Are the poor kids really the fat ones?

 
Obese boy Children from poorer backgrounds are more likely to be obese, but was it right for the minister to say it?

Public Health Minister Anna Soubry is no stranger to controversy.

During her four months in the job, she has hit the headlines for comments about "appalling" right-to-die laws and for claiming the government had "screwed up" its reform message.

Now she is back in the spotlight after suggesting you can spot poor children by looking at the size of their waistlines.

According to the plain-speaking Miss Soubry, in years gone by the poor children at school were the "skinny runts".

But as the nation struggles with the obesity epidemic that situation has reversed - with the deprived kids now the fattest, she says.

But is she right?

Well, clearly children from richer backgrounds can be obese, something she herself acknowledged in her comments to the Daily Telegraph when she said her point was more that the greater propensity for obesity lay among the more deprived communities.

And the statistics seem to back her up - to some extent at least.

'Hardly categorical'

The latest figures show that children from the most deprived 10% of backgrounds were nearly twice as likely to be obese.

The data from the government's child measurement programme, which is carried out in primary schools across England, shows that 12.3% of the poorest reception kids were obese, compared to 6.8% from the wealthiest backgrounds.

A similar pattern emerged among year six pupils - the other age group that takes part in the measurement programme - with 24.3% of the most deprived children obese, compared to 13.7% of the least.

Where the waters get a little muddied is with overweight children that are not quite classed as obese.

Again the children from the more deprived backgrounds are the most likely to be overweight, but by a much smaller margin.

In the case of year six pupils the difference is less than one percentage point.

Perhaps the best thing to do is to combine the two groups, overweight and obese.

BBC

When you do that you find about four in 10 children from the most deprived backgrounds are carrying excess weight, compared to nearly three in 10 from the richest.

The gap for reception age children is even closer - one in four, compared to just under one in five.

So while Miss Soubry is right, it is hardly categorical.

In fact, when you look at it another way she could have said you are more likely to be a healthy weight and poor just as you are more likely to be a healthy weight and rich.

But, of course, that would not have been newsworthy.

And perhaps that is the point.

As minister for public health she wants to get people talking and thinking about lifestyle issues.

But has she gone about it the right way?

Experts have mixed views on this.

It is unusual these days to find a minister using such colourful language -and there are some who believe it will harm the drive to tackle obesity.

Tam Fry, from the National Obesity Forum, says it is an "insult" to people on low incomes who are working hard to provide their children with a healthy diet when the odds are stacked against them.

He believes ministers would do better to take a firmer line with industry.

"The government has to be tougher and set limits to the salt, sugar and fat in foods. We are living in an obesogenic environment where it is harder to make healthier choices. Parents have to feed their children."

There are many people who share Mr Fry's sentiments.

But equally some are pleased to see ministers talking so bluntly.

Prof Alan Maryon-Davis, a former president of the UK Faculty of Public Health, has some sympathy with the suggestion that such comments can stigmatise people.

But he says: "By saying what she did in the way she said it she got attention. People start talking about the issue and that is good.

"And it must be remembered she also talked about bad food and industry so I prefer to give her credit."

 
Nick Triggle Article written by Nick Triggle Nick Triggle Health correspondent

NHS strikes: What next?

The first NHS strike over pay for more than 30 years has taken place. It could be the start of a period of industrial unrest. Is there a way out of this dispute, asks Nick Triggle.

Read full article

More on This Story

More from Nick

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 260.

    I'm 69, cycle about 100 miles a week, swim and weight-train twice weekly and walk as much as possible.
    I'm the same weight as I was when I was 21. I've always been active like so many of many generation.
    Being slim and muscular I'm amazingly attractive to women although the size of my pension helps.
    Alan

  • rate this
    +3

    Comment number 259.

    I'm afraid this is what happens when the only reason people have kids is so that they can claim benefits.

  • rate this
    +4

    Comment number 258.

    230 comment. No they dont their utility bills get paid by our tax. A spud a £1 nonsense,dont buy baking spuds buy nomal same price a kilo. Aldi sell beans 4for£1.08, plus fresh veg cheaper. Work your menu to cheaper veg, making excuses is pathetic & doesnt excuse laziness. Cooking fresh veg is cheaper than ready made without the addatives, something we have always done.

  • rate this
    +4

    Comment number 257.

    Although there is a strong statistical correlation between fatness and social class, people are generally getting fatter including many middle class people. Whereas nurses used to be slim and "fly" around the wards now many are seriously overweight.
    People are eating too much and not taking enough exercise.
    Drive less, cycle and walk more, use public transport and eat more fruit.
    Alan

  • rate this
    +4

    Comment number 256.

    No its just laziness in just not cooking proper meals, eyes watching TV too many hour a day on Sky, [we canrt afford sky, I wouldnt want it anyway ] if its so called poor, then are Prescott, AbbottBrown,Balls, I notice Clegg has certainly put on weight. Even at my age we walk. When parents/kids poor/rich wont excercise/eat rubbish then obesity happens, stop trying to make excuses for bad parents

 

Comments 5 of 260

 

Features & Analysis

BBC Future

(Getty Images)

‘Why I want to die at 75’

The folly of aiming for ever-longer life Read more...

Programmes

  • St John's, CanadaThe Travel Show Watch

    It’s a ships’ symphony – listen to these freighters in Canada play music with their horns

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.