Pianist Krystian Zimerman storms out over phone recording

 
Krystian Zimerman Krystian Zimerman did not perform an encore, despite a rapturous reception

Related Stories

One of the world's leading pianists has surprised concertgoers by storming off stage because a fan was filming his performance on a smartphone.

Krystian Zimerman, 56, returned moments later and declared: "The destruction of music because of YouTube is enormous."

He carried on with his recital, but chose not to perform an encore and cancelled a post-concert reception.

The Polish pianist joins several high-profile musicians who have spoken out against filming.

In April, indie rock band the Yeah Yeah Yeahs put up a note for fans entering a gig.

"Please do not watch the show through a screen on your smart device/camera," it said, along with some stronger words.

Former Pink Floyd bassist and vocalist Roger Waters described filming at gigs as showing a "lack of respect" to the artist.

Agitated

Zimerman was performing at the Ruhr Piano Festival in Essen, western Germany, where he was said to have spotted a member of the audience filming the concert from the balcony.

"He noticed someone up in the choir seats filming the concert on their smartphone. We think it was probably an iPhone," said festival spokeswoman Anke Demirsoy after the performance.

Start Quote

It is becoming part and parcel of modern music promotion”

End Quote Jasper Hope Royal Albert Hall

"He asked them to stop, but they didn't. So he interrupted the recital and walked off stage."

Zimerman then apparently told the audience that he had lost recording contracts and projects because of recording company executives telling him: "We're sorry, that has already been on YouTube."

The festival's director, Franz Xaver Ohnesorg, said he sympathised with Zimerman's frustration.

He told German media: "What happened is theft, pure and simple. It cuts particularly deeply when the artist is of a sensitive nature."

The BBC could not reach Zimerman on Wednesday for comment.

Be discreet

Jasper Hope, chief operating officer at London's Royal Albert Hall, said filming at live events was not a problem - as long as it did not disturb the artist or the audience.

"It's not hard to be discreet," he told the BBC.

LJ Rich looks at how videos are being shared as they are made

"If you're the kind of artist that is prepared to use digital media to promote yourself, then provided you're not distracted I don't see a problem with that."

He added: "Do I seriously think that recording contracts for any artists can be jeopardised in this way? No I do not. It is becoming part and parcel of modern music promotion."

Violinist and composer Steve Bingham said for many musicians the issue was not about theft, but instead about terrible quality.

"You want people to pass on your music to friends, but the downside is you don't get the quality control you want if someone is recording in the 17th row on a smartphone.

"You either miss the bass because phones don't pick up the bass or the view is such that visually it isn't that good."

Smashed phone

Frustration at amateur filming is not just shared among musicians.

Lee Hurst Comedian Lee Hurst admitted smashing a phone belonging to an audience member

British comedian Lee Hurst found himself in court in 2009 after smashing up an audience member's mobile phone during a gig.

He told the court: "TV programmes have writers writing for the performers and they go around to gigs and take the material and sell it to the BBC and ITV and that material is gone.

"You are then accused of stealing your own material. It has happened to me with material shown on national TV that I had already done.

"There are thieves amongst the circuit, sadly, and amongst the writing community.

"Nobody will protect us, we have to protect ourselves."

Follow Dave Lee on Twitter @DaveLeeBBC

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

From other news sites

* May require registration or subscription

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +38

    Comment number 282.

    A number of my acquaintances seem to film the gigs they go to solely to gloat to others via social media about where they've been. I do perhaps get that aspect to it, funnily enough, but what I don't get is voluntarily removing yourself from the experience at hand in order to film, or indeed wanting to view the results later which, as most agree, tend to be rather poor and hence dissatisfying.

  • rate this
    +63

    Comment number 108.

    Surely this is simple to deal with. A no recording sign and announcement could be made. Anyone found to be recording should be immediately told to leave.

    This type of recording is how so many movies have been pirated in cinemas particularly in China, where such recording is now actively discouraged.

  • rate this
    +126

    Comment number 67.

    This is the strange thing now - all life has to be lived through a lens. People are tourists in their own lives, marching around like zombies with the yoke of social media slung around their necks like a camera strap. They obsessively record everything as if they have to in order to prove it actually happened. "If no one knows I did this/saw this/said this, then what's the point?!' Frightening.

  • rate this
    +86

    Comment number 59.

    Good for him. Filming a performance like this is an insult to the performer. The audience becomes dislocated from the experience as they concentrate on filming and not appreciating. The essence of the intimacy of the moment is lost. People who use their phones to film performances like this are worthy of contempt.

  • rate this
    -99

    Comment number 52.

    Performers need to get over the fact that we live in the 21st century and people like to communicate with their friends. No one is filming a concert with a smart phone so that they can burn 10,000 DVDs to sell at a car boot sale. People film as a memento of the event or to share a moment with their friends on Youtube. Performers are just to sensitive and pretentious.

 

Comments 5 of 10

 

More Technology stories

RSS

Features & Analysis

BBC Future

(Getty Images)

Secrets of the aircraft boneyards

The vast storage sites for surplus planes Read more...

Programmes

  • A computer simulation showing a planned station upgrade in Hong KongClick Watch

    Simulated world - how architects are using virtual and augmented reality to transform our cities

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.