Remembering the DC-10: End of an era or good riddance?

Biman Bangladesh Airlines DC-10 Biman Bangladesh Airlines is the last commercial carrier to use DC-10 aircraft

The DC-10, which makes its final passenger flight later, has been labelled a "death trap", hailed as a "workhorse" and even immortalised in a Clash song.

For some, the controversial aircraft's last landing at Birmingham Airport will mark the end of an era in consumer aviation. But how will the rest of the world remember it?

First put into service in 1971, the American-made "trijet" was one of several aircraft credited with shaping modern air travel.

But its early history was marred by several high-profile crashes as the result of a fatal design flaw.

'Horrific accidents'

A new, outward-opening cargo door did not latch properly, leaving the cabin prone to depressurising.

In 1974, a Turkish Airlines DC-10 crashed 10 minutes after taking off from Paris, killing 346 people. Modifications to all DC-10 cargo doors were ordered by the US Federal Aviation Authority (FAA)

On 25 May 1979, 271 people died when an American Airlines DC-10 crashed just after take-off in Chicago. A short-cut maintenance procedure which damaged hydraulic lines was identified as the cause.

Six days later, the plane's poor safety reputation led the FAA to temporarily ground the aircraft while manufacturer McDonnell Douglas addressed issues with the plane's design.

Even after it returned to the air, there were other high-profile incidents involving the DC-10.

DC-10 wreckage A Turkish Airlines DC-10 crashed outside Paris in 1974, killing 346 people
Workers prepare a DC-10 The final international flight left Dhaka for Birmingham on Thursday
Pilot checks controls Some of the DC-10 crew will retire alongside the plane

A Fedex employee attempted to hijack one of the company's cargo planes in 1994 while a French flight was blown up by terrorists over the Sahara desert in September 1989, killing 170 people.

In total there have been 53 serious incidents - not all fatal - involving the aircraft.

But the DC-10 has, until this week, continued to be used to carry passengers, and, in one case, been repurposed as an airborne operating theatre. It also remains popular as a cargo plane.

Its expensive three-engine design has seen it gradually disappear from passenger fleets, with the USA's Northwest Airlines, which dropped the DC-10 in 2007, the last major company to use the plane.

A brief history of the DC-10

DC-10 nosecone
  • 1971 - The first DC-10s enter service
  • June 1972 - Problems with the planes' cargo doors are identified after a depressurised cabin forces an emergency landing near Detroit
  • March 1974 - A Turkish Airlines DC-10 bound for London crashes 10 minutes after taking off from Paris, killing 346 people
  • May 1979 - A crash involving an American Airlines DC-10 kills all 271 people on board - the deadliest accidental plane crash on US soil
  • 6 June 1979 - The Federal Aviation Authority grounds all DC-10 aircraft
  • 13 July 1979 - DC-10s are allowed back into service by the FAA, which orders a number of fixes to the aircrafts' design
  • 1990 - McDonnell-Douglas begins to roll out MD-11 aircraft to replace the DC-10
  • 2014 - Biman Bangladesh, the last commercial operator using the planes, announces it will retire them

Biman Bangladesh Airlines - the only commercial carrier still using the DC-10 - will replace its remaining aircraft with a more fuel-efficient Boeing 777.

It made a final international journey from Dhaka, Bangladesh, on Thursday, and will carry passengers for the final time on a one-hour pleasure flight at 15:00 GMT.

Plane enthusiast Gordon Stretch, from Solihull, travelled to Dhaka to travel on the Biman Bangladesh Airlines flight.

He pointed out that, of 446 DC-10 aircraft built, a relatively small number were involved in fatal crashes.

"There have been high-profile crashes for every type of aircraft," he said.

"They only built 20 Concordes and one of those crashed.

"I wouldn't say the DC-10 was an unsafe aircraft, there was a specific problem and the maintenance procedures at the time weren't up to speed.

"Sadly these things do happen and the only way is to learn from that."

Aviation expert Chris Yates agreed the DC-10 may have been unfairly maligned by some and too much focus placed on high-profile crashes.

"There were some pretty horrific accidents a number of years ago and ultimately it was grounded for a while," he said.

"But then it got back in the air and it was all go really."

Some say the DC-10, which was capable of carrying 250 to 380 passengers, paved the way for mass long-haul air travel.

Radio 2 presenter Janice Long worked as an air stewardess for British airline Laker Airways, whose flamboyant chairman Sir Freddie Laker introduced the DC-10 to Europe.

Laker Airways DC-10 Laker Airways was the first British and European airline to use the DC-10

She remembers a luxurious plane where passengers had their every need attended to.

"It had a bad press at the time but I had just turned 19 when I started on the DC-10 so I had no fear," she said.

"It was fantastic; there were 345 passengers and 10 stewardesses.

"For a girl from Bootle who had never been abroad to suddenly be flying on this huge plane was just amazing."

"Laker was bringing flying to the masses, you just bought your ticket and got on the plane.

"The passengers got everything, breakfast, lunch and liqueurs and they didn't pay any extra for it."

Long is not the only person who remembers the DC-10 fondly.

Nicholas Chiu Nicholas Chiu travelled from Edinburgh to see the plane land in Birmingham
Rob Edson Rob Edson said he felt older planes had "more character" than modern jets

When the plane made its last international flight on Thursday, dozens of enthusiasts turned up at Birmingham Airport to watch its final landing.

University Student Nicholas Chiu, 21, originally from Hong Kong, travelled from Edinburgh.

"It's the last scheduled flight, so that's historic," he said.

"I remember this plane used to fly out of Hong Kong a lot. I last flew on one a few years ago and I didn't want to miss the last chance to see it."

Airline operations manager Rob Edson, 34, also turned up in the hope of spotting the DC-10.

"I thought it was worth coming to see it," he said.

"It's another old [aircraft] type disappearing to be replaced with a modern one.

"It's sad that they're going; they've got a bit more character than the new ones."

DC-10 The final international DC-10 flight landed in Birmingham on Thursday

Gordon Stretch said he hoped the DC-10 would be remembered as paving the way for modern distance flight.

"It's an airliner of the first age of long-haul travel," he said.

Chris Yates said, despite its history, he believed the DC-10 would leave behind a "hell of a legacy".

"It was one of the big jets which did essentially open up long haul markets to the masses," he said.

"Without them I guess we'd be a lot further back than we are now."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country

Weather

Birmingham

Min. Night 3 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    16:26: BBC young voter panel

    If you are aged between 18 and 24, and eligible to vote in May's General Election, the BBC wants to hear from you.

    BBC generation 2015 project

    BBC Politics is building Generation 2015, a UK-wide group of young voters who will take part in local and national BBC programmes in the run up to the General Election in May.

    You could find yourself on the One Show, Radio 1 Newsbeat, or Newsnight - in fact, anywhere across BBC output where the Election is being discussed. Read more online now.

     
  2.  
    16:13: Ed Doolan: My Life with dementia Caroline Martin BBC WM Presenter

    "I've spent my entire life communicating and suddenly I realise I can't do it anymore. Sometimes I go blank." Ed Doolan talks about his diagnosis of dementia.

    Caroline Martin talking to Ed Doolan about dementia

    Ed has been speaking to me about his diagnosis of dementia. We've put the interview online - hear our conversation with Ed and his wife Christine now.

     
  3.  
    15:56: News on the hour Alice Rosenthal Journalist, BBC WM

    In the news at 16:00 on BBC WM: A Birmingham teenager's been jailed for five years after admitting dangerous driving following a car crash which killed a grandfather and injured a nine-year-old boy.

    Kirpal Sokhi

    The collision happened on Bills Lane in Shirley last August.

    Kirpal Sokhi (pictured) from Sparkhill was driving at 80 mph in a 30 mph zone - without insurance or permission to drive the Range Rover he was in.

     
  4.  
    15:40: Herd loaned to Wigan BBC Sport

    Aston Villa midfielder Chris Herd has joined Wigan Athletic on loan.

    Chris Herd

    He will be with the Latics until the end of the season.

    The Australia international hasn't featured for Villa since December 2013 and is out of contract in the summer.

     
  5.  
    15:27: Ghosts signs Satnam Rana Arts reporter, BBC Midlands Today

    I'm out on the hunt for faded advertising wall art. I've been filming in a workshop filming with a traditional sign maker.

    Traditional sign maker

    If you spot any today then email or tweet @BBCMTD.

    Do you think we should we keep them or let them fade out?

     
  6.  
    15:13: Heartlands Hospital treats 1,500 FGM victims Birmingham Mail

    A Birmingham hospital has dealt with 1,500 cases of Female Genital Mutilation (FGM) in just five years.

    The shocking statistic was discussed this week at a meeting of the West Midlands Police and Crime Panel.

     
  7.  
    14:56: News on the hour Alice Rosenthal Journalist, BBC WM

    BBC WM presenter Ed Doolan has revealed publicly for the first time that he is living with dementia.

    More on this in our 15:00 bulletin.

     
  8.  
    14:48: Rose Nose Day 2015

    This year's Comic Relief campaign has been launched.

    Red Nose Appeal 2015

    Last year - £2.5m was raised by people in the West Midlands - and this year's campaign is "make your face funny for money".

    This year nine noses have been launched, question is, which one is your favourite?

    Put it in your diary - Friday 13 March.

     
  9.  
    14:29: 'A big part of me died' Bob Hockenhull Reporter, Midlands Today

    The family of Cynthia Beamond from Halesowen have been speaking outside court after the case was formally closed following the the death of the accused Leo Barnes.

    The daughter of Cynthia Beamond, Beverley Hadley

    "Mum was not just my mum but also my best friend," said her daughter Beverley Hadley (pictured wearing blue jacket).

    She added: "She always called me her rock but she was also mine. Not a day would go by when we wouldn't speak or text. A big part of me died when my beloved mum died."

     
  10.  
    14:10: Case formally concluded Bob Hockenhull Reporter, Midlands Today

    The Leo Barnes court case was formally concluded after a police officer identified his body as the same person he had interviewed about the murders of Cynthia Beamond and Philip Silverstone.

    West Midlands Police say they will not be looking for anyone else in connection with their murders, saying the "evidence was over whelming".

     
  11.  
    13:59: News on the hour Alice Rosenthal Journalist, BBC WM

    West Midlands Police says it won't be looking for anyone else in connection with the murders of Cynthia Beamond from Halesowen, and Philip Silverstone from London.

    Officers say say the evidence against Leo Barnes "was overwhelming". More in the news at 14:00

     
  12.  
    13:37: Birmingham's MIPIM cohort larger than ever Birmingham Post

    City's delegation heading to south of France in March will be showcasing developments including Paradise and Resorts World.

    The region is taking more partners than ever before at real estate show MIPIM with New Street station, Resorts World and Grand Central expected to draw crowds.

    Thirty people will make up the Greater Birmingham delegation at the global real estate show in Cannes this March, made up of public and private professionals.

     
  13.  
    13:21: Ed Doolan: 'I have dementia' Caroline Martin BBC WM Presenter

    Recently I sat down with BBC WM broadcasting legend Ed Doolan and his wife Christine.

    Ed Doolan

    Ed revealed publicly for the first time that he has been diagnosed with dementia.

    You can hear the interview on BBC WM now.

     
  14.  
    13:10: BBC One this lunchtime Joanne Malin Presenter, Midlands Today

    From today the Midlands Today lunchtime bulletin is on slighter later than usual at 13:38 and has been shortened but it's still packed with local stories.

    Today the latest from Wolverhampton Crown Court as a man standing trial for murder is found dead in his prison cell.

    Plus we'll have the latest weather forecast from Sara Blizzard.

     
  15.  
    13:00: News on the hour Alice Rosenthal Journalist, BBC WM

    In the news at 13:00 on BBC WM: It's emerged a double murder suspect from Birmingham whose been found dead in his prison cell was being monitored for self harm.

     
  16.  
    12:44: Tram delays

    The Metro tweets: Midland Metro - Trams are operating from Snow Hill to Priestfield only. This is due to very heavy congestion on the street. Metro apologises

     
  17.  
    12:33: Your Story Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    Who was number in the charts when you were born?

    BBC Your Story

    BBC Taster is giving you the opportunity to try the new tool Your Story that intertwines your back story with BBC News archive.

     
  18.  
    12:14: '93 passengers onboard' Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    United Airlines said in a statement: "A Boeing 757-200 aircraft with 93 customers and a crew of 9 on board, was cancelled following a mechanical issue."

    "The necessary maintenance work could not be completed before the crew exceeded their legally permitted duty hours."

     
  19.  
    11:59: News on the hour Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    Our top story in the news at 12:00 on BBC WM: The Ministry of Justice has confirmed that a Birmingham murder suspect found dead in his prison cell at HMP Hewell was on suicide watch.

    Five deaths were recorded at the jail last year and Juliet Lyon from the Prison Reform Trust says another one makes the situation even more worrying.

     
  20.  
    11:51: Child killer funeral Joanne Malin Presenter, Midlands Today

    It's emerged funeral costs for the Walsall child-killer Raymond Morris, who died in prison last year, were paid by the Prison Service.

    Walsall child-killer Raymond Morris

    Morris was jailed for life for the 1967 murder of a seven-year-old girl. Her death, along with two others became known as the Cannock Chase Murders.

    Guidelines suggest prisons offer to pay towards funeral expenses, if a prisoner dies in custody.

     
  21.  
    11:41: 'Mechanical issue' Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    A flight which left Birmingham Airport this morning and turned back shortly after take off landed due to a mechanical issue.

    The United Airlines flight was bound for New York at about 09:00.

    A spokesperson for the airline's told me Flight UA26 from Birmingham to Newark was abandoned after the necessary maintenance could not be done.

     
  22.  
    11:26: Cynthia Beamond: 'A wonderful woman' Bob Hockenhull Reporting from Wolverhampton Crown Court

    At the trial of Leo Barnes, Stephen Linehan QC's told the jury that Cynthia Beamond's family had been concerned about the accused visiting her, but she saw the good in everyone - the judge thanked the jury and dismissed them.

    Mr Justice Haddon Cave then told the family in the public gallery that no one is in any doubt what a wonderful woman Cynthia Beamond was, and she will be truly missed by all who knew her.

    The accused, who denied murder, was found hanged in his cell at HMP Hewell in Redditch yesterday.

     
  23.  
    11:16: Delph extends Aston Villa contract BBC Sport

    Aston Villa midfielder Fabian Delph has signed a new four-and-a-half-year deal with the club.

    Fabian Delph

    The 25-year-old England international was out of contract in the summer but will now stay at the Premier League side until at least 2019.

    "I am a loyal person and committing my future will hopefully show everybody what type of guy I am," he said.

     
  24.  
    11:00: News on the hour Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    The violent pasts of around 1,300 people - including 45 in the West Midlands have been revealed to their partners.

    Hear more on this story and others in the news bulletin at 11:00.

     
  25.  
    10:42: Murder trial Bob Hockenhull Reporter, Midlands Today

    I'm at Wolverhampton Crown Court following the murder trial of two pensioners - Cynthia Beamond, from Halesowen, and Philip Silverstone, of London.

    The accused, Leo Barnes was found dead in his cell on Sunday.

    Proceedings are just about to get under way. The prosecution team has just asked for the jury to be brought in.

     
  26.  
    10:32: Have your say Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  27.  
    10:21: 'Accused was being monitored' Caroline Gall BBC News

    I've just spoken to the Ministry of Justice who have confirmed Leo Barnes was being monitored in his cell at HMP Hewell in Redditch for self-harm.

    Leo Barnes

    The 33-year-old, who denied murder, was found hanged in his cell on Sunday.

     
  28.  
    10:03: Flight returns to airport Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    I've just spoken to Birmingham Airport which confirms a flight leaving the airport this morning heading to New York-Newark at about 09:00 has returned back to the airport.

    The United Airlines flight UA 026 returned to Birmingham at about 09:45. The reason for the return is currently unknown.

    I've put a call into the airline's press office for more details and will bring you information when we have it.

     
  29.  
    10:00: News on the hour Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    In the news at 10:00 on BBC WM: An investigation is underway after a Birmingham man accused of murdering two pensioners has been found dead in his prison cell.

     
  30.  
    09:45: Birmingham's first 'Instameet' via Facebook

    Birmingham Updates posts: Birmingham Instagram exhibition launches following official Instameet success.

    Around 50 intagramers from across the city and beyond gathered at the Library of Birmingham on Saturday (24/01) for Birmingham's first official Instameet. Read more on Storify.

     
  31.  
    09:28: Woman jailed after dogs starved Express and Star

    A pet owner from Halesowen has been jailed for five months after she failed to care for her two starving two dogs - with one dying as a result of her neglect.

    Jodi Russell, from Hillwood Road, was sentenced at Dudley Magistrates Court after magistrate Neville Jinks described the animal cruelty case as 'one of the worst the court had seen'.

     
  32.  
    09:11: Villa 2-1 Bournemouth BBC Sport

    Aston Villa have joined West Bromwich Albion in the last 16 of the FA Cup after a 2-1 home victory yesterday afternoon over Championship leaders Bournemouth.

    Aston Villa's Carles Gil

    Carles Gil's stunning goal helped Aston Villa avoid another FA Cup fourth-round giant-killing.

     
  33.  
    08:56: News on the hour Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    A double murder suspect from Birmingham has been found dead in his prison cell.

    In the news at 09:00 we'll get reaction from Juliet Lyon from the Prison Reform Trust.

     
  34.  
    08:43: Rail problems

    London Midland tweets: Owing to signalling problems between Northfield & Longbridge services are currently having to run at reduced speed.

     
  35.  
    08:32: Delays on the roads BBC Travel
    • One lane is closed on the M42 northbound between junctions 5 and 6 due to a broken down vehicle.
    • The A4123 Birmingham Road is closed in Wolverhampton due to an accident.

    Read about the latest disruptions on BBC Travel.

     
  36.  
    08:17: Murder accused found dead

    A man currently on trial for the murder of two pensioners has been found dead in his prison cell.

    Cynthia Beamond

    Leo Barnes was accused of murdering Cynthia Beamond (pictured), from Halesowen, and Philip Silverstone, of London, on consecutive days in June last year.

    West Midlands Police say the 33-year-old, who denied murder, was found hanged in his cell at HMP Hewell in Redditch yesterday.

     
  37.  
    08:06: Today's forecast Sara Blizzard Weather Presenter, BBC East Midlands Today

    Rain across the region at first will clear quickly this morning. It will then be dry with sunny spells, the best of which will be in the south and east.

    Sara Blizzard

    Cool in a northwesterly breeze with a high of 9C (48F).

     
  38.  
    08:00: Good morning Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    I'm in the BBC Birmingham newsroom bringing you the very latest news, sport, travel and weather for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    If you'd like to get in touch with the BBC Local Live team today - email or tweet @BBCWM.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

Programmes

  • Robbie RogersHARDtalk Watch

    Gay footballer Robbie Rogers on locker room homophobia and the ‘pack mentality’ in soccer

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.