Christina Edkins killing: Phillip Simelane detained

A passenger describes how she tried to help Christina, giving her CPR

Related Stories

A man who killed 16-year-old Christina Edkins on a rush-hour bus in Birmingham has been detained indefinitely under the Mental Health Act.

Phillip Simelane, from Walsall, stabbed the teenager in a random attack as she made her way to school in March.

He had been released from prison, unsupervised, three months before the attack - despite warning signs over the state of his mental health.

The 23-year-old admitted manslaughter in a hearing at Birmingham Crown Court.

Mrs Justice Thirlwell, sentencing Simelane, said it was "likely to be a life-long order".

The judge added: "It is made for the nature of the offence and necessary to protect the public from serious harm."

She also expressed concern that Simelane had not been receiving treatment at the time of the killing.

Phillip Simelane under arrest Simelane was arrested a short distance from where the stabbing took place following a police search

Christina had been travelling to Leasowes High School in Halesowen on the number 9 bus, two weeks after her 16th birthday, when she was attacked.

Start Quote

The authorities didn't help him... just abandoned him”

End Quote Chris Melia Christina's great uncle

Simelane, who was sitting behind her on the upper deck, stabbed her in the chest as he walked past to get off.

He was arrested a few hours after the attack following an extensive manhunt.

Simelane had previously been in prison for threatening his own mother with a knife. West Midlands Police said they had been called to his mother's address in Walsall about 20 times.

Seven days after completing a 101-day prison term for the threats, he was convicted for interfering with a vehicle and possessing cocaine. He was released from jail on 13 December.

But, according to the police, because the crimes were deemed minor offences there was no policy to monitor Simelane after he left jail.

Simelane was on the bus for more than two-and-a-half hours

During his time in prison, concerns were raised about his mental health and notes were put on his police file for suicide and self-harming risk, as well as for violence and weapons use.

Birmingham and Solihull Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust provided psychiatric assessments for Simelane during his prison term.

Phillip Simelane

  • He was jailed last year for threatening his mother and had another conviction for violence
  • West Midlands Police said it had "no further contact" with Simelane between him leaving jail in December and the killing
  • Police said he was not under "any kind of care plan" after leaving prison
  • Simelane was homeless and unemployed at the time of the killing
  • He has "only recently" been diagnosed with schizophrenia, police said
  • Agencies involved in managing him before the attack are now undergoing independent reviews

It said it was conducting an external review, commissioned by Birmingham Cross City Clinical Commissioning Group, on behalf of all agencies involved in treating him.

In a statement, the trust promised a "thorough investigation", adding "we will seek to learn from and fully implement these findings across the healthcare providers involved".

Supt Richard Baker, who led the initial police investigation, said police and prison services were also carrying out reviews to determine what, if anything, could have been done to prevent Christina's death.

He said: "It was immediately apparent that Simelane suffered from mental health issues, and to this day we have not been able to interview him about what happened that day."

In court, Simelane entered his plea in front of more than 30 of Christina's friends and family, many wearing purple ribbons - Christina's favourite colour.

Killer 'abandoned'

Speaking afterwards, Christina's great uncle Chris Melia said: "We have no sense of vengeance or revenge. We just want him out of the way and [to] remember Christina.

"The authorities didn't help him, [they] just let him out of the prison door and let him go, just abandoned him.

"If there had been some help and authority he wouldn't have been on the bus."

Phillip Simelane Simelane was sitting behind Christina on the upper deck

Prosecutor Peter Grieves-Smith said CCTV captured Simelane carrying a white plastic bag containing what prosecutors said was a knife, 10in to 12in in length.

He said within seconds of Christina boarding the bus "the defendant got up and moved forwards three seats and pulled out the knife, which he then hid".

Simelane then walked towards where Christina was sitting, "leant closer to her", stabbed her and started to walk off, the court heard.

"Such was the nature of the attack, nobody else on the upper deck realised what had happened until Christina reacted," Mr Grieves-Smith said.

Friends lay flowers

Other passengers on the bus tried to treat and comfort Christina before paramedics arrived within minutes.

She was stabbed at about 07:30 and was confirmed dead about 30 minutes later.

Head teacher Neil Shaw: "Christina was a hardworking girl, really driven...bright and lively"

Following her death, friends gathered by Hagley Road in Birmingham to lay flowers in Christina's memory, while many more were left outside her school's gates.

A memorial garden dedicated to Christina is due to be opened at her former school on Thursday.

Speaking on behalf of the family, the great uncle said Christina was a "bright, beautiful girl" who was looking forward to her school prom and loved sports.

He added: "Her headmaster said, 'if a school could choose its pupils it would be full of Christinas'.

"Now the family asks the question - when this man was discharged from prison on 13 December 2012, why was the recommendation, made a few weeks earlier by mental health experts, that he be supervised after release whilst adjusting to life back in the community, not followed up?"

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country



15 °C 7 °C

BBC Local Live

    Coming up 13:22: Elizabeth Glinka Presenter

    Coming up in Midlands Today at 13:30 - the leader of Birmingham City Council Sir Albert Bore condemns two national newspapers for their reporting of the alleged Trojan Horse plot by Muslim hardliners to infiltrate Birmingham schools.

    And we'll be looking ahead to the big celebrations in honour of the 450th anniversary of Shakespeare's birth in Stratford-upon-Avon.

    Join us for the latest on BBC One.

    Teenage fundraiser hits £1m target 13:12:

    Stephen Sutton has raised £1m for charity after he posted a final farewell message to followers of his blog, reports BBC News Online

    BBC Online

    The 19-year-old from Staffordshire asked people to help him raise £1m for the Teenage Cancer Trust.

    News on the hour 12:59: BBC WM

    The top story at 13:00 is:

    • A telephone hotline is being set up for anyone with concerns over the Trojan Horse allegations
    • Scotland Yard says six new incidents have come to light since a fresh appeal was issued in the Madeleine McCann case last month
    • A woman has been arrested on suspicion of murder after three children were found dead at a house in south London
    Happy St George's Day 12:51: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    Happy St George's Day! Although some celebrate 23 April each year, many are unaware and disinterested.

    Children with St George's flag painted on their faces

    What would encourage more English people to celebrate the nation's patron saint?

    Cricket: Lancashire v Warwickshire 12:39: Mike Taylor BBC WM Sport

    The weather in Manchester is kinder today than it was for most of yesterday, but Warwickshire's match here against Lancashire seems likely to be drawn unless the Bears make a flying start today.

    Warwickshire's Director of Cricket Dougie Brown was much encouraged by their bowling after the rain stopped last evening, but they couldn't take a wicket in a 22-over session against some obstinate Lancashire batting.

    Jeetan Patel found some turn and bounce, and Chris Wright seemed in a better rhythm, so there is encouragement, but there's no time to waste. Hear ball-by-call coverage

    Information to 'benefit our inquiry' 12:28:

    Chief Executive of Birmingham City Council Mark Rogers says a confidential email address will also be set up alongside a telephone hotline and postal address, for people to send information to about claims that a number of schools in the city have been taken over by Muslim hardliners.

    He tells the BBC: "If there's anyone out there who has information they think will benefit our inquiry, send it to one of those three contact points and they will be published by the city council before the end of the week."

    'I'm emotional' 12:19:

    We tweeted the news via @BBCWM that more than £1m has been raised for the Teenage Cancer Trust.

    Paul Fozard replies: @_StephensStory@bbcwm I'm very emotional at this point, can't imagine what it's like for you!

    Trojan Horse hotline set up 12:07:

    Birmingham City Council says a hotline will be set from Monday for whistleblowers to come forward with specific concerns over the Trojan Horse allegations.

    The council's announced a review group into the claims Islamic hardliners are trying to influence how schools in the city are run.

    The review group includes the Bishop of Birmingham David Urquhart and Labour MP Liam Byrne. See the full list on the council's website.

    Midday news 11:57: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    The top three stories coming up on BBC WM at midday:

    'Just wow' 11:42:

    Stephen's Story ‏tweets: The whole situation is just breathtaking in many ways!!

    Adding: But seriously... Wow. Just wow. Thank you all so much :)

    'You did it!' 11:31:

    Teenage Cancer Trust tweets: ‏BREAKING: you've done it! £1 million! We really can't thank you all enough!! #stephensstory…

    Stephen Sutton in hospital
    Breaking news Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    Great news, Stephen Sutton's Just Giving page has now received more than £1m in donations.

    Stephen Sutton's Just Giving page
    Blogger close to £1m mark 11:03: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    A teenage blogger with terminal cancer is close to raising £1m for charity after posting his final message to followers.

    Stephen Sutton

    Stephen Sutton, 19, from Burntwood, Staffordshire, was diagnosed with bowel cancer aged 15 and started raising funds for the Teenage Cancer Trust.

    As it stands at just after 11:00, his Just Giving page has raised more than £990,000.

    Trojan Horse 'review group' 10:57: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    We've just learnt who'll be on Birmingham City Council's review group for the inquiry into the Trojan Horse allegations.

    The authority is investigating claims that hardline Islamists are trying to take over some schools in the city. Hear more in the news on BBC WM with Steve Hermon shortly.

    'Record Easter visitors' 10:42:

    Heart of England tweets: Record Easter numbers for Dudley Zoological Gardens...: Visitor numbers throughout the 10-day holiday period t...

    Trojan Horse media briefing 10:30: Phil Mackie Reporter, BBC Radio 5 live

    I'm at a media briefing at Birmingham City Council. Here's the official list of 18 schools inspected by Ofsted investigating the so-called Trojan Horse letter alleging an Islamic plot to influence how schools are run.

    Official list of 18 schools inspected by Ofsted into the so-called Trojan Horse inquiry

    Council leader Sir Albert Bore says leaks to the Telegraph newspaper were "wholly reprehensible and completely unacceptable" and the Cabinet Office is investigating the source.

    Noticeable by his absence on the review group is Khalid Mahmood MP - and by his inclusion Kamal Hanif, head at Waverley.

    Listen: Stephen's story 10:20:

    Stephen Sutton, from Burntwood, has terminal cancer. When he was diagnosed, he made a bucket list of things he wanted to do before he died.

    Stephen Sutton's story

    One of them was to raise money for the Teenage Cancer Trust and it went so well, he said he wanted to raise £1m before he lost his battle with the illness.

    Pete Morgan on BBC WM spoke about Stephen's campaign as well as talking to his family and people affected by his story. Listen online now.

    Shakespeare's England 10:06:

    From Birmingham to Milton Keynes - Shakespeare's legacy exists far beyond the confines of Stratford-upon-Avon.

    William Shakespeare

    On the Bard's 450th birthday, BBC News takes a tour of the "sceptred isle" that inspired his works and looks at how the locations have changed.

    BBC Midlands Today will be live from Stratford-upon-Avon from 18:30 on BBC One.

    In the news 09:57: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    In the news at 10:00 on BBC WM, we'll hear from the Howard League for Penal Reform, after a young offenders institution near Wolverhampton was labelled one of the worst that inspectors have seen.

    Bids to buy Birmingham City 09:51:

    Birmingham City officials are meeting in Hong Kong today to discuss four potential bids to buy the club.

    Inside St Andrew's - Birmingham City ground

    The interested parties are said to be a British-based consortium willing to pay about £32m, plus bidders from Australia, China and the Middle East.

    The club has been for sale for two years and the team are currently battling to avoid relegation from the Championship.

    Call for youth prison closure 09:39:

    Campaigners are calling for a young offenders institution near Wolverhampton to be closed after inspectors found inmates were living in squalor.

    Brinsford Young Offenders Institution

    Chief Inspector of Prisons Nick Hardwick described conditions at Brinsford Young Offenders Institution as the worst his team had seen.

    The call for it to be shut has come from the Howard League for Penal Reform.

    On the programme 09:28: Robert Thompson Editor, Midlands Today

    Happy St George's Day and Happy Birthday Shakespeare!

    Nick Owen and Mary Rhodes are in Stratford tonight for Midlands Today, celebrating the bard's 450th birthday.

    We'll be asking just what Shakespeare means to the Midlands economy (lots) and how the Midlands will be celebrating this big anniversary for the next few days. If you've got any thoughts then drop us an email.

    Dying man hopes to raise £1m 09:13:

    The uncle of a 19-year-old from Birmingham who is dying of terminal cancer says his nephew hopes to raise £1m today.

    Stephen Sutton

    Stephen Sutton started a bucket list of things he wants to do before he dies, which includes raising £1m for the Teenage Cancer Trust. Last night he wrote on Facebook that he was facing "the end" after being taken ill at home.

    Andrew Reeves says: "Hopefully today we can make £1m, especially as it's St George's Day and Stephen is like St George. We can't express how he's been - he's just unbelievable."

    News headlines 08:59: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    The top three stories coming up on BBC WM at 09:00:

    • People living near a young offenders institution near Wolverhampton that's been labelled unsafe and dirty say they are not concerned
    • The uncle of a West Midlands teenager with incurable cancer says they're hoping to fulfil his final wish by raising £1m for charity
    • The Hong Kong based owners of Birmingham city are expected to discuss four potential bidders for the club today
    St George's Day 08:54: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    Today is St George's Day and 25% of people in the West Midlands will be marking it in some way, according to a survey.

    Man standing with St George's flag on his back

    Will you be celebrating the patron saint of England's day? Share your photos with us on email or Twitter.

    M6 northbound delays 08:42:

    There's delays and queuing traffic on the M6 northbound at J8, M5, because of an accident involving a lorry and two cars earlier on. Travel time is about 55 minutes. Read the latest on BBC Travel News.

    Your views 08:30:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

    Damning prison report 08:19:

    A damning report into Brinsford Young Offenders Institution, near Wolverhampton, has found violence levels too high, inefficient security and drug usage three times above targets. Read the full story on BBC News.

    Brinsford Young Offenders Institution in Wolverhampton
    Dying wish 08:07: Pete Morgan Presenter, BBC WM

    A West Midlands teenager with incurable cancer is getting closer to his final wish of raising £1m for charity.

    Stephen Sutton, 19, from Burntwood, posted a message on social media from hospital last night which led to a massive increase in his fundraising total for the Teenage Cancer Trust.

    I'll be speaking to Stephen's uncle on BBC WM in the next 20 minutes. Listen live.

    Good morning 08:00: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    I'll be bringing you the the latest news, sport, travel and weather updates for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    If you'd like to comment on any of the updates we're featuring today then please do email or tweet @BBCWM.



Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Phantom BadgerReporting for duty

    BBC Autos discovers what makes Boeing’s new versatile and transportable war machine so special


  • Papers Please gameClick Watch

    Meet the ‘bedroom programmer’ whose game has sold half a million copies and won a Bafta

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.