Clinton Cards: How greetings cards are changing

 
From left, clockwise: Card stack, Scribbler shop facade, customer shopping for cards, Clinton cards facade, Christmas card

While Clinton Cards has gone into administration, the UK is actually sending more greeting cards than ever. But the type of cards is slowly changing.

For the past decade or so, "the internet is killing…" has been a popular refrain when it comes to declining businesses.

And it would be easy to assume that the traditional card shop has suffered at the hands of websites offering personalised cards and cheap deals.

But that's not the case. The High Street greetings card shop is doing just fine.

Last year saw a 3% rise in card sales compared with 2009, and while Clinton Cards may have struggled, other chains such as Scribbler and Paperchase flourished.

"Cards make us feel loved," says Sharon Little, chief executive of the Greeting Cards Association. Thus there is still a bit of stigma about the likes of e-cards.

"It's a lovely thing to receive a card from someone, and people certainly don't all buy their cards off the internet - people tend to think that's a bit lazy."

Birthday cards are still the most purchased cards, followed by Christmas, Valentine's Day and Mothers' Day. Fathers' Day follows closely behind.

But there are new categories that reflect changing times.

"There's a card for passing your driving test, cards to congratulate you on your divorce, and there are cards for many multicultural events too - Diwali, Eid and Chinese New Year are just a few of them," adds Little.

"There are more and more occasions to send a card for now."

Christmas cards from Five Dollar Images Cards collaged with glitter and other embellishments sell well

Easter cards, once unheard of, now make up a significant portion of the spring season card sales - the period that includes Valentine's Day and Mothers' Day.

Once upon a time you might send a congratulations card to someone who had had a baby - now cards are frequently sent upon the announcement of a pregnancy. Another seasonal novelty - an import from the US - is the Halloween card.

The divorce cards now available might be thought a tad unpleasant by some. But there's an echo of the first commercial Christmas card, which reportedly caused offence in 1843.

Greetings card pioneer Sir Henry Cole erred by including picture of a festive family scene where the adults were holding aloft their wine glasses in front of young children.

Popular Edward Monkton cards picturing a pig and the words: "May his joyful smile remind us how much there is to be happy about" and Popular Edward Monkton card picturing three hamsters and reading: "Every night they visit you, every night they come. And bit by bit they steal your brain and feed it to their mum." Surreal cards - like those of Edward Monkton - are increasingly popular

It is hard to imagine what Cole's critics would have made of the current range of rude cards.

Scribbler, a card company that boasts 15% year-on-year growth, puts part of their success down to the popularity of their rude and, at times, downright obscene cards.

They make up 15% of the company's sales and their website has a function to turn off the offensive cards, blocking them from view.

Why have cards survived the internet?

Stephen Bayley

Stephen Bayley, design critic and cultural commentator

In our exhaustingly pixellated world where gigabytes count for more than a winning way with a rhyming couplet, the greetings card may seem a quaint anomaly.

But its survival is not so very strange.

Nowadays any fool can reach 50 million people after a few minutes heartless work on a keypad, but reaching an individual is altogether more interesting.

In the same way that a single witty postcard is worth more than 25 million Tweets, a card suggests something that went missing in the digital revolution: intimacy.

Saccharine? Coarse? Bogus? Crass? All those things, but we are not discussing taste, we are discussing compulsion.

If you ask me, and you are, cards are not so much enjoying a survival as ready for a big uptick of a revival.

"People love edgy humour," Scribbler chief executive John Procter argues. "Rude cards do very well for us - it's one of our USPs. We like to be a bit near the knuckle."

Funny photography and knitted animals are also popular, making up another 20% of Scribbler's sales, while retro humour, featuring old photographs, is 20% again.

Despite their popularity, rude cards do not fare well at the Henries, the industry awards, named after Sir Henry Cole, held each October at The Lancaster Hotel in London.

Organiser Jakki Brown, who edits Progressive Greetings, the monthly industry magazine, says: "The rude cards don't get very far with us, they don't tend to win. Quirky humour is popular, not the rude, not the risque."

"The Henries are the Oscars of the greetings card industry. We had 14,000 cards entered last year."

Brown is so passionate about greetings cards that she once spent £12,000 at auction on an original Sir Henry Cole Christmas card. It is one of only nine still in existence.

There are 20 categories at the Henries, including cutest cards, funniest, best design and best sentiment, as well as the Henry Cole Honorary Achievement award, which last year went to Giles Andreae, the man behind Purple Ronnie and Edward Monkton.

With the internet rife with cat-related memes, it is perhaps no surprise that the physical greetings card industry has some of the same content.

"Britain and Japan go crazy for cute cards. One that won last year was a rather angry-looking cat dressed in a little denim outfit."

Duncan Cox is a card designer at Urban Graphic, the company behind the angry cat.

"That cat divided the office, but sometimes you see a picture that is so bizarre you just have to go for it.

Urban graphic cards. Card on left reads: "The older you get, the better you get, unless you're a banana." Card on right shows picture of a cat As on the internet quirky quotes and angry felines are well regarded

"Quotations cards do really well for us. We had a card that said 'the older you get, the better you get, unless you're a banana'. That was a massive seller.

"Animals-wise, it's obviously cats and dogs that do best - animals people can relate to. After that, you're going down the road of monkeys and bears."

The greetings cards industry is massive in the US, but the custom is not uniformly observed everywhere.

"Sending cards is a very British thing," Little says. "I have a few French friends who think we're all a bit potty for doing it, but it's engrained in our social culture - it's what we do."

 

More on This Story

In today's Magazine

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 69.

    My mum would happily forgo a present for the sake of a lovely card - it shows that we've taken time out of our day to think about her and got her something she likes. My nan always says don't bother, but she's never once just binned it without looking and always keeps her cards up for weeks. We humans are simple creatures; we like to be shown that people care.

  • rate this
    +4

    Comment number 66.

    There are different ways of looking at the 'Hallmark holiday' / greetings card culture. Is it the cynical use of peer pressure on customers to flog them millions of tons of waste paper, or a vital part of our economy and one of the few 'genuine' means of communication left in the FB age? A card I saw recently really summed up our times for me: 'Congratulations on Losing Weight' :o(

  • rate this
    +23

    Comment number 49.

    27 Tex
    "It's a woman thing. Period."


    Yikes, for a minute there I thought you were suggesting a somewhat inappropriate range of cards!
    Although I've heard they do exist in America...

  • rate this
    +10

    Comment number 39.

    In case no one else has said it.......

    The best cards are the ones you make yourself.

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 27.

    It's a woman thing. Period. The greeting card industry would not exist if it wasnt for women. Women (on the whole ) send and receive to please other women. Men dont tend to buy for other men only (usually) for the special woman in their life.

 

Comments 5 of 11

 

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • MoviesMovie magic

    Tech that reads your desires is helping to increase your odds of producing a hit film, says BBC Future

Programmes

  • Ade Adepitan at the ColosseumThe Travel Show Watch

    The challenge of providing disabled access at Europe’s leading ancient monuments

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.