West Midlands PCC Bob Jones criticises role

Police and Crime Commissioner Bob Jones Bob Jones gave the PCC model just two out of 10 for raising public confidence in the police

Related Stories

West Midlands Police and Crime Commissioner Bob Jones has criticised the posts, saying they have done nothing for police accountability.

The comments come a year on since the directly elected PCCs took up their jobs across England and Wales.

He said £100m had been "spent so far on making police accountability less effective".

In a statement, Police Minister Damian Green said Mr Jones's claims had "no basis in fact".

In a style similar to a school report, Mr Jones - responsible for the second largest force in the country - gave the model an overall four out of 10.

The PCCs were elected for the first time last year, replacing police authorities.

However, fewer than 15% of voters turned out for the elections.

Representing Labour, Mr Jones said he had originally chosen to stand as he felt police accountability was "crucial", despite considering the PCC model as "extremely risky".

'Record low turnout'

"There is clearly a limit on how much can be achieved and as someone who has been involved locally and nationally for almost 30 years, I believe I can offer an objective assessment as to how the model compares," he said.

"With a record low turnout at the election, record levels of hostile publicity, record numbers of investigations into PCCs and clashes between chief constables and PCCs etc, there is not much evidence that PCCs have led to more confidence in policing or the governance of policing."

He gave the PCC model two out of 10 for its impact on public confidence in the police and three out of 10 for its effectiveness in cutting crime.

In his first anniversary report, Mr Jones also criticised some of his fellow PCCs, saying they had introduced "gimmicks" and budgets that seemed unsustainable in the long term.

Responding to Mr Jones's comments, Mr Green said: "The real picture shows that crime has fallen by more than 10% under this government and for the first time, people have a proper say in local policing.

"Across the country, police and crime commissioners are driving reform and holding their forces to account. And it's the public who'll decide how well they've performed - at the ballot box."

PCCs are expected to hold their forces to account, set priorities for local policing and, alongside the chief constable, set the budget.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country



Min. Night 11 °C

BBC Local Live


    Local Live has finished for the day. Tomorrow, we'll be starting at the earlier time of 07:00 as strong winds are forecast with the possibility of travel disruption.

    Send us your photos and comments, if it's legal and safe to do so.

    Coming up on TV 17:50: Dan Pallett Sports presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    I'm heading to St Andrew's for reaction to Lee Clark's sacking as Birmingham City manager.

    Despite the chaos in Hong Kong, a record of just one league win in a calendar year has cost him his job.

    I'll have more on Midlands Today at 18:30 on BBC One.

    Feedback 17:48: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service, which we write here in Birmingham.

    Cuts plan to go to cabinet 17:42: Chris Blakemore News editor, BBC WM

    Leader of Walsall Council Sean Coughlan held a press conference to announce the authority's draft budget proposals for the next four years.

    He's due to put forward the plan to Cabinet on 29 October.


    Up to 430 jobs could go at Walsall Council due to budget cuts, the leader of the authority says.

    A consultation is going to be held to decide on the future of libraries and children's services as the council, which employs 9,500 people, seeks to save £86m over the next four years.

    Sean Coughlan says the closure of seven libraries and eight children's centres is being considered.

    Pub bombings anniversary 17:31: James Bovill Journalist, BBC WM

    BBC WM is producing a radio documentary to commemorate the 40th anniversary of the Birmingham pub bombings. It will be broadcast on the night of the anniversary, 21 November at 20:00, just before the bombs went off.

    We are looking for people who were in Birmingham city centre that night or have family/friends who were. The documentary will focus on people's memories of the night rather than the aftermath.

    If anyone has a story they'd be willing to share - no matter how big or small - I'd love to hear from you. You can contact me via email.

    Brum not curry capital 17:25:

    Birmingham has come third in a competition for the title "Curry Capital", losing out to Bradford in first place and Brighton in second..

    Who fancies the job? 17:20: Richard Wilford BBC WM Sport

    It is ironic that Lee Clark's final game should have come against Bolton - the same club against whom Blues gained that priceless stoppage time point back in May to retain their status.

    The only question now is who fancies taking on a tough job? Given the delicate ownership situation at St Andrew's it is a task that should not be considered lightly.

    'Hoping injury is not permanent' 17:15:

    Ch Insp Stephen Morrey says the officer who was shot in Rugeley yesterday should be commended "for carrying out his duty in this way".

    "My thoughts are currently with the officer and his family hoping that the injury is not permanent. We are currently supporting his family and we are all hoping that he is able to make a swift recovery.

    "The incident is now being investigated by detectives and we are not seeking anybody else in relation to this matter."

    First half marathon 17:06: Andy Akinwolere Presenter, BBC Inside Out West Midlands

    Yesterday I took part in the Great Birmingham Run - my first ever half marathon. It was an amazing atmosphere and I loved high fiving the crowds and feeling the buzz of the city. Running down the finish on Broad Street with the crowds cheering is something I won't forget in a long time.

    Andy Akinwolere running Great Birmingham Run

    Find out how I did on Inside Out tonight at 19.30 on BBC One.

    News on the hour 16:55: Chris Blakemore News editor, BBC WM

    I'll have more details on the police officer who was shot with an air weapon in Rugeley yesterday evening. Listen live.

    Real ale pub guide launched 16:48: Halesowen News

    Dudley Council and the Campaign for Real Ale have teamed up to launch a guide to some of the borough's finest pubs.

    Lee Clark facts 16:38:

    Lee Clark joined Blues in June 2012 after being sacked from Huddersfield Town.

    • 1972 - Born Wallsend (26 October)
    • 1990-97 Newcastle. Played 195 games, 23 goals, winning 11 England Under-21 caps
    • June 2006. Became Newcastle coach under Glenn Roeder
    • November 2007. Followed Roeder to Carrow Road to become Norwich City coach
    • December 2008-2012. Manager of Huddersfield Town
    West Brom v Man Utd 16:28: Richard Wilford BBC WM Sport

    West Bromwich Albion's recent up-turn in form will be tested by Manchester United at the Hawthorns tonight.

    West Bromwich Albion playing Liverpool

    The Baggies could leapfrog local rivals Villa in the Premier League table if they turn over a United team missing suspended skipper Wayne Rooney.

    The former Albion midfielder Richard Sneekes will be part of the BBC WM team live at the Hawthorns, starting with the football phone-in at 18:00.

    Bus passenger dies outside police station 16:17: Express and Star

    A passenger died on a bus parked outside a police station as the driver waited inside for at least 20 minutes for an officer to respond, it is claimed.

    Warning of strong winds 16:10: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    Gusts of more than 50mph are expected tomorrow, as the Met Office issues a yellow weather warning.

    Met Office yellow weather warning

    Gales are expected to affect much of the country on Tuesday, around the morning rush hour.

    Read more on the Met Office website and stay up to date with the latest on BBC Weather.

    Rail delays expected 16:01:

    London Midland tweets: Due to signalling problems services south of #NewStreet on #CrossCity line are subject to delays & cancellations at short notice. More soon.

    News on the hour 16:00: Chris Blakemore News editor, BBC WM

    Our sports reporter Mark Regan spoke to Lee Clark this morning, just hours before he was sacked.

    Mark asked him about criticism from the fans and the now ex-Blues boss told him that "everybody needed to stick together".

    "It's about trying to turn around the results. We've got to keep fighting and looking after each other and keep the belief." Hear more in the news bulletin.

    'Sexed up' Archers 15:48:

    BBC Birmingham PR tweets: Fan of @BBCTheArchers? Read this interview with the editor of the BBC #Birmingham based radio drama via @Telegraphfw.to/Cv90kRH

    Restaurants named among UK's best 15:39: Birmingham Post

    Seven restaurants in the Midlands have won a place on a new national top 100 list.

    Birmingham is one of the few British cities outside London to feature more than once in this weekend's Sunday Times 100 Top Restaurants.

    Not a major surprise 15:28: Richard Wilford BBC WM Sport

    Lee Clark's departure at Birmingham can hardly be viewed as a major surprise.

    Lee Clark

    They have won only one home game in the Championship since 1 October 2013 - that is 24 games and counting.

    It was their away form that saved them on the final day of last season and it is also points on their travels that holds them a point above the drop-zone now.

    Rowett favourite 15:17: Owen Bradley BBC Sport

    It's not a surprise to see Burton Albion manager Gary Rowett already installed as the early favourite to replace Lee Clark at Birmingham.

    News on the hour 14:59: Chris Blakemore News editor, BBC WM

    Coming up in the news at 15:00 on BBC WM our Birmingham City correspondent will have more on the news that Lee Clark has been sacked as the manager of Blues.

    Your reaction: Blues sacking 14:47: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    What do you think to Lee Clark being sacked from Birmingham City?

    Email or tweet us know your thoughts.

    'Nothing to gain' 14:39: Richard Wilford BBC WM Sport

    So the end has come for Lee Clark at Birmingham City - the situation clearly couldn't go on any longer. The club had nothing to gain from waiting any longer.

    Lee Clark
    Search for new manager 14:28:

    Birmingham City says the search to find a new manager has already begun.

    First-team coach Richard Beale and chief scout Malcolm Crosby have been placed in charge.

    Clark leaves Birmingham City 14:23: BREAKING NEWS

    Birmingham City has "parted company" with manager Lee Clark with immediate effect, the club says.

    The week in 60 seconds 14:14:

    The Library of Birmingham loses out on the Stirling prize, 350 jobs could be lost at Cadbury and Ebola checks are to be introduced at Birmingham Airport.

    BBC Sunday Politics West Midlands: The political week in 60 seconds

    See last week's political headlines in 60 seconds.

    News on the hour 13:59: Chris Blakemore News editor, BBC WM

    Residents at a care home near Stourbridge are facing an uncertain future after the company which operates it went into administration.

    Hear more on this story and others in the news at 14:00 on BBC WM.

    Social worker shortage 13:44:

    The cabinet member for children and family services at Birmingham City Council's says there needs to be more emphasis on recruiting permanent social workers rather than relying on agency staff.

    New head of children's services Bernadette McNally announced last week she was quitting before even properly starting her job.

    Councillor Brigid Jones says: "We do have a nationwide shortage on our hands but of course for councils which have had issues like Birmingham, that shortage is more acute."

    Council says school is 'safe to use' 13:35:

    Read more on BBC News about Yardleys School, which remains closed despite reassurances it would reopen today.

    Clean-up crews at Yardleys School

    The school said it was still waiting for written confirmation from Birmingham City Council to say the site was "safe to use".

    The council said it had already advised the school to reopen.

    'Make sure she's safe' 13:25:

    More on the girl who said she had been separated from her mother in Birmingham.

    West Midlands Police tweets: There are no missing children reports that match the description of the girl but we want to make sure she is safe. bit.ly/1CKdY9C

    Midlands Today 13:16: Joanne Malin Presenter

    This lunchtime, find out how medics in Birmingham are saving more lives thanks to techniques they've learnt treating soldiers in Afghanistan.

    And as the weather takes a turn for the worse, we'll have the full forecast for Birmingham and the Black Country with Mel Coles.

    Mel Coles with the latest forecast

    Join me for the latest on BBC One from 13:30.

    Arrested under Mental Health Act 13:06:

    A 34-year-old man has been arrested under the Mental Health Act after a police officer was shot in the eye with an air weapon yesterday in Rugeley.

    A sergeant from the Cannock Chase District Local Policing Team is at the Queen Elizabeth Hospital after the shooting at about 19:30 in Wat Tyler Close.

    Police officer shot in eye 12:54: BBC WM

    A police officer is in hospital after he was shot in the eye with an air weapon yesterday in Rugeley, Staffordshire.

    Hear more in the 13:00 news bulletin.

    Girl boarded bus at station 12:51:

    Police want to trace a young girl who asked passersby for help in Birmingham city centre yesterday, saying she had become separated from her mother.

    Missing girl

    The girl, thought to be aged between 8 and 12, is black and wore a red/pink top and black leggings. She has braided hair and a scar under her eye and is thought to be from Birmingham.

    West Midlands Police believes she got on a number 46 bus at Snow Hill station. Anyone with information is asked to call the force on 101.

    Burglar stuffed kittens in oven 12:40: Birmingham Mail

    A cruel burglar stuffed three kittens in an oven while ransacking their owner's home.

    Harvest festival gathering 12:33: David Gregory-Kumar Correspondent, BBC Midlands Today

    Here's the Duchess of Cornwall and Dean of Birmingham Catherine Ogle, ahead of the National Harvest Festival in the city.

    The Duchess of Cornwall and the Dean of Birmingham Catherine Ogle

    The service is at Birmingham Cathedral and our reporter Bob Hockenhull is inside.

    Video: 1984 People's Marathon 12:20:

    Did you know Birmingham used to have a full marathon? Take a look back at the footage from Midlands Today, filmed 30 years ago.

    Birmingham Marathon 1984
    Reaction to Lynda Bellingham's death 12:10: Caroline Martin BBC WM Presenter

    It's such sad news about the death of Lynda Bellingham aged 66.

    I want to pay tribute to her on the show. Have you been touched by her story in any way? I'm live on BBC WM between now and 14:00.

    'Separated' girl appeal 11:56:

    Police want to trace a young girl after she asked for people's help in Birmingham city centre yesterday, telling them she had become separated from her mother.

    Missing girl, CCTV image

    The girl, thought to be aged between eight and 12, spoke to people near St Philip's Cathedral. She has not been seen since.

    Insp Adam Henderson says: "There are no missing children reports which match the description of the girl, but this is an unusual incident which we must get to the bottom of."

    Coming up on Midlands Today 11:45: Colin Roobottom Producer

    We'll be finding out how survival rates of patients with serious injuries have gone up 30% because of the skills learned from dealing with soldiers wounded in Afghanistan.

    There's a report on rogue garages illegally removing particle filters from diesel vehicles rather than carrying out expensive repairs.

    And we'll be at the National Harvest Service which is bringing schoolchildren from all over the country to Birmingham.

    School applications deadline looming 11:39:

    Applications for children to start secondary school in September 2015 should be made by the end of the month, Birmingham City Council warns.

    Read more about school admissions.

    People's Marathon 11:29: Andy Akinwolere Presenter, BBC Inside Out West Midlands

    Like me, many of you will have either watched or taken part in the Great Birmingham Run yesterday. While mass participation events like that are fairly commonplace now, it wasn't that long ago that distance running was the preserve of elites.

    However, on 11 May 1980 when 750 people gathered in Chemsley Wood to take part in the inaugural People's Marathon, all that changed forever.

    Mac screen

    Inside Out will have the full story tonight at 19:30 on BBC One - join me then for some great archive, short shorts and fetching vests.

    HS2 college site to be allocated 11:19: Birmingham Updates

    The site for the National College for High Speed Rail in Birmingham is to be allocated later today.

    Have your say 11:06: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you news, sport, travel and weather updates in one place. We'd like to find out what you think.

    News on the hour 11:01: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    In the news at 11:00: Police have released CCTV images of men they want to identify in connection with large scale disorder in Sparkhill this summer, during which one man died.

    Duchess to attend service 10:47:

    The National Harvest Festival, usually held at Westminster Abbey in London, is being held in Birmingham today.

    The Duchess of Cornwall will be at the service at Birmingham Cathedral and schoolchildren from around the country will bring boxes of homegrown produce.

    About 360 children from 20 schools are expected to attend the service later.

    Your photos 10:37: via Facebook

    BBC Midlands Today posts: Welcome to Monday - here are some more viewers' photos to start your working week.

    Photos of the Midlands sent in by viewers of Midlands Today

    Remember, we love to see your photos.

    Please email midlandstoday@bbc.co.uk or post to Facebook.

    Strong winds expected 10:26: Mel Coles BBC Weather

    The Met Office has issued a yellow weather warning for strong winds from midnight.

    It covers many parts of the West Midlands and we could see gusts reach up to 55mph.

    School to stay closed 10:09:

    A Birmingham school that's been closed for three weeks because of a nearby fire won't reopen today, even though the city council says it's safe.

    Scene of fire

    Yardleys School has been shut since a suspected arson attack at an industrial unit next door.

    The academy's head teacher says she wants written confirmation it's safe, though it's hoped the school will reopen later this week.

    News on the hour 09:59: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    This afternoon, the leader of Walsall Council's announcing the budget plans for the next four years.

    In the news at 10:00, we'll hear from Sean Coughlan.

    Rail delays 09:38:

    London Midland tweets: Due to poor rail conditions, services between #Redditch & #Lichfield Trent Valley are subject to delays and cancellations. More when known.

    Follow @LondonMidland on Twitter for further updates.

    CCTV appeal after disorder death 09:27:

    Do you recognise these men? Police want to speak to them after "violent disorder" in Sparkhill where a man died in July.

    Two CCTV images of men police want to speak to

    The disorder broke out on the evening of 2 July in Grantham Road and Farm Road.

    Ikram Ullah Khan, 28, known as Ikram Elahi, died after being stabbed in the neck.

    'Brandy' driver arrested 09:18: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    I've just spoken to police who say they arrested a 27-year-old man found "clutching" a bottle of brandy while driving and found him to be over the drink-drive limit.

    He was arrested on Chester Road in Castle Bromwich just after 04:00.

    Army surgeons 09:06: Joanne Malin Presenter, Midlands Today

    Experience gained by Army surgeons treating the wounded in Afghanistan is now helping to save civilian lives here in the West Midlands.

    Army surgeon treating a patient

    Trauma centres, such as at the Queen Elizabeth Hospital in Birmingham, have seen a 30% increase in survival rates as a result of techniques learnt during the war, which has so far claimed more than 400 British lives.

    News on the hour 08:57: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    The cabinet member for children and family services at Birmingham City Council says there needs to be more emphasis on recruiting permanent social workers rather than relying on agency staff.

    Hear more in the news at 09:00 on BBC WM.

    Reduced parking at Metro station 08:46:

    Midland Metro tweets: Today, extension works start at Priestfield car park, the car park will remain open during work but with less spaces available. 21/10/14.

    Driver 'clutching' brandy 08:37:

    West Midlands Traffic Police say they arrested a motorist earlier this morning who was seen clutching a bottle of brandy while driving. Here's the brandy pictured on the car's roof.

    Bottle of brandy on top of car
    Great Birmingham Run 08:27: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    Legs aching? Feeling a little more tired than usual - maybe you competed in the Great Birmingham Run yesterday?

    I saw lots of photos of friends looking proud wearing their medals, while also a little bit sweaty.

    Great Birmingham Run 2014

    You can see footage from the day and photographs on the BBC WM Facebook page.

    Shopping centre sold 08:17:

    The Mander shopping centre in Wolverhampton has been sold.

    Mander shopping centre, Wolverhampton

    The precinct, currently in the middle of a £30m revamp, was put on the market earlier this year for £50m.

    Chance of showers 08:07: Mel Coles BBC Weather

    It's another breezy day and although there'll be some sunshine first thing, the cloud will increase and there'll be a few showers around.

    Still plenty of dry, bright spells but the winds will start to pick up towards this evening. Feeling a bit cooler than yesterday with highs of 14C (57F).

    Good morning 08:00: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    I'm in the BBC WM newsroom bringing you the very latest news, sport, travel and weather for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    If you'd like to comment on any of the updates we're featuring today then please do email or tweet @BBCWM.



Elsewhere on the BBC

  • MoviesMovie magic

    Tech that reads your desires is helping to increase your odds of producing a hit film, says BBC Future


  • Ade Adepitan at the ColosseumThe Travel Show Watch

    The challenge of providing disabled access at Europe’s leading ancient monuments

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.