End of the road? Are major routes through cities outdated?

Queensway tunnels The A38 Queensway tunnels have been criticised for being noisy and unattractive

Related Stories

A report looking at Birmingham's transport network for the next 20 years has concluded the future of the Queensway tunnels should be examined. It is not the only place in the UK that relies on a route for cars through the city. So are such roads outdated?

When it emerged Birmingham's Queensway tunnels would be closed for six weeks over the summer, it is no surprise there were predictions of "chaos".

The main through route for the A38, the tunnels are used by thousands of drivers each day and have been an integral part of the city's transport network since they were built in the 1970s.

There was some surprise, therefore, when the anticipated gridlock did not materialise.

The reality was so different that a report into Birmingham's transport network for the next 20 years has called for a debate about how much they are needed, pointing out they create a "noisy unattractive barrier to intra-centre movement".

Motorists in Manchester, Leeds and Glasgow rely on similar urban routes - the A57M, A58M and M8. But do we really need them?

'Almost vandalism'

"Our view is that it is entirely inappropriate to have major roads crashing through the middle of cities," said David Tittle, from the Design Network, which advises on design in urban environments across the country.

He said while such roads were effective at getting drivers directly from one place to another they split areas down the centre, reducing the scope for development and regeneration.

"The more we can do away with them - the better," he said.

Peter Rayner, a fellow of the Chartered Institute of Logistics and Transport and former advisor to the government's transport select committee, said major urban roads through cities "fly in the face of the inevitable".

"In the future we will not have the oil to run cars so it is foolish to have large roads running through city centres," he said. "It's almost vandalism."

Mr Rayner said councils needed to think about moving away from a reliance on such routes and instead concentrate on the development of integrated public transport and tram networks.

Big Dig tunnel Studies have shown the Big Dig project has yielded financial benefits for Boston's economy

There have already been a number of schemes to abolish major urban routes in the US to create extra space.

In Boston, an underground highway was created to replace an elevated six-lane route which previously carried 200,000 cars per day through the heart of the city.

Although the Big Dig project, which also saw the creation of two new bridges over the Charles River, overran by billions of pounds, studies have shown it has already yielded benefits.

A study by the Massachusetts Turnpike Authority said getting rid of the road had encouraged $5.3bn worth of construction projects in the freeway's vicinity which had generated nearly 36,000 new jobs.

Meanwhile in Portland, Oregon, city bosses in 1974 closed the Harbor Drive freeway to make way for a 37-acre park.

The three-mile long highway ran alongside the Willamette River and carried 25,000 vehicles a day.

'Trusted friend'

But a report called the Seattle Urban Mobility Plan said the move had increased land values in Portland from a total of $466m to more than $1.6bn and reduced trips on nearby roads by just under 10%.

Council bosses have already been looking at the long-term future of the A58M in Leeds and the M8 in Glasgow.

Councillor Richard Lewis, responsible for highways at Leeds City Council, said he believed the city could cope without the A58m but said the council would need to do a lot of things to replace it.

"It's a trusted friend," he said. "There may come a time when we don't need it anymore but we would not want to part company with it in a hurry."

Mr Lewis said they were spending £20m to refurbish the east-west link at various sections and said: "I don't want to be spending large sums of money on something that is no longer fit for purpose."

Meanwhile Alistair Watson, executive member for transport at Glasgow City Council, said he would welcome exploration of alternatives to the M8 but said any change would require a "radical overview" of how Glasgow connected to other towns and cities.

The tunnels Birmingham Chamber of Commerce believes the city could survive without the Queensway tunnels

And back in Birmingham? Katie Teasdale, from Birmingham Chamber of Commerce, believes the city could survive without its tunnels.

"Yes of course, but there would need to be a genuine alternative in place," she said.

"At the moment they are very important. Yes we want a safer, cleaner, greener city but we also need to make sure people can get from A to B."

But Dr Pat Hanlon, a lecturer in transport economics at the University of Birmingham, could not see the benefit.

"It would create such an accumulation of traffic at the bottom end by Bristol Road... I shudder to think what would happen to all the traffic," he said.

"I would be really worried if they did that."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country



20 °C 15 °C

BBC Local Live

    Good evening 18:00:

    BBC Local Live has finished for the day. We'll be back with more news, sport, travel and weather from 08:00 on Thursday.

    Showers possible 17:53:

    Staying dry for most overnight with some lengthy clear spells. It may turn a little cloudier later in the night with a few showers possible across the northwest towards dawn.

    Coming up 17:41: Midlands Today

    On tonight's programme Nick Owen has been chatting to Black Country wrestler Chinu Singh after his bronze medal at the Commonwealth Games and we'll be live at his wrestling club in Wolverhampton.

    We'll also have the latest on the Stafford Hospital downgrading saga. And we've spent the day with Environment Agency staff rescuing fish at risk of being starved of oxygen.

    Join Nick at 18:30 on BBC One.

    Things to do before you're 11 3/4 17:30: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    If you're looking for ways to entertain the children over the summer holidays, the National Trust could help. They've put together a list of 50 things to do before you're 11 3/4.

    Tree climbing

    Activities include camping, exploring caves and picking wild berries. I reckon I managed about 42 of the 50 before I was 11 3/4 - although to be fair I don't think geocaching was around when I was growing up.

    Blues' signing could be useful 17:20: Richard Wilford BBC WM Sport

    Denny Johnstone, who has just been signed by Birmingham, could be another useful addition to manager Lee Clark's strike options, competing with fellow summer signings Wes Thomas and Clayton Donaldson and another Scottish forward, Andy Shinnie.

    Clark has now added 10 new faces to his squad ahead of the Championship season, hoping to avoid another flirtation with relegation.

    Graffiti yobs target Brierley Hill 17:05: Dudley News

    Vandals armed with spray paint left Brierley Hill looking "a state" when they graffitied walls, telecom boxes and shop shutters.

    News on the hour 16:59: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    Plans to allow driverless cars to use roads in the West Midlands by next year have been set out today.

    At the moment the vehicles are only allowed on private roads. Professor David Bailey, from Aston Business School, has told Paul Franks it raises a number of issues. Listen live

    Travel updates 16:54:

    The M6 has a lane closed on the exit slip road and there's slow traffic northbound at J7, A34 (Great Barr), because of an accident. There's congestion to J6 A38(M) Aston Expressway.

    And Hob Moor Road in Yardley is blocked in both directions at the Heybarnes Road junction because of a building fire.

    See BBC Travel News for more.

    More on Bordesley Green fire 16:45: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    I've just looked into the fire that has caused the number 17 bus to be diverted.

    West Midlands Fire Service says it has deployed 25 firefighters to a blaze at a lock-up garage in Hob Moor Road, Bordesley Green.

    Bus diversions 16:38:

    NX West Midlands says the number 17 bus service is diverting via Green Lane, Yardley Green Road and Newbridge Rd in both directions due to a building fire on Hob Moor Road.

    Your views 16:30: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service which we write in Birmingham.

    Driverless cars 16:16: via Facebook

    Driverless cars could be tested on the West Midlands' roads next year and we've been asking what you think of the concept.

    Stephen Walton has concerns about the technology and writes: "Sensors and cameras are not going to work when iced over and covered with snow. Road surface conditions should also be able to be considered for speed/breaking."

    Neil Hayward has insurance queries: "I just wonder how the insurance industry will work with driverless cars - If I have one of these cars and it is in a collision with another, as I am not in control would the manufacturer be at fault?"

    PCC By-election 16:05: Birmingham Updates

    tweets: West Midlands Police and Crime Commissioner By-Election on Thursday 21st August birminghamupdates.com/post/928454180...

    WM PCC
    News on the hour 16:00: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    The foreign secretary is insisting the Ebola virus is not currently a threat to Britain.

    This year the disease has killed nearly 700 people in West Africa, where officials are struggling to get the recent outbreak under control.

    A man was given all the all-clear after being tested for the disease when he arrived on a flight at Birmingham Airport on Monday. Listen live

    Plans to expand Edgbaston ground 15:52: Birmingham Post

    Edgbaston Stadium could be expanded by a further 800 seats for the first time in five years to meet huge demand for two matches against India.

    Blues' new signing 15:39:

    Birmingham City have signed Celtic's Scotland Under-19 striker Denny Johnstone on a three-year contract.

    Denny Johnstone

    The 19-year-old has been on trial with the Championship club over the past few weeks and completed his move after a compensation fee was agreed.

    Drugs accused in court 15:28:

    Two men have appeared in court charged with drugs offences after crack-cocaine with a street value of about £50,000 was found at two Black Country addresses.

    The drugs were seized after raids at Henley Close, Great Bridge and Moat Road, Oldbury on Saturday.

    No action over alleged sex assault 15:19:

    A nursing home worker arrested on suspicion of sexually assaulting an 85-year-old man will face no further action, police have confirmed.

    The 25-year-old man worked at the privately-run Warrens Hall Nursing Centre in Tividale, in the Black Country, and was arrested in April.

    'No insurance, no car' 15:08:

    Traffic WMP tweets: Another no insurance seizure @SandwellPolice #noinsurancenocar

    News on the hour 14:55: BBC WM

    West Midlands Police says it's still assessing information received as part of the report into the so-called Trojan Horse plot.

    The force says no crimes have been referred for police investigation directly linked to the alleged plot and no fresh inquiry has been launched. Listen live.

    Police investigate poppy farm 14:47:

    Soho and Vic Police tweets: An unusual call we are currently investigating is the harvesting of poppies @CDTWMP

    Poppies being grown
    Job opportunity at museum 14:38: via Facebook

    The Black Country Living Museum is recruiting and writes: "Interested in history research? We are looking to recruit an apprentice on a 1 year apprenticeship to assist the Collections and Learning Teams."

    The sound of music 14:27: Express and Star

    A live orchestral performance in the middle of a forest has been bringing Cannock Chase to life.

    Special training for firefighters 14:18:

    Hay Mills Fire Station tweets: RTC training with @BillesleyFire Creating space to work & a safe working enviroment. #RTB #operationalexcellence

    Firefighters training
    News on the hour 14:05: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    A man's been checked for the deadly Ebola virus after landing at Birmingham Airport.

    He went to hospital feeling feverish after arriving from a West African country on Monday, but doctors gave him the all clear.

    Iommi nominated for award 13:51: Birmingham Mail
    Activities at the Bullring 13:40:

    National Express tweets: If you're in Birmingham today our coach tour is at the @Bullring again. There's free face painting and the chance win lots of prizes too!

    Commuter cycle ride 13:28:

    Cycle South Brum is running a group ride from Northfield to Birmingham city centre on Tuesday 12 August.

    It is suitable for beginners or existing cyclists who wish to learn a good commuter route into the city centre and will be on roads and some designated cycle routes.

    Coming up 13:16: Midlands Today

    We'll be talking live to Chinu Singh, the Black Country wrestler who won bronze in the Commonwealth Games.

    Join Elizabeth Glinka at 13:30 on BBC One.

    Accident on Lichfield Road 13:07:

    BBC Travel News reports the A4124 Lichfield Road in Bloxwich is closed and there's slow traffic in both directions between the Field Road junction and the A34 Stafford Road junction because of an accident.

    News on the hour 12:55: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    A man's been checked for the deadly Ebola virus after landing at Birmingham Airport.

    He went to hospital feeling feverish after arriving from a West African country on Monday, but doctors gave him the all clear. Listen live

    Birmingham City signing 12:44: Richard Wilford BBC WM Sport

    Blues have added to their strike options by signing 19-year old Denny Johnstone from Celtic.

    Although he was out of contract at Parkhead, Blues have had to pay a compensation fee for the teenager.

    Video: 'Car is driving itself' 12:34:

    Watch the BBC's Rory Cellan-Jones take a ride in a driverless car.

    Driverless car report

    He says the car he was in used a sophisticated GPS system to guide it around the track.

    Birmingham venues on hidden gem list 12:24: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    A number of the national papers, including the Daily Mail and the Independent, are reporting on a new list of "hidden city spots" that has been compiled by American Express.

    Research shows 87% of people admit not taking advantage of what is around them in their hometown or city, with a further 43% acknowledging they are missing out on what their cities have to offer.

    Bloggers from various cities around the UK helped compile the list. Seven Birmingham locations feature on the list, including Moseley Bog, the Custard Factory and the Hockley Flyover.

    CCTV of suspected bank robber 12:12:

    Pictures have been released of a suspected bank robber who claimed he had a gun.

    Police were called to the Washwood Heath Road branch of West Bromwich Building Society last Wednesday afternoon after a man demanded they hand over the contents of the till drawer.

    WM police CCTV

    Anyone with information should call police on 101 or speak to Crimestoppers anonymously on 0800 555 111.

    News on the hour 11:58: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    A man's been checked for the deadly Ebola virus after landing at Birmingham Airport.

    He went to hospital feeling feverish after arriving from a West African country on Monday, but doctors gave him the all clear.

    Public Health England says the risk to people in the UK "remains low". Listen live

    Train services affected 11:46:

    London Midland tweets: The 12:34 and 13:34 services from #LiverpoolLimeStreet to #BirminghamNS will now begin from Crewe at 13:19 and 14:19. Sorry if affected.

    Third Sector project for Birmingham 11:37: via Facebook

    Birmingham City Council are currently running a project named Mapping the Third Sector, which aims to gather information about third sector groups and organisations in our city that are not yet recognised by the council.

    Trojan Horse: Police release statement 11:24:

    West Midlands Police has released a statement saying "contrary to media reports today, no crimes have been referred for police investigation directly linked to the alleged [Trojan Horse] 'plot' and no fresh inquiry has been launched by the force".

    PC commended over arrest 11:14: Stourbridge News

    Brave Dudley cop PC Jessica Preston has been commended for her courage after she put her life in danger to arrest Stefan Rattray.

    Things to do 11:05:

    The BBC has put together a list of Things To Do in the region. Activities include sports and nature trails.

    to do
    News on the hour 10:55: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    It's emerged a man's been checked for the deadly Ebola virus after landing at Birmingham Airport.

    Tests were carried out as a precaution, but doctors gave him the all clear. Listen live

    Sandwell welcomes Stimpson back 10:50: via Facebook

    Sandwell Council writes: "Our very own double gold medal winner Jodie Stimpson is back in Sandwell on Sunday to compete in the Jodie Stimpson Aquathlon at Sandwell Valley Country Park.

    "So please come along and cheer Jodie and all of the competitors on!

    "The 750m Swim starts at 9am from Swan Pool, followed by a 5k run. If you fancy taking part, please register here: http://www.stuweb.co.uk/events/2014/08/03/1669/."

    Your views 10:43: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    We've introduced BBC Local Live in Birmingham and the Black Country to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think about this local service.

    New breed of buses 10:31: Birmingham Post

    A new breed of buses are set for Birmingham's streets within two years under a £15m scheme.

    New wrestling correspondent 10:21: John Bray Assistant editor, BBC Midlands Today

    We've just had the Midlands Today morning meeting where we discuss what stories we're going to cover today.

    I've given Kath Stanczyszyn the task of getting to the bottom of what Oldbury's bronze medal winning wrestler Chinu's surname is, so she's off to Wolverhampton Wrestling Club where he trains.

    New Street work 10:08:

    Birmingham New Street Station says it's "another step closer" as work on the new Hill Street staircase nears completion.

    Bham New St steps July 2014
    News on the hour 09:59: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    The Police Federation in the West Midlands has told BBC WM government cuts are to blame for an increase in attacks on officers.

    It comes a day after a drug dealer was jailed for 10 years for attacking a female officer in Dudley. Listen live

    Disappointment for Hannah 09:47: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    Birmingham based athlete Hannah England finished a disappointing seventh in the 1,500m final last night.

    Compatriot Laura Weightman took the silver though to round off a day of success for Team England.

    Hannah's husband Luke Gunn will be competing in the 3,000m steeplechase later in the week.

    Bank robber dressed as builder 09:35: Express and Star
    Chopra ton helps Bears win 09:24:

    Varun Chopra hit his first century of the summer as Warwickshire made it two wins out of two in the One-Day Cup with victory over Sussex by 118 runs.

    varun chopra
    Good news for hayfever sufferers 09:15:

    Health Brum tweets: Today's #healthybrum pollen count is again low. #hayfever advice ow.ly/vgBq2

    Bronze for Wolves wrestler 09:07: John Bray Assistant editor, BBC Midlands Today

    Congratulations to Wolverhampton wrestler Chinu Xxx, who won bronze last night in the men's 125kg.

    We're hoping to hear from him later - and our priority will be to ask him about his unusual name. Apparently it comes from a bit of confusion with the Passport Office.

    Wolverhampton Wrestling Club call him Chinu Singh so we'll go with that for now.

    News on the hour 09:00: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    It's emerged a man's been checked for the deadly Ebola virus after landing at Birmingham Airport.

    Tests were carried out as a precaution, but doctors gave him the all clear.

    It comes just hours before Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond chairs a meeting of the Cobra emergency committee to discuss the outbreak of Ebola in West Africa.

    Aid agencies there say the disease has killed more than 670 people since February. Mr Hammond says the epidemic "is a threat". Listen live

    Driverless cars to be tested 08:48:

    Driverless cars are to be tested on roads in the West Midlands next year.

    Nissan car

    The vehicles are guided by a system of sensors and cameras and are said to be potentially safer and more efficient than normal cars.

    The government is to outline measures later to permit driverless cars to use public roads by next year.

    • News, sport, travel, weather for Wed 30 July
    • More updates from 08:00 on Thursday
    • Listen to BBC WM
    Protest over council flag decision 08:36: Birmingham Mail

    Gaza supporters are to stage a silent protest in Victoria Square after Birmingham City Council refused to fly the Palestine flag.

    Trojan Horse: No criminal investigation 08:27: Kath Stanczyszyn Political reporter, BBC WM

    West Midlands Police says there will be no Trojan Horse criminal investigation following the recently published Clarke Report into the alleged takeover of certain Birmingham schools by hardline Muslims.

    Information is "still being assessed" though.

    Travel updates 08:17:

    Two lanes are closed and there's queuing traffic on the M42 northbound between J7a M6 and J8 M6 because of over-running roadworks. Travel time is about 25 minutes and there's congestion to J6, A45 (Birmingham Airport).

    There are also delays in and around Birmingham city centre because of the planned tunnel closures. See BBC Travel News for more.

    Brighter later 08:07:

    A mainly fine and dry day once again. Often fairly cloudy through the morning, but becoming brighter with some warm sunny spells into the afternoon and early evening.


    See BBC Weather for more information.

    Good morning 08:00: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    I'll be bringing you the latest news, sport, weather and travel throughout the day for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    You can get in touch by emailing locallive@bbc.co.uk.



Elsewhere on the BBC

  • ClockMore for less?

    Could spending less time in the office make you perform more efficiently?


  • A factory in JapanThe Travel Show Watch

    Factory infatuation – why Japan’s industrial compounds are drawing large crowds at night

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.