Mark Duggan inquest: Family fury at lawful killing decision

Mark Duggan's aunt Carole, speaking outside court: "He was executed"

Mark Duggan's family have said they will fight for justice after an inquest jury concluded by a majority of 8 to 2 that he was lawfully killed by police.

Mr Duggan was shot dead by armed officers in August 2011 in Tottenham, sparking riots across England.

Following the inquest at the Royal Courts of Justice, his aunt Carole Duggan said he had been "executed".

Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe has asked for a meeting with local community leaders.

There were angry scenes outside the court, with supporters of Mr Duggan's family chanting "murderers" at Assistant Commissioner Mark Rowley as he read a statement.

'Lethal force'

Jurors concluded Mr Duggan did not have a gun when he was shot by officers who surrounded a minicab he was travelling in.

But the jury said it was more likely than not that he had thrown a gun on to some nearby grass just before he was killed. The weapon was found about 20ft (6m) away from the scene.

Assistant Commissioner Mark Rowley was met with a barrage of chants

The panel of seven women and three men was asked to answer five questions:

  • In the period between midday on 3 August 2011 and when state amber was called at 6.00 pm on 4 August 2011, did the Metropolitan Police Service and the Serious Organised Crime Agency do the best they realistically could have done to gather and react to intelligence about the possibility of Mr Duggan collecting a gun from Mr Hutchinson-Foster? The jury said a unanimous no.
  • Was the stop conducted in a location and in a way which minimised, to the greatest extent possible, recourse to lethal force? Unanimous yes.
  • Did Mr Duggan have the gun with him in the taxi immediately before the stop? Unanimous yes
  • How did the gun get to the grass area where it was later found? A majority of 9 to 1 said it was thrown.
  • When Mr Duggan received a fatal shot, did he have the gun in his hand? A majority of 8 to 2 said no, he did not have a gun in his hand.

Following the verdict his mother, Pamela Duggan, was led out of the court in tears, while Mr Duggan's brother was seen screaming and shouting.

Mark Duggan's mother Pamela (left) and aunt Carole outside court Mr Duggan's family said he was "executed"

BBC News home affairs correspondent Dominic Casciani tweeted: "I don't think I have ever heard of a jury, performing their civic duty, being abused in court by members of the public."

Following the conclusion to the inquest, an Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) spokesperson said: "We note the inquest jury's determination and findings and we are considering them as a matter of urgency in relation to our ongoing investigation."

'No justice, no peace'

Outside court, his aunt Carole Duggan said: "The majority of people in this country know that Mark was executed.

"We're going to fight until we have no breath in our body for justice for Mark, for his children, and for all of those (unclear) with deaths in custody that have had nothing.

Sir Bernard Hogan Howe: "We need to do more to build trust"

"We are not giving up. No justice, no peace!"

But Met Police Commissioner Mr Hogan-Howe said: "I welcome the verdict of a jury that our officers acted lawfully when they confronted an armed criminal who they believed posed a threat to them and to the public.

"The death of Mark Duggan in 2011 was a tragedy for his family and led to a significant reduction in trust between London's black communities and the Metropolitan Police.

"I know that we have much work to do with black Londoners to build trust and confidence in the Metropolitan Police.

"I have asked some of the capital's political representatives, and local community leaders from Tottenham, to meet me tomorrow [Thursday] to discuss how the Metropolitan Police can build better relationships for the future."

'Shot on sight'

The Duggan's family lawyer Marcia Willis Stewart said "We can't believe this was the outcome. He had no gun in his hand, yet he was shot, he was murdered.

"To us, that is unlawful killing."

In a statement later, Ms Stewart said: "The jury has found that Mark Duggan was unarmed at the point at which he was shot.

"We cannot countenance a situation in which an unarmed citizen is shot on sight.

"The jury found that there were failings in the way the police conducted the gathering and actioning of evidence. Had they done their job properly, this fatal shooting could have been avoided.

She added the family would seek an urgent meeting with the IPCC, their MP David Lammy, and MP Keith Vaz, in order to ensure the IPCC "carry a vigorous review".

Deborah Coles, from the charity Inquest, said Mr Duggan's family were considering whether to apply for the decision to be judicially reviewed.

Assistant Commissioner Mark Rowley Assistant Commissioner Mark Rowley attempted to read a statement outside court

Outside court, Assistant Commissioner Rowley attempted to read a statement which said the force had sympathy with Mr Duggan's family.

"No officer sets out at the start of the day to run an operation that results in someone dying," he said.

"We send out well-trained, professional armed officers thousands of times a year to combat this threat [of gun violence], only firing shots once or twice. These careful tactics have significantly reduced gun crime."

He added: "We know the trust is not shared by everyone. I will be offering to meet Mark Duggan's family to express our sorrow."

Tottenham MP David Lammy said the IPCC investigation had questions to answer, in particular what happened days before the shooting.

He said: "The Duggan family's sorrow and anger was palpable in court this afternoon and it is a feeling that will inevitably be reflected in the wider community.

"Further clarification on the events surrounding Mark Duggan's shooting is essential to enable the relationship between the community and the police to move forward.

"There are aspects of this verdict that are somewhat perplexing and seemingly contradictory to those of who us who have carefully followed the proceedings over the last few months."

Tottenham 'calm'

A Home Office spokeswoman said it was "inappropriate to comment" while the IPCC was still carrying out its investigation.

BBC News correspondent Tom Symonds, who is in Tottenham, said the area was "very calm but has a high police presence".

The Met said there was an operation in place across London this evening where they have the ability to deploy extra officers if needed.

After Mr Duggan was shot, rioting spread across London and other parts of England in what became some of the worst disturbances in decades.

The inquest began in September. Before the jurors retired for what was seven days of deliberation, Judge Keith Cutler told them to reach their decisions "on the evidence and the evidence alone".

The coroner thanked the jury and told them they will be excused from future jury service for life if they want.

More on This Story

BBC London

Weather

London

20 °C 10 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    18:00:

    That's all from BBC Local Live today. Join us tomorrow from 08:00 for all the latest news, sport, travel and weather.

     
  2.  
    Easter bonnets and dancing 17:46:

    In this image from 1892, a group of women are wearing their Easter bonnets and dancing on Hampstead Heath during the Bank Holiday break from work.

    Women on Hampstead Heath
     
  3.  
    Dry and mild 17:43:

    It will be a largely dry night, with some clear spells at first, allowing some patchy mist or fog to develop.

    Minimum temperature: 8C (46F).

     
  4.  
    Travel 17:37:

    The A243 is very slow in Chessington because London Fire Brigade are attending to a fire in a shed.

    Get up to date travel information on BBC London Travel News or on Twitter @BBCTravelAlert.

     
  5.  
    Crew member rejoins world race 17:33:

    A crew member from the Derry-Londonderry yacht, who fell overboard in the Pacific Ocean in March, has rejoined the crew.

    Andrew Taylor Andrew Taylor was in the water for 90 minutes before being rescued

    Andrew Taylor, 46, from London, went over the side of the yacht on 30 March while competing in the Clipper round the world race.

     
  6.  
    VIDEO: Donor sister refused visa 17:26:

    Oliver Cameron, a north London plumber who is suffering kidney failure, has been told he may have to wait for three years before a transplant after his sister, who is a perfect donor match, was refused entry to the UK.

    Oliver Cameron

    Keisha Rushton had her request to travel to the UK for the operation refused by the British High Commission on the grounds that she may not return to Jamaica after the operation.

     
  7.  
    Queen's portrait 17:11:

    A portrait of the Queen by photographer David Bailey, who grew up in east London, has been released in honour of her 88th birthday on Monday.

    David Bailey's portrait of the Queen

    The black and white photo, which shows the Queen smiling, was taken at Buckingham Palace in March.

     
  8.  
    Fire shuts central London road 16:46:

    A fire in an electrical sub-station in New Oxford Street has caused the closure of a busy road in central London, London Evening Standard reports.

    Firefighters were called to Castlewood House this afternoon, leading to the closure of a street between Tottenham Court Road and Bloomsbury Street.

     
  9.  
    The Monarch 'gagged' 16:30:

    The poster for the satirical play King Charles III at the Almeida Theatre in Islington this afternoon, with a duct tape on the Prince's mouth. And a censored version of the same at Angel station.

    Poster for King Charles III The poster outside the theatre (left) and the poster at Angel station

    Transport for London said: "The decision was made by our advertising contractor without reference to us and does look to have been a little over enthusiastic".

     
  10.  
    Arsenal win at Hull 16:12:

    Arsenal keep control of their Champions League destiny with a comfortable 3-0 win at Hull.

    Lukas Podolski Lukas Podolski scored two goals

    Lukas Podolski scored two goals for the London side after Aaron Ramsey scored the first goal about half-an-hour into the game.

     
  11.  
    Easter - not a British tradition? 16:04: via Facebook

    Thanks for your comments on your Easter memories.

    Lucan Alan said: "No! Because that's an American pass-time or "tradition" or could it be I'm one of few who remember this is England"

    Vivienne Merryweather responds: "I am not sure this is an American tradition. My mum used to hide our eggs on Easter Sunday when I was a kid and I am now 67! I did it for my children and they did it for theirs etc. we also used to roll hard boiled eggs down a hill near Hampstead Heath."

     
  12.  
    Olympics legacy 15:43:

    BBC World Service tweets: What's the legacy of the #Olympics for those who live near to the main venues? Hear @RebeccaKesby1's #SundayFeature

     
  13.  
    Have your say 15:25:

    Tell us what you think of BBC Local Live. We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  14.  
    Half-time: Hull v Arsenal 15:10:

    At half-time, Arsenal are two goals up at Hull City.

    Aaron Ramsey scored the opening goal

    Aaron Ramsey scored the first goal 31 minutes into the game while Lukas Podolski scored the second just before half-time.

     
  15.  
    Drug offences 15:06:

    Islington MPS tweets: 18 ppl in custody this morning for drug offences, offensive weapon, assault, affray, possessing stolen moped, burglary (x 3)

     
  16.  
    Easter memories 14:44: via Facebook

    Thanks for your comments on your memories of Easter.

    Elsa Emanuela Stella said: "In Italy we call it colazione di pasqua (Easter breakfast): when you wake up, instead of cappuccino, pizza di formaggio (cheese bread) with salami, boiled eggs and a glass of wine!"

    Colin Johnston said: "Yes we did a Easter egg hunt for the children in Parsloes Park Dagenham....organised by friends of Parsloes Park....good time had by all."

     
  17.  
    In pictures: Passion play 14:22:

    Hundreds of people gathered at Trafalgar Square in central London on Good Friday to watch performances of the Passion of the Christ.

    The play depicted Christ's entry to Jerusalem, his betrayal, capture, trial, crucifixion and resurrection.

    Passion of the Christ
     
  18.  
    Hull v Arsenal 13:47:

    Hull and Arsenal will fight it out at KC Stadium in Hull from 14:05. Follow the live text commentary here.

    The London club were given a "massive scare by Wigan in last week's FA Cup semi-final" football analyst Mark Lawrenson said, hence this match will be very important for them.

     
  19.  
    Quango boss resigns 13:30:

    Responding to the resignation of Tony Caplin as the chairman of the Public Works Loan Board, a Conservative Party spokesman said: "Tony Caplin has no role in the Conservative Party nor is he contributing to the manifesto.

    "He was appointed to a number of public bodies by the previous government. He was re-appointed to the PWLB by the prime minister.

    "He should have declared he was bankrupt. This has been pointed out to him and as a result he has resigned."

     
  20.  
    Lanes blocked 13:14:

    TfL Traffic News tweets: A1261 Aspen Way (E14) W/B approaching Limehouse Link Tunnel - Lns 1 & 2 (of 3) blocked due to a Rd traffic collision.

    Lanes blocked near Limehouse Link Tunnel
     
  21.  
    Easter themed studio 13:00: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Tony Blackburn (@tonyblackburn) is now live till 3pm! Live streaming from his Easter themed studio...

    Tony Blackburn
     
  22.  
    Signal problem 12:45:

    First Great Western tweets: There's a signal problem between Paddington and Hayes & Harlington. Network Rail are on site, but delays of up to 20-mins are expected.

     
  23.  
    Finishing canoe race 12:31:

    Hundreds of canoeists and kayakers who began a 125-mile race to Westminster have crossed the finish line.

    Canoeist cross the finish line

    The race began in the Devizes in Wiltshire on Friday.

     
  24.  
    Quango boss resigns 12:13:

    Labour has said it is "astonishing" Prime Minister David Cameron could appoint Tony Caplin as head of the Public Works Loan Board.

    Shadow Chief Secretary to the Treasury Chris Leslie said: "For him to be bankrupted in 2012 and appointed by the Prime Minister as chairman of this key Treasury body the following year is surely a misjudgement too far by a Prime Minister with a track record of poor judgement in relation to his cronies."

     
  25.  
    Stabbing in Thornton Heath 11:55:

    A man has been stabbed following a fight in Brigstock Road, Thornton Heath, south-east London, last night.

    The victim, believed to be in his 20s, is in a stable condition in hospital, Met Police said. No arrests have been made.

     
  26.  
    The Monarchy 'gagged' 11:33:

    On the gagged poster of Prince Charles advertising the play on the monarchy a Transport for London spokesperson, said: "The decision was made by our advertising contractor without reference to us and does look to have been a little over enthusiastic.

    "We will speak to them about it."

     
  27.  
    Chelsea lose 11:14:
    Connor Wickham scores

    Bottom club Sunderland earned a stunning win at Chelsea that severely dented the Blues' title hopes and gave leaders Liverpool a major boost.

    Connor Wickham followed up Marcos Alonso's shot to equalise after Samuel Eto'o had given Chelsea the lead. This was Jose Mourinho's first home Premier League defeat in 78 games as Chelsea manager.

     
  28.  
    Public Works Loan Board boss resigns 10:54:

    A businessman appointed by the prime minister to head the Public Works Loan Board, a quango managing public funds, has resigned after reports that he had been declared bankrupt.

    Tony Caplin, who was the chairman of the North West London Hospitals NHS Trust until January last year, resigned as chairman of the Public Works Loan Board, a Conservative spokesman said.

     
  29.  
    The Monarchy 'gagged' 10:34:

    A poster advertising a satirical play at the Almeida Theatre in Islington, north London, about the monarchy and showing Prince Charles gagged, has been censored on the London Underground, the Mail Online reports.

    The poster for King Charles III features a punk-style portrait of the Prince with his mouth covered by white duct tape.

     
  30.  
    As it happened
     
  31.  
    VIDEO: River Thames levels 10:21:

    As the boating season gets under way, river users are being urged to take extra care on the Thames because of higher than usual water levels.

    River Thames at Teddington

    The Environment Agency says there are strong currents and lots of debris in the water between Teddington, west London and Lechlade, Gloucestershire.

     
  32.  
    Archbishop of Westminster 09:53: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The Archbishop of Westminster, Cardinal Vincent Nichols was in the studio earlier and told Jumoke Fashola people often ask him to pose for "selfies".

    "It's fun but I want to know like everybody else... what's it look like? Does it look alright? But we should have eyes that go beyond the appearance," he said.

    Cardinal Vincent Nichols, the Archbishop of Westminster
     
  33.  
    Easter service 09:42: Jason Rosam Journalist, BBC London

    The Bishop of London Richard Chartres has led a dawn Easter service on the steps of St Pauls Cathedral this morning. He handed me a red painted egg for Easter when I interviewed him on BBC London 94.9.

    He told me it's because red is the colour of the resurrection and the egg promises new life. His message for Easter is celebrating a wider Christian community around the world.

     
  34.  
    Easter Sunday 09:15:

    BBC London 94.9 reporter Jason Rosam tweets: The Bishop of London hands me a red painted egg for #Easter during his interview on @BBCLondon949 today. #HappyEaster

    Easter egg
     
  35.  
    Top news stories 08:53: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    From 09:00, Harriet Scott and Chris Rogers will be looking back over some of the big news stories of the week, including teenage pregnancies after a 12-year-old London girl became a mother and the rise in the number of people using food banks.

    Also in focus are the big issues in next month's local elections.

     
  36.  
    Easter travel 08:36:

    Disruption over the Easter period for improvement works:

    • District Line: No trains between Ealing Broadway and Turnham Green until Tuesday
    • Jubilee Line: No trains between Waterloo and Finchley Road until Tuesday
    • Piccadilly Line: No trains between Acton Town and Uxbridge until Tuesday
    • Bakerloo Line: No trains between Harrow & Wealdstone and Willesden Junction today
    • London Overground: No trains between Surrey Quays and Clapham Junction all weekend, and no trains between Watford Junction and Queens Park today
    • DLR: No service between Stratford and Bow Church until 2200 on Friday 25 April.
     
  37.  
    Cloudy with rain 08:12:

    It will be cloudy with occasional rain this morning.

    A band of heavier and more persistent rain will spread from the south in the afternoon, but it is expected to become drier by late evening. Highs of 15C (59F).

     
  38.  
    08:00: Debabani Majumdar BBC News Online

    Good morning. I'll be with you until 18:00 with the latest news, sport, travel and weather for London.

    You can tell me your news by emailing london.locallive@bbc.co.uk or tweeting @BBCLondonNews.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • ITChild's play

    It's never been easier for small businesses to get their message out to the world

Programmes

  • An aerial shot shows the Olympic Stadium, which is closed for repair works on its roof, in Rio de Janeiro March 28, 2014.Extra Time Watch

    Will Rio be ready in time to host the Olympics in 2016? The IOC president gives his verdict

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.