End of the road? Are major routes through cities outdated?

Queensway tunnels The A38 Queensway tunnels have been criticised for being noisy and unattractive

Related Stories

A report looking at Birmingham's transport network for the next 20 years has concluded the future of the Queensway tunnels should be examined. It is not the only place in the UK that relies on a route for cars through the city. So are such roads outdated?

When it emerged Birmingham's Queensway tunnels would be closed for six weeks over the summer, it is no surprise there were predictions of "chaos".

The main through route for the A38, the tunnels are used by thousands of drivers each day and have been an integral part of the city's transport network since they were built in the 1970s.

There was some surprise, therefore, when the anticipated gridlock did not materialise.

The reality was so different that a report into Birmingham's transport network for the next 20 years has called for a debate about how much they are needed, pointing out they create a "noisy unattractive barrier to intra-centre movement".

Motorists in Manchester, Leeds and Glasgow rely on similar urban routes - the A57M, A58M and M8. But do we really need them?

'Almost vandalism'

"Our view is that it is entirely inappropriate to have major roads crashing through the middle of cities," said David Tittle, from the Design Network, which advises on design in urban environments across the country.

He said while such roads were effective at getting drivers directly from one place to another they split areas down the centre, reducing the scope for development and regeneration.

"The more we can do away with them - the better," he said.

Peter Rayner, a fellow of the Chartered Institute of Logistics and Transport and former advisor to the government's transport select committee, said major urban roads through cities "fly in the face of the inevitable".

"In the future we will not have the oil to run cars so it is foolish to have large roads running through city centres," he said. "It's almost vandalism."

Mr Rayner said councils needed to think about moving away from a reliance on such routes and instead concentrate on the development of integrated public transport and tram networks.

Big Dig tunnel Studies have shown the Big Dig project has yielded financial benefits for Boston's economy

There have already been a number of schemes to abolish major urban routes in the US to create extra space.

In Boston, an underground highway was created to replace an elevated six-lane route which previously carried 200,000 cars per day through the heart of the city.

Although the Big Dig project, which also saw the creation of two new bridges over the Charles River, overran by billions of pounds, studies have shown it has already yielded benefits.

A study by the Massachusetts Turnpike Authority said getting rid of the road had encouraged $5.3bn worth of construction projects in the freeway's vicinity which had generated nearly 36,000 new jobs.

Meanwhile in Portland, Oregon, city bosses in 1974 closed the Harbor Drive freeway to make way for a 37-acre park.

The three-mile long highway ran alongside the Willamette River and carried 25,000 vehicles a day.

'Trusted friend'

But a report called the Seattle Urban Mobility Plan said the move had increased land values in Portland from a total of $466m to more than $1.6bn and reduced trips on nearby roads by just under 10%.

Council bosses have already been looking at the long-term future of the A58M in Leeds and the M8 in Glasgow.

Councillor Richard Lewis, responsible for highways at Leeds City Council, said he believed the city could cope without the A58m but said the council would need to do a lot of things to replace it.

"It's a trusted friend," he said. "There may come a time when we don't need it anymore but we would not want to part company with it in a hurry."

Mr Lewis said they were spending £20m to refurbish the east-west link at various sections and said: "I don't want to be spending large sums of money on something that is no longer fit for purpose."

Meanwhile Alistair Watson, executive member for transport at Glasgow City Council, said he would welcome exploration of alternatives to the M8 but said any change would require a "radical overview" of how Glasgow connected to other towns and cities.

The tunnels Birmingham Chamber of Commerce believes the city could survive without the Queensway tunnels

And back in Birmingham? Katie Teasdale, from Birmingham Chamber of Commerce, believes the city could survive without its tunnels.

"Yes of course, but there would need to be a genuine alternative in place," she said.

"At the moment they are very important. Yes we want a safer, cleaner, greener city but we also need to make sure people can get from A to B."

But Dr Pat Hanlon, a lecturer in transport economics at the University of Birmingham, could not see the benefit.

"It would create such an accumulation of traffic at the bottom end by Bristol Road... I shudder to think what would happen to all the traffic," he said.

"I would be really worried if they did that."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country

Weather

Birmingham

7 °C 2 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    15:26: Barcode replacement

    Birmingham City Council tweets: Payment cards to pay rent, council tax & business rates to be replaced with barcodes on bills & letters. Info here: birmingham.gov.uk/barcode

     
  2.  
    15:03: Weather snapshot Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    If you're wondering what the weather's going to be like over the coming couple of days, you can get the latest forecast on BBC Weather.

    Weather forecast

    You can also get updates by following the team @BBCWeather on Twitter.

     
  3.  
    14:59: News on the hour BBC WM

    It's emerged that the bill for policing last month's EDL protest in Dudley was £321,000.

    You can hear more on this story in our 15:00 bulletin.

     
  4.  
    14:52: Event to discuss housing challenges

    An event to look at housing across the West Midlands is being hosted by Wolverhampton City Council today.

    The Local Government Association conference in Wolverhampton discussing housing

    The Local Government Association event is looking at "collaborative working in the region to address the housing challenge".

    Speakers include Sir Michael Lyons (pictured), chairman of the English Cities Fund. You can follow the event via the Twitter hashtag #BuildingBritain and see more on Midlands Today at 18:30 on BBC One.

     
  5.  
    14:34: Bournemouth v Wolves BBC Sport

    Wolves welcome back striker Kevin Doyle after he missed the 1-0 win at Cardiff for the birth of his daughter.

    Goalkeeper Carl Ikeme and midfielder Tommy Rowe (both metatarsal) remain sidelined. Read more on BBC Sport.

    You can hear match updates on BBC WM 95.6FM tonight from 19:00.

     
  6.  
    14:21: BBC Introducing track Louise Brierley BBC Introducing

    Congratulations to Birmingham's Thai Mason, whose song Drunk has been selected for the BBC Introducing slot on BBC 1Xtra in the week starting 16 March.

     
  7.  
    14:09: Cold day Sara Blizzard Weather Presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    We're starting to see some brighter weather after a wintry start first thing this morning.

    Sara Blizzard

    There are a few showers lingering around and it's pretty blustery out there, making it feel much colder, with a high of of 7C (44F).

     
  8.  
    13:56: News on the hour BBC WM

    Coming up in the news at 14:00 on BBC WM: It's emerged that the bill for policing last month's EDL protest in Dudley was £321,000.

    It was the third EDL rally in the town in the past five years and hundreds of police officers were drafted in.

     
  9.  
    13:45: Ex-manager dies aged 80 Chris Blakemore News editor, BBC WM

    The former Walsall and Blues manager Dave Mackay has died aged 80. He was the Saddlers boss from March 1977 to August 1978.

    Dave Mackay, manager of Walsall FC

    He was in charge at St Andrew's between 1989 and 1991.

    Paul Franks will be speaking to his official biographer live on Drivetime today on BBC WM.

     
  10.  
    13:33: Mander Centre future Express and Star

    The new owners of the city's Mander Centre, Benson Elliot, have said they want to change the face of shopping in the centre by getting rid of a perceived 'discount store mentality' as it looks ahead to a £25 million revamp. Read more.

     
  11.  
    13:22: Villa v West Brom BBC Sport

    Aston Villa's Ron Vlaar has completed a ban but is "touch and go" to face West Brom because of a calf injury.

    Kieran Richardson and Aly Cissokho remain unavailable so Matt Lowton could again deputise at left-back.

    Tim Sherwood and Tony Pulis

    West Brom boss Tony Pulis (pictured right) has fitness concerns over Saido Berahino and Brown Ideye, who both limped off against Southampton on Saturday with respective foot and knee injuries.

    Fellow striker Victor Anichebe remains sidelined by a groin problem. Read the full match preview on BBC Sport.

     
  12.  
    13:05: Coming up on TV Sarah Falkland BBC Midlands Today presenter

    We'll be hearing from some of the women who were victims of the negligent breast cancer surgeon Ian Paterson. They've come out in force in Solihull today demanding answers about compensation.

    Plus, we'll have the latest forecast from Sara Blizzard. Join me and the team this lunchtime.

     
  13.  
    12:56: News on the hour BBC WM

    In the news at 13:00 on BBC WM: Sandwell Council is encouraging lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people to consider adoption to help meet the need for more foster carers in the borough.

     
  14.  
    12:52: Boy attacked walking home with girlfriend

    Read more on BBC News about a teenager who is critically ill in hospital after being attacked with a hammer as he walked home with his girlfriend.

     
  15.  
    12:35: V Festival line-up BBC Newsbeat

    Rock band Kasabian and singer songwriter Calvin Harris will be among the headline acts at this year's V Festival at Weston Park in Staffordshire.

    Sam Smith, Tom Jones, Olly Murs and the Stereophonics will also be on the bill for the two-day event in August. Read more on this story.

     
  16.  
    12:24: Birmingham Digital Week Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    Birmingham Digital Week is taking place across the city from 14-20 March.

    It's aimed at developing people's digital skills, sharing knowledge and creating networking opportunities for the city's digital sector.

    Birmingham Digital Week 2015

    Each day is themed, from Games to a Business Day. Take a closer look on the BBC Academy website.

     
  17.  
    12:11: Tributes to Dave Mackay

    Tributes are being paid to Former Walsall and Birmingham City boss Dave Mackay who has died aged 80.

    Dave Mackay

    Mackay was a midfielder during his playing days for Tottenham, Derby, Hearts and Scotland.

    He was only in charge at Fellows Park for just over a year between 1977 and 78 and he managed Blues from 1989 to 1991.

     
  18.  
    12:03: News on the hour BBC WM

    In the 12:00 news bulletin: Hundreds of women who had unnecessary breast operations at a private Solihull hospital are protesting today, because they're still waiting for compensation.

     
  19.  
    11:51: Hammer attack witnesses sought

    Police are appealing for witnesses in Hodge Hill after a 16-year-old was left in a critical condition when he was hit over the head with a hammer.

    Det Con Mike Griffiths says: "From speaking to the boy's girlfriend we know that the couple first encountered the group of suspects outside the Tesco store on Chipperfield Road.

    "The assault then took place by a bus stop outside Hodge Hill United Reformed Church and St Philip & St James Church on Coleshill Road. It was here that a bus passenger handed wet wipes to the boy's girlfriend prior to getting on to a bus and we hope that this person comes forward."

     
  20.  
    11:39: Heptathlete thanks tweeters

    Following the Crimewatch appeal last night Kelly Sotherton tweets: Thank you to everyone who has retweeted or messaged me regarding the medals. It means a lot!

     
  21.  
    11:24: 'I didn't need a mastectomy' Michelle Dawes Journalist, BBC WM

    This morning I've been speaking with Frances Perks, who had an unnecessary mastectomy at Spire Health Care.

    Frances Perks

    She was told by a consultant in 2012 that all the operations she'd had she didn't need.

    Ms Perks says: "I started seeing Ian Paterson in 1994 and saw him until 2010. He always told me my family was high risk and [I have] since found out that wasn't the case. It's had a dreadful effect on me and my family. I just never thought I'd be in this position."

     
  22.  
    11:15: Three arrested and bailed

    Police say the teenager was walking home with his girlfriend in Coleshill Road on Saturday evening when he was approached by three other teenagers before an argument started.

    The victim has been put in an induced coma after he was struck over the head with a hammer.

    Three boys, aged 15 and 16, have been arrested and bailed pending further inquiries.

     
  23.  
    11:10: Boy attacked with hammer

    A 16-year-old is in a critical condition after he was attacked with a hammer in Birmingham on Saturday, police say.

     
  24.  
    11:01: News on the hour BBC WM

    In the news at 11:00 on BBC WM: We'll hear from a woman who says she's still waiting for compensation after unnecessary breast operations at a private Solihull hospital.

     
  25.  
    10:49: Stories we're looking at Hilary McConnell Producer, BBC Midlands Today

    We're speaking to women demonstrating outside the Spire Parkway hospital in Solihull. They were treated by Dr Ian Paterson, who operated unnecessarily on some women who'd seen him privately under the NHS.

    The women will deliver an open letter to management at Spire Health Care - expressing their frustration at the slow reaction to their legal cases.

    And our reporter Ben Sidwell is in Wolverhampton at a special conference looking at housing issues in the region.

     
  26.  
    10:32: Appeal to find missing woman

    Police say they're concerned for a 22-year-old Syrian woman who was last seen in Birmingham city centre in February.

    Soumia Altaha

    West Midlands Police says Soumia Altaha went missing on Broad Street on 17 February at about 11:00.

    The woman, who does not speak English, is 5ft 5in (1.65m) tall with shoulder length black hair. When last seen, she was wearing a dark blue skirt, pink woollen coat, beige headscarf and black handbag.

     
  27.  
    10:21: 'I want them back'

    Kelly Sotherton told the BBC Crimewatch programme: "The fact that someone came in our house while we were asleep... is a bit creepy.

    Kelly Sotherton

    The former heptathlete and 400m runner says: "My Commonwealth gold medal was my first international medal. When I look back on it now I'm really proud of myself.

    "It's the sentimental reason I want them back so I can treasure them for the rest of my life."

     
  28.  
    10:09: Open letter to hospital Sarah Falkland BBC Midlands Today presenter

    Hundreds of women who suffered negligent treatment by a breast surgeon will stage a protest in Solihull today.

    Dr Ian Paterson

    Dr Ian Paterson (pictured) operated unnecessarily on women who'd seen him privately and under the NHS.

    The women will deliver an open letter to management at Spire Health Care, which has apologised "unreservedly" to all patients.

     
  29.  
    09:57: News on the hour Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    Coming up in the news bulletin on BBC WM shortly: A protest is due to take place outside the Library of Birmingham this afternoon over cuts to opening hours and job losses.

    Birmingham City Council says the library, which opened in September 2013, would open 40 hours a week - down from 73 hours.

     
  30.  
    09:51: Meeting over pub bombings

    Campaigners for victims of the Birmingham pub bombings are due to meet the home secretary this week to try to secure a new inquest into the deaths of their loved ones.

    Birmingham pub bombings in 1974

    Twenty-one people died and 182 were injured in the explosions in 1974.

    The group Justice 4 the 21 will ask for the support of Theresa May and Northern Ireland Secretary Theresa Villiers in a meeting at the Home Office on Wednesday.

     
  31.  
    09:40: Signal failure

    London Midland tweets: #BhamInternational update- Due to a signal failure NX West Midlands are accepting our tickets between #Birmingham & #BirminghamInternational

    For more updates follow @LondonMidland on Twitter.

     
  32.  
    09:23: Have your say Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you news, sport, travel and weather updates in one place. We'd like to find out what you think of the service.

     
  33.  
    09:10: Police investigate medal lead

    Police say they're investigating a new lead in their search for a Commonwealth Gold medal which was stolen from the home of Birmingham heptathlete Kelly Sotherton.

    Kelly Sotherton

    It follows an appeal on Crimewatch last night for information about the burglary at her Sutton Coldfield home last month.

     
  34.  
    09:00: News on the hour BBC WM

    In the news at 09:00 on BBC WM: At least 500 parents in Birmingham and the Black Country were prosecuted for their children's truancy during the past school year.

     
  35.  
    08:43: Charter flights to China Trystan Jones BBC News

    Charter flights are to be introduced between Beijing and Birmingham this summer, the UK airport has revealed.

    Birmingham International Airport

    Hainan Airlines is to operate two flights a week between 3 July and 28 August, expected to pave the way for a regular service.

    Birmingham Airport said it would be branding itself in China as "Shakespeare's airport" and promoting links to nearby Stratford-upon-Avon.

     
  36.  
    08:32: Mice found in Poundland branch

    A mice infestation was behind food being removed from shelves of a branch of Poundland in Birmingham city centre, the council has revealed.

    On Friday, Poundland claimed it had been advised to remove food from its Corporation Street store because of nearby roadworks.

    But the council's environmental health team said it had received complaints of mice and, after a visit, concluded there was an "imminent risk". Poundland has yet to comment.

     
  37.  
    08:19: Protest over wait for operation payouts BBC WM

    Hundreds of women who are still waiting for compensation after unnecessary breast operations at a private Solihull hospital will be protesting later.

     
  38.  
    08:07: Today's forecast

    It's a frosty start for many. A mixture of sunshine and showers, heavy, wintry and thundery at times, will ease during the morning and become scattered showers of mostly rain in the afternoon.

    Sara Blizzard

    It will stay windy with a high of 6C (43F).

     
  39.  
    08:00: Good morning Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    I'm in Birmingham to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather updates throughout the day. Get in touch if you have a story or picture you'd like to share.

     

Features

  • Mukesh SinghNo remorse

    Delhi bus rapist says victim shouldn't have fought back


  • Aimen DeanI spied

    The founder member of al-Qaeda who worked for MI6


  • Before and after shotsPerfect body

    Just how reliable are 'before and after' photos?


  • Woman with closed eyeStrange light show

    What do you see when you close your eyes?


Elsewhere on the BBC

  • StudentsBull market

    Employers are snapping up students with this desirable degree

Programmes

  • Former al-Qaeda double agent Aimen DeanHARDtalk Watch

    Islamic State is about revenge says former al-Qaeda member turned spy Aimen Dean

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.