The real Jewish treasures of World War Two
- 10 November 2013
- From the section Magazine
A New York Times headline summed up one view of the missing art story: "Art trove a triumph over Nazism," it announced.
I wonder. For art historians, perhaps the sheer survival of these magnificent paintings is enough.
But reading through some of the comments online, it seemed clear that some saw the story through a very different lens - another tale of Jewish wealth and privilege, as though every Jewish family in pre-war Europe owned a Picasso or a Matisse. And as though anyone who now came forward to claim ownership was greedily depriving the public of works that rightfully belonged in museums.
So, maybe not such a triumph over Nazism after all?
The more I read, the more I found myself thinking about my own family's history. And my own obsessive interest in finding out what had survived the war - and what had been lost.
My mother's family were Polish Jews, rooted for centuries in a land they knew intimately and considered home.
I thought of my great-great-grandfather, Menachem Mendel Szpiro.
He grew up a devout Hasidic Jew, but as a young man he cut off his sidelocks, trimmed his beard and embraced a world of secular knowledge.
He set up a school for girls and became a renowned educator and a passionate linguist.
Already fluent in Yiddish, Hebrew, Polish and Russian, he sat at his kitchen table late into the night, teaching himself Esperanto by candlelight, then Spanish, French and German.
His small apartment was crammed with books on all subjects - a library built up over 50 years.
The books are long gone. Aged 78, Menachem Mendel attempted suicide in the Warsaw Ghetto, failed, and ended up dying in the Treblinka death camp.
I only know about the library because I found a description of it in a memoir by a former pupil of his who survived the war.
That's a much more typical wartime story than the miraculous survival of some valuable paintings.
I thought of another relative, my cousin Paul, who I first met in Boston when he was in his sixties.
Paul was a tough, plain-speaking sort of guy - a survivor of the war, and of life in general. He was the first adult I ever met with a concentration camp number tattooed on his arm.
He had made a new life for himself in the United States. But his most treasured possession was a single, torn-off cover from an old round fob watch.
He unwrapped it proudly to show me. It was engraved with a photographic portrait of his grandfather, Moyshe Asch, the family patriarch, who had given all his 10 children an identical watch.
Nine of the watches disappeared over time. But at the age of 20, Paul had torn the inner cover off his watch and hidden it inside a window sill in his home in the Polish city of Lodz, before he was deported.
He returned as a liberated survivor, persuaded the new occupants of his home to let him in, and retrieved the sliver of metal from its hiding place.
It's these stories, not the headline grabbing news of long-lost paintings, that are the stuff of modern Jewish history. And not just Jewish history.
World War Two was a time of rupture, loss and uprooting on an epic scale.
Family links were torn apart, extended family networks accumulated over generations swept away. And along with the people, a world of possessions, heavy with the weight of memory and meaning.
Behind this week's looted art discovery lies an intensely human story, faced by millions of refugees past and present.
What would you take if you had to leave your home in a hurry?
What are the treasured possessions that connect you to your past, that you hope to pass on to future generations?
What have the millions of Syrian refugees now shivering in makeshift camps been able to take with them? What have they had to leave behind? And what state will their homes be in if they ever return?
I imagine myself faced with these impossible choices.
Would I hastily gather up family photographs? Or essential documents? Would I try and pack the fragile little clay elephant, with oversize ears, that my daughter made for me in art class?
I don't know. I'm lucky that I've never had to make these choices.
But I do know that for my family a fragment of an old fob watch is every bit as precious as a painting by Picasso or Matisse.
A selection of your comments on this story is published here.
BBC Radio 4: Saturdays at 11:30 and some Thursdays at 11:00
BBC World Service: Short editions Monday-Friday - see World Service programme schedule.