Wine fraud: How easy is it to fake a 50-year-old bottle?

Old wine bottles With vintage wines fetching prices in excess of $200,000, wine fraud has become a lucrative business

Related Stories

Rudy Kurniawan was sentenced to 10 years in jail for committing wine fraud. But just how easy is it to fake a fancy bottle of Burgundy?

Wine fraud was a problem in classical Rome and it continues to be one now. Some estimate that over 5% of wine consigned and sold at auction is fake.

But even though it is a very big problem, it is a very difficult thing to do.

"There is a distinctive taste in aged wine," says wine chemist Andrew Waterhouse, of the University of California, Davis.

That taste?

"Canned asparagus," he says.

Old wines - mostly those from the Burgundy and Bordeaux regions of France - have lost the majority of their tannins, giving them a softer taste reminiscent of the spring vegetable.

But taste is only one part of the equation. "It is the experience of drinking something that's quite rare that's appealing," explains Prof Waterhouse.

Counterfeit kitchen

So how to do it? Mr Kurniawan's case provides a good road map.

Mr Kurniawan managed to sell over $20m (£11.9m) worth of fake wine for more than a decade before he was caught.

A courtroom sketch of Mr Kurniawan A courtroom sketch of Mr Kurniawan, who was sentenced to 10 years in jail and ordered to pay $23.8m

Geoffrey Troy is a wine merchant in New York who became suspicious when Mr Kurniawan bought bottles of 1974 Domaine de la Romanee-Conti. It was a good, but not great, vintage of French Burgundy.

"A serious collector wouldn't be buying off-vintages," says Mr Troy.

"He was so eager to buy these bottles that I suspected that he could possibly be using them to change the vintage at some point and sell them for a lot more money."

line
Five ways to spot a fake vintage wine
Wine corks
  • Label - Labels that are not on proper paper stock from the period, or do not have the proper font, are a giveaway
  • Capsule - Some fakes swap wax for foil at the top of the bottle, or use the wrong colour wax
  • Cork - Often branded with the name of the winery and the vintage, the font and shading can be clues
  • Wine colour - Old wine has its own colour, some fakes don't
  • Glass - Very old bottles have distinctive glass

Source: Allan Frischman, Hart Davis Hart Wine Auction house

line

And that's exactly what Mr Kurniawan was doing in his kitchen in Arcadia, California - essentially creating a "better" vintage by mixing old, good-but-not-great wines with some newer, vibrant pinot noirs.

Give it a shake, put it in an old bottle, smack on a vintage label - say, one from 1985 instead of 1982 - and voila.

"He could take a $200 bottle and turn it into over a $1,000 bottle," says Mr Troy.

Mr Troy Mr Troy sold several bottles of wine to Mr Kurniawan, but came to suspect him

Unless you are used to drinking fine vintages regularly - which not that many people are, given that they can cost thousands of dollars - the taste would not necessarily ring any alarm bells.

"By blending the fruitiness of a new wine with the aged character of the old wine he would approximate in some manner a very, very good aged Burgundy," explains Prof Waterhouse.

Label lies

Furthermore, in choosing extremely old vintages to consign to auctions, Mr Kurniawan made a savvy choice.

Mr Kurniawan's kitchen When police raided Mr Kurniawan's house, they found his kitchen filled with wine fraud supplies

"Back in the 1920s and 30s, many of the producers never branded their corks, or used capsules (the foil or wax at the top of a bottle) that were plain," explains Mr Troy.

Those plain markers were easy to forge. What tripped up Mr Kurniawan was the label.

In June 2008, Mr Kurniawan attempted to consign some $2,613,860 of wine to auction house Hart Davis Hart.

Allan Frischman, a vice-president and wine inspector with Hart Davis Hart, rejected the lot.

"It didn't really require a lot of study - most of the wines we were able to tell pretty easily from photographs of the labels that they were not authentic," he says.

Mr Frischman says that less than 2% of the wines he has inspected at Hart Davis Hart have been forgeries, and the labels are often what tip him off to frauds.

To find a fraud

Mr Kurniawan's case has sent shockwaves through the small world of vintage wine collectors, auction houses, and vineyards. Some say it will take years to figure out just how many of his fake bottles are still in the market.

Mr Kurniawan's vintage labels Mr Kurniawan had over 12,000 wine labels in his possession, but they didn't fool experts

That has led for calls to have auction houses examine more carefully the provenance of bottles, as well as for better fraud detection technologies.

line
Can tech prevent frauds?
Selinko scan technology

Patrick Eischen cites his personal experience with wine fraud as the motivation behind his firm, Selinko, which uses chip technology to help prevent old bottles from being reused.

A part-owner of a vineyard in Italy, he found his wines were being widely counterfeited in China.

So Mr Eischen developed a technology that takes advantage of the same thing in many credit cards - microchips - which are then tagged using an operator's phone.

"We developed a technology which goes on the capsule of the bottles so that when you open them it deactivates the system," he says.

This way, it is not just auction houses and experts who are looking to prevent fraud, but vineyards and consumers as well.

line

"One big problem is most of the analyses require opening a bottle," explains Prof Waterhouse.

"Given the value of these bottles and the scarcity, most people will say 'maybe not'."

Some have pointed to isotope analysis that could better break down the origins of the wine in a bottle, and another professor at UC Davis, Matthew Augustine, has recently published papers on using magnetic resonance imaging to determine if wine has turned into vinegar.

Others have argued for chip technology to be put on all bottles, so that old bottles could not then be re-used to package fake wine.

But for now, those who have been duped can take comfort in joining an elite group that spans the centuries.

"Not even our nobility ever enjoys wines that are genuine," complained Pliny the Elder, back in First Century Rome.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories

RSS

BBC Business Live

  1.  
    07:21: GERMAN GROWTH BBC Radio 4

    Germany has very low unemployment, Dr Stephanie Hare, senior analyst for western Europe at Oxford Analytica tells Today. "Making more jobs for Germany isn't the issue here," she says. "We need stimulus and investment in countries that are going to help boost the future of Germany's trading partners in the eurozone. So we can either increase demand in Germany, or Germany could be part of a wider European solution to increase stimulus in its eurozone trading partners." She points out Germany has benefitted from other countries investing and stimulating its economy once or twice in the past century.

     
  2.  
    07:11: EUROTUNNEL

    Eurostar results yesterday, Eurotunnel results today. Revenues for the third quarter of 2014 increased 7% to €343.9m (£271.5m).

     
  3.  
    06:57: UK BORROWING Radio 5 live

    "The main reason tax receipts aren't as high as you'd like is the increase in personal tax allowance," says Alan Clarke, UK and eurozone economist at Scotiabank on Wake Up to Money. He's talking about yesterday's disappointing figures. There are more people in work, though, which means less spending on benefits, he says. Low-paid jobs mean that doesn't help as much as you may think, points out presenter Mickey Clark.

     
  4.  
    06:47: GERMAN GROWTH BBC Radio 4

    Christian Schultz, senior economist at Berenberg Bank, tells the Today programme Germany needs to work on its infrastructure, but even if it started to work on inward investment now the effects would not be felt for several years. This as more political pressure builds on Germany to act to avert another eurozone crisis. But German inward investment doesn't solve the problem, he says. "How does Germany fixing some bridges make French and Italian entrepreneurs invest more?"

     
  5.  
    06:34: STORM POWER
    storm

    The UK's wind farms generated more power than its nuclear power stations on Tuesday, the National Grid says. The energy network operator said it was caused by a combination of high winds and faults in nuclear plants. Wind made up 14.2% of all generation and nuclear offered 13.2%. As BBC environment analyst Roger Harrabin reports, for a 24-hour period yesterday, spinning blades produced more energy than splitting atoms.

     
  6.  
    06:24: CITY POWERS Radio 5 live

    On things like transport and education, local government can make better decisions, says Alexandra Jones, chief executive of the Centre for Cities, which does independent research and policy analysis on UK city economies on 5 live. "Whatever you're doing in a city, you have to balance the books, though, she says. Competitiveness on tax becomes a "race to the bottom" she adds.

     
  7.  
    06:13: CITY POWERS Radio 5 live

    "I think there's real momentum... this is the biggest opportunity in decades to transport the relationship with local government," says Mr Wakefield on 5 live. The debate for Scottish independence shows there are a lot of people interested in local powers, he adds.

     
  8.  
    06:04: CITY POWERS Radio 5 live

    Allowing UK cities to make their own decisions on tax and spending could boost economic growth by £79bn a year by 2030, a year-long study has concluded. "More people want local powers in Leeds," says Councillor Keith Wakefield, leader of Leeds City Council on Radio 5 live. He thinks councils can target some spending more efficiently.

     
  9.  
    06:01: Howard Mustoe Business reporter

    Good morning! Get in touch via email at bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or on twitter @BBCBusiness

     
  10.  
    06:00: Matthew West Business reporter

    Morning all. We have the latest minutes from the Bank of England's September Monetary Policy Committee meeting at 09:30; Argos and Homebase owner Home Retail Group publishes interim results before that and there are trading updates from GlaxoSmithKline, British American Tobacco and Everything Everywhere. We'll bring you it all as it happens.

     

Features

From BBC Capital

Programmes

  • Smart glassesClick Watch

    Smart spectacles go into battle – the prototypes looking to take on Google Glass

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.