England

Cheeki Rafiki: 'Structural weakness' blamed in MAIB report

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionThe crew were sailing back to Southampton following a regatta in Antigua

A yacht that capsized leaving four UK sailors missing in the North Atlantic may have been affected by structural weaknesses, a report has said.

The Cheeki Rafiki crew had diverted the vessel after it began taking on water last May but contact was then lost.

Days later the hull of the 40ft yacht was found with its life raft still on board. There was no sign of the crew.

The vessel may have been weakened by previous groundings and subsequent repairs, the MAIB report has said.

Skipper Andrew Bridge, 22, from Farnham in Surrey, was lost in the disaster along with crew members James Male, 22, from Romsey, Steve Warren, 52, from Bridgwater in Somerset, and Paul Goslin, 56, from West Camel in Somerset.

They were returning from Antigua Sailing Week to Southampton when they capsized approximately 720 miles (1,160km) east-south-east of Nova Scotia in Canada.

An air and sea search mission covered hundreds of miles east of Cape Cod, Massachusetts but was eventually called off.

Image copyright PA
Image caption The crew were sailing back to Southampton following a regatta in Antigua
Image copyright US Navy/Reuters
Image caption The report says the Cheeki Rafiki capsized "following a detachment of its keel"

The Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) said the cause remained "a matter of some speculation" in the absence of survivors and material evidence.

"However, it is concluded that Cheeki Rafiki capsized and inverted following a detachment of its keel," says the report.

"In the absence of any apparent damage to the hull or rudder other than that directly associated with keel detachment, it is unlikely that the vessel had struck a submerged object.

"Instead, a combined effect of previous groundings and subsequent repairs to its keel and matrix (or lining) had possibly weakened the vessel's structure where the keel was attached to the hull."

It said one or more keel bolts may have deteriorated and it was "probable that the crew were fatigued and their performance was impaired accordingly".

Since the disaster the yacht's operator, Stormforce Coaching Ltd, said it had made changes to its internal policies and taken a number of actions aimed at preventing a recurrence.

A Stormforce spokesman added: "We have worked fully with the MAIB on its thorough investigation into the loss of Cheeki Rafiki and her four crew Andy, James, Paul and Steve.

"Our thoughts continue to be with the families following this tragic accident."

The Maritime and Coastguard Agency has been working with the Royal Yachting Association to clarify the requirements for the stowage of inflatable life rafts on such vessels."

'Avoidable circumstances'

Kay Coombes, the sister of sailor Steve Warren, said: "We hope the safety recommendations are implemented by the sailing industry to help prevent a similar tragedy in the future.

"We now await the findings of the Maritime Coastal Agency investigation, which we hope will provide further clarity regarding the incident.

"This is a very difficult time for all the families involved, especially as we approach the first anniversary of the incident."

In a statement, Paul Goslin's wife, Cressida, said she also hoped the safety recommendations would be adopted.

She added: "However, implementing safety recommendations should not detract from the fact that four much-loved men have lost their lives in avoidable circumstances.

"Anyone reading the report on the MAIB website will be able to draw their own conclusions as to the causes of the accident but it is important to remember that the remit of the MAIB is specifically not to apportion blame.

"I am now awaiting the findings of the MCA investigation which is due soon and has a much wider scope. This will determine if they intend to bring any legal action against the parties involved."

David Bridge, whose son Andrew was skippering the yacht, said today's "no fault" report showed its loss "could have been avoided".

Like the other two bereaved relatives, he also hoped the recommendations in the report would be put into place.

Mr Bridge added: "It's factual and they've put down everything that they've found out."

Darren Williams, spokesman for another of the crew's relatives, said Graham Male, who lost his son when the yacht capsized, would not be giving interviews today.

More on this story