EU referendum: A simple choice but a complex decision

Image copyright altamira83

By definition, a referendum presents us all with a choice. That was true with the independence plebiscite in 2014. It is true now with the vote over whether the UK should remain within the European Union or not.

As in 2014, it is a simple choice - Remain or Leave - but a complex decision, with a range of competing factors.

That complexity, those layers, were on display at Holyrood today in what was a rather intriguing debate. More interesting than the advance arithmetic would have suggested, with the vote weighed heavily towards Remain.

Firstly, let me praise those MSPs who were speaking for the first time. Each delivered cogent, substantive contributions. Seriously, they were good. It would be invidious to single any one out. So I won't. Ok, maybe later.

Incidentally, several of the newbies said they were delivering their "maiden" speeches, in defiant contradistinction to the prevalent view that this is an inappropriate term.

Read full article EU referendum: A simple choice but a complex decision

Name checks and Ninja Turtles

party leaders Image copyright PA
Image caption Ruth Davidson's Conservative's were the only opposition party not to have been name checked by Nicola Sturgeon

Let me bring you a few lines from the first minister's statement at Holyrood this afternoon. Here's one. "We will consider the introduction of a young Carers' Allowance…….this is a proposal that was in the Green Party manifesto. I think it has real merit…"

Here's another. "This work will be led by a new, dedicated minister for mental health - a key ask of the Liberal Democrat manifesto".

Read full article Name checks and Ninja Turtles

When worlds collide and upset the path of order

Jonathan Swift
Image caption Jonathan Swift - the poet and essayist who penned 'The Lady's dressing Room'

Argument persists to this day over the import of Jonathan Swift's poem "The Lady's Dressing Room".

To qualify that comment, argument persists in very limited, literary circles. I still recall one of my English tutors at St Andrews repeating lines from the poem with evident, ironic relish. Ok, one notorious line in particular.

Read full article When worlds collide and upset the path of order

The wry banter before rampant battles

Nicola Sturgeon Image copyright Getty Images

This, Nicola Sturgeon informed the chamber, is a serious government with a serious job to do. Cue an outburst of solemn nodding.

Thankfully, this comment - at the conclusion of the first minister's speech - did not pre-empt the drollery and wit which customarily attends the appointment of new ministers.

Read full article The wry banter before rampant battles

Nicola Sturgeon's cabinet choices reveal her priorities

Cabinet Image copyright Getty Images
Image caption Nicola Sturgeon paraded her new Cabinet outside Bute House

To govern is to choose. Politics is the language of priorities. One should avoid cliches like the plague.

Had enough now? Thought so.

Read full article Nicola Sturgeon's cabinet choices reveal her priorities

Willie versus Nicola: Holyrood chooses its first minister

Cahmber
Image caption MSPs gathered to choose a nominee for first minister

Always glad to welcome a listener. Or two. Willie Rennie confided to parliament that he had been listening to the wireless this morning in the company of his twelve year old son.

The subject? My report informing an astonished nation that Mr Rennie planned to stand for the post of first minister.

Read full article Willie versus Nicola: Holyrood chooses its first minister

Welcoming Holyrood's new Presiding Officer Ken Macintosh

KenMac

Congratulations, then, to Ken Macintosh who has been elected as Holyrood's new Presiding Officer. He has a tough job ahead, of which more anon, but he made a notably fine start.

First, there was no hubris or bombast in his tone. Indeed, in acknowledging victory, he deployed some deft drollery, at his own expense.

Read full article Welcoming Holyrood's new Presiding Officer Ken Macintosh

Sturgeon and Pym on landslides and successful government

Francis Pym
Image caption Margaret Thatcher disagreed with Francis Pym's assertion

Remember Francis Pym? Chief Whip and Northern Ireland Secretary under Ted Heath? Later, Defence Secretary, Leader of the House and, finally, Foreign Secretary during the Falklands War?

That's the fella. Anyway, I thought idly of him as I listened to the first minister at her news conference today.

Read full article Sturgeon and Pym on landslides and successful government

Holyrood 2016: MSPs return to Holyrood

Darren McGregor scores for Hibernian Image copyright SNS
Image caption The cheers for Hibernian's goals against Raith Rovers echoed across Leith on Saturday

I chanced to be in a supermarket in the eastern sector of Edinburgh on Saturday. To narrow the topography still further, I heard, as I entered, a raucous cheer from the nearby stadium of Hibernian Football Club.

The yell no doubt greeted one of the two goals which Hibs scored that day to defeat their rivals, Raith Rovers, in the Championship play-off. I'm afraid I cannot offer more detail.

Read full article Holyrood 2016: MSPs return to Holyrood

Holyrood 2016: Results, rethinks and reappraisal

Christine Grahame won the final constituency seat for the SNP
Image caption Christine Grahame won the final constituency seat for the SNP

07:50 The final constituency is in - and it goes to the SNP. But still the firm forecast is that they will fall short of an overall majority. Very good result for them, nevertheless, bearing in mind that voting system is designed to constrain majorities of seats on popular minorities.


06:29 - Kezia Dugdale, returned as a Lothian list Labour member, says that steering clear of the constitution in this election cost her party votes.

Read full article Holyrood 2016: Results, rethinks and reappraisal