Mail goes to Parliament

    That's all happening at 9:30, by the way.

    Royal Mail goes to Parliament 07:02: Via Blog Kamal Ahmed BBC Business editor

    Royal Mail chief executive, Moya Greene, will for the first time appear in public to make the case about why the universal, UK-wide postal service is in imminent danger. And if the written evidence Royal Mail has sent to the committee is anything to go by, her words will certainly be punchy. The written evidence calls for urgent intervention by regulator Ofcom and warns if not: "A tipping point could be reached. The universal service could become unviable before effective changes can be implemented."

    06:52: Bank culture Radio 5 live

    One more from Lord McFall on Wake Up to Money. He says senior managers at banks "have often pleaded ignorance or stupidity rather than culpability" and that has to change. He cites an example of four top executives at Swiss bank UBS who came before the Committee on Banking Standards. Asked if they knew the name of their "star performer" who had just lost the bank $2bn, they replied that they didn't, he says. "The first they had heard of it was on the Bloomberg wires," Lord McFall adds.

    06:46: BG boss' pay BBC Radio 4

    Mr Walker adds that BG Group's pay offer illustrates "poor corporate governance", and "puts fund managers in a position where they are forced to approve" the £25m remuneration package for new boss Helge Lund.

    06:44: Bank culture Radio 5 live
    Air force

    The £27bn that banks have paid in fines for the mis-selling of Payment Protection Insurance (PPI) outstrips this year's defence budget, says Lord McFall. Since the start of the financial crisis, banks have paid out more than £38bn in fines, for a litany of sins. What makes matters worse is that he and other MPs were warning the banks over the dangers of PPI for 20 years, before the mis-selling scandal broke, he adds.

    06:32: BG boss' pay BBC Radio 4
    Mr Lund

    "A red rag to anti-capitalists," is what Simon Walker, from the Institute of Directors (IoD), calls the proposed £25m pay packet for the incoming head of gas explorer BG Group, Helge Lund. He tells Today "you could not calculate a measure that is more likely to inflame" politicians, and the general public, who will balk at the sum, which is "more than 10 times [Mr Lund's] pay in Norway", where Mr Lund ran the state's oil firm.

    06:24: Bank culture Radio 5 live

    Lord McFall tells Wake Up to Money initiatives to change the culture in banks are "fledging and fragile". He adds: "Rhetoric at the top has been implemented, but not carried down the line [into bank departments]". The aggressive sales culture of the banks will be eliminated eventually. But the banks can't do it alone, he adds. He is also calling on the banks to provide annual progress reports to Parliament's Banking Standards Committee.

    06:14: Welfare reforms

    The UK's National Audit Office has warned that the cost of introducing major welfare reforms could run into billions of pounds if the IT system needed to deliver the changes isn't completed on time. The Universal Credit programme has been beset by IT problems, and the chairman of the public accounts committee, Margaret Hodge, has accused the government of throwing good money after bad. Ministers insist they are getting value for money.

    06:10: Bank culture Radio 5 live

    UK think tank New City Agenda says it will take "a generation" to fix the culture of the banking industry, in a report published today. The organisation's chairman, Lord McFall, who is also former chairman of the Treasury Select Committee, tells Wake Up to Money the report is the first to have gone inside the banks - it visited 11 of them - so provides a real insight into what is going on, and it's not pretty.

    06:05: Clegg on immigration

    The UK's deputy prime minister, Nick Clegg, has said he supports further restrictions on benefit payments to migrants from elsewhere in the European Union. Writing in the Financial Times, the Liberal Democrat leader also warns David Cameron against trying to limit the number of EU migrants coming to the UK.

    06:00: Matthew West Business Reporter

    Plus Moya Greene, chief executive of the Royal Mail, will be giving evidence to the Business Committee - as will a number of her rivals - on competition in the postal sector and the government-mandated obligation to deliver to all UK addresses. As always, get in touch on email at bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or on Twitter @bbcbusiness.

    06:00: Joe Miller Business Reporter

    Morning. The president of the European Commission, Jean-Claude Juncker, will set out details this morning of a €300bn plan intended to revive Europe's flagging economy. Most of the money is expected to be provided by the private sector. More on that in the next few hours.



From BBC Capital


  • Ladybird - a robot designed to help with farm workClick Watch

    From weed detecting to a robotic dairy - the tech that could help farmers be more efficient

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.