Migrants to face NHS emergency care charges in England

 

Lord Howe: "We've got to get better at detecting them (health tourists)"

Related Stories

Migrants and overseas visitors are to face new charges for some NHS services in England, ministers say.

They include extended prescription fees, the introduction of charges for some emergency care and higher rates for optical and dental services.

However, GP and nurse consultations will remain free, and nobody will be turned away in an emergency.

Ministers say they are keen to clamp down on any abuse of the system, but doctors' leaders have voiced concerns.

The government had considered charging for GP consultations, but decided that easy initial access was important to prevent risks to public health such as HIV, TB and sexually transmitted infections.

Other types of primary care services that are being considered for charging include minor surgery that is carried out by a GP and physiotherapy that has been referred through a GP.

There are also plans to introduce a new system for identifying and recording patients who should be charged for NHS services.

Specific details of how the plans will be implemented are due to be unveiled in March 2014.

FREE NHS FOR WHOM?

  • Free NHS care is offered to anyone living in the UK who has temporary or permanent permission to do so
  • Asylum seekers, non-European Economic Area nationals who do not have permission to live in the UK, British expats, and visitors usually have to pay for treatment
  • The UK has reciprocal agreements with most European nations and 28 other countries, and under these visitors are given free NHS care
  • The NHS should claim these costs back from the relevant governments - but research suggests just £73m a year is recouped out of more than £460m at present.

The government said the changes would allow the NHS to recoup money, and encourage only those who need urgent and emergency care to attend.

Health Minister Lord Howe said: "Having a universal health service free at the point of use rightly makes us the envy of the world, but we must make sure the system is fair to the hardworking British taxpayers who fund it.

"We know that we need to make changes across the NHS to better identify and charge visitors and migrants. Introducing charging at primary care is the first step to achieving this.

"We are already looking at taking action and next year we will set out our detailed plans to clamp down on the abuse of our NHS."

A report by the King's Fund think tank has estimated that an average attendance at A&E costs the NHS approximately £111.

'Unintended drawbacks'

The British Medical Association said it was concerned the proposals would require doctors and GPs to spend more time on paperwork and that it could cost more in administration charges than what it would recuperate.

Dr Mark Porter, chairman of the BMA Council, said: "The government's current proposals could create unintended drawbacks for the NHS and patients.

"They are likely to create a complex patchwork of charging and access entitlements where some services remain free, such as GP appointments, while others will be chargeable, including A&E visits and other services provided via many GP practices, such as physiotherapy."

Dr Chaand Nagpaul, who leads the BMA's GP committee, added: "We cannot have a situation where any patient with a serious health need is deterred from visiting a GP, especially if their condition raises a potential public health risk."

Labour shadow health minister Lord Hunt accused ministers of "putting spin before substance".

"Labour is in favour of improving the recovery of costs from people with no entitlement to NHS treatment," he said.

"Rather than more grand-standing, the government needs to deliver practical, thought-through changes to make that happen.

Annual costs. total migrants using NHS 2.6m, cost to NHS £1.9-2bn, average cost per head £690, government estimate of saving £500m.

"Instead this out-of-touch government is left asking doctors and nurses to act as surrogate immigration officials."

The announcement follows a Department of Health study which estimated that up to £500m could be recovered from overseas visitors' and migrants' use of the NHS every year through better charging. However, it estimated that only approximately £8m would come from charges for using A&E.

However, academics have argued that the extent of deliberate health tourism - where people travel to the UK specifically to use the NHS - has been hugely overstated and is responsible for only a small part of NHS expenditure.

The government has already announced a £200-a-year levy on migrants from outside the European Economic Area staying for between six months and five years.

A cost-recovery unit will help hospitals claw back money they are owed by other governments for treating foreign nationals visiting the UK.

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +3

    Comment number 1598.

    No wonder there are long waiting times ! I believe in helping others but surely if people can afford the flights over here they would be able to pay for treatment wherever they are. Obviously we have one of the best health services in the world but where do these people get health numbers from to get treated for free ?

  • rate this
    +3

    Comment number 1593.

    Measure which do not go far enough unfortunately. Pay or have insurance to pay........ end of........ same as it is for UK citizens going abroad for whatever reason who find themselves requiring medical help.

  • rate this
    +104

    Comment number 629.

    I can understand where people are coming from when they talk about helping people, healthcare is undoubtedly a right we should all be entitled too....

    however, This is reality and the NHS only has finite resources and manpower to which the British taxpayer pays for. This move should have been implemented ages ago. The UK needs to stop trying to provide for everyone in the world!

  • rate this
    +109

    Comment number 613.

    These proposed measures don't go far enough. The NHS is free at the point of use, but it isn't free. It is funded with taxpayer money and it is an incredibly expensive system. Emergency care should be free to all. For the good of the public, services related to infectious diseases should be free to all. Visitors to the UK and non-tax paying immigrants should pay full cost for all other services.

  • rate this
    -137

    Comment number 101.

    We are all human so we all deserve a level of care, that's pure & simple & It would be barbaric of any society to turn down some level of medical treatment, especially in an emergency.

    My only concern is that people begin to abuse the system to their own ends & let's face it, this will happen in a diverse society.

    I personally like the fact that the UK provides this service to others in need.

 

Comments 5 of 8

 

More Health stories

RSS

Features & Analysis

BBC Future

(Thinkstock)

The truth about music and sex

Do primal rhythms rule laws of attraction? Read more...

Programmes

  • Papers Please gameClick Watch

    Meet the ‘bedroom programmer’ whose game has sold half a million copies and won a Bafta

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.