Rosetta: Riding a ‘bucking bronco’ in space

Comet Ison Will Comet Ison break apart in the next few weeks?

The excitement is mounting. We're going to be talking about comets an awful lot in the coming months.

First of all, we have Comet Ison to enjoy. We hope.

This mountain of ice and dust has come hurtling in from the outer Solar System and is about to swing around the Sun.

At closest approach on 28 November, it will be no more than 1.2 million km (800,000 miles) from our star's boiling surface.

The big question is: will it survive the encounter? "Sungrazers" like Ison very often just fall apart. But if it can remain intact, this "dirty snowball" will swing back out past the orbits of the inner planets, potentially throwing off huge streams of gas and dust.

The comet could appear as a great arc across the sky, no binoculars required. Then again, it might not. Comets are notoriously unreliable.

Recent observations have suggested that Ison might fall short of being spectacular, but could still put on a decent show. We won't know for sure until December.

And come December, we'll all have started looking forward to the space mission of 2014: Rosetta.

This is the European Space Agency probe that was launched way back in 2004. It's spent the past nine years working its way out to the orbit of Jupiter, to chase down Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko.

The plan is for Rosetta to circle and track this comet as it sweeps in towards the Sun.

The big highlight, though, will be the deployment of the probe's Philae lander. It's going to try to lock down on 4km-wide 67P and ride it.

How long Philae could withstand any outgassing as the ices heat up on approach to the Sun is anyone's guess. Will 67P be a "bucking bronco"?


Model of 67-P
  • Named after its 1969 discoverers Klim Churyumov and Svetlana Gerasimenko
  • Referred to as a "Jupiter class" comet that takes 6.45 years to orbit the Sun
  • Orbit takes it as close as 180 million km from the Sun, and as far as 840 million km
  • The icy core, or nucleus, is about 4km across and rotates every 12 hours
  • Its shape is reasonably well known (model above). There are three key active regions

"Philae's got screws and harpoons to hold it down," says Dr Matt Taylor, the Rosetta project scientist.

"I have to be confident we'll succeed. We'll be investing a lot of time before the landing trying to find the best place to put down."

Telescopic investigations are encouraging. 67P appears to have three main areas that produce jets, which Philae might want to avoid. But on the whole, the comet's recent passes of the Sun have been relatively smooth - it hasn't been prone to explosive outbursts.

Rosetta is a long way from Earth currently. Probes sent out to the vicinity of Jupiter would usually use radioisotope batteries, but the European spacecraft was equipped only with solar panels.

As a consequence, the probe was put to sleep in 2011 to reduce to its systems' demand for energy.

Controllers at Europe's Space Operations Centre in Darmstadt, Germany, are not in contact with Rosetta at present.

They're keeping their fingers crossed that an internal alarm clock will rouse the probe on 20 January 2014.

Once awake, it can activate its instruments and prepare for the rendezvous. Needless to say, the alarm clock event has quite a bit of tension associated with it.

"Before turning everything off, we spun up the spacecraft to keep it stable," explains Prof Mark McCaughrean, a senior official in Esa's science directorate.

"At the moment, Rosetta's not pointing its high-gain antenna at the Earth. So, we rely now on that alarm clock going off on time, because if it doesn't we'll have great difficulty communicating with the spacecraft.

"But we do expect it to go off. And when it does, Rosetta will warm up, spin down and point to Earth again, and we will receive a signal. We don't know exactly when we'll receive that signal. It will happen in a window."

Artist's impression of Philae lander Philae will deploy ice screws and harpoons to hold itself down on the comet's surface

Here's a timeline for the key events:

  • 20 January 2014: Wake-up from hibernation
  • Mid-March 2014: Check-out instruments
  • 21 May 2014: Major rendezvous manoeuvre
  • 6 August 2014: Arrive at Comet 67P
  • 27 August 2014: Start global mapping
  • 11 November 2014: Philae deployment (at about 450 million km from the Sun)
  • 13 August 2015: Perihelion - closest approach to the Sun (at about 185 million km from the Sun)
  • 31 December 2015: Nominal end of mission (although Esa is unlikely to switch off a working Rosetta)

As you can see, it's quite drawn out. We talked of the "minutes of terror" endured waiting for Nasa's Curiosity rover to land on Mars last year. Rosetta is likely to give us months of torture.

Yes, there will be periods of relative inactivity, but there will also be moments of intense drama along the way. The wake-up, the orbit insertion, the Philae landing and the close approach to the Sun could make Rosetta one of the most remarkable missions we've ever seen.

I'm expecting the pictures to be sensational.

The main camera system onboard Rosetta is Osiris (Optical, Spectrocopic and Infrared Remote Imaging System). It has wide-angle and narrow-angle views and will be returning high-resolution perspectives of the comet's icy core, or nucleus. Osiris has already demonstrated its remarkable capability in a pass of Asteroid Lutetia in 2010.

Lutetia Osiris returned some great pictures of Asteroid Lutetia in 2010

The principal investigator is Holger Sierks from the Max Planck Institute for Solar System Research (MPS) in Katlenburg-Lindau, Germany.

"We will get thousands of images on approach," he says. "Our [best] resolution is on the order of centimetres and we will be mapping to find suitable landing sites. It is unknown whether we will catch the moment of landing - it is pure speculation right now. But it is our aim to present a movie and to get an image of Philae on the surface."

Artist's impression of Rosetta Rosetta was launched way back in 2004

There's a lot of science to be done, of course.

Comets contain pristine materials from the formation of the Solar System. They give us insights on a time billions of years ago that we cannot get from studying planetary rocks.

"There are many very interesting questions related to comets," explains Dr Jessica Agarwal, also of MPS.

"One is to study whether they brought the water to Earth. It's thought that the water that is now on the Earth is not a remnant from the time of formation of our planet but was delivered later when it was cool enough to retain it.

"Comets are rich in water. One theory is that they may have impacted in large numbers in the past - since they would have been more numerous back then - and could have delivered enough water to fill Earth's oceans. And they may even have delivered organics. These are the things we'd like to understand with Rosetta."

Comet McNaught Comets are unpredictable, but occasionally they can put on a great show, as Comet McNaught did in 2007
Jonathan Amos Article written by Jonathan Amos Jonathan Amos Science correspondent

Sentinel-2: Europe's 'Landsat' ready to picture Planet Earth

The "workhorse" satellite in Europe's new multi-billion-euro Earth observation programme is built and ready to go into orbit.

Read full article

More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 7.

    Dear Jonathan,
    How accurate are these dates accurate?
    Would have been nice if you explained that this is coincidental and approximately.
    Your article has one too many pictures which has thrown most people off
    Pretty Boy

  • rate this

    Comment number 39.

    Doesnt seem good they switched it off to save power and have to wait for it to "call in". Sounds too much like that whatisname ESA Mars rover that went missing. Can just imagine some wild haired prof on the telly almost exploding with enthusiasm before he says "oh bugger where is the damned thing".

    There is an issue with radioactive batteries and pollution if launch fails though. So well dun ESA

  • rate this

    Comment number 20.

    Won't the astronauts on the probe be in great danger of radiation exposure when it passes close to the sun? It's amazing that people volunteer to go on such missions. I would not put my name down to travel to Jupiter (one way trip) because I enjoy life here on planet Earth too much.

  • rate this

    Comment number 58.

    Praise Him (54) "Any comment in the science section that even dares to mention God is removed"

    Ah, well, the militant frothing-at-the-mouth atheists can't stand anything which might conflict with their faith in science.

  • rate this

    Comment number 23.


    Any astronaut anywhere in the universe off planet earh (or a planet with a similar protective magnetic field) will be exposed to huge radiation exposure.

    It is why humans will never leave the solar system unless someone comes up with a miracle shield as yet un thought up let alone made pratical....


Comments 5 of 83


Features & Analysis

BBC Future

A helicopter casts a shadow over the chasm in Guatemala (Getty Images)

When the Earth swallows people

What should we do to avoid sinkholes?


  • A robot holding a table legClick Watch

    The robots who build flat-pack furniture - teaching machines to work collaboratively

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.