Life at two A&E units: 'People just need looking after'

Great Yarmouth's hospital struggles to cope with the demands of the town's population, even before the season influx of tourists, and with problems recruiting enough A&E doctors.

Across England last year, accident and emergency departments dealt with more than one million more patients compared to three years ago and many say they are struggling to cope.

Ahead of a review being carried out by NHS Medical Director Prof Sir Bruce Keogh about the future of emergency provision in hospitals, BBC News Online visited hospitals in two contrasting areas to find out what the situation is like there.

Accident and emergency, Salford Royal Hospital

A problem drinker who cut his mouth swigging from a broken bottle has been brought in by ambulance, making it his third visit of the day.

Start Quote

Dr Bruce Martin

Emergency services are very stretched at the moment”

End Quote Dr Bruce Martin

Just an hour earlier he was released when he urinated in the department.

The pungent smell of stale alcohol drifts from the cubicle.

The idea of having quiet days in A&E are "long gone", says Dr Bruce Martin, an emergency medicine consultant.

"Most of the time I'm in resus[citation] and I expect to see two or three critically ill patients who need a high level of care," he said.

"Most days we have at least one major trauma case."

There are nine people in the waiting area of the A&E unit on this weekday lunchtime, but others have been rushed straight through on stretchers.

'Lot of blood'

In January, the unit became a major trauma centre, meaning it now takes patients with multiple, life-threatening injuries - caused by anything from road crashes to shootings - from across Greater Manchester.

BBC Inside Out

BBC Inside Out filmed at 10 A&E departments across England on the same day - 1 September - over a 12-hour shift.

The programmes collected statistics, breaking down details of all the A&E admissions on that day.

They focus on how many A&E patients are seen with the government recommended time of four hours and how hospitals are coping to meet them.

The research does not claim to be scientific but will aim to give a general snapshot of A&E on one day across England.

Each regional programme will be broadcast on BBC One at 19:30 BST.

It was also the location Prime Minister David Cameron chose last month to announce an extra £500m funding for the English A&E departments struggling most.

However, the most common accidents they see in Salford involve people who have fallen or have been in motorbike crashes, according to Dr Martin.

Peak times for Salford's A&E are between 10:00 and 19:00. Numbers wane into late evening and then peak again between midnight and 01:00.

One of Dr Martin's patients arrives at hospital with her concerned husband.

"There was a lot of blood," he says.

His wife, who has motor neurone disease, slipped on a grape in a supermarket and cut her head, leaving them both worried.

But, after a scan, it turns out there is no lasting damage and the woman is sent home.

David Cameron at Salford Royal Hospital's A&E The prime minister chose the unit to announce extra funding for struggling A&Es

By 14:00 BST, four patients are in resuscitation and another seven are suffering from major injuries.

A woman arrives at A&E unable to get her regular medication after having just changed doctors. The team liaises with her GP surgery to make sure she gets the right care elsewhere.

Salford Royal Hospital

  • It has the fifth lowest mortality rate and the lowest outside of London
  • In 2012 the A&E dealt with a total of 86,377 people
  • 90% of patients rate their care as good or excellent
  • Across the hospital its specialisms are neuroscience, intestinal failure, stroke, trauma, dermatology and renal expertise

Dr Martin said that about 30% of the patients who arrive at A&E could have been seen by their GP instead, and about 10% of people who turn up at the hospital are just told to go and see their own doctors instead.

All GPs in Salford are now made to assign at least two appointments a day for people referred from A&E.

"Emergency services are very stretched at the moment," he said.

But despite this, the hospital has managed all year to meet the government's four-hour target to see 95% of patients within four hours.

At the 16:00 BST handover, doctors discuss the most seriously-injured patients, who now also include a man who became ill while climbing a ladder and an elderly man who collapsed in the street. Their illnesses remain a mystery.

Meanwhile, a patient retches loudly in a nearby cubicle while a woman with severe stomach cramps is wheeled through the department taking gas and air.

Accident and emergency, Grantham and District Hospital

Hospital waiting room (generic) Staff said they were seeing increasingly poorly people arriving at A&E

Over in rural Grantham there are five people waiting patiently in the hospital's single-storey A&E.

In one corner, a mother and two children are playing in a glassed-off children's waiting area. One patient says she has been warned she will have an hour-and-a-half wait.

It can be hard, says senior sister Teresa Shepherd, for people to understand why they have to wait to be seen on such an apparently quiet day.

"Over there," she says, thumbing at a pair of secure-access double-doors, "that's where all the action is."

Start Quote

Kay Myciuk

When you work in a big city hospital, you have every speciality under one roof. Here, the doctors and nurses need to solve problems quickly”

End Quote Kay Myciuk Junior sister

Mrs Shepherd is Grantham born-and-bred, along with many of the hospital's 894 staff.

Often, she says, they are on first-name terms with whoever walks through the door.

Since the hospital's mental health service closed, A&E has increasingly been the place mental health patients choose to go for treatment.

The removal of many maternity services from the hospital has also meant some visits from mothers-to-be in the latter stages of labour - the most recent A&E birth was in June.

The team also sees plenty of "worried well", such as a man concerned about his "itchy ears".

"People just need looking after," says junior sister Kay Myciuk

"When you work in a big city hospital, you have every speciality under one roof.

"If you need a neurologist or a spinal surgeon, you page them. Here, the doctors and nurses need to think on their feet and solve problems quickly."

And - following the closure of those hospital services - there have also been fears A&E could close.

Since 2007, the most seriously-injured people have been sent to Lincoln, a specialist trauma centre like Salford. But that is 30 miles away.

Farming accidents

Mrs Shepherd said she thought it was unlikely Grantham would lose its A&E.

"We cover such a large area," she said.

Grantham's accident and emergency unit The department at Grantham takes patients from four counties

"There's no way they could manage without us."

The hospital serves four counties - Lincolnshire, Nottinghamshire, Leicestershire and Rutland - and its A&E sees between 80 and 100 cases a day.

Many of the casualties have suffered farming or horse-related accidents.

Famous faces have passed through the A&E, including dukes and duchesses from the local aristocracy and even members of the Royal family. But the nurses remain tight-lipped about their identities.

'Make a fuss'

Mrs Shepherd said they were seeing increasingly poorly people arriving at A&E.

"I've noticed patients are waiting until they're really ill before they come and see us," she said.

"Particularly elderly people - they don't like to make a fuss."

Grantham and District Hospital

An ambulance at the hospital
  • Grantham's A&E unit was built in 1987, replacing two portable cabins
  • It operates a 24-hour service, dealing with acute, rather than chronic cases
  • It is one of four hospitals operated by United Lincolnshire Hospitals Trust

The hospital gets busiest from early afternoon into evening.

Saturday and Sunday afternoons are when visits reach a peak, said Mrs Shepherd.

"People spend all week at work, then at the weekend they go and injure themselves, playing football or doing DIY," she said.

In one of the curtained examination rooms, one patient, Phil, is waiting for a verdict on his fractured elbow after he fell from a ladder.

"They told me I'd done a good job of it," he says, ruefully.

It turns out it is broken in four places and the orthopaedic surgeon is on his way.

Outside, staff are dashing about after an ambulance pulls up outside.

"Stretcher coming through," one nurse shouts.

"You step back into the waiting room and you can't tell any of that is going on behind the scenes," said Mrs Shepherd, walking back through the double doors.

The staff work hard to stick to NHS targets.

"We rarely fall below 95% [being seen within four hours]," said Mrs Shepherd.

"We know Grantham and we know our patients.

"We make sure our standards are what we would expect for our own parents and children."

Great Yarmouth's hospital struggles to cope with the demands of the town's population, even before the season influx of tourists, and with problems recruiting enough A&E doctors.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More England stories


Features & Analysis

  • BeefaloBeefalo hunt

    The hybrid animal causing havoc in the Grand Canyon

  • Actor Jackie Chan gestures as he stands on the set of his new movie 'Around the World in 80 Days' on 6 May, 2003 in Berlin, GermanyDuang duang duang

    How a new word 'broke the Chinese internet'

  • Sound of Music PosterFar from a flop

    Even Sound of Music film crew surprised by success

  • Don Roberto Placa Quiet Don

    The world's worst interview - with one of the loneliest men on Earth

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • KnucklesGood or bad?

    For many it can be very satisfying to 'crack' the bones in your hand, but is it bad for you?


  • 3D model of Christ the Redeemer statueClick Watch

    Using drones to 3D map the famous Brazilian landmark Christ the Redeemer

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.