War on Christmas: Is the festival under attack?

 
Santa in cross hairs composite

Dozens of US congressmen have pledged to protect Christmas from attempts to undermine it. So is the West's foremost public holiday really under attack?

One of the most famous family scenes in history, the nativity, appears to be facing threats from all sides.

A tug of war is going on over a nativity setting on a courthouse lawn in Texas, with the Freedom from Religion Foundation urging it be removed or an atheistic solstice banner put up nearby. In South Carolina, a state hospital has banned a nativity scene from its premises.

It's part of a wider assault on the Christmas tradition, say some Christian groups, who also point to a rule barring congressmen from sending Christmas cards through the official congressional post.

Theirs is a very modern crusade over the place of religion in public life that has been taken up on both sides of the Atlantic. In the UK, rumours the very name "Christmas" had been replaced in some places by "Winterval" provoked outrage.

Contests over Christmas past

Christmas has always been a very difficult holiday to Christianise - it's never been wholly in the control of the Church.

Since the Fourth Century, there have always been pious Christians who have tried to make Christmas into an occasion of devotion and meditation, but I don't think those people have ever really controlled the way the holiday is celebrated.

If you put yourself back into a pre-modern agricultural society, Christmas is the convergence of the solstice with a very important seasonal development: Once the work of the harvest and the post-harvest is done - at least if you're male - there's an extended period when you have nothing to do.

And it's the only time of the year when you slaughter animals in a systematic way.

If you put together this season of leisure with the availability of alcohol and fresh food, especially fresh meat, you've got a very combustible combination of circumstances.

Christmas was celebrated by most people in England as an occasion of revelry, of overeating, of drinking. Christmas was a rowdy holiday.

Source: BBC interview

Now the US Congress has joined the fight. A non-binding resolution sponsored by 67 Republicans and Democrats expresses "the sense of the House of Representatives that the symbols and traditions of Christmas should be protected for use by those who celebrate Christmas".

The resolution "strongly disapproves of attempts to ban references to Christmas" and "expresses support for the use of these symbols and traditions by those who celebrate Christmas".

It was never brought up for a vote, in part because Congress has been consumed with fights over taxes and the budget. But it has sparked debate.

"In recent years, there has been an effort by some to ban any reference to Christmas by the federal government or our elected officials," Arkansas Democratic Congressman Mike Ross wrote to supporters on Monday.

"While I certainly respect the US Constitution... it does not expressly ban any mention of religion or reference to God, Christianity or Christmas by practising Christians."

In wading into the debate, Congress joins a coalition of conservatives who say they are fighting to save Christmas from, say, shopkeepers who would offer discounts for the "holiday season" rather than for Christmas alone.

In Anchorage, Alaska, a group was planning to converge on city hall to hold a carol-singing protest in defence of Christmas customs they believe to be under threat, such as the habit of wishing someone "Merry Christmas" instead of "Happy Holidays".

Republican presidential contender Rick Perry used a recent advert to complain that children could no longer celebrate Christmas openly, and that President Obama had launched a "war on religion".

Start Quote

There's something wrong in this country when gays can serve openly in the military but our kids can't openly celebrate Christmas”

End Quote Texas Governor Rick Perry Republican presidential candidate

Last week, Pastor Nathan Lorick of the First Baptist Church of Malakoff, Texas led a rally of about 5,000 Christians to defend the right of a courthouse to display the nativity scene while forbidding a banner celebrating solstice.

"Each year, as you sit back and watch, the attacks on Christmas are becoming more and more prevalent," says Mr Lorick.

"We found an opportunity here to stand up and address the issue that's going on nationwide, an ever-intensifying persecution of Christianity in America."

Members of the Freedom from Religion Foundation, who want the display removed, insist they are not out to rid Christianity from public life, but want to enforce the separation of church and state.

"Either they take the nativity scene down because it's there as a sole-focus display, or they truly have a public forum and they allow us to put our sign up too," says co-president Annie Laurie Gaylor.

"Nobody is talking about banning nativity scenes in church lawns and private homes."

'Winterval' v 'Christmas'?

The same debate has been aired in the UK. On Thursday, it was reported that Christmas decorations had been banned at a government office by "Scrooge pen pushers" who said they were inappropriate in a "diverse workplace".

Rockefeller Center You can't escape Christmas in New York

That kind of clampdown was on the mind of Communities Secretary Eric Pickles last year, when he criticised unnamed town councils that he said had toned down their Christmas themes for fear of causing offence.

"We should actively celebrate the Christian basis of Christmas, and not allow politically correct Grinches to marginalise Christianity and the importance of the birth of Christ," he said on his website.

Some of the stories about a "war on Christmas" have turned out to be more complicated than initially thought. One newspaper printed a correction last month after wrongly reporting that Christmas had been renamed "Winterval" in parts of the UK. There was an instance in 1998 when Birmingham City Council was criticised by church leaders for calling a series of religious and secular events "Winterval", but it said Christmas still played a part within that programme of events.

And a story that government bureaucrats had suddenly banned congressmen from writing "Merry Christmas" in official constituent communications was actually due to a policy inscribed in a federal law that bars official mailings offering "holiday greetings" and other personal notes. The rule dates back at least as far as 1974, and forbids members sending birthday, anniversary, retirement or similar greetings in official mail.

But if anyone is fighting against Christmas, they seem to be losing the battle. Indeed, polls indicate the vast majority of Americans celebrate the holiday, with most incorporating religious elements into the observance.

The 'Happy holidays' debate

  • 'Happy holidays' is more commonly heard in the US than the UK (where 'Merry Christmas' is the greeting of choice)
  • It's used in the period between Thanksgiving and the New Year
  • Critics say it's anti-Christian and have called on shops that use it to be boycotted
  • But others say the greeting is more inclusive of other festivals such as Hanukkah

"We're inundated with Christmas," says Max Brantley, a journalist and political analyst in Arkansas who has followed Mr Ross's career.

"Christmas is not in danger, and the notion that the US congress needs to waste time with a resolution that asserts it's in danger is just silly."

But many believe there is a battle to fight, to preserve the Christian traditions, and it's a conflict in which they are in ascendancy, with the vast majority of people on their side.

"The tide is turning," says Andrew Marsh, spokesman for Not Ashamed, a UK campaign founded last year by former Archbishop of Canterbury Lord Carey to reinvigorate public Christianity in Britain.

"This year, I have been encouraged. The vast majority of the public are sympathetic to the Christian message at Christmas time. Some of the attacks seem small minded and scrooge-like."

 

More on This Story

In today's Magazine

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +43

    Comment number 319.

    It's a bit surprising to find no mention of the period in which Christmas was indeed banned in England--1648-60 under the Commonwealth and Protectorate. Ironically, it was banned as being 'idolatrous'--i.e., there was no reference to it in the Bible. The resolutely idolatrous population attempted to celebrate it anyway and welcomed its return with the king.

  • rate this
    +11

    Comment number 313.

    I can't help noticing that those claiming to be offended by the religious aspects of the Christmas holiday are never so offended that they don't take the day off with the rest of us--or to demand holiday pay if asked to work that day.

  • rate this
    +9

    Comment number 303.

    There is a misunderstanding here,with all the negative anti-Christian comments posted.Christmas and Christianity enshrine values that all major religions and humanists believe in- tolerance, peace, love, right action, non violence.These are values that we need to expand to other parts of the year,not diminish.A year-round of commercialism and "me me" is the last thing that we need!Merry Christmas!

  • rate this
    +10

    Comment number 233.

    If you want to ban the Nativity or the cross from public places, please also ban all ethnic or religious dress forms at the same time. If you want to prevent us celebrating our faith, feel free to stop all other religious celebrations too. I think that, if people want to live in a Christian founded country that welcomes diversity, they must at least accept ALL of the symbolism that accompanies it.

  • rate this
    +38

    Comment number 226.

    Christmas is a Christian holiday, just like Ramadan is a Muslim event. I choose to not take part in Ramadan as I am not Muslim, by the same reasoning if you are not Christian you can choose not to take part in Christmas but don't you tell Christians that they can not celebrate their holiday.

 

Comments 5 of 17

 

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • ITChild's play

    It's never been easier for small businesses to get their message out to the world

Programmes

  • An aerial shot shows the Olympic Stadium, which is closed for repair works on its roof, in Rio de Janeiro March 28, 2014.Extra Time Watch

    Will Rio be ready in time to host the Olympics in 2016? The IOC president gives his verdict

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.