Ban pesticides linked to bee deaths, say MPs

 
German bees Bee numbers have declined significantly in many countries with no clear explanation as to why

Related Stories

The UK government should suspend the use of a number of pesticides linked to the deaths of bees, a committee of MPs has said.

Members of the Commons Environmental Audit Committee are calling for a moratorium on the use of sprays containing neonicotinoids.

Britain has refused to back an EU ban on these chemicals saying their impact on bees is unclear.

But MPs say this is an "extraordinarily complacent" approach.

Wild species such as honey bees are said by researchers to be responsible for pollinating around one-third of the world's crop production.

Stinging criticism

In their report, MPs say that two-thirds of these species have suffered population declines in the UK.

They argue that a "growing body of peer-reviewed research" points the finger at a group of pesticides called neonicotinoids.

What exactly are Neonicotinoids?

  • Nicotine is not just lethal to humans in the form of cigarettes, but the chemical is also extremely toxic to insects
  • Neonicotinoid pesticides are new nicotine-like chemicals and act on the nervous systems of insects with a lower threat to mammals and the environment than many older sprays
  • Pesticides made in this way are water soluble which means they can be applied to the soil and taken up by the whole plant - they are called "systemic", meaning they turn the plant itself into a poison factory with toxins coming from roots, leaves, stems and pollen
  • Neonicotinoids are often applied as seed treatments which means coating the seeds before planting.

"We believe the weight of scientific evidence now warrants precautionary action," said the committee's chairwoman, Labour MP Joan Walley.

"So we are calling for a moratorium on pesticides linked to bee decline to be introduced by 1 January next year."

Following on from research published in January by the European Food Safety Authority that suggested these chemicals posed an "unacceptable" threat to bees, the European Commission proposed that neonicotinoid sprays be restricted to crops not attractive to pollinators.

There are already some restrictions in place in France, Germany, Italy and Slovenia. But the idea of a two-year ban did not attract enough support after the UK and Germany both abstained.

Joan Walley says the UK government's approach to the issue is "extraordinarily complacent".

"If farmers had to pollinate fruit and vegetables without the help of insects it would costs hundreds of millions of pounds and we would all be stung by rising food prices," she added.

But the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) says that a ban is not justified at present.

Dr Heather Whitney from the University of Bristol told the BBC's Jon Kay more research on pesticides needs to be done

Defra's chief scientist Dr Ian Boyd admitted the research was "very finely balanced".

"Neonicotinoids will kill bees, let me be absolutely clear about that. It is what numbers do they kill and whether it affects populations - the question is whether banning them in any way would be proportional and at the moment the balance of evidence suggests it wouldn't be," he said.

There have been a number of studies showing that the chemicals, made by Bayer and Syngenta, do have negative impacts on both honey and bumblebees.

One study suggested that neonicotinoids affected the abilities of hives to produce queen bees. More recent research indicated that the pesticides damaged their brains.

But Defra argues that these studies were mainly conducted in the laboratory and do not accurately reflect field conditions.

It has published its own work showing that in the field, these chemicals had little effect on bee health, although Defra acknowledges the study lacks statistical power.

They are also calling on the European Commission to agree to a major new field study that would settle the debate.

"That will allow informed decision-making, rather than rushing into a knee-jerk ban based on inconclusive studies," said a Defra spokesman.

Open data

Dr Ian Boyd says that despite being used for 20 years, there has been no satisfactory answer to the key question: what effect are these chemicals having on pollinators in the field?

Given the finely balanced state of the science he says that other factors such as the costs to farmers have to be considered in the decision to keep using these pesticides.

Why are bees in decline?

  • Varroa mite - A parasitic mite that sucks the blood from bees. Unless beekeepers control Varroa, their colonies can collapse and die within two or three years
  • Diseases - Other viruses are known to affect bees including deformed wing virus, acute paralysis virus, slow paralysis virus and cloudy wing virus. These weaken honeybee colonies by reducing the longevity of adult honeybees
  • Neglect - Bee keepers need to work harder than ever to keep their colonies alive because of the dangers posed by infections and to ensure they have enough honey in their hives to keep them going until nectar becomes available again in the spring

"It is a very difficult analysis to do, we really don't have full data - but it does suggest that the cost-benefit trade-off at the moment is weighted to retaining neonicotinoids because if you just cost this in financial terms then you move in the direction of having a significant financial cost to take them out of the system," he said.

But the Commons Environmental Audit Commission rejects this approach, saying that "economic considerations should not form part of environmental risk management decision-making".

The committee also asks for more openness from the chemical manufacturers who should publish their own research on the safety of these products.

This seems to be one thing on which Defra and the committee agree.

"I personally believe that all those data should be open access; I think that everyone should be able to see them," said Dr Boyd.

"There are issues around confidentiality but I don't think any of those are insurmountable," he added.

Pesticide manufacturer Bayer said it "strongly disagrees" with the idea of a two-year moratorium.

With fellow producer, Syngenta, it has produced its own action plan on how to protect bee health.

"There has been a long history of the safe use of neonicotinoid insecticides and it is clear that when they are used responsibly and properly, any impact on bees is negligible," said Utz Klages of Bayer.

"This has already been confirmed by the competent EU and member-state authorities in their market authorisation assessments, based on the extensive safety data that had previously been submitted and proven in many monitoring studies."

Bees In the UK, bees are one of a number of pollinators in decline

The committee of MPs says the government's lack of action is in marked contrast to the efforts of the UK's largest garden chains.

B&Q, Wickes and Homebase have withdrawn non-professional plant protection products that contain neonicotinoid chemicals.

The report has been welcomed by many campaigners including the charity Buglife, which praised the "robust stance".

The issue is unlikely to disappear anytime soon. The European Commission told the BBC that it would continue to press forward with plans for a moratorium.

A spokesman said they were planning to appeal against the recently rejected ban.

In the US, the Environmental Protection Agency is being sued by beekeepers and environmental groups over its "failure" to protect pollinators from neonicotinoids.

Follow Matt on Twitter.

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +24

    Comment number 358.

    I think everyone should do their bit in their gardens. I never use pesticides, for weedkiller you can combine vinegar with liquid soap which sticks to the leaves. If you have wood piles you encourage hedgehogs which eat the slugs. If you encourage the birds into the garden they will eat the pests that destroy the plants. You should plant bee, butterfly and bird friendly old fashioned plants.

  • rate this
    +12

    Comment number 344.

    We used to have about a dozen thriving bee hives in our orchard but over the last 5 years the bees have all died off, leaving empty hives and fruit trees with nothing to pollenate them.

    Needless to say, the fruit harvest last year was dreadful.

  • rate this
    -29

    Comment number 289.

    Honey Bees didn't even exist 10,000 years ago. They're a very new species, if they vanish, something will replace them or some other things will vanish with them.

    I lost 1 of my 2 hives this winter, entirely my fault for not feeding them early enough, but it did show that 2012 was a bad food year for bees, regardless of what pesticides are also doing.

  • rate this
    +58

    Comment number 281.

    The most telling comment on the Today program was that the Government AND the manufacturers of the chemicals want more evidence before they will act, so now we know who calls the shots, it's big business as usual. If pollinators are killed off food production could well collapse so, I ask, why not stop using the suspect chemicals for a couple of years and see if the bees recover.

  • rate this
    -22

    Comment number 268.

    The organic lobby can try to take the moral high ground, but as switching organic methods would reduce the world food supply by around 30%, when 60% of the worlds population do not have enough to eat must be wrong. It's not all about money.
    British farmers care greatly about bees and have a vested interest in maintaining them. These insecticides further investigation and sensible action taken.

 

Comments 5 of 12

 

More Science & Environment stories

RSS

Features & Analysis

BBC Future

(Thinkstock)

‘I freeze people to cheat death’

The man with 100 bodies in his freezer Read more...

Programmes

  • Hitch-hiking robot HitchBOTClick Watch

    Hitch-hiking robot HitchBOT completes a 6,000 km (3,700 mile) trip plus other tech news

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.