Coal gasification: The clean energy of the future?

Coal gasification plant Turning coal into gas is not as environmentally friendly as it sounds

Dirty it may be, but coal is cheap.

For this simple reason, it remains the world's main source of power, providing a quarter of our primary energy and more than 40% of our electricity. And it will continue to do so for many years to come.

The challenge, then, is how to harness coal's energy more cleanly. While global attempts to develop carbon capture and storage (CCS) have stalled, a number of countries are looking at different ways to exploit their abundant coal reserves.

Not all are motivated by environmental concerns, but are driven instead by economics and a desire for energy independence.

Old and new

The main technology being used is coal gasification - instead of burning the fossil fuel, it is chemically transformed into synthetic natural gas (SNG).

The process is decades old, but recent rises in the price of gas mean it is now more economically viable. The US has dabbled in the technique, but China is going all out in a bid to satisfy its soaring demand for power and reduce its dependency on imported liquefied natural gas (LNG).

The country's National Energy Administration has laid out plans to produce 50 billion cubic metres of gas from coal by 2020, enough to satisfy more than 10% of China's total gas demand.

Fuelling the future

Not only does it make economic sense, but it allows China to exploit stranded coal deposits sitting thousands of kilometres from the country's main industrial centres. Transporting gas is, after all, a lot cheaper than transporting coal.

Coal gasification can also help address local pollution problems that have in recent months brought parts of the country to a virtual standstill.

But there are two big problems. First, coal gasification actually produces more CO2 than a traditional coal plant; so not only will China be using more coal, it will be doing so at a greater cost to the environment.

As Laszlo Varro, head of gas, coal and power markets at the International Energy Agency (IEA), says: "[Coal gasification] is attractive from an economic and energy security perspective.

"It can be a nice solution to local pollution, but its overall carbon intensity is worse [than coal mining], so it is not attractive at all from a climate change point of view".

Great Plains Synfuels plant in US The US has experimented with coal gasification in recent years

Indeed a study by Duke University in the US suggests synthetic natural gas emits seven times more greenhouse gases than natural gas, and almost twice as much carbon as a coal plant.

The second problem is water use. Coal gasification is one of the more water-intensive forms of energy production, and large areas of China, particularly in the western parts of the country that would host new gasification plants, already suffer from water shortages.

Mr Varro says a recent IEA report concluded that coal and coal gasification plants would use "quite a substantial portion of the available water in China".

Abundant reserves

Other countries are looking at different ways to get gas from coal. One method, particularly popular in Australia, is coal-bed methane, a process allowing access to coal deposits that are too deep to mine. Water is sucked out of the seam and the methane attached to the surface of the coal is freed and then collected.

Start Quote

We need to get more radical - we need to get to zero carbon”

End Quote Dr Harry Bradbury Founder and chief executive, Five Quarter

China, Indonesia and Mozambique are looking at coal-bed methane, while the US and Canada also have abundant reserves.

Very little CO2 is emitted, but the process is not without controversy. Opponents highlight concerns about water contamination, land subsidence and disposing of waste water safely, while the water intensive process sometimes involves fracking.

And yet coal-bed methane has "fundamentally changed the dynamics of the gas industry in Australia," according to Phil Hirschhorn, partner at the Boston Consulting Group's energy practice in Sydney.

He says there are 200 trillion cubic feet of coal-bed methane resources in the country, with projects under construction to liquify and export 25 million tonnes of gas every year - equivalent to 10% of the entire global LNG market.

Clean access

A very different way to produce gas from coal is known as underground coal gasification (UCG), a process that has been around since the 19th Century but which has yet to become commercially viable on a grand scale - there is currently one working facility in Uzbekistan and pilot projects in Australia and South Africa.

Chinese lady wearing a mask in Beijing Heavy pollution has forced China to rethink how it exploits its coal reserves

According to Julie Lauder, chief executive of the UCG Association, the process is a "new way of harnessing the energy of coal without the usual environmental impacts".

Technological developments and the rising price of gas mean UCG is now a feasible way of accessing the vast resources of coal that are too deep to mine, she says. Indeed, estimates suggest that as much as 85% of the world's coal resources cannot be accessed through traditional mining techniques.

Opening them up to exploitation has potentially disastrous implications for CO2 emissions and climate change, but the industry says these resources can be accessed cleanly.

The process involves pumping oxygen and steam through a small borehole into the coal seam to produce a small and controlled combustion. Unlike coal-bed methane, therefore, the actual coal is converted from a solid state into gas. The hydrogen, methane, carbon monoxide and CO2 is then siphoned off through a second borehole.

According to Dr Harry Bradbury, founder and chief executive of UK clean energy company Five Quarters, this process results in 20% of the CO2 produced from traditional coal mining.

underground coal gasification projects

But his company is developing a process that requires no burning of coal, and which combines what Dr Bradbury calls "solid state chemical engineering" with releasing gases that are trapped not just in the coal, but in the surrounding rocks as well. And all of this takes place offshore, relieving concerns about water contamination and subsidence, he argues.

But the real advantage lies in the ability to capture the CO2. "We need to get more radical - we need to get to zero carbon," Dr Bradbury says. "Full carbon capture and storage is absolutely crucial."

This can take place through re-injecting the CO2 back into the coal seams, or by converting the carbon into products such as plastics and graphene, he says.

The UK government has established a working party to investigate the merits of UCG, undoubtedly excited by the vast resources of coal sitting under the North Sea. Other governments are equally keen to exploit new technologies to access their hidden coal seams.

The problem, of course, is that the process depends entirely on wider efforts to develop CCS, efforts that have, so far, singularly failed to find a solution.

Until one is found, any attempts to gasify coal underground will either remain theoretical or will exacerbate the already grave problem of CO2 emissions. And if recent efforts are anything to go by, we could be waiting a long time.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories

RSS

BBC Business Live

  1.  
    Via Twitter Dave Lee Technology reporter, BBC News

    tweets: "AFP: European Parliament votes to split up Google"

     
  2.  
    12:00: Future of the eurozone
  3.  
    11:55: Future of the eurozone
    Draghi

    The president of the European Central Bank, Mario Draghi, has been speaking at the University of Helsinki. Talking about the stability of the eurozone, he says countries "have to be better off inside than they would be outside". He adds: "If there are parts of the euro area that are worse off inside the Union, doubts may grow about whether they might ultimately have to leave. And if one country can potentially leave the monetary union, then this creates a replicable precedent for all countries."

     
  4.  
    11:40: Falling oil price
    Ali al-Naimi

    The inimitable Andrew Walker has been having a lively exchange with the Saudi oil minister, Ali al Naimi, at the Opec meeting. After he was asked how much of a production cut it would take to stabilise the market, Mr al Naimi said "Go ask other Opec ministers, they will tell you. We will tell you that when we conclude this meeting."

    Andrew then asks: "What do you think is a good price for crude, minister?"

    Mr al Naimi: "You probably know better than I do - why do you ask me?"

    Andrew: "Because you are the one whose budget depends on it."

    Mr al Naimi: "Who says? You say so, I don't say it."

    Andrew: "But it's true isn't it?"

    Mr al Naimi: "Have I ever said it? Never!"

     
  5.  
    UK migration 11:24: Via Email Peter Williams from Dorset

    writes in next: "Hi, for 1985, I reckon that the most number of immigrants came from Indian sub-continent. For 2013 - my guess is Poland."

     
  6.  
    11:22: Falling oil price
    Ramirez

    Rafael Ramirez, Venezuela's minister for foreign affairs, has been speaking to the BBC's Andrew Walker at the Opec meeting. "Perhaps for the stabilisation it is important to withdraw two million barrels per day from the market," he says. Andrew asks him what Venezuela would contribute to that cut. "We are ready to make our contribution," responds Mr Ramirez.

     
  7.  
    UK migration 11:12: Via Email Bob Curtis from Cheltenham

    writes: "Without looking it up I would guess; 1 (1985) Australia, 2 (2013) France"

     
  8.  
    11:06: Eurozone lending

    Lending to eurozone households and businesses fell again in October, but at a slightly slower pace than in previous months, official figures show. That's despite the European Central Bank stepping up its efforts to get credit moving again in a bid to revive economic growth. Banks have continue to tightening lending terms because of tougher capital requirements and companies are still hording cash. Loans to private sector firms fell 1.1% in October compared to 1.2% in September.

     
  9.  
    UK migration Via Email

    OK, so we've had the first couple of attempts to answer the migration questions. And they've thrown up some interesting answers. Both need to be correct for you to be declared the winner and we'll reveal the answer before we finish up today. Our first answer comes from Adrian Bird in Bristol. who says 1985: Australia; 2013: China. Keep them coming folks

     
  10.  
    10:35: UK migration

    The ONS figures also show that 583,000 people moved to the UK last year. That's up 81,000 on the previous year (502,000). What that also means is about 3,000 fewer people left the UK for another country than the previous year - the net figure is up 78,000. The total number of people that left the UK in the year to June was 323,000, the ONS says.

     
  11.  
    Via Twitter Andrew Neil Presenter, The Daily Politics

    tweets: "Net migration rises to 260,000 which means it's now higher than Labour's last year. Tory promise to cut it now in shreds."

     
  12.  
    10:12: UK migration

    OK it's quiz time.

    Question 1: In 1985 which country accounted for the most immigrants to the UK?

    And we're going to stay with the theme for the next question but we're going to fast forward to 2013. So, question 2: In 2013, which country accounted for the most immigrants to the UK?

    Send your answers to bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or via Twitter to @bbcbusiness. Don't forget to tell us your name and where you are writing in from.

     
  13.  
    Via Twitter Douglas Fraser Business and economy editor, Scotland

    tweets: "Scotland 2013: lowest net immigration of any nation/region, +2k out of 189k. Highest number of British citizens emigrating."

     
  14.  
    10:04: UK migration
    Interactive migration map

    The ONS has provided a rather interesting interactive map showing historic migration patterns to and from the UK around the world. It's quite fun and throws up some unusual information. We're going to delve in a little deeper in a moment, then we're going to throw some questions your way and test your migration knowledge.

     
  15.  
    10:02: East Coast sale Robert Drysdale, Edinburgh emails:

    "Very depressed to hear the news. Having travelled a lot recently on Virgin West Coast, the contrast between their level of customer service and that currently offered by East Coast is very obvious. East Coast trains have eight to 10 staff on board and there is always a train crew member available to help passengers, whereas on Virgin West Coast, the crew numbers are far less and you can often struggle to find anyone to assist."

     
  16.  
    UK migration Via Twitter Nick Robinson Political editor

    tweets: "Net migration now higher than when David Cameron became PM. No wonder he's got a very big speech to give. Ministers expect it tomorrow"

     
  17.  
    09:43: UK migration

    The ONS also reveals that 32,000 Romanians and Bulgarians immigrated to the UK in the year ending June 2014, up from from 18,000 in the previous 12 months. Restrictions on people from the two countries working in the UK were lifted on 1 January this year.

     
  18.  
    09:34: UK net migration

    The Office for National Statistics says net long-term migration to the UK (that's the amount of people coming in, minus the amount leaving these shores) was estimated to be 260,000 in the year to the end of June 2014. This is a "statistically significant increase" from the 182,000 in the previous 12 months, the ONS adds.

     
  19.  
    09:21: Energy blackouts BBC Radio 4

    Dr John Roberts is a member of the Royal Academy of Engineering, which has compiled a report for the prime minister on the dangers of power cuts in the UK. The report says power cuts could cost the economy billions of pounds. The main issue is that safety margins between peak electricity supply and demand have been falling after problems at a series of power stations. That makes power outages more likely, Dr Roberts told Today.

     
  20.  
    09:04: German unemployment

    Europe's largest economy saw a slight drop in unemployment in November, but the figure is unlikely to make much of an impression. Unemployment fell by 14,000, compared with a fall of 23,000 in October. It means the total number of those out of work fell to 2.87m from 2.89m. It also leaves the unemployment rate unchanged at 6.6% of the population eligible to work. None of which suggests the German economy is powering ahead, but given it only narrowly avoided a recession last week that should hardly come as a surprise.

     
  21.  
    08:54: Euronext failure

    European trading platform Euronext says a technical incident is affecting its data on cash and derivatives indexes and opening quotes are consequently being delayed. "We are currently addressing the root cause of this incident," it says in a statement. "Trading and order entry are allowed and market data dissemination is correct".

     
  22.  
    08:45: Fait accompli?

    A publishing glitch on Microsoft's blog appears to have accidentally revealed that the tech giant is buying up an email start-up called Acompli. An empty post was published on the site, but the URL was the giveaway - it contained the words "microsoft-acquires-acompli".

     
  23.  
    Via Twitter Jonah Hull, senior correspondent, Al Jazeera English
    Jonah Hull

    tweets: "#OPEC breakfast. This is what you get when the oil price falls below $80."

     
  24.  
    08:30: Vinyl record
    Vinyl

    More than one million vinyl records have been sold in the UK so far this year - the first time the milestone has been achieved since 1996, reports the BBC's Dave Lee. The Official Chart Company says it will soon launch a weekly vinyl chart.

     
  25.  
    08:22: Markets update

    Here's how the main European markets are looking in early trading:

    • In London, the FTSE 100 is down 0.1% at 6,721
    • In Frankfurt, the Dax is up 0.25% at 9,940
    • In Paris, the Cac is down 0.2% at 4,373
     
  26.  
    Via Twitter Adam Parsons Business Correspondent

    tweets: "Poundland shares up 3%. Company now valued at £800m."

     
  27.  
    08:12: East Coast sale BBC Radio 4

    "This was the best of the three bids," Transport Secretary Patrick McLoughlin tells the Today programme. He adds the Stagecoach/Virgin consortium known as ICR, is offering an increase in the premium that will be paid to the government. Asked if the consortium will paying more than the other bidders he replies "Oh yes". But he says services will also be improved - 23 more rail services will operate from Kings Cross. "We have seen a magnificent transformation on the railways in this country since privatisation."

     
  28.  
    08:05: Stagecoach shares

    Shares in Stagecoach are up more than 8% following the announcement that it won the East Coast rail franchise. Meanwhile, rivals FirstGroup are down 5.6%.

     
  29.  
    07:50: Poundland profits

    Discount retailer Poundland has reported a near 12% rise in pre-tax profits for the six months to the end of September - to £9.3m. The retail chain, which debuted on the London Stock Exchange in March, said its target was to open 60 new stores in the UK and Ireland next year. It added it was on track to open 10 stores in Spain by the end of 2016, with three already open.

     
  30.  
    07:46: East Coast sale
    Mick Cash

    The RMT trade union has come out all guns blazing. "It is a national disgrace and an act of utter betrayal that the government has confirmed that it is bulldozing ahead with the re-privatisation of the East Coast Main Line despite all the figures showing that the current public sector operator is handing over a billion pounds back to the British people while delivering huge improvements in service and customer satisfaction," says general secretary Mick Cash.

     
  31.  
    07:28: Mulberry finally bags new creative director
    A woman walks past a video display in the shop window of a Mulberry store in central London

    Luxury handbag maker Mulberry has finally completed its search for a new creative director. It comes 18 months after Emma Hill, the woman who helped make Mulberry a household name, departed following a row with the firm's then chief executive Bruno Guillon over "creative differences". Mr Guillon left in March after Mulberry issued three profit warnings. The new creative director is Johnny Coca, currently head of design direction at Céline. He joins Mulberry in July 2015.

     
  32.  
    07:24: East Coast sale

    ICR, as the consortium is being dubbed, is not an even partnership between Stagecoach and Virgin. The former holds 90% of the capital.

     
  33.  
    07:16: East Coast sale

    Inter City Railways says: "The company will shortly begin talks with Network Rail and the Office of Rail Regulation to agree its plans to run new direct services from London to Sunderland, Middlesbrough and Huddersfield".

     
  34.  
    07:12: East Coast sale

    "Over the next eight years Inter City Railways will pay the government around £3.3bn to operate the franchise."

     
  35.  
    07:10: East Coast sale

    Inter City Railways, as the Stagecoach/Virgin consortium is named, says the deal will bring 23 new services from London to key destinations, and 3,100 extra seats for the morning peak times by 2020.

     
  36.  
    07:00: East Coast sale

    A consortium made up of Stagecoach and Virgin has won the franchise to run the East Coast main line.

    East Coast
     
  37.  
    06:54: Rémy Cointreau
    Rémy Cointreau

    Cognac maker Rémy Cointreau reports a 15% drop in operating half-year profit, to €102m. The French group says it "remained adversely affected by evolving consumption patterns in China," by which it means that officials are having fewer Cognac-fuelled soirées.

     
  38.  
    06:50: Falling oil prices BBC Radio 4

    Speaking of balancing budgets, a number of analysts think Opec won't be able to reach an agreement on cutting oil production (which is needed to stop the supply surplus that is driving the oil price down) precisely because of a number of members have already done so - Iran has cut production by 1 million barrels a day as a result of international sanctions. Moreover, some members, such as Venezuela and Nigeria, simply can't afford to do so.

     
  39.  
    06:40: Tibetan tapestry
    Silk

    The latest entry in our Live Page series of artwork sold for exorbitant amounts is this 600-year-old Tibetan silk tapestry. It fetched $45m at an auction in Hong Kong - a record for art from the region. The good news is that the buyer will put the colourful thangka - which depicts the meditational deity Raktayamari, and was created during the Ming dynasty between 1402 and 1424 - on public display at a museum in Shanghai.

     
  40.  
    06:24: Falling oil prices
    Opec

    Here's an image that the delegates at Opec will be familiar with. It outlines the price per barrel of Brent crude oil that some states need to see in order to balance their budgets.

     
  41.  
    06:24: Falling oil price BBC Radio 4

    The main item on the agenda at the Opec meeting is the falling oil price, and what to do about it. BBC economics correspondent Andrew Walker says lower demand has pushed the price down, caused by a slowdown in industrial production in the eurozone and China. But US oil production - thanks to fracking - is also at its highest since 1986 and that is putting pressure on the price of Brent crude as well.

     
  42.  
    06:20: What is Opec?
    Opec

    The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (Opec) is holding talks in Vienna later today, on how to address the 30% fall in crude oil prices since June. Our colleagues have put together a 60-second explainer that will tell you what the meeting is all about.

     
  43.  
    06:10: Thomas Cook Radio 5 live

    Anne Richards, chief investment officer at Aberdeen Asset Management, tells Wake Up to Money that Harriet Green's shock departure from Thomas Cook yesterday doesn't feel "pre-ordained", and as a large shareholder, her company will be asking for an explanation. Thomas Cook's share price slumped 17% following the news.

     
  44.  
    06:02: Matthew West Business Reporter

    Morning. We should also be getting details of who the East Coast Mainline is being sold to this morning too. According to the Mirror newspaper, the government has decided upon a French consortium which includes Kelios - ultimately owned by French state rail operator SNCF. Will bring you that announcement when it happens. As always get in touch via email at bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or on Twitter @bbcbusiness.

     
  45.  
    06:00: Joe Miller Business Reporter

    Good morning. A cross-party report is understood to have recommended giving the Scottish Parliament new powers to set income tax and control some welfare payments. The report was commissioned after David Cameron, Ed Miliband and Nick Clegg promised shortly before the independence referendum that Holyrood would be given new powers, if people voted to stay in the UK. Stay tuned for more details.

     

Features

  • Afghan interpetersBlacklisted

    The Afghan interpreters left by the US to the mercy of the Taliban


  • Prosperi in the 1994 MdSLost in the desert

    How I drank bat blood and urine to survive in the Sahara


  • How ebola spread graphicPatient zero

    Tracking first Ebola victim and and how virus spread


  • Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammed Javad Zarif (left) and chief nuclear negotiator Abbas Araqchi wave to journalists from the Palais Coburg in Vienna (22 November 2014)Down to the wire

    How drama unfolded behind the scenes at Iran nuclear talks


From BBC Capital

Programmes

  • A model with a projection mapped onto her faceClick Watch

    Face hacking - how to use a computer to turn your face into a work of digital art

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.