Keanu Williams: Can Birmingham's children ever be safe?

Keanu Williams

Related Stories

The serious case review into the death of Keanu Williams is the 23rd to be published in Birmingham since the Local Safeguarding Board's inception in 2006. But given the second city's size, demographic and financial pressures, does the council have an impossible task protecting children?

Not impossible, but "very difficult" according to professor Wyn Grant, a local government expert at the University of Warwick.

"The council faces a very challenging situation at a time when resources have become more and more constrained," he said.

"I think people don't appreciate how difficult it is.

"Councils are always under pressure from two sides. On one hand they are accused of not intervening enough and, on the other, they are accused by families of intervening too much. It's a difficult balance to strike."

'No magic wand'

With a population of 1.1m to deal with, Birmingham City Council is the largest local authority in Europe. More than a third of the city's residents are of minority ethnic origin, according to Visit Birmingham.

The council has made more than 5,000 people redundant in recent years in a bid to balance its books and owes more than £1bn to workers through equal pay claims.

In 2010, Birmingham was ranked 13th in a government list of the most deprived parts of the country, behind authorities including Hackney and Tower Hamlets, both in London.


Inner city Birmingham regularly comes top of the bad league tables and bottom of the good ones. It has the highest rate of unemployment and the worst rates for deprivation and poverty in the country.

It means that its social workers are extremely busy and regularly have to deal with incredibly tough cases. Its children's services department was first handed an improvement notice by government inspectors in 2009, and there's little chance it'll come out of special measures in the next 12 months.

The city might just be too big for a single department to cope with. It has a population of 1.1 million, of whom around a quarter are children, and is more than twice as big as the next largest local authority. Ofsted's most recent report said the department was inadequate.

Absence and sickness levels are high and it's hard to recruit the best social workers. Even if they live in the city they probably covet jobs in less challenging circumstances nearby.

Regular criticisms featured in previous serious case reviews concern a lack of communication between different agencies and missed opportunities.

But Mr Grant said Birmingham had a harder task than many other authorities because of its diverse population and the resulting problems regarding language barriers and the importance of staying sensitive to tensions in communities.

He added: "It's characteristic of bureaucracy that people tend to operate in their own silos.

"Whether it's police, social services, schools, they do not work well across boundaries. Even if liaison officers are appointed, it's very difficult because groups have different priorities."

He also said there was "no magic wand" and people had to be realistic about what could be achieved.

But Labour MP for Perry Barr Khalid Mahmood has a less sympathetic view.

He pointed to "systemic failures" in the management structure of the council's children's department, which has had four different strategic directors - Tony Howell, Eleanor Brazil, Peter Duxbury and Peter Hay - since 2005 and been in special measures since 2011.

He also said it was not true the council did not have adequate resources to improve children's services, pointing out it had received more than £40m funding from government to turn around the service after the case of Khyra Ishaq.

Khyra, seven, died in 2008 after being starved at her home in the Handsworth area of the city.

Birmingham skyline In 2010, Birmingham was ranked 13th in a government list of the most deprived parts of the country

"It's true that it's a big authority but that does not mean it can absolve itself of responsibility," said Mr Mahmood.

"The issue is the council has continually failed to listen to the recommendations. It has failed to tackle issues like sickness. I have had workers come to me complaining about workload issues and feeling they have no choice but to go off sick.

"There is no integration, no communication, no responsibility."

Mr Mahmood and Mr Grant agreed breaking up Birmingham City Council into a number of smaller authorities, like in London, would not resolve the issue.

"It's a huge size but you still need to have central policy," said Mr Mahmood.

"I don't think it would work."

'Hard call'

Bob Badham, who resigned as children's services boss at neighbouring Sandwell Council after Ofsted rated the department inadequate, said nothing could be done to guarantee children's safety.

"It's the duty of every local authority to make sure we make children's lives as safe as possible but I don't think you will ever get a 100% success rate," he said.

"The people who commit these crimes are good at covering their tracks.

"There are always going to be cases that slip through the net."

He added: "Social workers can be hesitant to report things because they are worried about the consequences. React too quickly and they can find themselves in the papers for taking a child away too quickly. It's a very hard call.

"It's a difficult area to manage and come up with plans to make things safer for children but you have to try."

Birmingham City Council declined to comment ahead of the publication of Thursday's serious case review.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country



Min. Night 5 °C

BBC Local Live


    BBC Local Live will be back from 08:00 on Sunday with the latest news, sport, travel and weather updates for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    Turning chilly 17:50:

    It's a dry end to the day with bright or sunny spells.

    Tonight it will turn chilly under clear spells, leading to a patchy frost. However, it will become cloudier during the early hours, with increasing north-easterly winds. Lows of 2C (36F).

    'Overexuberant fans' 17:40:

    Linda texted BBC WM's Danny Kelly in response to the pitch invasion at Molineux yesterday.

    She says: "Whilst I don't agree with mass pitch invasion. Come on. Yesterday at the wolves match. It was exceptional. Who expected the scores to be as they were - 1- 1 score this pitch invasion wouldn't of happened.

    "I support all west Midlands teams. So lets celebrate the achievement of Wolves not the issue of over exuberant fans."

    Charity heroes concert 17:31:

    Musicians and comedians are staging a charity concert in Birmingham to raise thousands of pounds for injured servicemen and women tomorrow night.

    Singers at The Glee Club in Birmingham

    The proceeds from Stand up for the Heroes will go to Fisher House, the purpose-built home for relatives of soldiers being treated at Queen Elizabeth Hospital.

    You can see Ben Godfrey's report on Midlands Today at 18:50 on BBC One.

    Photos: National Record Store Day 17:27: BBC WM

    It's National Record Store Day today and more indie shops were opened last year in the West Midlands than in any other area of the country.

    National Record Store Day

    Reporter Louise Brierley was out and about across Birmingham and the Black Country speaking to a number of people in stores. You can see photos on the BBC WM Facebook page.

    'Disappointment for fans' 17:22:

    The Express and Star's Wolves correspondent says another pitch invasion at Wolves in the final home game next month could lead to disappointment for the fans

    Tim Nash says: "When Wolves went up from the Championship to the Premier League in 2009, they won promotion against QPR at home and there was a pitch invasion. The fans were warned if there was a repeat of that when they played against Doncaster and presented with the title and trophy the players would not come out and trophy would not be presented.

    "It would be terrible if the actions of a small minority were to prevent the trophy being presented at the last home game against Carlisle (3 May). Nobody wants that to happen."

    St George's Day 17:17: Birmingham Mail

    It's St George's Day on Wednesday and a number of celebratory events are taking place, including at the Library of Birmingham. Read more online.

    Pub fight man 'critical' 17:04:

    A 27-year-old man is in a "life-threatening" condition in hospital following a fight at a pub in Streetly on Friday evening.

    The Deer's Leap pub

    Two men were arrested at the scene, and both remain in police custody.

    Full-time scores 16:55:
    'Spoil it for everyone' 16:45: via Facebook

    We've been asking for your thoughts on the pitch invasion during Wolves v Rotherham yesterday.

    Pauline Corbett posts on Facebook: "Don't know why they did it, they spoil it for everyone, game not even finished."

    Birmingham City Ladies 0-0 Tyresö 16:27:

    Birmingham City Ladies draw 0-0 with Swedish side Tyresö in the first leg of the European Champions League semi-final. The second leg takes place next weekend.

    Student loan spent on vinyl 16:07: Louise Brierley BBC WM Reporter

    This morning I spoke to Gareth King about his vinyl habit. He admitted spending his student loan at The Diskery as we celebrate Record Store Day across the UK.

    Gareth King buying vinyl at The Diskery celebrating Record Store Day

    You can find out more by following @RDSUK on Twitter.

    Half-time scores 15:49:
    Trains delayed 15:44:

    Trains between Wolverhampton and Birmingham New Street are delayed due to signalling problems, Virgin Trains tweets.

    Services are being diverted via Bescot Stadium.

    Feedback 15:32:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    John Lewis celebrates 150 years 15:18:

    The John Lewis partnership is celebrating 150 years since it opened its first store in central London. BBC News look at how the retailer has changed over the years.

    John Lewis, Birmingham

    The retailer's expansion looks set to continue as next year John Lewis plans to open its biggest department store outside London, at Birmingham New Street Station.

    Three in court over fluid attack 14:59:

    A man has appeared in court charged with an attack in which a woman was doused in caustic fluid, leaving her with "life changing" internal injuries, reports BBC News Online.

    Matthew Wood, 27, is accused of causing grievous bodily harm to 19-year-old Aleena Rafiq, when she answered her door in Tividale, near Dudley.

    Mr Wood's partner, Lisa Wood, 25, and mother Debbie Wood, 46, are charged with perverting the course of justice.

    Aston Villa v Southampton 14:44:

    After a troubled week behind the scenes at Villa Park, manager Paul Lambert will be relieved to concentrate on playing matters this afternoon.

    Press box at Villa Park

    Southampton are the visitors as Villa attempt to reverse a slump that has seen them lose their past four matches.

    Lambert says three points are a must to lift the gloom surrounding the club at the moment. Listen to coverage on BBC WM 95.6 FM.

    Police: In numbers 14:32:

    West Midlands Police has released its week in numbers, which includes:

    • Two years since capture technology was introduced in Dudley, as officers fit spy cameras to lawnmowers and sheds
    • 12 months after a Walsall takeaway driver was killed, detectives renew their appeal for information
    Ready for kick-off 14:04: Rob Gurney BBC WM Sport

    Birmingham City Ladies and their opponents Tyreso get ready to kick off.

    Birmingham City Ladies and their opponents Tyreso get ready to kick off

    I'll be bringing you updates on BBC WM 95.6FM throughout the afternoon.

    Drink-drive crash injures officers 13:47:

    A suspected drink-driver has been arrested after a car ploughed into a police patrol vehicle, injuring two officers.

    Damaged police car

    The man, aged 44, was taken into custody at about 02:40 after a Volkswagen Golf mounted the pavement and then struck the officers' car in Dudley.

    The two police officers who were in the car were taken to hospital, where one remains.

    Nottm Forest v Birmingham 13:27: BBC WM

    Birmingham City need at least one more win to be safe in the Championship - and their excellent away form will need to continue if they're to get it at Nottingham Forest this afternoon.

    Lee Novak misses out through injury, while one or two other Blues players face fitness tests to see if they make it.

    There will be commentary on BBC WM 95.6FM from 15:00.

    Weather snapshot 13:09: Charlie Slater Weather presenter

    Some blue sky and sunshine is about in the West Midlands with cloud thrown in. There's some uncertainty around tomorrow but it's looking mainly dry.

    Weather forecast for Saturday afternoon
    Biggest game in their history 12:49: Rob Gurney BBC WM Sport

    Birmingham City Ladies are preparing for the biggest game in their history as they take on Tyreso in the Champions League semi-final at Solihull Moors.

    The likes of Remi Allen, Kirsty Linnett and Jo Potter are expected to return to the starting line up for the first leg after being on the bench for the midweek league game with Everton.

    It's a 14:00 kick-off and there'll be regular updates here on BBC WM 95.6FM.

    'No gender-based segregation' 12:30:

    Tristram Hunt, Labour's shadow education secretary, has warned against religious extremism in schools, reports BBC Education & Family.

    In a speech to the NASUWT teachers' union, Mr Hunt said schools should not have "gender-based segregation" and that teachers must not be "undermined".

    Queues for vinyl 12:11: Louise Brierley BBC WM Reporter

    Today is National Record Store Day and I've been reporting live from across Birmingham and the Black Country visiting shops across the area this morning.

    Queues outside Vinyl and Vintage in Wolverhampton

    People queued outside Vinyl & Vintage in Wolverhampton from 05:30. If you missed the programme, you can listen again.

    Early Kick-off 12:01: Jenny Wilkes Presenter, BBC WM

    I'm sitting in for Daz Hale on Early Kick-off today looking ahead to today's big matches including: Aston Villa v Southampton and Nottingham Forest v Birmingham City, plus Birmingham City Ladies v Swedish side Tyreso in the Uefa Women's Champions League semi-final first leg.

    And I want your earliest memories of going to a football match, who did you see? Listen live.

    12C for Villa match 11:51:

    BBC Weather tweets: Perfect conditions for some of the Premiership matches, take a look. Louise L

    'Rap across the knuckles' 11:33:

    Wolves correspondent for the Express and Star Tim Nash tells BBC WM the club can expect a "rap across the knuckles and a fine" after a number of supporters invaded the pitch yesterday.

    He says: "Those who went on the pitch aren't regulars. The Wolves gate average this season has been 20,000 and there were 30,000 there yesterday and that was the first time in 33 years they've seen that."

    Warning against school extremism 11:15:

    Labour's Tristram Hunt is to issue a tough warning against religious extremism in schools. Read the full story on BBC News.

    Tristram Hunt

    In a speech to the NASUWT teachers' union, Mr Hunt will welcome Birmingham council's investigation into the "so-called Trojan Horse conspiracy".

    The Department for Education is also examining claims of schools being "taken over" by Muslim hardliners.

    Charges after cleaning fluid attack 10:55:

    Three people have been charged after a teenager was seriously burnt when what is thought to be a high-strength cleaning fluid was thrown at her when she answered her front door in Tividale, police say.

    Matthew Wood, 27, from Alexander Road in Smethwick, is charged with causing grievous bodily harm with intent and is due to to appear at Wolverhampton Magistrates' Court today.

    Debbie Wood and Lisa Wood, of the same address, have been charged with committing an act to pervert the course of public justice.

    Have your say 10:37:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you news, sport, travel and weather updates in one place. We'd like to know what you think.

    Wolves condemn pitch invasion 10:17:

    Wolves have released a statement on their website "condemning" supporters who invaded the pitch during the closing minutes of yesterday's match against Rotherham United.

    Pitch invasion at Wolves v Rotherham 2014

    The club say: "The minority of supporters have marred a classic game, played in a competitive spirit, and prevented the Wolves players from celebrating with the majority of home supporters in the stadium.

    "The reality is that the referee was, understandably, close to abandoning the fixture, which would have nullified a tremendous victory. The club now awaits an inevitable follow-up from the Football Association."

    Carlisle 1-1 Walsall 09:58:

    A goal from second half substitute Michael Ngoo secured a point for Walsall as they drew 1-1 at Carlisle.

    The home side went ahead as early as the 13th minute, but the Saddlers stuck to their task and were rewarded with an equaliser.

    Eight tribes of vinyl 09:39:

    BBC Magazine takes a look at who is still buying vinyl, from the young enthusiast to a legendary DJ.

    Keb Darge listening to some of his collection of 50s and 60s 7 inch singles
    Wolves 6-4 Rotherham 09:18:

    Wolves scored two last-gasp goals to beat Rotherham 6-4 in an incredible game and close in on the League One title.

    Wolves striker Nouha Dicko

    Wolves looked to be coasting as Nouha Dicko's (pictured) close-range double and a Dave Edwards strike saw them respond to Kieran Agard's early headed opener.

    On air 09:00: Danny Kelly Presenter, BBC WM

    I'll be celebrating National Record Store Day - taking a whistle-stop tour of independent music shops across Birmingham to find out how they're celebrating the occasion.


    And this morning we're asking for your thoughts on the Wolves pitch invasion and what the penalties should be, after fans interrupted the game in the closing minutes. Listen live.

    Schools 'must have local oversight' 08:49:

    The shadow education secretary Tristram Hunt will criticise the government today over allegations that some Muslims are trying to impose their religious views on schools in Birmingham.

    In a speech to teachers in the city, he will say there must be local oversight of schools, including academies.

    The teachers' union NASUWT is meeting in Birmingham for its annual conference this weekend.

    Your bank holiday weekend 08:28: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    What are you up to this bank holiday weekend? If you've taken a photo of you local area share it with us and we'll feature our favourite ones on BBC Local Live.


    I took this photo as I headed into work this morning. If you were up you may have seen the stunning sunrise. Email, tweet or upload your pictures on Facebook.

    Plenty of brightness 08:11: Charlie Slater Weather presenter

    There may be a light frost in rural areas this morning ahead of another dry and bright day with some blue sky and sunshine thrown in with some cloud.

    More cloud will bubble up this afternoon, but there will still be plenty of brightness to be had. Highs of 14C (57F).

    Good morning 08:00: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    I'm in the BBC WM newsroom this weekend bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather updates for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    If you'd like to comment on any of the updates we're featuring today please do get in touch via email, Twitter or Facebook.



Elsewhere on the BBC

  • ITChild's play

    It's never been easier for small businesses to get their message out to the world


  • Tuna and avacadoThe Travel Show Watch

    Is Tokyo set to become the world's gourmet capital?

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.