M5 motorway crash: How safe are Britain's motorways?

A police helicopter takes off from an area on the M5 motorway near Taunton in Somerset where an accident occurred on 5 November 5 2011 The cause of the M5 crash is not clear but there had been heavy rain and reports of patchy fog in the area

Related Stories

After one of Britain's worst road accidents left seven people dead and scores more injured, we ask just how safe are Britain's motorways?

Many people will have woken on Saturday morning to the tragic news of the multiple pile-up on the M5 in Somerset.

Motorway accidents are certainly a regular occurrence, but experts say an incident on this scale is very rare.

In fact, they say Britain has not seen a road traffic accident on this scale for more than 20 years.

The only comparable incident, according to the AA, was a major crash involving 51 cars on the M4 in Berkshire in March 1991, which left 10 people dead and 25 injured.

So just how safe are these vital arteries, which keep the UK moving every day of the week?

Andrew Howard, head of road safety at the AA, says motorways are "our safest roads by a long, long way".

But road safety charity Brake says although there are fewer crashes on motorways per mile travelled than on other roads, when they do happen they are more likely to lead to death because of the high speeds involved.

In the UK, 2% of motorway crashes are fatal, compared with 1.4% of all crashes, according to the charity.

'Daily carnage'

"It [the M5 incident] is incredibly tragic," says Brake senior campaigns officer Ellen Booth.

Britain's worst road accidents

  • 20 October 2008: Family of six, including four children, killed in crash involving three lorries and two cars on the M6 in Cheshire
  • 7 May 2007: Six people, including five men travelling home from a stag party, killed on the M25 when the rescue truck carrying their broken-down minibus collides with a lorry in Surrey
  • 10 July 2003: Seven people - including three members of the same family - killed when a minibus collides with a car on the M56 in Greater Manchester
  • 10 March 1997: Three people killed and 160 vehicles involved in a pile-up on the M42 in fog
  • 17 November 1993: Crash on the M40 leaves 12 children dead when their minibus collides with a maintenance vehicle near Warwick
  • March 13 1991: Ten people killed, and 25 injured, in a 51-car pile-up in foggy conditions on the M4 near Hungerford
  • 28 October 1987: Diesel tank truck collides with stationary traffic on the M61 near Preston, Lancashire, killing 12 people
  • 11 December 1984: Nine people die in fog on the M25 at the Surrey/Kent border
  • 21 October 1985: Coach collides with stationary traffic on the M6, in Lancashire, between Preston and Lancaster, killing 13 people and injuring 34
  • 27 May 1975: Coach carrying pensioners comes off Dibbles Bridge, near Hebden, North Yorkshire, killing 32 people, in Britain's worst ever road accident

"But it's really important to stress that this kind of carnage is happening on a daily basis on our roads - five people are killed every day, but this often doesn't make the headlines."

Since 5 December 1958, when Britain's first stretch of motorway - the eight-mile Preston bypass - opened for business, motorways get us from A to B quicker than other routes.

But the government is considering allowing motorists to go even faster.

It believes the current speed limit of 70mph is out of date due to "huge advances in safety and motoring technology", and it should be increased to 80mph in England and Wales.

Currently, in Ireland and Spain the speed limit is 120km/h (75mph), in France it is 130km/h (81mph), while German autobahns are famous for being some of the few public roads in the world without blanket speed limits.

Department for Transport (DfT) figures show that as many as 49% of drivers currently flout the current 70mph limit - and Brake claims a move to 80mph would see speeds on Britain's motorways pushed ever higher.

In 2002, the Commons Transport Select Committee looked at raising the limit but decided against the move because it would result in a 5-10% increase in casualties on motorways.

"Government policy should not be doing anything to increase the number of man-made, unnatural deaths occurring," says Ms Booth.

She continues: "It's relevant to today's story [the M5 incident] because if you raise the motorway speed limit it sends out the message that it's ok to go faster on our motorways."

'Deaths halved'

DfT figures show that in 2010 there were 118 motorway fatalities from a total of 1,850 on Britain's roads; while in 2003 there were 217 fatalities from a total of 3,500.

Effectively, says Mr Howard, motorway deaths have been halved in the past seven years.

Then and now

1958

Today

Number of cars on the roads

4.5 million

31 million

Number of deaths on the roads

5,970

1,850

Source: AA

In fact, the Association of British Drivers (ABD) says despite the UK's motorways being significantly busier than other European motorways, there are far fewer fatalities.

In 2009, there were 1.2 fatalities per billion vehicle-kilometres on Britain's motorways - roughly on a par with Swiss motorways, according to figures quoted by the ABD.

In Denmark, that figure rises to 2.5 and Austria 4.2, and in the US it stands at 4.5.

But when compared to other forms of travel, such as by train or plane, motorways are more dangerous.

There were six deaths last year (not including suicides or trespass) on Britain's train network, according to the Office of Rail Regulation. And the Aircraft Crashes Record Office says in 2010 there were 130 accidents resulting in 1,115 fatalities worldwide.

'Head-on collisions'

Mr Howard says it is fairly logical that motorways are our - as he puts it - safest roads, given the four most common causes of road accidents:

  • "Vulnerable road-users", for example cyclists or pedestrians - are not allowed on motorways
  • Head-on collisions - unlikely given motorway drivers travel on opposite sides
  • Junctions - very few on motorways
  • "Falling off the road" - barriers lessen this risk

And, according to Mr Howard, we have come a long way since the opening of the first motorway. He says safety improvements come down to what he describes as the three Es - better engineering of cars and roads, better enforcement and better education.

But road safety charity Brake says there is more to be done to improve safety and reduce fatalities on Britain's motorways.

It says, for example, more adequate crash barriers are needed on many motorways.

Its website cites the incident that sparked the Selby rail crash on 28 February 2001, in which motorist Gary Hart fell asleep at the wheel on the M62.

Typical stopping distances

  • 20mph - 12m or three car lengths
  • 30mph - 23m or six car lengths
  • 40mph - 36m or nine car lengths
  • 50mph - 53m or 13 car lengths
  • 60mph - 73m or 18 car lengths
  • 70mph - 96m or 24 car lengths
  • In wet weather, stopping distances roughly double

Source: Highway Code

His vehicle left the motorway, went down a bank and on to a train line, causing a passenger train to derail and hit a freight train travelling the other way. Ten people were killed.

Brake says that government guidance does not recommended lengths for barriers at different sites. However, the DfT did later develop an "assessment tool" for authorities to assess protection required at different sites.

Another issue, Brake says, is there is too few rest stops for tired drivers.

The charity's own research suggests that in the past year, one in eight drivers fell asleep at the wheel for between two and 30 seconds. The survey of 1,000 drivers also found one in four admitted driving when they felt drowsy.

The AA's Mr Howard says staying safe on our motorways goes back to good old fashioned advice.

"It's getting the speed right so you can stop if anything happens - the key is speed and stopping distances," he says.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More UK stories

RSS

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • FordFactory facelift

    Watch as the plant that makes Ford's legendary F-150 undergoes a total overhaul

Programmes

  • A prosthetic legClick Watch

    How motion capture technology is being used to design bespoke prosthetics

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.