UK

Hillsborough papers: Key excerpts

  • 13 September 2012
  • From the section UK
Hillsborough Independent Panel report
The Hillsborough Independent Panel reviewed more than 450,000 pages in preparing its report

Papers which reveal evidence of failures and deceit over the deaths of 96 Liverpool fans at Sheffield Wednesday's Hillsborough ground have been released to the public for the first time.

The Hillsborough Independent Panel spent 18 months looking through more than 450,000 pages of documents relating to the fatal crush on 15 April 1989, which resulted in the deaths of 96 people.

The documents included cabinet minutes as well as evidence from public bodies such as the South Yorkshire Police, Sheffield City Council, the South Yorkshire coroner and the fire and ambulance services.

In its report, the panel said it uncovered new evidence detailing crowd safety deficiencies at the ground, shortcomings in the emergency services response, failures of leadership and co-ordination and widespread alteration of police statements in an attempt to blame the Liverpool fans for what happened.

Below are excerpts from some of the previously unreleased papers.

Statement from police officer on duty at Hillsborough

PC Brian Huckstepp was on duty at the ground on the day of the disaster. His original statement criticised the way police handled the tragedy - but his comments were removed before being submitted to Lord Taylor's 1989 inquiry. A letter from the panel set up to scrutinise the evidence said it was aware officers had been put under pressure to amend their statements. The critical paragraph is reproduced below.

Excerpt of police statement deleed from original
PC Huckstepp's original statement [671.7KB]

Statements edited

Statements by a number of other police officers at the scene were also edited. Some were told that alterations were made to exclude personal opinion and to leave the document as a factual report.

Comments by a PC S Smith describing "a situation of almost total panic," among senior officers were among those edited.

Extract from PC Smith's edited statement

The officer's potentially infammatory comments comparing the tragedy to the Hyesel Stadium disaster and blaming the deaths of innocent people on Liverpool fans were also removed.

PC Smith's original statement [206KB]

'No organisation'

A PC Michael Walpole had included comments in his statement about the lack of organisation or radio messages to officers on the ground. These were also removed for the final draft.

PC Walpole's handwritten account

When asked about the deleted paragraphs in 1998, PC Walpole said he was suffering post traumatic stress and depression and agreed to the deletions.

PC Walpole's letter explaining why his statement was changed
PC Walpole's letter about changing evidence [76KB]

Sun story "The Truth" based on MP's account

A headline story in The Sun newspaper which blamed the disaster at Hillsborough on drunken fans was based on a local news agency report of a conversation with the then MP for Sheffield Hallam Irvine Patnick and a senior police officer. The story caused outrage on Merseyside. The then editor Kelvin Mackenzie has now apologised for the story. This is part of Mr Patnick's notes of his conversation with police which was submitted to the Taylor inquiry as evidence.

Excerpt of conversation leading to Sun newspaper story
Irvine Patnick's notes of conversation with police submitted as evidence  [269.65KB]

Letter complaining about overcrowding in 1988

This letter from a spectator at a match between Liverpool and Nottingham Forest at the Hillsborough ground in 1988 was sent to the Football Association and the Minister of Sport Colin Moynihan. It raises concerns about severe overcrowding - a year before the disaster.

Letter complaining about overcrowding
Letter about overcrowding in 1988 [619.9KB]

Stand capacity was too high

This letter from the Acting Assistant Chief Constable of Operations at South Yorkshire Police raises concerns about the stand capacity at the Hillsborough ground. He points out that plans used to calculate a safe limit were inaccurate.

Letter saying plans for calculating stand capacity were inaccurate
Letter about stand capacity [269.7KB]

Senior ambulance officer criticised access for ambulances

A senior ambulance officer who attended the emergency at Hillsborough had parts of his statement amended. Criticism of the access for emergency vehicles was deleted and his request for more ambulances, because there were lots of casualties, was also crossed out.

Excerpt deleted from ambulance officer's statement
Letter with criticisms deleted [619.9KB]

More on this story

Related Internet links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites