E-cigarettes: Is a smoking alternative being choked by regulation?

A man vaping on an electronic cigarette

Dozens of countries are introducing legislation restricting the use of electronic cigarettes, but their proponents say they are harmless and their use could in fact save millions of lives. Could they be right?

A group of friends sits around a table in a pub in south London, exchanging stories and putting the world to rights in a cloud of scented vapour.

One of them is 31-year-old Jonny Lavery.

"I had a big problem with death, a really big problem with dying," he says. "I wanted to avoid dying at all costs."

But three years ago, Lavery realised that as a smoker of 15 years, his chance of doing this was diminishing. Roughly half the world's smokers die from their habit. The trouble was Johnny just enjoyed it too much to quit.

Then he found an alternative - the electronic cigarette.

Find out more

Alan Hodgson
  • Health Check is broadcast on the BBC World Service on Wednesday at 18:30 GMT

These gizmos contain batteries and "e-liquid" - a solution of propylene glycol or glycerine - containing a nicotine dose. A battery inside the e-cigarette heats up a coil attached to a wick. When the liquid is presented to the hot wick it produces vapour which can be inhaled.

They don't quite match the nicotine hit of a real cigarette, but they come close enough to have won over 1.3 million users in the UK alone (compared to nine million tobacco smokers). In the US, e-cigarette sales could pass $1bn (£650m) this year - up from $600m (£390m) in 2012.

Since there is no smoke, puffing on e-cigarettes is called vaping, not smoking. The group of men and women sitting in the pub call themselves vapers - they meet regularly to vape and to talk about vaping.

A little nerdy, they resemble a gang of home-brewing enthusiasts more than a stop-smoking support group.

They inspect one another's vaporisers - which come in all manner of shapes and sizes - and sniff one another's vapour. "I'm currently vaping toffee popcorn," says Shari Levy, emanating sweetness. "And this one here is coffee. And this one is tutti frutti - that's nice for the summer. Amaretto with a morning coffee is just delicious."

Different types of electronic cigarette Vaping paraphernalia comes in all shapes and sizes

Like everyone else in the group, Levy initially used e-cigarettes to help wean herself off the real thing. After a while she realised she no longer really liked the taste of tobacco.

While e-cigarettes can be used as a stepping stone to ending nicotine addiction, some vapers see them as a way to continue a hobby they enjoy without the attendant fear of death. That's because although nicotine is the addictive ingredient in cigarettes many experts do not think it is especially harmful. It's the tar and other nasties in tobacco that kill.

"Nicotine is not very dangerous, and it's very unlikely someone will overdose on the nicotine in electronic cigarettes by inhaling the vapour," says Maciej Goniewicz from Roswell Park Cancer Institute in Buffalo, New York - an oncologist who has analysed e-cigarettes and the vapours they produce.

He says that in the absence of research into the effects of long-term vaping, it is impossible to say that e-cigarettes are absolutely safe, but we know enough to say they are safer than the real thing. There is no such thing as passive vaping.

Do electronic cigarettes help smokers quit?

An e-cigarette
  • Researchers are still unsure how effective e-cigarettes are as a quitting aid in comparison to other therapies such as nicotine patches
  • One recent study at the University of Catania found that 9% of a sample of 300 smokers had quit after 12 months, using e-cigarettes as an aid
  • In the UK, 25% of all quit attempts are made using e-cigarettes, making it the most popular quitting aid
  • The UK's medicines regulatory body MHRA therefore believes that e-cigarettes could help save 57,000 lives in the UK over the next decade
  • E-cigarettes mimic the physical and social aspects of smoking but users have to learn how to do it

Nevertheless, a wave of legislation is threatening to extinguish e-cigarettes all over the world.

Brazil, Singapore and Mexico have banned importing and selling the devices, even though tobacco is still on sale in all those countries.

In the US, state-level legislation inhibits vaping in different ways. Arizona has banned the sale of the products to minors. The same rule applies in New York State, where vaping is also prohibited within 100m of a school entrance. In Washington State, all vaping in public is banned.

Previously in the Magazine

Is it OK to vape in public?

"If you're going to do it you should arm yourself with the legal rubric so that you can say, for example, 'under section 16 of the bill' - or whatever it is - 'I'm completely legal'."

Peter York, cultural commentator

Draft legislation in the EU - including a UK version that will affect the London vapers - will restrict the sale of e-cigarettes and bring them within medical regulation. Manufacturers will need to be licensed, and the components labelled clearly with their precise nicotine content. The products will not be marketed or sold to young people under 16.

So if e-cigarettes are relatively safe, what's motivating all this legislation?

One set of concerns has to do with safety and standardisation. The UK body that oversees the regulation of medicines, the MHRA, says e-cigarettes currently available do not meet appropriate standards of "safety, quality and efficacy". Anecdotal reports point to dangers caused by variations in product quality, including facial burns after a vaporiser exploded in a consumer's mouth. The US Food and Drug Administration has also found that nicotine doses vary between devices, and have been found to vary from the advertised dose on the label - while the ingredients in e-liquid are also not listed.

But there are also other concerns:

  • Some pressure groups fear that electronic cigarettes may "re-normalise" smoking, thereby undermining the smoking bans which have helped de-glamorise cigarettes - the British Medical Association (the UK's trade body for doctors) cites this concern in calling for a ban on public vaping.
  • Others point to the possibility that the red-glowing tips might prove enticing to children - New Jersey assemblywoman Connie Wagner has also voiced a common fear that children may enjoy the fruity flavours.

It's clear that some children have tried electronic cigarettes, but Prof Robert West, director of Tobacco Studies at University College London, says there is no sign they are becoming popular in the UK - the only country he knows where the uptake is monitored closely.

He adds that if and when young people do start smoking e-cigarettes, public health experts will have to study the causes carefully.

A Scandinavian precedent - snus

Someone holding some snus

Snus is a form of purified tobacco, popular in Sweden and Norway, that users insert between their teeth and their upper lip. It is banned elsewhere in the EU.

Snus provides users with an equivalent dose of nicotine to an e-cigarette and without known serious consequences (although a possible link has been made to pancreatic cancer).

"Most of us in the field think that snus has been a lifesaver," says Robert West, who points out that Sweden has the lowest rate of tobacco-related disease in Europe.

"If those young people are people who would have smoked but instead they're using e-cigarettes, then that's a huge public health gain. If they're people who would never have smoked but they've taken up e-cigarettes, frankly in public health terms it's not really an issue - it's like drinking coffee or something, there's no real risk associated with it.

"The real risk is if they start using e-cigarettes and this acts as a gateway into smoking. Now which of those things happens none of us knows at the moment."

As for the idea that e-cigarettes undo the work to de-glamorise tobacco smoking, West, who has done consultancy work for nicotine cessation medication, says the public health opportunity provided by e-cigarettes lies in their remaining trendy.

"The opportunity here is for something that's seen in a different light," he says.

"We never got communities of people really enthusing about nicotine patches or nicotine gum. You didn't get a sort of nicotine gum users' group, in which they'd rave about the gum and sort of say: 'This sort of gum's so much better, and I make my own gum,' and stuff like that."

Ninety per cent of e-cigarette users are also smoking, he says, indicating that the devices are being used as a quitting aid. Countries that have banned them are, in his view, "nuts".

Jonny Lavery and others are planning a trip to Brussels next week to protest against the draft European legislation, which they see as a threat to their hobby.

The organiser of the London and South-East Vapers meet-ups, Alan Hodgson, had tried quitting three times before he found e-cigarettes. Each time a rough spell in his personal life sent him back to the fags.

He would like to stop vaping altogether or lower the nicotine content of his e-liquid to zero - but it's not something he feels he needs to worry about too much.

"My worst-case scenario is really that I might be vaping for the rest of my life," he says, "rather than dying from normal tobacco cigarettes."

You can listen to Health Check on the BBC World Service. Listen to the episode about e-cigarettes via iplayer or browse the Health Check podcast archive.

You can follow the Magazine on Twitter and on Facebook

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Features & Analysis

  • Mukesh SinghNo remorse

    Delhi bus rapist says victim shouldn't have fought back

  • Painting from Rothschild collectionDark arts Watch

    The 50-year fight to recover paintings looted by the Nazis

  • Aimen DeanI spied

    The founder member of al-Qaeda who worked for MI6

  • Blow torchTorch of hope Watch

    An ancient art form helps troubled youth pick up the pieces

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • StudentsBull market

    Employers are snapping up students with this desirable degree


  • 3D model of Christ the Redeemer statueClick Watch

    Using drones to 3D map the famous Brazilian landmark Christ the Redeemer

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.