BBC 3G mobile survey: Our conclusions

 

WATCH: Rory Cellan-Jones travels from Cardiff to London to find the "hot spots" and "not spots" in the mobile data network.

When we launched our 3G survey last month we could not be sure how much interest there would be.

I'm glad to say there was plenty - more than 44,000 people downloaded the Android app on all manner of devices, and data came in from the tip of Cornwall to the Shetland Islands.

The data shows that, overall, people are getting 3G about three quarters of the time, but coverage is nothing like as uniform as the picture painted in the coverage map issued by the mobile operators.

So most of a city will have excellent coverage but there will be certain places even quite near the centre where some if not all the networks are just not providing a data connection.

To prepare some radio and television reports about the survey results, I took a train from London to Cardiff and back - and gathered some of my own evidence. As ever, I travelled light - just three mobile phones, one mobile broadband MiFi unit, two tablet computers and a laptop.

Even on a train these days we've come to expect decent 3G coverage, and from London to Swindon, as I fiddled with my various devices on different networks, it looked as though it would be possible to get online pretty easily.

Play video: Setting off Play video: Signal problems Play video: London calling Graphic: Rory's 3G journey from Cardiff to London
Find out about 3G in your area on our 3G coverage map

Setting off

Photo: The BBC's Rory Cellan Jones in a street scene

Signal problems

Photo: The BBC's Rory Cellan Jones and a companion looking at three handheld devices

London calling

Photo: The BBC's Rory Cellan Jones on a train platform

But as we headed further West and then into Wales, the periods where I got no signal - or no data signal at least - got longer and longer. Talking to various people who use that line a lot, I heard plenty of frustrations about the patchy coverage.

Filming in Cardiff the next day, we found a black spot, where the majority of our testers had failed to get a data signal in Roath, just a couple of miles from the city centre.  Again, passers-by told us of their frustrations when using smartphones in the area.

On the way back from Cardiff, I hopped off the train at Didcot Parkway to meet one of the people who had downloaded the UK 3G survey app.

ABOUT THE MAP

Snapshot of the map
  • The map can be searched by postcode
  • 42 million locations have been recorded
  • White space represents areas where no tests were conducted
  • Each tile represents a maximum area of approximately 200m x 200m
  • A green tile means that handsets spent most of their time on 3G in that area
  • A purple tile means handsets spent most of their time on 2G

Chris Phillips is training to be a Church of England vicar at a college in the Oxfordshire village of Cuddesdon. He's also a devoted to his Android smartphone - though he's struggling to use many of its capabilities.

That's because the village - just a few miles from the M40 - appears to be among our 3G notspots. The bar chart in the 3G survey app on Chris's phone showed that he'd spent around two thirds of his time on 2G - the 3G bar probably reflects his journeys into Oxford for lectures.

When I asked him why on earth a trainee vicar needed 3G anyway, Chris answered with Christian forbearance: "In this day and age we need to keep in touch with the real world - just because we're training to serve the church it doesn't mean we don't need to know what's going on."

What struck me during this project was just how many people - from priest to plumbers to paediatricians - now see a mobile phone with a data connection as essential to their working lives.

We're not making huge claims for our mobile map - it is after all just a snapshot - but it may provide consumers and the mobile networks themselves with a better picture of the real state of coverage.

And ours is not the only source - a London-based startup called OpenSignalMaps has also been mapping 3G across the UK. They've kindly given us access to their data, collected from 30,000 users of their Android app.  You can read more about their research here - but I've pulled out  a couple of headlines.

They identified over 22,000 locations where no 3G signal was available - for the most part, as you'd expect, in rural areas. The highest concentration was in Gwynedd in North Wales, closely followed by Cumbria.

But in terms of the amount of time people are spending on 3G, they've got that at 58%, much lower than our 75%.

And their overall conclusion - like ours - is that while most of the big cities are well served by 3G,  it can be a real challenge getting a decent connection elsewhere.

So, thanks to everyone who has made the effort to help chart the UK's  mobile coverage. Let's hope the map will be useful not just to consumers, but to mobile operators trying to make sure that the notspots get ever smaller.

 
Rory Cellan-Jones, Technology correspondent Article written by Rory Cellan-Jones Rory Cellan-Jones Technology correspondent

A new kind of tech bubble localisation->translate("watch"); ?>

Scientists at Bristol University are using bringing bubbles and technology together in unexpected - and potentially profitable - ways.

Watch Rory's report

More on This Story

More from Rory

Related Stories

Comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 1.

    All very interesting, but perhaps you might like to take the investigation a stage further.

    It's a little known fact that some network operators restrict upload and download speeds so you will never achieve the headline 2G/3G/HPDPA performance even if you live in an area with full coverage. You''ll struggle to find this mentioned in their marketing info!

  • rate this
    -1

    Comment number 2.

    No technical reason why every square inch of the UK could not have fast 3G coverage, except for one thing.... money. That is all it boils down to.

    And the best coverage on the UK - yes, got it in one - London. The centre of all things and anyone who lives outside the M25 - what do you expect!

    I live in Scotland - best network for 3G by far - the 'numerical' one.

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 3.

    This is a great project BBC, a fully independent widespread coverage map has been needed for some time.

    I do notice, however that in rural areas such as where I live (Cornwall) there are many areas where the survey has not covered. I think this is partly down to limiting the app used to just Android. Please consider a release in the future for iOS, RIM Blackberry, and Symbian and maybe others.

  • rate this
    -2

    Comment number 4.

    Very poor survey, when you rely on people downloading an App. That immediately cuts out all of us who don't even get a signal. How do you expect people in Herefordshire, not the city - the county, to download any App when our coverage is 0G. Just give us 2G, please. That would be wonderful.

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 5.

    The worst place for mobile, TV, radio and broadband is the West Coast of Scotland (including the islands). No one actually cares about equality of access to infrastructure. These fragile communities are also the areas that heavily rely on tourism and digital connection to survive. In my village on the Mull of Kintyre there are two spots to stand to get a basic mobile signal for almost any network.

 

Comments 5 of 108

 

This entry is now closed for comments

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • PortlandTake it easy

    Could this be the most relaxed business city in the world?

Programmes

  • Papers Please gameClick Watch

    Meet the ‘bedroom programmer’ whose game has sold half a million copies and won a Bafta

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.