What do you do with millions of extra graduates?

Students celebrating at the end of exams, June 2014 What goes up: Pupils celebrate with their teacher at the end of college entrance exams

Rising joblessness among new university graduates in China and India is creating an army of educated unemployed that some fear could destabilise these huge economies.

Both India and China have experienced a higher education revolution in the past decade, with the number of young people completing university degrees rising from a few hundred thousand a year to many millions.

Dramatic expansion of university education should have provided new graduates with opportunities unheard of in their parents' generation.

Instead, with an alarming rise in the number of unemployed and under-employed graduates, a large group of educated young people are becoming alienated, unable to become part of the growing middle class.

The numbers are staggering. In India one in three graduates up to the age of 29 is unemployed, according to a Labour Ministry report released last November. Total unemployment in the country is officially closer to 12%.

Universities and colleges turn out five million new graduates each year.

'Idling' graduates

In China this month a record 7.26 million will graduate from the country's universities - more than seven times the number 15 years ago.

Restaurant in Beijing, June 2014 Will China's economy meet the aspirations of its young people?

Unemployment among new graduates six months after leaving university is officially around 15%. Even that conservative estimate means over a million new Chinese graduates will be jobless.

The real unemployment rate could be closer to 30% - some 2.3 million unemployed from this year's graduating cohort alone, according to Joseph Cheng, professor of political science at City University of Hong Kong.

"These are big numbers. You can easily imagine this could certainly be a very important source of unrest in China," said Prof Cheng.

Those without degrees are more willing to take blue-collar jobs, with China's non-graduate unemployment as low as 4%, says Yukon Huang, senior associate at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace in Washington DC.

He said China's leadership has for some time been extremely worried that graduate unemployment could fuel unrest of the kind that prompted the Tiananmen crackdown on protesting students in 1989.

Because of its possible impact, the social and political implications of "idling" graduates are being studied by political scientists, economists and other social scientists.

China's education ministry has already indicated that it wants to turn 600 universities into polytechnics, providing more technical and employment-related courses, rather than academic and theoretical subjects.

Unfulfilled aspirations

"There are some who see it as fuelling violence and destructive politics," said Craig Jeffrey, professor of development geography at Oxford University, an expert on India's unemployed youth.

Rainfall in Bangalore Rainfall in Bangalore: India's young graduates can get stuck waiting for jobs

"In many government reports they are seen as hostile to the state. Some believe there could be huge migration of educated young people across borders.

"In the past, India was seen as the country of the bus conductor with a BA. Now it is the country of the MA manual labourer. It has got so much worse," said Prof Jeffrey. "It is a revolution of rising aspirations and the economy can't keep pace."

Many graduates used to find jobs in the state sector in both India and China.

But with a significant youth bulge in India's population and rapid expansion in university education in China, the numbers have outgrown what can be absorbed by the jobs market.

The private sector is picky. Indian students "spend a lot of time on their degrees and ultimately realise that these degrees are not going to provide a passport into the private sector jobs," says Prof Jeffrey.

Young people waiting for opportunities that never arrive have been dubbed by Prof Jeffrey as the "timepass" generation.

He describes a generation of bored young graduates, marking time and detached from the world. "Waiting has become a profession for these young people," he said.

"Their parents are on their backs wanting them to get a job. But they don't have the English language skills or knowledge and confidence to be able to compete for the small number of, for example, IT sector jobs, that are emerging in India."

'Ant tribe'

But even in China, with its searing economic growth, the "ant tribe" has been a growing phenomenon.

Recruitment advertisements at a labour market in Guangzhou, June 2014 Job adverts in Guangzhou: China has seven million more graduates to employ

The "ant tribe" refers to the army of under-employed or underpaid graduates unable to fulfil their ambitions, according to sociologist Lian Si, whose book The Ant Tribe was published in 2010.

It described the plight of the country's post-1980s generation of low-income graduates who live together in often squalid communities in big cities waiting to join the work force.

Many of them end up spending more than they can earn. They are now regarded by sociologists as part of the country's underclass, joining lowly social groups such as peasants, migrant workers and unemployed workers, despite being intelligent and hard working.

Since the Ant Tribe was published the outlook has deteriorated. China Youth Development Foundation in Beijing estimates there are more than 160,000 "ant tribe" members in the capital alone. Around a third graduated from China's most prestigious universities.

Yet surprisingly, rather than angry and militant, researchers have so far found these graduates in China and India to be calm and still generally optimistic believing there are still jobs out there.

"At the ground level educated India's underemployed young people are not often firebrand radicals," Jeffrey said, adding it is a surprise they are not more angry as in the case of Arab Spring youth.

Nonetheless there is disappointment and in both countries the educated unemployed have become detached from wider society.

They are adjusting their expectations rather than taking radical action, researchers note.

"Grievances are accumulating but these young people are not yet ready for confrontation with the Chinese authorities," Prof Cheng believes.

Well connected

But he warns against complacency. "A sharp economic downturn in China could trigger it," said Prof Cheng, combined with rampant corruption which makes many graduates feel they are being shut out of jobs and that merit matters little.

"The college educated in China are not the kind that go around causing a lot of trouble because they are still hoping they will eventually get a job," said Huang. Nonetheless, an increasing perception that the system isn't fulfilling their expectations is causing a lot of unhappiness.

In particular, a view is widespread among both "timepass" youth and the "ant tribe" that jobs only go to those with political connections, rather than qualifications or skills.

The economic effects are easier to predict than possible unrest.

In India, there are fears that the demographic bulge will not yield the anticipated economic advantage.

The International Monetary Fund (IMF) said India's young population has the potential to produce an additional 2% per capita GDP growth each year for the next two decades.

Instead experts now talk of a "gargantuan national crisis", a ticking time-bomb of unemployed and under-employed youth unable to contribute to the economy.

China's plan to transform from a manufacturing economy to a knowledge-driven innovation economy by 2020 could be jeopardised.

Getting more Chinese into universities was meant to help build the innovation-led knowledge economy. "Instead it is creating new vulnerabilities," said Mr Huang.

Many factory jobs are now paying more than entry-level office positions, Mr Huang said. It has led to a deterioration in China's export competitiveness as its goods become more expensive, reducing its current account surplus.

China's transition to a services-led economy "is not guaranteed," and that could have complex implications for the global economy, said Mr Huang.

As for India, if its youth bulge fails to become economically active, the country will remain a low-income economy with pockets of prosperity rather than even growth.

More on This Story

More Business stories


BBC Business Live

    THE POOND 10:01:
    Man with kilt, sporren and Scottish pound

    You'll have noted the small fall in the pound. This is a plausible enough reason - the growing threat of an independent Scotland. "A poll for the Sun and the Times newspapers showed support for the pro-independence "Yes" campaign had risen to 47%, a 4 point gain," notes Reuters. The "No" lead has narrowed from 22 points to just six now. Now, is this picture as inanely stereotypical as the earlier Swiss cheese one?

    BORIS ISLAND 09:45:

    OK, so what next for UK airport capacity? Having kyboshed Boris's island idea as too expensive and impractical, the commission has another year to pick from the remaining three options - two plans to expand Heathrow Airport and one to expand Gatwick Airport.

    MARKETS 09:20: BBC Radio 4

    An interesting nugget from BlackRock's investment boss Ewen Cameron Watt. He told Today the markets' current complacency will melt in the face of higher interest rates that everyone expects are on their way. He gives some striking figures: "A 1% rise in [UK] mortgage rates will add £800-900 to the average mortgage bill." And put a serious crimp in spending power.


    Europe's share markets have all opened modestly higher. The best gainer in the UK is Weir Group, which is up 3%. And the pound has fallen 0.25% against both the dollar and the euro. It is at $1.6568 and 1.2621 euros.

    • The FTSE 100 is up 20 at 6845
    • the Dax in Frankfurt is 68 higher at 9547
    • Paris's Cac 40 is 13 points higher at 4393
    SWISS ECONOMY 08:50:
    Big cheese

    No growth in Switzerland, reports the State Secretariat for Economics. A surprise: GDP was forecast to growth by about half a percent in the second quarter. Weaker exports and falling construction spending were the culprits. Yearly GDP growth was 0.6% - way under hopes of 1.7% growth. We will endeavour to find an even more fatuous picture before we pack up for the day. Might be hard.

    CHINA PROPERTY 08:34: Via Blog Linda Yueh Chief business correspondent

    The various steps that China is taking to stem house price rises seems to be working, but can the government manage an orderly slowdown in the property sector? Linda Yueh finds out here.

    BORIS ISLAND 08:19: Radio 5 live
    boris island

    Aviation expert David Bentley told Wake up to Money about one of the three remaining airport expansion options - that to expand Heathrow as a "hub", he says. A hub can mean base for airlines, or a major airport to change plane, as in a "hub and spoke system," he says. Whatever is decided, it will need to satisfy air travellers for the next 20 years or so, he adds.


    Australia's central bank kept its interest rate at a record low of 2.5% for a 12th consecutive policy meeting. The economy is growing sluggishly, initial data suggest.

    BORIS ISLAND Adam Parsons Business Correspondent

    tweets: Davies says Boris Island project would be "reckless" and unlikely to appeal to government "of any political colour"

    Redrow houses

    Redrow says a large number of its Help to Buy clients were first time buyers and over half were in the north of England. It says its order book is looking plump - up 85% on last year. Business Live has been debating Redrow's building style. Ease of upkeep of the wooden bits has excited debate.


    Housebuilder Redrow's results are here. The usual tale of rising prices and the government's Help to Buy scheme. Redrow reports a 13% increase in the average selling price to £239,500, record group revenues and record pre-tax profits (almost doubling). Help To Buy provided 35% of private completions.

    BORIS ISLAND 07:07:

    Sir Howard Davis, chairman of the commission, said it had come down against Boris's island airport plan because: "The economic disruption would be huge and there are environmental hurdles which it may prove impossible, or very time-consuming to surmount." Even the least-ambitious version of the scheme would cost £70-90bn."

    BORIS ISLAND 07:04:

    "The Airports Commission has today (2 September 2014) announced its decision not to add the inner Thames estuary airport proposal to its shortlist of options for providing new airport capacity by 2030. Following detailed further study into the feasibility of an inner Thames estuary airport the commission has concluded that the proposal has substantial disadvantages that collectively outweigh its potential benefits." A firm no, as expected.

    MARKETS 06:56: BBC Radio 4

    BlackRock is the world's largest asset manager with more than $4.5 trillion under management. Its investment boss Ewen Cameron Watt, discussing why markets are so steady in the face of so much global tension tells Today: "Volatility is exceptionally low by historical standards and there's too much money chasing too few assets."

    HSBC SHARES 06:42: Radio 5 live

    Ewen Cameron Watt, Chief Investment Strategist of the BlackRock Investment Institute, is now on 5 live talking about the news Neil Woodford, the fund manager, flogged his HSBC shares. "Neil bought HSBC because it was one of the few banks where he thought there was some dividend growth," he says. However, fines in the sector are likely to drain that prospect, he says. It's fines "more than anything that's sapping bank's willingness too lend, or ability to lend".

    MARKETS 06:27: BBC Radio 4

    Today is looking at why stock markets are at a 52-week high when the political situation around the world is so dire - there's the threat of war in Europe and conflict in the key oil producer Iraq. Ewen Cameron Watt, chief investment strategist at Investment Institute of giant asset manager BlackRock says: "At this stage in the summer months the thought that Russia might affect sending gas to Europe is not a worry. [Energy stocks] are about 90% of capacity."

    BANKING COMPLAINTS 06:12: Radio 5 live

    More from the Financial Ombudsman's Caroline Wayman. Fee-paying bank accounts are the cause of the increase in complaints about banking, she says. "People are getting in touch saying they didn't know they had a fee paying account or want one." People are "more aware but we see a lot of people who are reluctant to raise concerns," when coming forward to the service, she says. There are also more complaints about payday loans, but from a low starting point she says.

    BANKING COMPLAINTS 06:02: Radio 5 live

    Caroline Wayman, chief executive of the Financial Ombudsman Service is on Wake Up to Money talking about complaints about banks. Complaints about payment protection insurance have fallen by almost a third, but complaints about other things in banking are up: "Still a lot of people get in touch, more than 1,000 people a day," she says. "We've had to expand a lot."

    06:01: Howard Mustoe Business reporter

    Morning! Get in touch via email bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or via twitter @BBCBusiness

    06:00: Rebecca Marston Business reporter, BBC News

    Good morning and welcome to Tuesday's Business Live. Stick with us for the pick of the morning's news.



  • Ernest Hemingway, as war correspondent, travelling with US soldiers to Normandy for the D-Day landingsAbandoned hero

    Why Paris is forgetting Ernest Hemingway

  • Women doing ice bucket challengeChill factor

    How much has the Ice Bucket Challenge achieved?

  • Members of staff at James Stevenson Flags hold a Union Jack and Saltire flag UK minus Scotland

    Does the rest of the UK care if the Scots become independent?

  • Women in front of Windows XP posterUpgrade angst

    Readers share their experiences of replacing their operating system

From BBC Capital


  • Stranded shipThe Travel Show Watch

    Stranded in the icy Northwest Passage where only the polar bears move freely

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.