Christina Edkins killing: Phillip Simelane detained

A passenger describes how she tried to help Christina, giving her CPR

Related Stories

A man who killed 16-year-old Christina Edkins on a rush-hour bus in Birmingham has been detained indefinitely under the Mental Health Act.

Phillip Simelane, from Walsall, stabbed the teenager in a random attack as she made her way to school in March.

He had been released from prison, unsupervised, three months before the attack - despite warning signs over the state of his mental health.

The 23-year-old admitted manslaughter in a hearing at Birmingham Crown Court.

Mrs Justice Thirlwell, sentencing Simelane, said it was "likely to be a life-long order".

The judge added: "It is made for the nature of the offence and necessary to protect the public from serious harm."

She also expressed concern that Simelane had not been receiving treatment at the time of the killing.

Phillip Simelane under arrest Simelane was arrested a short distance from where the stabbing took place following a police search

Christina had been travelling to Leasowes High School in Halesowen on the number 9 bus, two weeks after her 16th birthday, when she was attacked.

Start Quote

The authorities didn't help him... just abandoned him”

End Quote Chris Melia Christina's great uncle

Simelane, who was sitting behind her on the upper deck, stabbed her in the chest as he walked past to get off.

He was arrested a few hours after the attack following an extensive manhunt.

Simelane had previously been in prison for threatening his own mother with a knife. West Midlands Police said they had been called to his mother's address in Walsall about 20 times.

Seven days after completing a 101-day prison term for the threats, he was convicted for interfering with a vehicle and possessing cocaine. He was released from jail on 13 December.

But, according to the police, because the crimes were deemed minor offences there was no policy to monitor Simelane after he left jail.

Simelane was on the bus for more than two-and-a-half hours

During his time in prison, concerns were raised about his mental health and notes were put on his police file for suicide and self-harming risk, as well as for violence and weapons use.

Birmingham and Solihull Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust provided psychiatric assessments for Simelane during his prison term.

Phillip Simelane

  • He was jailed last year for threatening his mother and had another conviction for violence
  • West Midlands Police said it had "no further contact" with Simelane between him leaving jail in December and the killing
  • Police said he was not under "any kind of care plan" after leaving prison
  • Simelane was homeless and unemployed at the time of the killing
  • He has "only recently" been diagnosed with schizophrenia, police said
  • Agencies involved in managing him before the attack are now undergoing independent reviews

It said it was conducting an external review, commissioned by Birmingham Cross City Clinical Commissioning Group, on behalf of all agencies involved in treating him.

In a statement, the trust promised a "thorough investigation", adding "we will seek to learn from and fully implement these findings across the healthcare providers involved".

Supt Richard Baker, who led the initial police investigation, said police and prison services were also carrying out reviews to determine what, if anything, could have been done to prevent Christina's death.

He said: "It was immediately apparent that Simelane suffered from mental health issues, and to this day we have not been able to interview him about what happened that day."

In court, Simelane entered his plea in front of more than 30 of Christina's friends and family, many wearing purple ribbons - Christina's favourite colour.

Killer 'abandoned'

Speaking afterwards, Christina's great uncle Chris Melia said: "We have no sense of vengeance or revenge. We just want him out of the way and [to] remember Christina.

"The authorities didn't help him, [they] just let him out of the prison door and let him go, just abandoned him.

"If there had been some help and authority he wouldn't have been on the bus."

Phillip Simelane Simelane was sitting behind Christina on the upper deck

Prosecutor Peter Grieves-Smith said CCTV captured Simelane carrying a white plastic bag containing what prosecutors said was a knife, 10in to 12in in length.

He said within seconds of Christina boarding the bus "the defendant got up and moved forwards three seats and pulled out the knife, which he then hid".

Simelane then walked towards where Christina was sitting, "leant closer to her", stabbed her and started to walk off, the court heard.

"Such was the nature of the attack, nobody else on the upper deck realised what had happened until Christina reacted," Mr Grieves-Smith said.

Friends lay flowers

Other passengers on the bus tried to treat and comfort Christina before paramedics arrived within minutes.

She was stabbed at about 07:30 and was confirmed dead about 30 minutes later.

Head teacher Neil Shaw: "Christina was a hardworking girl, really driven...bright and lively"

Following her death, friends gathered by Hagley Road in Birmingham to lay flowers in Christina's memory, while many more were left outside her school's gates.

A memorial garden dedicated to Christina is due to be opened at her former school on Thursday.

Speaking on behalf of the family, the great uncle said Christina was a "bright, beautiful girl" who was looking forward to her school prom and loved sports.

He added: "Her headmaster said, 'if a school could choose its pupils it would be full of Christinas'.

"Now the family asks the question - when this man was discharged from prison on 13 December 2012, why was the recommendation, made a few weeks earlier by mental health experts, that he be supervised after release whilst adjusting to life back in the community, not followed up?"

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country

Weather

Birmingham

12 °C 10 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    News on the hour 14:58: BBC WM

    More than 700 people have been arrested as part of a Europe-wide police operation organised from the West Midlands. We'll have the details in our 15:00 bulletin.

     
  2.  
    Dudley Council jobs 14:48: Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Councillor Stuart Turner, Dudley Council's finance chief, has vowed the authority "will be as innovative as possible to look at every option of finding the savings in order to protect key services."

    "We can also assure our staff that we will continue to work tirelessly to minimise the need for compulsory redundancies," he added.

     
  3.  
    Children 'unaware dad's dead' 14:39: Birmingham Mail

    Relatives of a Birmingham dad stabbed to death on a city street have revealed they cannot bear to tell his four young children he is dead.

     
  4.  
    'Flattered' by Blues interest 14:29: BBC Sport

    MK Dons boss Karl Robinson has said he is "flattered" by Birmingham City's interest in his services and his own club's desire to keep him.

    Karl Robinson

    Dons chairman Pete Winkelman has dismissed an approach from the Blues for the 34-year-old.

     
  5.  
    Restraint inquiry clears hospital 14:15: Halesowen News

    Russells Hall hospital has been cleared of illegally restraining patients after allegations from workers turned whistleblowers.

     
  6.  
    News on the hour 13:57: Alice Rosenthal Journalist, BBC WM

    We hear from Colin Barratt in the 14:00 bulletin. He was one of the Wolverhampton residents affected when the roof blew off a nearby garage block and hit nearby houses.

    Listen live to BBC WM.

     
  7.  
    Takeaway plans rejected 13:43: Halesowen News

    A councillor has breathed a sigh of relief after a plan to change conditions on a shop unit in Cradley's Windmill Hill was thrown out amid fears there could be three hot food outlets sited side by side along the busy road.

     
  8.  
    People Like Us 13:31: BBC WM

    The BBC website says the programme People Like Us is a "documentary series about young people growing up on a housing estate near Birmingham".

    Screenshot from the second series trailer showing a panorama of the area

    "Life on this big council estate is never dull and often a challenge for the large population of young people who live there. However, they have their own way of getting by and getting on," the website adds.

     
  9.  
    Clear-up after hurricane damage 13:22: Midlands Today

    The clear up is under way today after the tail-end of Hurricane Gonzalo swept through the region.

    Our reporter Nicola Beckford will join us from Wolverhampton where people in one street had a lucky escape when the roof blew off a garage block and careered into houses.

    Tune into BBC One at 13:30 or watch the programme afterwards here.

     
  10.  
    Arts café opens 13:06: Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    The Sandwell Arts Café, based at Central Sixth - formerly The Public gallery - in West Bromwich town centre, has been officially opened.

    Critics of the decision to convert the gallery into a sixth form centre had said it was borne out of a lack of appreciation of the arts.

    The Sandwell Arts Café

    The borough council and Sandwell College say the arts café is part of their commitment the arts will play "an essential role in the future of the building".

     
  11.  
    News on the hour 12:55: BBC WM

    A man is in a critical condition after being attacked as he walked through Wednesbury.

    For more on this story and others listen to our 13:00 bulletin.

     
  12.  
    Training for young carers 12:41:

    A project aimed at helping young carers to get better training and qualifications is being launched by Birmingham City Council.

    Birmingham City Council house

    The young carers pilot programme will begin in schools across the city and will work with about 50 young people.

    It will try to harness their experiences looking after relatives as a way to gain qualifications in health and social care.

     
  13.  
    Fish bar attacker hunted 12:30: Birmingham Mail

    Police are hunting a thug who left a peacemaker scarred for life and needing 30 stitches in a Birmingham chip shop glass attack.

     
  14.  
    Attacked man critically ill 12:19: Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    A man is critically ill in hospital after being attacked as he walked through Wednesbury.

    The 41-year-old man was found lying unconscious in Vicarage Road on Sunday. West Midlands Police is appealing for information.

     
  15.  
    Rowett approached by Blues 12:07: BBC Sport

    Birmingham City have made an approach to Burton Albion for manager Gary Rowett to succeed the sacked Lee Clark.

    Burton Albion manager Gary Rowett
     
  16.  
    News on the hour 11:57: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    Listen to what Dean Caswell, from the Central Motorway Police Group, has to say on Operation Trivium in our 12:00 bulletin.

    Police from across Europe are teaming up with West Midlands colleagues to tackle foreign criminals on the region's roads.

     
  17.  
    Supermarket jobs saved 11:44: Birmingham Post

    Jubilant unions have saved dozens of Midland supermarket jobs put at risk after Sainsbury's moved to scrap night shifts.

     
  18.  
    Call for immediate assessments 11:35: Amy Cole Presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    The Care Quality Commission is calling for people detained by police under the Mental Health Act to be taken to a safe place immediately for assessment, such as a mental health hospital.

    This year West Midlands Police has teamed up with psychiatric nurses and paramedics who are involved with people suffering mental health problems.

    The move has led to fewer people being held in police cells.

     
  19.  
    Delays on cross-city line 11:25:

    London Midland tweets: Please be aware that there are ongoing delays / cancellations on the #CrossCity line, due to earlier signalling problems at #Bournville.

     
  20.  
    Care home owner in administration 11:16: Stourbridge News

    The cash-strapped company that owns a care home in Prestwood has gone into administration.

     
  21.  
    Concern over People Like Us 11:06: BBC WM

    There's concern over a BBC TV programme - likened to Benefits Street - which is set in Chelmsley Wood.

    Character from People Like Us series 2 trailer

    People Like Us starts next week on BBC Three. Chris Williams, a councillor for the area, is worried it could be made to look bad - like James Turner Street in Winson Green.

     
  22.  
    News on the hour 10:57: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    In the 11:00 bulletin, we hear from Sylvia Ellis, the daughter of a woman living at a privately-run care home near Stourbridge.

    Residents are still waiting to be moved after the company running it went bust. Listen live to BBC WM.

     
  23.  
    Rail disruption 10:46:

    There's disruption on London Midland rail services at Bournville due to an earlier signalling problem, reports BBC Travel.

     
  24.  
    Man critically ill after attack 10:36: Express and Star

    A man is critically ill in hospital after he was found unconscious in a Wednesbury street following an attack.

     
  25.  
    Have your say 10:23: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you news, sport, travel and weather updates in one place. We'd like to find out what you think.

     
  26.  
    News on the hour 09:58: BBC WM

    In the 10:00 news bulletin: There's concern for the welfare of elderly residents who are still at a care home near Stourbridge despite the company that runs it going bust.

     
  27.  
    Hundreds of council jobs at risk 09:31: BBC WM

    About 300 jobs are at risk at Dudley Council because it needs to save £117m over the next three years.

    The authority, which has already saved £60m of that, is blaming a lack of government funding saying its budget has halved in seven years.

    It comes after Walsall Council told us it needs to save £86m by 2018 and possibly cut more than 400 jobs.

     
  28.  
    Drones warning 09:21:

    The use of drones in the UK will rise over the next 20 years, raising "significant safety, security, and privacy concerns", a report has said.

    Undated handout photo issued by Greater Manchester Police of a drone, which was flown over a packed football stadium

    The University of Birmingham Policy Commission Report raised the prospect that the aircraft could be used by terror groups to attack public events.

    However, it also acknowledged greater use could bring "significant benefits" to the UK's security and economy.

     
  29.  
    IPCC investigate fatal crash 09:11:

    An inquiry has been started by the Independent Police Complaints Commission after a man died in a collision with a police car in the Black Country yesterday.

    The incident happened at about 11:00 at the junction of Central Drive, Bridge Street and Martin Close in Coseley. The van driver died at the scene.

    Police say the officer, who was driving a marked car and not responding to an emergency, wasn't injured.

     
  30.  
    TOP HEADLINES
     
  31.  
    Mary J Blige coming to Birmingham 09:01:

    BBC Birmingham PR tweets: .@maryjblige is coming to #Birmingham! She has been added to the #1XtraLive line up on Saturday 15 November - excited?! We are!

    For details on how to get tickets visit here.

     
  32.  
    Coseley crash death 08:52:

    A van driver died in a crash involving a police car in Coseley yesterday morning.

     
  33.  
    Concerns for care home residents 08:40: Michelle Dawes Journalist, BBC WM

    I'm at this Stourbridge care home where residents in their 90s fear being moved out after the firm went bust.

    The Homestead care home near Stourbridge

    Administrators say their priority is to make sure The Homestead Care Home works efficiently and disruption is kept to a minimum while they find an alternative home.

     
  34.  
    Wolves 2-0 Middlesbrough 08:29:

    Wolves moved into the Championship play-off places with a comfortable win over Middlesbrough.

    Bakary Sako of Wolverhampton Wanderers celebrates his goal with team-mate Dave Edwards

    Kenny Jackett's side took the lead through a Bakary Sako (pictured left) penalty after Nouha Dicko had been fouled in the box. Read more on BBC Sport.

     
  35.  
    Blackburn 1-0 Birmingham 08:20: BBC Sport

    Birmingham City's first match since the departure of Lee Clark ended in a 1-0 defeat last night away at Blackburn.

    Blues almost snatched a stoppage time equaliser, but substitute Andrew Shinnie's shot struck the crossbar.

     
  36.  
    A38 delays 08:11:

    One lane is closed and there's queuing traffic on the A38 St Chad's and Queensway tunnels northbound in Birmingham city centre, at the A38 Great Charles Street Queensway junction, because of a broken down vehicle and recovery work.

    Congestion goes to Holloway Circus, says BBC Travel.

     
  37.  
    Today's forecast 08:05:

    After a mainly dry, bright and chilly start, cloud will thicken with light, patchy rain possible through the afternoon.

    Winds will be much lighter than on Tuesday and it will feel less cold with a high of 13C (55F).

     
  38.  
    Good morning 08:00: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    I'm in the BBC WM newsroom bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather updates for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    If you'd like to comment on any of the updates featuring today, please email or tweet @BBCWM.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • FutureThe future is now

    Get the latest updates and biggest ideas from BBC Future’s World-Changing Ideas Summit

Programmes

  • St John's, CanadaThe Travel Show Watch

    It’s a ships’ symphony – listen to these freighters in Canada play music with their horns

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.