York & North Yorkshire

Katie Rough death: Girl pleads guilty to manslaughter

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionKatie Rough's parents described seeing their dying daughter after the attack

A 16-year-old girl has pleaded guilty to killing seven-year-old Katie Rough.

The girl, who cannot be named for legal reasons, pleaded guilty to manslaughter by diminished responsibility.

Katie was smothered and slashed with a Stanley knife by the teenager on a playing field in Woodthorpe, York, on 9 January. She died later in hospital.

Leeds Crown Court heard the killer suffered with severe mental health issues and was convinced people "weren't human and were robots".

Katie's family were in court to hear the guilty plea.

Killed girl's parents relive body find

More stories from across Yorkshire

Nicholas Johnson QC, defending, asked the court if the charge of murder could be put to the girl again and she wrote her plea on a piece of paper.

Her solicitor told the court: "I can confirm she has indicated not guilty to murder but guilty to manslaughter."

Graham Reeds QC, prosecuting, said: "We are going to accept that plea of manslaughter by diminished responsibility."

Image copyright Getty Images
Image caption Katie Rough died in hospital after suffering serious injuries to her neck and chest
Image copyright Google
Image caption Katie was found on a playing field near Alness Drive, in Woodthorpe, York, on 9 January

Mr Reeds said the the defendant had developed severe mental health problems during 2016 and had been taken out of school as a result.

He said that she had been self harming since Christmas 2015 and suffering from delusions, believing that people around her "may not be human and may be controlled by a higher and hostile force".

He said that although psychosis was being investigated prior to the killing, it had not been diagnosed.

However, he said since the killing she had undergone four psychiatric and psychological assessments and there was no dispute that her mental health problems meant she was suffering from diminished responsibility at the time she killed Katie, even though the killing was planned.

He told the court that when the teenager was found in the street in York by a member of the public, she told him Katie was dead and asked where she was.

The man then found Katie lying on a nearby piece of land with a cut to her neck.

A post-mortem examination showed Katie had two severe cuts to her body - one to her neck and the other to her torso - but neither caused her death.

The prosecutor said Katie had been smothered before the cuts were made.

'Nice but weird'

The court heard the teenager handed police a blood-stained Stanley knife which she had taken from her grandmother's kitchen.

Police also recovered a number of items from the scene and the teenager's home.

Among the items were drawings of stick-men in various poses depicting killing and death, and a reference to "they are not human".

The paper was blood-stained and the court heard it had been cut with the same knife used to slash Katie.

Mr Reeds said she had displayed "strange behaviour towards other people and herself", and had started to self-harm before she killed Katie.

A friend interviewed by police following Katie's death told them she was "nice but weird" and said she liked to talk about death.

The judge, Mr Justice Soole, said he wanted more questions answering by the medical experts before he could pass sentence. He adjourned the case to 20 July.

Image caption Katie was described as a "daddy's girl"

Katie was a pupil at Westfield Primary School in the Acomb area of York.

In the days after Katie's death Tracey Ralph, head teacher at the school, described her as a "kind and thoughtful child who was well-liked by both pupils and staff".

More than 300 people attend Katie's funeral service, which took place at York Minister in February and was led by the Archbishop of York, Dr John Sentamu.

Her coffin was decorated with characters from the Dr Seuss children's books.

Image copyright PA
Image caption More than 300 people attended Katie's funeral
Image copyright PA
Image caption Her funeral service was held at York Minster

During the service Katie's uncle described her as a "smart, fun, beautiful child".

He said she had selective mutism, but that it did not stop her from having fun.

"Her family were her world," he said.

"She loved her mum and dad but she was definitely described as a daddy's girl."


Katie Rough killing timeline:

  • 9 January - A seven-year-old girl is found seriously injured near a playing field in the Woodthorpe area of York. She was taken to hospital but died a short time later
  • 10 January - Police name Katie Rough as the dead girl and appeal for witnesses who may have seen two girls, aged 15 and 7
  • 11 January - A 15-year-old girl appears at York Magistrates' Court charged with murder and possession of an offensive weapon, namely a knife
  • 11 January - The prime minister and leader of the opposition both pay tribute to Katie in the House of Commons
  • 13 January - The 15-year-old charged with Katie's murder appears at Leeds Crown Court via video-link and denies the charges against her
  • 16 January - Balloons released in Katie's memory at her school, Westfield Primary School, on what would have been her 8th birthday
  • 30 January - Inquest opened and adjourned
  • 13 February - Public funeral in York Minster for Katie led by the Archbishop of York
  • 16 February - Second appearance at Leeds Crown Court by teenage girl who formally denies both charges through her solicitor
  • 3 July - Girl, now aged 16, admits manslaughter due to diminished responsibility on the first day of her trial for murder

Related Topics

More on this story

Related Internet links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites