MPs raise concerns over new tax powers in Budget

 
Cash on bank statement The plans would allow the tax authority to take tax debts from accounts

Plans to allow the tax authority to settle unpaid demands by taking money from people's bank accounts have been criticised by a group of MPs.

The Treasury Committee says it is very concerned because tax officials have a history of making mistakes.

Chancellor George Osborne unveiled the plan at this year's Budget.

But in a wide-ranging report, the committee did welcome another Budget plan - to allow greater flexibility on how pension savings can be used.

In the Budget, Mr Osborne outlined plans for new powers for HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) to recover tax debts from anyone who owes more than £1,000 in tax or in tax credits.

This would allow the tax authority to seize the tax owed directly from debtors' bank accounts.

HMRC Performance

But the committee said the plan was problematic owing to HMRC's performance in the past when it has failed to accurately calculate tax bills.

"People should pay the right amount of tax. But HMRC does not always ask for the right amount," said committee chairman Andrew Tyrie.

Planned safeguards

  • HMRC will only target those who have long-term debts and have received at least four demands for payment
  • At least £5,000 must be left in total across all debtor's accounts, including savings accounts, after the unpaid tax is seized
  • The tax authority will freeze the amount owed in accounts for 14 days to allow time for a debtor to pay before the money is seized

"Some taxpayers may find money taken from their accounts that later should be paid back. That would be unacceptable."

He said the committee also had "deep reservations" about changes to tax policy that would require upfront payment of any disputed tax associated with tax avoidance schemes.

"Retrospection should be considered only in wholly exceptional circumstances. The latest measure would have to be justified on those grounds," Mr Tyrie said.

"Retrospection puts policy on a slippery path to arbitrary taxation, discouraging investment and innovation and creating the scope for great unfairness."

Committee member Mark Garnier, a Conservative MP, said at the moment HMRC needed a court order to be able to seize money from accounts.

The committee is concerned that the current system of checks and balances could be upset.

Budget measures for savers

piggy bank
  • New Individual Savings Accounts (NISAs) will shelter up to £15,000 a year tax-free from July
  • 10% tax rate on savings abolished
  • Number of monthly £1m Premium Bond prizes increased to two
  • More generous Premium Bond savings limits
  • New Pensioner Bond for the over-65s.

"What we worry about is... that essentially HMRC will be acting as judge and jury," Mr Garnier told the BBC.

HMRC recently explained how the system will work.

It will only target those who have long-term debts and have received at least four demands for payment and will ensure that at least £5,000 is left in total across all debtor's accounts, including savings accounts, after the unpaid tax is seized.

HMRC will freeze the amount owed in accounts for 14 days to allow time for a debtor to pay before the money is seized.

The Low Incomes Tax Reform Group has called on HMRC to give more concrete assurances about the right to appeal against any seizure.

But the ACCA accountancy body, which after the Budget described the plans as "seriously draconian", now calls them "less fearsome than first thought" after more detail was published.

"On paper, the safeguards look relatively robust, and the reality is it is unlikely that anyone will be left penniless," said Chas Roy-Chowdhury, head of taxation at the ACCA..

The plans are now going through a consultation process. If approved by Parliament, they will take effect in 2015-16.

Pensions

The Treasury committee also called for pensions and savings to be taxed in the same way.

Savings pot The Budget included major changes in the way people save

The most eye-catching measure in Mr Osborne's Budget was a plan that effectively abolishes the requirement for some people to buy an annuity - a retirement income for life.

From next year millions of people reaching retirement age will be able to spend their pension pot in any way they want, including cashing in their pension savings in one, taxed, lump sum. Temporary rules are in place in the meantime.

The committee said that all of the witnesses it heard from welcomed the "greater flexibility and choice" that the reforms proposed.

However, it said the guidance that was being promised ahead of retirement should be clear and at least offer an opportunity of face-to-face help.

The changes are likely to lead to the creation of a variety of new financial products for retirees, and the committee said these must be sold responsibly.

"Following the financial crisis, and the mis-selling scandals, the reputation of the industry is under scrutiny," said Andrew Tyrie, who chairs the committee.

He added that it would be a "great prize" were the tax treatment of pensions and savings treated in the same way.

The chancellor announced an extension to the amount that could be saved in an tax-free Individual Savings Account (Isa) from 1 July 2014 to up to £15,000 either as cash or shares.

 

More on This Story

From other news sites

* May require registration or subscription

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +10

    Comment number 331.

    Is this not about how the House does work. Something has been put in place by the chancellor which MPs have picked up on and are querying. That is good is it not?
    The article also says this system could be used against companies and people using tax avoidance. Maybe with some tinkering it actually could have some merit.

  • rate this
    +92

    Comment number 269.

    This proposal would fundamentally alter the relationship between the individual and the state. The state should certainly be able to pursue unpaid tax through the courts just like any creditor, it shouldn't have the right to just dip into your bank account.

  • rate this
    +3

    Comment number 181.

    it would only apply to people who have ignored 4 demands for payments over a long period, accounts would be frozen first & they'd be given a chance to negotiate payment at that stage or indeed, take legal action so it would only apply to people who refuse point blank to communicate with HMRC or do anything at all about their tax bill.
    The problem as the commitee points out is if a mistake is made

  • rate this
    +15

    Comment number 131.

    I pay my tax via PAYE, what happens if they get me mixed up with someone who doesnt pay by that method and has the same name as me-this could be disastrous!! Its very rare that any government department admits that they have made a mistake so what happens then-I dont have any confidence in the 'checks and balances' they say that will be put in place. This needs to be stopped.

  • rate this
    +35

    Comment number 52.

    I can see problems, particularly with small businesses, if HMRC makes a mistake, takes the money and thereby wrecks cashflow. It could even cause a company to go under, and I can't imagine the interest on the stolen money would be fair compensation. This is a really bad idea.

 

Comments 5 of 8

 

More Business stories

RSS

BBC Business Live

  1.  
    HOUSE PRICES 09:26:
    A row of houses in the Ardoyne area of Belfast

    It's a new day and there's a new house price index. This time it's from Nationwide Building Society which says average property values rose 0.1% this month compared with a 1% rise in June. House prices have now been rising for 15 months in a row, according to Nationwide's index.

     
  2.  
    CENTRICA PROFITS 09:04: BBC Radio 4

    Centrica's outgoing boss, Sam Laidlaw, has been telling Today the company's earnings were hit by two weather-related phenomena: "We had warmer weather in the UK which meant that actually our average customers' consumption of gas was down 24%. We actually also simultaneously had very cold weather in the US - the polar vortex - which resulted in generating companies charging us with a lot of additional ancillary costs." Nicely put.

     
  3.  
    ROLLS ROYCE PROFITS 08:54:
    A crew member works on the Rolls Royce engine

    Ah the regular battle between underlying and statutory pre-tax profits continues. See if you can get your heads around this. Rolls Royce has reported a 1,000% - yup 1,000% - rise in its statutory pre-tax profits to £717m in the six months to the end of June compared with a loss of £527m a year earlier. But the underlying figure shows a 20% fall in profits to £644m from £804m the year before.

     
  4.  
    MARKET UPDATE 08:39:

    European markets have opened mixed as investors attempt to digest the glut of corporate results out today. The biggest rise on the FTSE 100 in early trade is oil and gas firm BP Group - not to be confused with British Gas - up 2.67% to 1212.00p.

    • The FTSE 100 is higher by 0.34% to 6796.48
    • Germanys Dax is lower by 0.17% to 9577.32
    • France's Cac-40 is up 0.52% to 4334.64
     
  5.  
    HEADLINES
  6.  
    SONY RESULTS 08:26:
    A man plays a video game on Sony's PlayStation 4 console

    Its not just major UK results that are whooshing out at speed this morning. After Samsung's figures, here's Far East fellow Sony's. The company said it made $261m (£367m) in the past three months, thanks to strong sales of its PlayStation 4 console. The weak yen, which makes its products cheaper for outsiders, also helped. But not enough, it still expects to make a full-year loss.

     
  7.  
    COMMONWEALTH AUCTION 08:18:
    Giant Tunnocks

    The diet has been a most austere one this morning. Time for something pretty, Who could take against a Tunnock's tea cake? (Other cakes are available, says the BBC). The giant ones used to such arresting effect at the Commonwealth Games' opening ceremony are being auctioned today.

     
  8.  
    BAE SYSTEMS 08:09:
    A F-35B Lightning II jet landing vertically on aircraft carrier HMS Queen Elizabeth.

    BAE Systems, which is Europe's biggest defence contractor, has reported a 7% fall in six month profits. The reason? Lower military spending by major customer the US. Half-year earnings were £802m. BAE warned earlier this year that earnings would by between 5-10% down on last year because of US defence spending cuts. Or defense spending, as it would say.

     
  9.  
    TSB PROFITS 08:05:

    TSB says costs rose by £62m in the last six month. That's in part because the bank no longer benefits from the economies of scale that Lloyds Bank gave it. That said, it won 9.2% of new or switched current accounts and is managing to maintain its market share. Lloyds still owns 65% of TSB but must get rid of its remaining shareholding under an agreement with the EU Commission by the end of 2015.

     
  10.  
    TSB PROFITS 07:55:

    Back to TSB for a moment. The figure that TSB would prefer investors paid more attention to (because they believe it is more reaslistic) is the near 17% fall in pre-tax profits to £78.6m in the past six months. Part of the problem with assessing TSB's accounts is that the bank only listed on the stock exchange in June, and has only existed as a separate entity from Lloyds Banking Group since 9 September last year.

     
  11.  
    CENTRICA PROFITS 07:50:

    Outgoing boss Sam Laidlaw says profit per household in 2014 expected to be around £40 (£51 before tax), that's 20% lower than in 2013. He also warns that profits won't be as good this year as last.

     
  12.  
    LLOYDS BANK PROFITS 07:46:

    OK.... so those legacy issues in full. Lloyds says these include set aside payments for Payment Protection Insurance (PPI) of £600m and £226m for Lloyds' involvement in the 2012 Libor interest rate rigging scandal and fiddling the repo rate. Lloyds also paid out £1.1bn to investors as part of a scheme that is seeing it buy back fixed income bonds - known as Enhanced Capital Notes - issued in 2009. That was then partly offset by a pensions credit of £710m, the bank says.

     
  13.  
    CENTRICA PROFITS 07:42:

    Prices now: The company says average actual British Gas customer bill is expected to be around £90 lower - 7% - per household in 2014 than last year.

     
  14.  
    LLOYDS BANK PROFITS 07:36:
    A general view of a sign for Lloyds Bank.

    So, good results for TSB on the face of it but not so good for parent Lloyds Banking Group? The bank has reported a big fall in statutory pre-tax profits to £863m in the six months to the end of June from £2.1bn for the same period a year earlier. That's a fall of nearly 60%. It says it took another hit of £1.1bn for what it initially describes as legacy issues - we'll investigate that and tell you what they are momentarily.

     
  15.  
    CENTRICA PROFITS 07:33:

    Energy regulator Ofegm said this week that UK suppliers' profits would grow from 4% to 8% this year, but Centrica said its profit margins would be lower for the year.

     
  16.  
    ASTRA ZENECA RESULTS 07:29:
    AstraZeneca

    The drugs giant recently beat off a $118bn takeover attempt by US giant rival Pfizer. One of the key planks of its defence was its drugs "pipeline" - the products it is creating and hopes will work safely. There's a full report on how that's going here.

     
  17.  
    TSB PROFITS 07:25:
    A woman walks into a branch of TSB bank

    A huge rise in profits at TSB today, although hard to really gauge properly given it was only recently spun off from parent Lloyds Banking Group. It says statutory pre-tax profits in the six month to the end of June rose 164% to £128.5m compared with the six months to the end of December 2013. The bank says the statutory figure when compared to the first six months of 2013 is "of limited benefit".

     
  18.  
    ASTRA ZENECA RESULTS 07:23:

    Drugs giant Astra Zeneca reports second quarter revenue rose 4% to $6.5bn.

     
  19.  
    BALFOUR BEATTY TALKS OFF 07:21:

    Construction company Balfour Beatty has called off talks with Carillion over a possible £3bn merger - just days after the possible deal was first mentioned. There may be interesting share price reaction to that when the markets open in under an hour.

     
  20.  
    SHELL PROFITS 07:19:

    Oil giant Royal Dutch Shell has reported profits doubled in its second quarter to $5.1bn (£3bn) from $2.4bn a year earlier.

     
  21.  
    BNP PARIBAS 07:19:
    BNP PARIBAS

    Giant French bank BNP Paribas reports a loss of 4.3bn euros (£3.4bn), after being whacked by an $8.95bn fine for breaking US sanctions, but BNP said the underlying result was strong and a sign clients had not been scared off. The loss was its first since the 2008 financial crisis.

     
  22.  
    CENTRICA PROFITS 07:18:

    Centrica's headline profit before tax for the six months to end of June is £890m, 40% down on last time.

     
  23.  
    BT PROFITS 07:14:

    Yet another major company reporting today. BT says revenue up 0.5% percent on an underlying basis to £4.4bn and profits flat at £1.4bn. It says there's record demand for superfast broadband and its sports TV service is growing nicely.

     
  24.  
    DIAGEO RESULTS 07:11:

    Drinks giant Diageo reports profits of £2.7bn, down from £3.06bn.

     
  25.  
    CENTRICA PROFITS 07:08:

    Operating profits for its British Gas residential energy supply fell 26%, Centrica says.

     
  26.  
    CENTRICA PROFITS 07:03:

    The energy giant's statutory pre-tax profit for the six months to end of June are £890m, down 40% on last time.

     
  27.  
    CENTRICA PROFITS 06:49: BBC Radio 4

    More from Trevor Sikorski, this time on Centrica, which releases its half-year results shortly. He tells Today: "We are expecting quite a dramatic fall in profits at Centrica and at the moment, their cost base isn't representing that fall in gas prices - essentially because energy companies bulk buy - and so the gas they bought on the wholesale prices won't have fed through yet, but will do later down the line."

     
  28.  
    ENERGY PROFITS 06:49: BBC Radio 4

    Energy company profits are all being driven by "a big reduction in wholesale power prices," Trevor Sikorski, from consultants Energy Aspects, tells Today "When you have a mild winter, you don't use a lot of gas and you don't draw down gas reserves," He adds consumers are as responsible for the state of the market as the energy firms themselves. They "generally don't switch very much" and "we're not sensitive to price changes when they happen, which isn't encouraging competition," he says.

     
  29.  
    SAMSUNG SLOWDOWN 06:41:
    Samsung products

    Smartphone maker Samsung reports its worst quarterly profit in two years as smartphone sales slow. Net profit for the three months to June fell 20% to 6.3 trillion won ($6.1bn).

     
  30.  
    ARGENTINA DEFAULT 06:33: BBC Radio 4

    "The repercussions of a default are coming through and we're going to see Argentina under pressure and inflation running higher and the country falling further into recession," Eimar Day from foreign exchange company Monex Europe tells the Today programme. Argentina is paying 7% on its bonds so why should bondholders be surprised when it defaults? she asks. "These are risky investments and creditors should have been prepared for that." Investors should also allow countries like Argentina to default and get back on their feet, she argues.

     
  31.  
    ENERGY PROFITS 06:24:
    Light bulbs

    Energy regulator Ofgem says the big six energy firms could double their profit margins from 4% to 8% over the coming year, FROM 4% TO 8%. That's the equivalent of making £100 per dual-fuel customer.

     
  32.  
    MANU SHARE SALE 06:16:
    Joel Glazer, left, Bryan Glazer, center, and Tampa Bay Buccaneers team owner and president Malcolm Glazer Malcolm Glazer (right) with his sons Joel and Bryan.

    Another development late last night was news the Glazers sold 5% of their stake in Manchester United - raising about £90m.

     
  33.  
    US ECONOMY 06:09: Radio 5 live

    Eimar Day from foreign exchange company Monex Europe is on Wake Up to Money, looking at Wednesday's news the US economy is growing at 4% a year. She's not convinced it's all that great: "Most of it was rebuilding inventory. There's an armchair labour market in the US. People who have just given up looking for work. The unemployment rate is 6.1%, which gives a glowing image of the US economy, but the economically inactive do not show up in this data."

     
  34.  
    ARGENTINA DEFAULT 06:01: Radio 5 live

    Argentina in default this morning after the collapse of last-minute talks in New York between its government and a group of bond-holders. But the rest of the world need not worry too much, James Lockhart Smith, Latin America analyst for Maplecroft, tells Wake Up to Money: "Negative news for the Argentina economy as a whole but it is unlikely to spread to other countries."

     
  35.  
    06:01: Matthew West Business Reporter

    Morning folks. You can get in touch with us as always via email bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or you can tweet us @bbcbusiness.

     
  36.  
    06:00: Rebecca Marston Business reporter, BBC News

    Welcome to Thursday's Business Live. It's all about energy this morning as we wait for Centrica's results - as regulator Ofgem says the biggest six firms are set to double their profit margins over the next year.

     

Features

From BBC Capital

Programmes

  • A factory in JapanThe Travel Show Watch

    Factory infatuation – why Japan’s industrial compounds are drawing large crowds at night

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.