US 'in denial' over poor maths standards

Emergency vehicle used in quelling of a disturbance at Jackson State College in 1970 Lost direction: Rusting emergency vehicle used in the 1970 protests at Jackson State College, Mississippi

The maths skills of teenagers in parts of the deep south of the United States are worse than in countries such as Turkey and barely above countries such as Chile and Mexico.

An international study of maths ability in the US shows how individual states would have performed if they were ranked against other countries, using the OECD's Pisa results as a benchmark.

The study also shows that privileged youngsters in the US, with highly-educated parents, are lagging behind similar youngsters in other developed countries.

This analysis, from academics at Harvard and Stanford in the US and Munich University in Germany, punctures the idea that middle-class US pupils are high achievers.

Southern states Mississippi, Alabama and Louisiana are among the weakest performers, with results similar to developing countries such as Kazakhstan and Thailand.

West Virginia is also among the group of lowest performers, where maths levels are far below western European countries or high-performing Asian education systems in South Korea or Singapore.

The US has been a mediocre performer in international education tests, based on average performance across the country, but this study shows how this average conceals a remarkably wide range of successes and failures.

Northern lights

There is a band of high achieving states across the north of the US, where maths results would be as good as many successful European and Asian countries.

US townscape There is a complacency about mainstream US education standards, says study

If Massachusetts had been considered as a separate entity it would have been the seventh best at maths in the world.

Minnesota, Vermont, New Jersey and Montana are all high performers.

But there is a long tail of underachievement that dips well below the levels of secondary school pupils in wealthier western European countries. It dips into levels closer to the developing world.

New York and California are similar in ability to countries such as Bulgaria, Romania and Turkey, well below the averages for the US and OECD industrialised countries.

There are 23 US states which would be ranked below 30th place in an international ranking of 34 OECD countries at maths.

The study also overturns the idea that middle-class children in the US are as good as their international counterparts.

It shows that in the US, as in other countries, children from better educated, wealthier families will achieve better results than poorer children.

Among children of parents with a low level of education, only 17% were proficient in maths, compared with 43% of children from well-educated families.

Falling behind

But this standard of maths among well-educated families in US is well below their counterparts in other countries.

In Poland, 71% of children from well-educated families were likely to be proficient in maths. In Germany, 64% of better-off children were proficient at maths and 55% in France.

Start Quote

Paul Peterson

There is a denial phenomenon”

End Quote Paul E Peterson Professor of government at Harvard University

Even such a poor performance was unlikely to set off alarm bells, said Paul Peterson, report co-author and professor of government at Harvard University and director of the Program on Education Policy and Governance at the Harvard Kennedy School.

"There is a denial phenomenon," says Prof Peterson.

He said the tendency to make internal comparisons between different groups within the US had shielded the country from recognising how much they are being overtaken by international rivals.

"The American public has been trained to think about white versus minority, urban versus suburban, rich versus poor," he said.

The outcome was a misleading sense of complacency about middle-class education, which always appeared to be ahead, he said.

Report authors, Prof Peterson, Eric Hanushek at Stanford University and Ludger Woessmann at the University of Munich, wrote in Education Next magazine: "Lacking good information, it has been easy even for sophisticated Americans to be seduced by apologists who would have the public believe the problems are simply those of poor kids in central city schools. "

"Our results point in quite the opposite direction," .

California down

The underachievement in some southern states was a reflection of deep-rooted historical divides and disadvantages, Prof Peterson said, such as slavery and segregation.

Massachusetts state capitol Massachusetts has high results by international standards

But the study raises questions about how other southern states can buck the trend, such as Texas.

Among the children of poorly educated families, Texas is a spectacularly strong performer, equivalent to sixth place in the OECD rankings, just behind Finland.

California raised another set of negative questions, said Prof Peterson, with a very low performance.

"California was historically thought to have a good education system, but it's plunged since the 1970s," he said.

It has an economy big enough to match many OECD countries, but in education comparisons it would be a lightweight, its maths performance weaker than in almost any other industrialised country.

"It's where the rubber hits the road," said Prof Peterson.

There were long-term implications from all this, he said. Industries were concentrating around areas with successful education systems. And success in education was linked to healthier and wealthier lives for individuals.

Rebecca Winthrop, director for the Center for Universal Education at the Brookings Institution, said the findings would "raise eyebrows". In particular, she thought it would be a wake-up call for well-educated parents who thought that worries about education were a problem for "other people's children".

But she said it was important to remember the great size of the country - and that even getting down to state level there were still huge underlying disparities and inequalities.

"California is in itself a huge place," she said. And any aggregate results are going to hide the gulf between schools serving the Silicon Valley super rich and the migrant poor.

Andreas Schleicher, responsible for the OECD's Pisa tests, said this study was a challenge to middle-class households who thought that debates about school standards did not apply to them.

"The general perception has typically been that this is mainly a concern around poor schools in poor neighbourhoods and so middle-class families have often not been particularly engaged in this," he said.

In the short term, he said, the US economy would be insulated against this underachievement because it still had a "strong skill base, simply because it was the first economy investing in universal education in the 1960s, and those people still make up a large part of the workforce".

But this legacy would not last forever.

"As time goes by, skill gaps will become increasingly apparent," he said.

The report authors conclude that as well as focusing on the gap between rich and poor, the US needs to pay more attention to the rear lights of their international rivals as they race away ahead of them.

Maths standards

How US states would compare with OECD member states in maths tests

1. South Korea

2. Japan

3. Switzerland

4. Netherlands

5. Finland

6. Estonia


7. Canada

8. Belgium

9. Germany

10. Poland


New Jersey

11. Austria



12 Australia

13. Czech Republic

14. Ireland

New Hampshire


15. New Zealand

16. Slovenia

17. Denmark

North Dakota

18. France

South Dakota

19. United Kingdom



20. Iceland



21. Luxembourg



22. Norway



23. Portugal



24. Italy

25. Slovak Republic

North Carolina

26. Spain




27. United States

28. Sweden


Rhode Island


29. Israel

30. Hungary





South Carolina





New York








31. Greece


New Mexico

32. Turkey


West Virginia



33. Chile

34. Mexico

More on This Story

More Business stories


Business Live

    09:16: Market update

    Hong Kong and mainland Chinese stocks closed lower, in line with sharp declines across most Asian share markets. The Nikkei 225 index at the Tokyo Stock Exchange fell 189.51 points, or 1.06% to 17,606.22. The benchmark Hang Seng Index fell 1.07%, or 265.96 points, to 24,595.85. Analysts said the drop was down to declines on Wall Street and concerns that China's market regulator will clamp down on margin trading, which has helped to fuel a recent rally.

    Saudi oil Via Email

    Benjamin Higgins says "about $15 a barrel". Tristan McCooey, goes with "about 3 dollars per barrel ". Dr Ian McCormick asks: "Isn't it about $4?" All good contributions.

    08:45: Deutsche earnings

    Deutsche Bank has reported a surprise pre-tax profit of €253m in the three months to the end of 2014, helped by an unexpected drop in litigation costs and a rise in trading revenue at its investment bank. Germany's largest lender was able to postpone major legal expenses in the quarter because a number of major cases have yet to be settled, but the threat of future fines still hangs over the lender, frustrating management's efforts to boost profit.

    Shell earnings Kamal Ahmed BBC Business editor

    As the first of the major oil companies to report its figures for last year, Shell plays the role of the canary in the coal mine - or on the oil rig. After a rather sickly 2013, profits are actually up. But the impact of the low oil price is clearly biting. The company announced that it would be cutting investment over the next three years in new exploration and the development of oil and gas fields, a move that will raise fresh concerns about its business in the North Sea.

    08:19: House prices
    The sun illuminates property in the historic city centre of Bath

    Nationwide says house price growth got off to a weak start in January with property values up just 0.3% in the month and 3.8% higher than the same month a year earlier. That marks the lowest rates of house price growth for 14 months.

    Saudi oil Via Email Neil Carter, Business live reader from Devon

    "In the eighties it was one to three dollars a barrel. Today I expect that it is in the region of six to eight dollars. Some newer fields may have higher costs due to higher exploration and extraction costs, so maybe ten to twenty dollars a barrel."

    07:55: Diageo results Radio 5 live

    "The results today show we are seeing a pick up in momentum," Diageo's John Kennedy tells Radio 5 live breakfast. "If you look at the overall picture... we've seen an emerging market slowdown... but the big developed markets... are performing well despite a muted recovery particularly in Europe." India is performing strongly, as is Mexico, he adds.

    07:51: Diageo results

    Distillers Diageo say profit for the six months to the end of December dropped to £1.36bn from £1.65bn as the pound strengthened and they suffered "lower income from associates and joint ventures".

    07:41: Shell earnings

    Shell's has also pulled $15bn of investment in oil exploration over the next three years. It says organic capital investment in 2015 is expected to be lower than 2014 levels. "Shell has options to further reduce spending, but we are not over-reacting to current low oil prices and keeping our best opportunities on the table," it adds.

    07:24: New fund BBC Radio 4

    Nigel Wilson, chief executive of asset manager and insurer Legal & General, says the firm will put £1.5bn for a new infrastructure fund in the UK on Today. "We are very long-term investors - 20, 30, 40, 50, years," he says. Longer-term financing from fund managers like him are the future rather than shorter-term bank lending, he says. Will £1.5bn be enough? He's attracting outside investors and will borrow money to grow the fund to about £25bn.

    07:15: Royal Mail chairman

    Donald Brydon will step down as chairman of Royal Mail, the company says. The company is looking for a new one. Mr Brydon will carry on until the firm's annual meeting in the summer.

    07:10: Shell earnings

    Shell has reported full year earnings (on a current cost of supply basis) of $19bn compared with $16.7bn a year earlier. Fourth quarter earnings were also higher at $4.2bn compared with $2.2bn for the same quarter a year ago.

    06:58: Eurozone union BBC Radio 4

    Bank of England Governor Mark Carney yesterday said the eurozone needs fiscal union to manage monetary union. James Bevan, an asset manager CCLA, tells Today "a root cause of the problem is absence of growth," low money rates alone won't get growth going.

    06:48: Shell results
    Car lights are seen streaking past an oil rig extracting petroleum

    Some discussion here on the business livepage as to just how cheap it really is to extract oil in Saudi Arabia. So we thought we'd open it up to the floor. How much do you think it costs Saudi Arabia - per barrel - to extract oil from the ground. Send your answers to or tweet @bbcbbusiness. Usual rules apply: no peeking at the internet.

    06:38: Shell results Radio 5 live

    How does the lower oil price affect alternative ways of exploring for oil such as shale? Michael Hewson of CMC markets tells Wake Up to Money shale oil exploration is largely dead in the water. Getting shale oil out of the ground is still far more expensive than getting oil out of the ground in Saudi Arabia, he says. What pushed up Saudi Arabia's oil extraction costs was the welfare programme the country introduced when the Arab Spring broke out in 2011. He adds Saudi Arabia can live with a low oil price for a long time.

    06:23: Shell results Radio 5 live

    "I think there is a good chance that we could see a reduction in [Shell's] dividend and that could affect pension funds here in the UK," Michael Hewson of CMC markets tells Wake Up to Money. He doesn't see that happening just yet, but if the oil price continues to fall, or stays low for a long time, then he thinks it is unavoidable.

    06:11: Shell results Radio 5 live

    Michael Hewson of CMC markets tells Wake Up to Money he expects Shell's revenues will be slightly lower when it publishes results later this morning. He is, naturally, interested in how Shell is coping with the lower oil price. He doesn't think "we've hit bottom yet" in terms of oil prices. "The Saudi's have still got their foot to the floor in terms of market share," he says. "The low hanging fruit in terms of getting oil of out the ground is gone," he adds.

    06:01: Apple analysis

    Apple caught up with Samsung as the world's biggest smartphone seller in the fourth quarter of 2014, thanks to booming sales of its new iPhone 6, market researcher Strategy Analytics said. Strategy Analytics said Apple flogged 74.5 million handsets in the fourth quarter, compared to 51 million a year ago. Samsung shifted the same number, which for them was a reduction from 86 million the previous year.

    06:01: Matthew West Business Reporter

    Morning. Do get in touch at or tweet us @bbcbusiness.

    06:00: Howard Mustoe Business reporter

    Good morning everyone. Overnight, McDonald's has said Don Thompson will retire as chief executive of the fast food firm to be replaced by British-born Steve Easterbrook, the company's current chief brand officer. We have house price data from the Land Registry at 09:30 and Shell's results to look forward to. Stay tuned.



From BBC Capital


  • Virtual courtroomClick Watch

    The 'forensic holodeck’ system that recreates crime scenes as 3D virtual worlds

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.