Learning from Mr Daisey

 
Mike Daisey performing The Agony and Ecstasy of Steve Jobs Mike Daisey in his stage show about Apple

Back in January, I heard the most extraordinary piece of radio I can remember in a long time. This American Life, the brilliant Chicago Public Media series, devoted its whole programme to an investigation into working conditions at the Chinese factories where Apple products are made.

What made it so compelling was that it was the work not of a journalist, but an actor Mike Daisey, whose stage show The Agony and Ecstasy of Steve Jobs formed the basis of the programme. It seemed to provide more evidence of the democratisation of journalism. Who needs trained reporters when bloggers, actors, ordinary citizens can do as well or better?

And Mr Daisey himself had already made this case, accusing technology journalists last year of being cowards, suborned by the companies they covered, and so incapable of exposing the kind of abuses he had uncovered.

But two months later This American Life has revealed something shocking. The programme's presenter Ira Glass told listeners in a blogpost: "We've learned that Mike Daisey's story about Apple in China - which we broadcast in January - contained significant fabrications. We're retracting the story because we can't vouch for its truth."

It turns out that the Mike Daisey misled the programme's editors and fact-checkers about the nature of his visit to China and what he had seen with his own eyes. Crucially, he'd made it impossible for them to contact the interpreter he'd taken with him on trips to the factories, claiming he had no way to reach her.

When a China-based correspondent for a sister programme, already suspicious about some of the details in the report, did manage to contact the interpreter, much of the story fell apart. She didn't remember meeting any underage workers with the actor, they'd not encountered workers damaged by a dangerous chemical, and, as for that extraordinary moment when an injured worker exclaimed in wonder when shown a working iPad for the first time - it never happened.

Over the weekend This American Life again devoted a whole hour to Mike Daisey and his investigation. But this edition was a mea culpa by the programme makers, revealing what had gone wrong and how it had been uncovered.

In some ways it was as gripping as the original programme. The encounter between Mike Daisey and Ira Glass was painful, with achingly long silences as Daisey pondered his responses. At stages it felt like a therapy session, with Glass trying to draw out the actor's reasons for thinking that it was alright to be cavalier about the facts.

But what emerged was a profound clash of cultures between the journalist and the actor. Ira Glass believes that if all the "facts" are not true, then Mike Daisey's work should be clearly labelled - in the theatre as well as on the radio - as fiction. The actor believes that his method is a valuable way of getting across a higher truth: "I'm not going to say that I didn't take a few shortcuts in my passion to be heard. But I stand behind the work."

He does, however, concede that his story "isn't up to the standards of journalism" and should have stayed in the theatre, rather than being elevated to a radio programme. So what should we conclude from this whole sorry saga? That there was nothing worth investigating about working conditions in China?

I don't think so. The professional journalists at the New York Times mounted their own inquiry into how those iPads and iPhones are made, uncovering some worrying issues, and Apple has been forced to respond by calling in an external group to carry out inspections. (It should be noted that other electronics firms which use the same suppliers have been rather quiet about the whole issue.)

The bigger question is what we've learned about journalism in the age of what the writer Andrew Keen has called the "cult of the amateur". I believe the whole affair has reinforced the value of journalism as a profession. Because it was professional journalists at This American Life who uncovered the truth about their own programme, and professional editors who had the courage and integrity to make a very public admission of their errors.

Mike Daisey was not completely wide of the mark in his criticism of technology journalists - there is a real danger for any specialist in being too close to an industry. But he has done a lot of damage to the idea that anyone with a bit of passion and a flair for language can be a reporter.

That's not to say that citizen journalists and bloggers haven't contributed greatly to the flow of information, comment and insight that the digital age has brought us. Nor is a professional training any guarantee that a journalist will prove to be accurate, honest or ethical.

But to listen to the forensic job that Ira Glass does in his interview with Mike Daisey is to come away convinced that the values to which professional journalists aspire are worth preserving.

 
Rory Cellan-Jones Article written by Rory Cellan-Jones Rory Cellan-Jones Technology correspondent

Who has won the social referendum?

Millions on both sides of the Scottish referendum have taken to tweeting and Facebooking their views on the issues - who has come out on top in the social media battle?

Read full article

More on This Story

More from Rory

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 33.

    Those of us old enough to remember the Hitler Diaries brouhaha wouldn't necessarily consider this a new phenomenon. Sometimes, the desire for a scoop is just too strong to resist.

    Then again, if you spend a lot of time around an industry which is increasingly prone to shipping stuff with inadequate testing, I guess some of that attitude might just rub off, too.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 32.

    Wait, people are surprised that an actor embellished the truth? When did this become a new thing? They're actors! Hollywood is full of celebs speaking out on things they know little about, yet they feel their fame is the only credential they need. I think the real question here is whether the ends justify the means? After all, Daisey's tactics did bring about awareness and could do some good.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 31.

    I wonder whether the show really did contain exaggerations or whether he is suddenly a whole lot richer. ALL Chinese factories are riddled with terrible conditions - Apples, and soon Nokia's and of course those turning out your trainers, clothes, the Royal wedding plates, British armies uniforms.....

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 30.

    By trying to "sex up" the accusations he has undermined an important area of genuine concern. It is not good enough to do this.

    He is hypocritical at best and possibly criminal at worst. Don't demand high standards and then use lies to back up your case. He is deserving of the anger his actions have provoked.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 29.

    "What made it so compelling was that it was the work not of a journalist.."

    Mr Cellan-Jones, imagine the truths you and your colleagues could tell us if it weren't for the fascist controls, sorry, editorial 'guidelines', of the organisation you work for. sometimes not being affiliated helps; anyway, not all journalists lick boot though they tend to die -- just google "list of journalists killed"

 

Comments 5 of 33

 

Features & Analysis

  • Medea Benjamin Code Pink

    Why authorities refuse to ban disruptive protesters


  • Pellet of plutoniumRed alert

    The scary element that helped save the crew of Apollo 13


  • HandshakeKiss and make up

    A marriage counsellor on healing the referendum hurt


  • Burnt section of the Umayyad Mosque in the old city of AleppoBefore and after

    Satellite images reveal Syria's heritage trashed by war


BBC Future

(USAF)

Secrets of the aircraft boneyards

The vast storage sites for surplus planes Read more...

Programmes

  • A screenshot from Goat SimulatorClick Watch

    The goat simulator which started as a joke but became a surprising hit, plus other tech news

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.