Keanu Williams: Changing heads of Birmingham's children's service

As a serious case review is published into the death of two-year-old Keanu Williams, who was beaten to death by his mother Rebecca Shuttleworth, BBC News looks at the recent bosses of Birmingham City Council's troubled children's department.

The authority has had four strategic directors of Children, Young People and Families since 2009.

Tony Howell (April 2006 - Jan 2011)

Tony Howell

Tony Howell started as strategic director for children, young people and families in April 2006. He announced his retirement in July 2009 but stayed in post until January 2011.

During his reign there were 14 serious case reviews. Khyra Ishaq - the seven year old who was starved to death by her mother and her boyfriend in Handsworth - came to the attention of social services in March 2006 and died in 2008.

Ofsted concludes the department is "failing to protect vulnerable children" in July 2010 and brands it inadequate.

Eleanor Brazil (Jan 2011 - April 2012)

Eleanor Brazil

Appointed interim strategic director on a 12 month contract in 2011. The contract had an option to extend to 18 months - which it was. She was reportedly paid £1,000 a day.

Keanu Williams was murdered by his mother Rebecca Shuttleworth during her tenure, in January 2011.

Colin Tucker, Birmingham City Council's director of children's social care, was suspended in January and left his post by "mutual agreement" in April 2011.

A senior council source said Mr Tucker's department had not improved quickly enough.

No serious case reviews were published in 2011/2012.

Peter Duxbury (April 2012 - July 2013)

Peter Duxbury

Started in April 2012 but left after just 15 months. A council spokesman said this was by "mutual agreement" after taking "unplanned emergency leave to deal with private family matters".

They added: "The council is continuing with the improvement strategy for its services for children, young people and families and has asked Peter Hay CBE, strategic director for adults and communities, to take over responsibilities in the interim."

Before he left Mr Duxbury, a former social worker, said there was "little likelihood of special measures being lifted before 2015."

No serious case reviews were commissioned during his tenure.

Peter Hay (July 2013 - current)

Peter Hay

Appointed to manage the department "in the interim". One serious case review has been commissioned so far.

Birmingham City Council leader Sir Albert Bore said in September the most urgent issue facing the council was the need to establish permanent management arrangements for children's services. He said they needed someone who could "win the loyalty and respect from staff and give confidence to the political leadership."

"We believe we have in Peter Hay, who has been asked to manage the service in the interim, such a person," he said.

He added: "It is clear that with Peter Hay we do have an officer who has all the requisite qualities to lead the service and provide assurance. In fact the last time Children's Social Care showed signs of externally accredited improvement was when he managed it."

Perry Barr MP Khalid Mahmod said the department would not improve until there was some continuity with the person in charge.

"There are never any results because people are always in limbo," he said.

"Every time a new person takes charge, the department is changed to suit them.

"None of the leaders ever look at the systemic failures. They come in, give out press releases, then in the end they are booted out because they have not delivered what they should have."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country

Weather

Birmingham

Min. Night 9 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Queen's Awards 16:46: Birmingham Post

    Companies and individuals in the West Midlands have been handed 11 prestigious Queen's Awards - handed out for business excellence.

     
  2.  
    Wolves success 16:30:

    Wolves goalkeeper Carl Ikeme says it's a "massive relief" that they've effectively clinched the League One title by winning 3-1 at Leyton Orient.

    Carl Ikeme

    Wolves have scored 85 league goals this season, but Ikeme also praised the defence today.

    He said: "We've been winning twos and threes and everyone talks about the firepower but we've broken the club record for clean sheets."

     
  3.  
    Warwickshire cricket 16:18: Mike Taylor BBC WM Sport

    At tea Warwickshire are 222-3, replying to Lancashire's 247. A patient partnership between Ian Bell and Ateeq Javid realised 61 runs before tea and steadied Warwickshire after an awkward period.

    Bell allowed himself the indulgence of a six over long-on off Simon Kerrigan, and some high-quality cover-driving, but the emphasis was mainly on defence.

    Javid accumulated steadily to reach 25 by tea. The new ball is only three overs old, and if Lancashire can't break through with it, Warwickshire could be well ahead by the close.

     
  4.  
    Half time scores 16:02:

    Birmingham City were booed as they walked off 4-0 down at half time.

    Rudy Gestede has scored a hat-trick for Blackburn. Blues, who are without a home win since the start of October, kicked off only one point above the Championship relegation zone.

    BBC WM's Mark Regan says it's "an absolute mess" and it "could have been six or seven".

    Walsall's League One game with Gillingham was goalless at half time.

     
  5.  
    'Intense thunderstorms' 15:55:

    BBC Weather tweets: On the move later in Mids/S.Eng/S.Wales? You may encounter some intense thunderstorms. Charts show areas at risk. MT

    BBC Weather graphic
     
  6.  
    Traffic congestion in King's Heath 15:45:

    BBC Travel News warns there's traffic congestion on the A435 High Street in the King's Heath junction.

     
  7.  
    Fire safety 15:34:

    The team which delivers the safety message for Staffordshire Fire and Rescue is being expanded.

    It gives advice to homes and businesses and feeds back concerns and ideas to the service.

    Dean Stephens, director of the prevent and protect programme, says it now needs new volunteers who'll be given full training.

     
  8.  
    Wolves reaction 15:13:

    Wolves boss Kenny Jackett (below) has hailed the "great" 3-1 win at Leyton Orient which has effectively sealed the League One title.

    Wolves boss Kenny Jackett

    He said: "To beat Rotherham and Leyton Orient over this weekend, when there was a lot of pressure on us, we did very well."

    Jackett said consistency in the second half of the season has been "key" and he felt goalkeeper Carl Ikeme was today's man of the match as he "proved what he is - a top-class goalkeeper".

     
  9.  
    Officers have lucky escape 14:54: Birmingham Mail

    Two police officers had a lucky escape after an out-of-control car ploughed into their vehicle.

     
  10.  
    Midlands history 14:38:

    As part of a BBC Radio 3 series marking the 450th anniversary of Shakespeare's birth, five essayists are shedding light on the history and culture of the Midlands.

    Birmingham Bullring shopping centre

    In the first essay, novelist and journalist Geoff Dyer tries to work out what is the true home of the Midlander.

    He wrote that Birmingham itself was represented by "precisely two things" - the Bull Ring shopping centre (above) and Spaghetti Junction.

     
  11.  
    Wolves triumph 14:13:

    Wolves have effectively sealed the League One title by winning 3-1 at Leyton Orient.

    Richard Stearman scored in the 17th minute, Bakary Sako added Wolves' second on 32 minutes and James Henry found the target on the stroke of full time.

    Brentford in second place can also reach 99 points, but Wolves' goal difference is 25 goals better than Brentford's.

     
  12.  
    Warwickshire cricket 13:47: Mike Taylor BBC WM Sport

    At lunch on day two Warwickshire were 144-2, replying to Lancashire's 247.

    Warwickshire remain in the stronger position but Lancashire deserved their two wickets in the second hour.

    William Porterfield did not convert his excellent start into a long-awaited first Championship hundred for Warwickshire, chipping Kerrigan to mid-on for 77, though he left looking disappointed, his overall form was heartening.

    Varun Chopra was cautious but largely sound until walking across his stumps in Glen Chapple's last over before lunch to be lbw for 52.

     
  13.  
    Football gossip 13:36:

    BBC Sport's gossip column reports that Aston Villa manager Paul Lambert has shrugged off talk of a multi-million-pound takeover at the club and intends to discuss his and the club's future with owner Randy Lerner at the end of the season.

    You can read the full story in the Birmingham Mail.

     
  14.  
    Language of the Black Country 13:22: Halesowen News
  15.  
    Coming up 13:01: Midlands Today

    Join Joanne Malin at 13:16 when we'll have more about a demo against proposed houses in Warwickshire and the latest weather.

     
  16.  
    Trojan Horse investigation 12:51:

    Khalid Mahmood, the Labour MP for Birmingham Perry Barr, says there is definitely a plot to take over some state schools in Birmingham by a small group of Muslim individuals, reports BBC WM.

    Khalid Mahmood

    Ofsted chief Sir Michael Wilshaw is expected to visit Birmingham this week to finalise reports from inspections into 18 schools in the city.

     
  17.  
    Saddlers at home 12:32:

    Walsall will be seeking a return to winning ways when they entertain Gillingham later.

    Dean Smith

    They drew 2-2 at Gillingham in December and Saddlers manager Dean Smith said: "I'm still probably a little bit aggrieved that we didn't come away from their place with three points after a goal in the last minute from a blatant push on Adam Chambers."

     
  18.  
    Teachers vote for June strike 12:17:

    The National Union of Teachers' conference has voted for a strike that could close schools in England and Wales in the week beginning 23 June.

    Voting at NUT

    The union's conference in Brighton has also decided to consult teachers on further action in the autumn term.

    The strikes are part of a long-running campaign over teachers' pay and workload.

     
  19.  
    Campaign to save Dudley theatre 12:06: BBC WM

    Campaigners fighting to save the old Hippodrome theatre in Dudley say they're delighted that an entertainment company is thinking of taking it on.

    The company called Events That Rok was co-founded by businessman Jonathan Kendrick, whose father Vic owned the Castle Hill theatre in the 1960s when it was being revamped as a casino club.

     
  20.  
    Captain out 11:46:

    Birmingham City captain Paul Robinson (below) starts a three-match ban as Blues face the first of three crucial home matches against Blackburn Rovers this afternoon. They're just one point clear of the Championship relegation zone

    Paul Robinson

    Manager Lee Clark said: "[Robinson's] been inspirational for us. He's a leader both on and off the pitch. He leads by example, but I've got some senior pros that have to take that mantle on now."

    There'll be commentary on BBC WM 95.6.

     
  21.  
    Parents failing to pay fines 11:28: Birmingham Mail

    Almost two-thirds of Birmingham parents fined for taking their children out of school without permission have failed to pay up, government figures show.

     
  22.  
    Skin cancer 11:14:

    Cases of the most serious form of skin cancer have doubled in the West Midlands in the last 20 years.

    New figures from Cancer Research UK show 930 people are now developing malignant melanoma in the region every year.

     
  23.  
    Live cricket 10:59:

    Warwickshire will resume their first innings on 63-0, replying to Lancashire's 247, on the second day of the County Championship match at Old Trafford.

    Old Trafford

    Here is the view from the commentary box window from BBC WM's Mike Taylor. You can listen live online from 11:00.

     
  24.  
    Wolves in capital 10:47:

    For the second time in four days, Wolves face a team looking for promotion via the League One play-offs as they visit Leyton Orient.

    Wolves striker Nouha Dicko

    The game, which kicks off at 12:15, is one of three commentary matches on BBC WM today.

    Wolves go into the game on the back of Good Friday's thrilling 6-4 victory at home to Rotherham, when Nouha Dicko (above) scored a hat-trick.

     
  25.  
    Warwickshire cricket 10:31: Mike Taylor BBC WM Sport

    Warwickshire start day two on 63-0 replying to Lancashire's 247.

    Clear skies above Old Trafford mean there will be no need for the floodlights to be on today, as they were throughout yesterday, and should offer Warwickshire ideal conditions to consolidate their hard-won advantage.

    In yesterday's severe crosswinds, the Bears seamers outlasted the Lancashire batsmen, too many of whom played loose shots to get out against disciplined bowling on an apparently good pitch.

    Chopra and Porterfield batted through the last hour to cement the Warwickshire position.

     
  26.  
    Metro running 10:20:

    The Metro tweets: Midland metro running a normal bank holiday service. Trams every 15 minutes with no delays

     
  27.  
    Manslaughter charge 10:02:

    A man has been charged with manslaughter after the death of a 27-year-old man who was injured in a fight outside a pub.

    Adam Lynn, 24, is due before Birmingham Magistrates' Court later following the disorder outside the Deer's Leap pub in Queslett Road, Streetly, on Friday.

    Jonathon Woodhall

    Mr Lynn, of Kingstanding Road, is accused of killing Jonathon Woodhall (pictured) who died in hospital on Saturday.

     
  28.  
    Woman taken to hospital after crash 09:36: Express and Star

    A woman had to be cut free from her car after crashing into a lamppost in West Bromwich.

     
  29.  
    LATEST UPDATES
     
  30.  
    Pollen count 09:15:

    Healthy Brum tweets: Today's Bank Holiday #healthybrum pollen count is moderate. Check out our #hayfever advice ow.ly/vgBq2

     
  31.  
    Your views 09:02:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  32.  
    Trojan Horse 08:45:

    Ofsted chief Sir Michael Wilshaw is to take personal charge of the watchdog's investigation into claims that a number of schools in Birmingham have been taken over by Muslim hardliners.

    Sir Michael Wilshaw

    Ofsted has carried out inspections in 18 schools in the city.

    Ofsted and the Department for Education (DfE) are expected to publish their findings in early May. The DfE has ordered its own review of the evidence in the so-called Trojan Horse conspiracy.

     
  33.  
    Adderley Street closed 08:30:

    BBC Travel News says Adderley Street in Birmingham is closed at the B4100 High Street Bordesley junction because of an event at The Rainbow.

     
  34.  
    Weather 08:11:

    A dry morning with mist and fog patches soon clearing. Scattered showers developing by the afternoon, some heavy and thundery, especially over the higher ground. Feeling warm in the sunshine. Max temp 18C (64F).

     
  35.  
    08:00: Andrew Dawkins BBC News

    I'll be bringing you the very latest news, sport, travel and weather updates for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    If you'd like to comment on any of the updates we're featuring today please do get in touch via email, Twitter or Facebook.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • ITChild's play

    It's never been easier for small businesses to get their message out to the world

Programmes

  • A person using a Mogees to turn a stone into a musical instrumentClick Watch

    How to turn objects into musical instruments with a device you link to your smartphone

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.