Jeremy Hunt's Lewisham hospital cuts plan quashed at High Court

Campaigners celebrated at the Royal Courts of Justice following the ruling, but will the jubilation last? Jane Dreaper reports

Related Stories

Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt has had his decision to reduce services at a major hospital declared unlawful and quashed by the High Court.

Mr Justice Silber ruled Mr Hunt acted outside his powers when he announced casualty and maternity units at Lewisham Hospital would be downgraded.

He said the Secretary of State had breached provisions of the National Health Services Act 2006.

The judge gave him permission to appeal against the decision.

Mr Justice Silber said recommendations of the Secretary of State had to have regard to, or be supported by, GP commissioners.

It was quite clear that the Lewisham GP commissioners did not give support to the proposals, said the judge.

'Incredible day'

He went on: "On the contrary, they strongly opposed them although those GP commissioners in a number of surrounding but different areas were happy with them.

Analysis

There were cheers and tears in Court 76 as Mr Justice Silber gave hospital campaigners the news they had hoped for.

He ruled that Jeremy Hunt and the administrator he appointed to South London Healthcare had acted outside their powers when they decided to reduce services at Lewisham hospital.

He ruled that local GPs had not supported the plans and therefore they should not be allowed to go ahead.

Today's ruling comes six months to the day since Jeremy Hunt announced the downgrading of services like the A&E and maternity units at Lewisham.

Campaigners had argued it was being made to suffer because of the failings of the neighbouring South London Healthcare Trust which is £65m in deficit.

This was the first time the Trust Special Administrator regime had ever been used.

The government has been given permission to appeal.

"I considered that it was the absence of support from the local GP commissioners which constituted an additional reason why the decision of the Secretary of State cannot stand."

The challenge was brought by Save Lewisham Hospital and the London Borough of Lewisham.

Dr Louise Irvine, a local GP who chairs the Save Lewisham Hospital campaign, said: "This is an incredible day.

"We are delighted for every single person who has supported the campaign and those who will now continue to benefit from this extraordinary hospital."

Rosa Curling, a lawyer with solicitors' firm Leigh Day acting for the campaigners, described it as a "tremendous victory".

She said: "This judgment should serve as a warning to the government that, if they try to do this, local communities will fight back to ensure their healthcare services remain in place."

Mayor of Labour-run Lewisham Council, Sir Steve Bullock, said justice had been delivered to a hospital "well-managed, highly-respected and financially solvent".

In January Mr Hunt told MPs that the cuts were necessary because neighbouring South London Healthcare NHS Trust has been losing more than £1m every week.

A spokesman said Mr Hunt's department was "disappointed by the decision" and would consider the judgment carefully.

He said: "This judgment applies to one aspect of a package of changes which we believe are in the best long-term interests of patients and the public across south-east London.

"We expect to continue other elements of that package of changes, including the dissolution of the South London Healthcare NHS Trust, planned for October 1 - although there are a number of steps to go before that can take place."

The other changes expected to go ahead are King's Health Partners taking over Princess Royal Hospital and the merger of Queen Elizabeth Hospital and Lewisham Hospital trusts.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

24 °C 14 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    BBC London News 13:22: Victoria Hollins Journalist, BBC London

    On the programme at 13:30 on BBC One: We try out the new way to pay on public transport as contactless debit and credit cards can be used from today and we speak to one woman who believes the stress of her eviction while pregnant contributed to the death of one of her twins. Housing charity Shelter says one in eight families renting in London have been the victim of a revenge eviction- where tenants are forced to leave their homes after complaining about their conditions.

    Also, inspired by the art of taxidermy? We meet the author whose latest book delves into the strange world of stuffed animals.

     
  2.  
    Gas leak evacuation 13:11:

    About 200 people have been evacuated from their homes in Romford following a leaking gas main.

    London Fire Brigade said it was called to Victoria Road at about 10:30 and as a precaution closed the road as well as nearby South Street.

     
  3.  
    News on the hour 13:00:

    The lead headline at 13:00: About 200 people have been evacuated from their homes in Romford following a leaking gas main.

     
  4.  
    Have your say 12:45:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

     
  5.  
    Fire responsibility ruling needed 12:31:

    A man whose daughter died in an apartment block blaze in Canary Wharf wants clearer rules on fire safety responsibility.

    Sophie Rosser

    Sophie Rosser died in August 2012 after seeing her apartment block on fire and rushing inside to warn her fiancee.

    A coroner said the 23-year-old's death was accidental, but Ms Rosser's father Julian said: "Nobody was blamed because the coroner wasn't sure who the responsible person was."

     
  6.  
    EastEnders star settlement 12:20:

    EastEnders actor Steve McFadden has settled a damages claim against News Group Newspapers and the Metropolitan Police, issued following the phone hacking revelations.

    Steve McFadden

    Tamsin Allen, representing Mr McFadden, who plays Phil Mitchell in the soap, told a High Court judge that a police officer had sold private information about the actor to a News of the World journalist in 2010.

     
  7.  
    Pensions and music 12:09: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On the Robert Elms show: Mike Pentelow and Peter Arkell, the authors of Freedom Pass London - Make the Most of Your Travel Pass, talk about their guide to free travel for pensioners in London and singer Chastity Brown plays live.

    You can listen live on BBC London 94.9 and contact the team on 020 7224 2000.

     
  8.  
    News on the hour 12:00:

    The top headline at noon: The detective leading the search for the missing west London teenager Alice Gross will appear on Crimewatch tonight to appeal for information and show CCTV footage of her last known movements.

     
  9.  
    Male rape CCTV image released 11:49:

    A CCTV image of a man police want to speak to in connection with the rape of a 19-year-old man in a Kingston-upon-Thames nightclub has been released.

    CCTV image

    The incident occurred in the early hours of Thursday, 3 April, in the male toilets of the Pryzm nightclub in Clarence Street, Kingston. The suspect is believed to be in his mid 20s and is described as being of Mediterranean appearance.

     
  10.  
    Airport fog disruption 11:37:

    London City Airport tweets: Visibility has now improved, but flights may be delayed by the earlier disruption.

     
  11.  
    Top university city 11:28:

    London is the only city to have five of the world's top 100 universities, according to the QS World University Rankings.

    Imperial College

    Imperial College London was named the second best university in the world, alongside Cambridge University, but The Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) came out top for the third time.

     
  12.  
    Contactless payment 11:18:

    BBC London 94.9's Jason Rosam tweets: Wow! This man just used contactless on his mobile phone to enter the Tube gates! @TfLOfficial@BBCLondon949

    Contactless payments
     
  13.  
    Girls arrested over stabbing 11:07:

    Two teenage girls have been arrested after a 38-year-old man was stabbed and bitten on football fields on Wanstead Flats.

    The 13 and 16-year-olds were arrested at the scene yesterday afternoon on suspicion of causing GBH, Scotland Yard said.

     
  14.  
    News on the hour 11:00:

    The top story at 11:00: Detectives investigating the disappearance of west London teenager Alice Gross say they've had a "great response" from the public, but still no confirmed sightings after she was last seen on CCTV.

     
  15.  
    Coca-Cola takes on London Eye 10:54:

    It has been revealed that Coca-Cola is to become the new sponsor of the London Eye from January.

    London Eye
     
  16.  
    Injury doubts for Arsenal 10:46:

    Arsenal have injury problems in defence as they begin their Champions League campaign away to Borussia Dortmund tonight.

    Arsene Wenger

    Right-back Mathieu Debuchy and left-back Nacho Monreal are out, while new signing Calum Chambers is a doubt.

     
  17.  
    Car collides with train 10:36:

    A woman has been arrested on suspicion of dangerous driving after her car went through a level crossing barrier at Datchet, Berkshire, at 06:05 and collided with a train.

    Datchet level crossing

    British Transport Police said the 67 year old's Volkswagen Golf collided with a train travelling from Clapham to Windsor and Eton Riverside Station.

    She escaped injury.

    The crash has caused travel disruption to services.

     
  18.  
    Alice Gross rucksack 'seen' 10:26:

    Police investigating the disappearance of Alice Gross say a couple have come forward with a new sighting of Alice's rucksack.

    Image of Alice's bag

    A Crimewatch appeal for more information about the 14 year old girl, from Hanwell, will be made tonight.

    Alice was last seen on 28 August.

     
  19.  
    Death row meals 10:21:

    A pop-up restaurant inspired by the last meal requests of people on death row is coming to Hackney, Dalstonist reports.

    The restaurant, which will be open for a month until the end of November, will be located on Hoxton Square.

     
  20.  
    Greenwich regeneration 10:11:

    Plans to build 10,000 new homes on the Greenwich Peninsula will go on display this week.

    O2 development

    The scheme, which would be the UK's largest new development, involves 160 acres of land near the O2 and would take up to 25 years to complete.

     
  21.  
    News on the hour 10:00:

    The lead headline at 10:00: A woman is in a critical condition in hospital after a suspected hit and run involving a stolen car that was being chased by police in Highgate.

     
  22.  
    Rail disruption 09:46: Louise Pepper Journalist, BBC London

    Buses are replacing trains on South West services between Windsor & Eton Riverside and Staines-upon-Thames because of a level crossing incident.

    For travel updates on twitter, follow @BBCTravelAlert

     
  23.  
    Shooting arrest 09:36:

    Detectives investigating the fatal shooting of a 21-year-old man in Battersea have arrested a second man on suspicion of murder.

    Sebastian Jamal Hyman-Knight

    Sebastian Hyman-Knight was shot in the head in Tennyson Street on Thursday night. Police say they are keeping an open mind about the motive.

     
  24.  
    W1A returns 09:27: Beth Rose BBC News Online

    I may have ended up on the extras cutting room floor in the first series, but Hugh Bonneville is to reprise his role as Ian Fletcher in BBC mockumentary W1A for a second series next year.

    W1A

    Based on the real workings of the newsroom, hundreds of BBC journalists offered to be extras and pretend to work away at their computers. If you were lucky enough to be "given direction" as I was, you could reach the heady heights of having to walk between two desks.

    In the new show, Fletcher will have the additional challenge of having to deal with the issue of the BBC's charter renewal, which is due in 2016.

     
  25.  
    Changing visibility 09:16:

    The RNLI's Matt Leat tweets: Since starting work today the visibility has reduced just a bit #fog #thamesbarrier

    Thames barrier
     
  26.  
    Suspected hit and run 09:10:

    A woman is in a critical condition in hospital after a suspected hit and run involving a stolen car that was being chased by police in Highgate.

     
  27.  
    On air 09:03: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    London's mental health services are struggling to cope with the demand for psychological therapies, according to new research by the We Need to Talk coalition.

    It found that nearly a quarter of Londoners needing therapy have been waiting for more than six months.

    What is your experience? You can listen live to BBC London 94.9 and contact the team on 020 7224 2000.

     
  28.  
    Top headlines
     
  29.  
    Airport disruption 08:52:

    Heavy fog has caused dozens of flights to be delayed or cancelled at London City Airport.

    Eurocontrol, which co-ordinates air traffic control across Europe, said there could be delays of up to 160 minutes.

     
  30.  
    Contactless payments on Tube 08:42:

    Contactless bank cards are being introduced across London's Tube, DLR and Overground train networks.

    contactless card

    From this morning, people can use their bank cards instead of having to top up Oyster Cards, although these will still be accepted.

     
  31.  
    UCH to get Sutton money 08:32:

    University College Hospital is set to benefit from a share of the almost £5m raised by cancer sufferer Stephen Sutton in aid of the Teenage Cancer Trust.

    Stephen Sutton

    The trust said the hospital's 18-bed unit was in "desperate need" of refurbishment and a £168,000 donation would be added to £192,000 already raised by other supporters to enable improvements to be made.

     
  32.  
    No Woolwich ferry 08:23:

    TfL River tweets: No service on the Woolwich Ferry due to adverse weather conditions.

     
  33.  
    Hull 2 - 2 West Ham 08:15:

    West Ham produced a spirited fightback to twice come from behind and deny Hull City victory at the KC Stadium.

    Hull v West Ham

    Abel Hernandez, a club record £10m buy, gave Hull the lead before Enner Valencia equalised with a spectacular 25-yard strike.

    Mo Diame restored Hull's lead against his old club, only for Curtis Davies to divert Diafra Sakho's shot into his own net.

     
  34.  
    Fog flights disruption 08:06: Louise Pepper Journalist, BBC London

    There is disruption to flights to and from City Airport because of the fog.

    For more travel updates, visit BBC London's travel website.

     
  35.  
    08:01: Beth Rose BBC News Online

    Good morning. I'll be bringing you all the latest news, sport, travel and weather from London today for BBC Local Live.

    You can send your news, pictures and comments to london.locallive@bbc.co.uk.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Green animalLife in green

    BBC Earth discovers some of nature's weird and wonderful creatures dressed in a colourful coat

Programmes

  • Three men solving a puzzleThe Travel Show Watch

    Why tourists are heading to the Hungarian capital Budapest for the chance to break out of a room

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.