'Trojan Horse': Campaign to impose 'faith-based' ideology

Aerial view of Park View School Park View School was one of five schools rated inadequate by Ofsted and put into special measures

Related Stories

Head teachers claim there was an organised campaign to impose a "narrow, faith-based ideology" at some schools in Birmingham, Ofsted has said.

The watchdog has placed five of the city's schools in special measures after "deeply worrying" findings.

It inspected 21 schools after an anonymous letter alleging a Muslim takeover plot was circulated.

Ofsted chief Sir Michael Wilshaw said a number of schools inspected were "doing well" to promote social awareness.

Inspectors carried out monitoring visits at 16 schools, and full inspections at the five schools branded inadequate.

Governors 'too involved'

These included Park View School, Golden Hillock School and Nansen Primary, run by the Park View Educational Trust.

Oldknow Academy, in Small Heath, and Saltley School were also put into special measures.

Reports found music lessons had been removed from the timetable at Nansen, where Muslim pupils exhibited "limited knowledge" of other religions.

Governance and leadership was particularly criticised at all five schools rated inadequate.

David Hughes, Park View Education Trust: ''The speed and the ferocity with which the school had been condemned was truly shocking''

Sir Michael said teachers at some of the schools inspected had reported being unfairly treated due to their faith and gender.

He said inspectors had "uncovered evidence of unfair and opaque recruitment practices, including examples of relatives being appointed to unadvertised senior posts".

"Although exam results are often good, the curriculum has become too narrow, reflecting the personal views of a small number of governors, rather than the wider community in Birmingham and beyond," he said.

Sir Michael also criticised Birmingham City Council for its "failure to support schools in their efforts to keep pupils safe from the risk of extremism".

"There's been a lack of urgency in the council's response to persistent complaints from head teachers about the conduct of certain governors," he said.

Ofsted's key findings at five inadequate schools

  • Nansen Primary was criticised for the leadership of the school as well as pupils' behaviour. Ofsted said: "The governing body has removed some subjects, such as music, from the timetable." It added that the school "does not prepare pupils adequately for life in modern Britain".
  • Inspectors recommended Oldknow Academy was put in special measures despite being rated outstanding in some categories. The report said a small group of governors was "making significant changes to the ethos and culture of the academy without full consultation". "They are endeavouring to promote a particular and narrow faith-based ideology in what is a maintained and non-faith academy," it said.
  • Saltley School, previously rated good, was criticised in every area, including governance, teaching standards, pupils' achievement, safety and leadership. Inspectors also criticised financial management at the school and relationships between senior staff and governors.
  • Ofsted found Park View School did not do enough to alert students to the risks of extremism. It said speakers invited to the school were not vetted and pupils were not taught about the safe use of the internet. Pupils are not given adequate preparation for living in a multi-cultural society, it said.
  • At Golden Hillock, inspectors concluded leaders and governors were "not doing enough to mitigate against cultural isolation". Ofsted concluded it "could leave students vulnerable to the risk of marginalisation from wider British society".

Park View Educational Trust said it "wholeheartedly disputed" the watchdog's findings and would mount a legal challenge to them.

Vice chair of Park View Educational Trust Dave Hughes accused inspectors of operating in a "climate of suspicion".

"Ofsted inspectors came to our school looking for extremism, looking for segregation, looking for proof that our children have religion forced upon them as part of a religious plot," he said.

"The Ofsted reports find no evidence of this, because this is categorically not what is happening at our schools.

"Our schools do not tolerate extremism of any kind," he added.

Map of 21 schools

The trust said Golden Hillock was "categorically not an inadequate school" and had only been part of the trust for five months when it was inspected.

"A number of the judgments are based on data and information that pre‐date the trust's involvement," it said.

In a statement, Saltley School said Ofsted had "found not the slightest shred of evidence" of an extremist influence at the school.

"Parents and the wider community can be wholly confident that students here are safe and well looked after," it said.

Sir Albert Bore: "There has been a failure of governance and we are party to that along with the Department for Education"

Head of Birmingham City Council Sir Albert Bore said the authority was "reassured that no evidence of a plot or conspiracy have been found by Ofsted".

"It is clear from Ofsted's inspection findings and Sir Michael Wilshaw's report that some governors do not fulfil their roles and responsibilities and have interfered improperly in the ethos, policies and day-to-day running of certain schools," he said.

Head of the National Association of Head Teachers Russell Hobby said he believed the original "Trojan Horse" letter was a hoax but had elements of truth within it.

"It's a mixture of the true and the false. The root of this is not a true document in its entirety," he said.

Arshad Malik Parent Arshad Malik said he felt inspectors had been biased in their approach

Mr Hobby was speaking at a press conference attended by the head teachers of schools involved in the Trojan Horse probe.

Bhupinder Kondal, principal of Oldknow Academy, said she was removed from her post in January against her will.

Anderson Park head Sarah Hewitt-Clarkson said "none of the contents of the Trojan Horse letter came as a shock".

Another head teacher, speaking anonymously, told the BBC they had been "bullied" into employing a senior member of staff with no experience.

Arshad Malik, whose son, Imran, attends Park View School, said he believed people were "trying to use this school to push their own agendas".

"‎Inspectors came with loaded questions...This issue is a political football," he said.

Gaafar Tariq, a taxi driver and father-of-five, has two children who attend Nansen Primary School.

The 47-year-old said: "I don't think there's any concern about extremism in this area and these reports prove it. I don't see any problem with this school."

The 21 schools inspected
  • Adderley Primary School
  • Alston Primary School
  • Chillwell Croft Academy
  • Golden Hillock School - A Park View Academy
  • Gracelands Nursery School
  • Heathfield Primary School
  • Highfield Junior and Infant School
  • Ladypool Primary School
  • Marlborough Junior School
  • Montgomery Primary Academy
  • Nansen Primary School - A Park View Academy
  • Ninestiles School - An Academy
  • Oldknow Academy
  • Park View School Academy of Mathematics and Science
  • Regents Park Community Primary School
  • Saltley School and Specialist Science College
  • Shaw Primary School
  • Small Heath School
  • Washwood Heath Academy
  • Waverley School
  • Welford Primary School

More on This Story

Related Stories

BBC Birmingham & Black Country



Min. Night 15 °C

BBC Local Live

    Good evening 18:00:

    BBC Local Live will be back from 08:00 on Thursday with the latest news, sport, travel and weather updates for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    Dry overnight 17:50:

    It will be a mostly dry evening, but cloud will continue to thicken from the south west with outbreaks of rain gradually spreading north eastwards overnight.

    Dry, clear conditions will follow into the west by dawn. A minimum temperature of 12C (54F).

    Coming up 17:40: Nick Owen Presenter, Midlands Today

    We're talking about a world first in the newsroom here. It's a fascinating story about how a donated liver was delayed on its way to a patient in Birmingham's Queen Elizabeth Hospital.

    It actually took seven hours to get there - and usually anything over four hours means it's too late. Surgeons used a new technique to revive the organ so they could operate successfully.

    Find out more in Midlands Today on BBC One at 18:30.

    Housing advice 17:37:

    Dudley Council tweets: INFO: Live in Brierley Hill & worried about keeping your home? Advice at Chapel St, every Thur, 10am-12noon. goo.gl/Z4YVQV

    Feedback 17:36: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you news, sport, travel and weather updates in one place. We'd like to know what you think of the service, written right here in Birmingham.

    'Excited' by liver resuscitation 17:33: Giles Latcham Reporter, Midlands Today

    Transplant surgeons in Birmingham are celebrating a world first - giving a patient a liver which would normally have been considered unusable.

    Organ transplant machine

    I met a businessman from Walsall who now has a new liver and it's thanks to this procedure pioneered here in Birmingham.

    It is basically resuscitating a liver that has been on ice much longer than desired by doctors, but is still useable. One of the surgeons, Thamara Perera, who performed the operation which took more than nine hours, says he's very happy and excited by the development.

    College to open India centre 17:31:

    A British college is to open a training centre in India, as part of plans to strengthen ties between the two countries through education.

    Bournville College

    Birmingham's Bournville College expects to open the £500,000 centre, specialising in technical education and healthcare, in Kolkata, by the end of the year.

    The news was announced as part of a trade delegation to India led by Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg.

    Birmingham bike scheme 17:29:

    A bicycle rental scheme open to Birmingham's commuters, residents and visitors has begun operating in the city centre.

    Man in body suit at launch of scheme
    Crash death woman named 17:27:

    An 81-year-old woman from Rubery who died in a three-car accident has been named by police. Read more on BBC News.

    Baby brought back to life 17:23: Birmingham Mail

    When he flashes a beaming smile, it's hard to imagine little Samuel Stables locked in a fight for his life.

    But the nine-month-old - who was once so ill that his mother could not hold him - survived no fewer than three cardiac arrests within a week of his birth.

    WW1 memorabilia valuations 17:18: Louise Brierley BBC WM Journalist

    Do you have any First World War memorabilia lying around in your attic?

    Bargain Hunt auctioneer Charles Hanson

    Bargain Hunt auctioneer Charles Hanson is coming along to the public space here at BBC Birmingham between 11:00 and 16:00 tomorrow to give free valuations of your WW1 antiques.

    He'll also be speaking to BBC WM's Paul Franks on the drivetime show today from 16:00.

    Crash death man named 17:13:

    A 59-year-old man who died in a car crash Solihull has been named by police.

    Stephen Beckett was driving a Vauxhall Astra in Bills Lane on 17 August when a crash involving a Range Rover happened. The man died at the scene - his grandson who was a passenger, remains in a serious condition in hospital.

    The 19-year-old driver of the Range Rover was arrested on suspicion of causing death by dangerous driving. Anyone with information is urged to contact West Midlands Police on 101.

    Trade in India 17:10:

    The West Midlands office for the Cabinet Office Regional News Network tweets: Did you know trade to India from the West Mids is worth £267,726,000? #UKIndia

    The principal of Bournville College is currently in India meeting Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg, along with the Indian government.

    Aston Villa v Leyton Orient 17:04:

    Joe Cole is in line to make his full Aston Villa debut and Shay Given could make his first start of the season in the League Cup match against Leyton Orient tonight.

    Hear match build-up and updates on the game on BBC WM 95.6 FM and DAB radio from 18:00.

    Library stats 17:02: Matt Lee BBC News, West Midlands

    Here are a couple of figures I've found out while researching the feature I'm writing about the Library of Birmingham, as it prepares to celebrate a year since opening its doors:

    • More than 2.7m people have visited the Library of Birmingham in its first year, managers say
    • People have borrowed about 316,000 books, DVDs and CDs since £189m building opened on 3 September 2013
    • Figures released by the city council show its website has had more than three million page views
    News on the hour 16:56: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    Police say they're concerned for the welfare of a Walsall man who's been missing for almost a week.

    Jason Whitehouse

    Jason Whitehouse, 43, from Willenhall, was last seen on 21 August at Walsall Manor Hospital where he'd been receiving treatment. Hear more in the bulletin.

    Black Country Echoes project 16:49: via Facebook

    Dudley Borough Council posts: "Exhibitions, events and entertainment will be on offer at venues across Dudley as part of a project to celebrate the Black Country's manufacturing creativity and innovation - Echoes."

    Bus sexual assault 16:40:

    A 59-year-old man from Dudley has been charged with a sexual assault on a bus in Cradley Heath earlier this year, police say.

    How to teach 'disruptive children' 16:26:

    Baverstock Academy, in Kings Heath, is pioneering a new way of teaching disruptive pupils and says it will go to any length to keep them in mainstream education.

    Baverstock Academy in Kings Heath

    Last year more than 146,000 children were excluded - 3,900 on a permanent basis - across the country.

    The Birmingham academy says it doesn't exclude disruptive children and promises that each will achieve at least five GCSEs.

    See more on this on BBC One tonight in Panorama: Last Chance Academy at 21:00.

    BBC One this Monday 16:14: Inside Out

    Inside Out West Midlands is back for a new series on Monday with surprising stories from familiar places on BBC One from 19:30.

    BBC Inside Out presenter Andy Akinwolere

    Former Blue Peter presenter Andy Akinwolere is fronting the current affairs programme.

    See the trailer for the new series on YouTube now.

    News on the hour 15:58: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    Coming up in the news at 16:00 we'll hear from one of the consultants who carried out a liver transplant in which a liver was revived through pumping oxygenated blood through it.

    Hear more in the news on BBC WM shortly.

    College to open centre in India 15:47: Birmingham Post

    Bournville College is to open a £500,000 centre of excellence in Kolkata as part of a drive to reinforce links between educational institutions in the UK and India.

    'The Jewellery Quarter at War' 15:31:

    A series of special drama performances in the Smith & Pepper factory, at the Museum of the Jewellery Quarter, takes place next month.

    See and hear about the story of the family business and what life was like during World War One. Read more on the Birmingham Museums website.

    Getting warmer next week 15:14: Charlie Slater Weather Presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    There's lots of talk that the weather will settle down next week and get warmer! Here's the high pressure that's doing the work on Monday.

    Weather map for Monday
    News on the hour 14:58: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    A West Midlands-wide transport smart card is still being worked on, according to the boss of London Midland.

    Hear more on that story and others at 15:00 on BBC WM.

    Pub 'at risk' 14:48: B31 Voices

    Local businesses and residents are concerned after a supermarket has put forward several planning applications to construct a small store on the car park of an historic pub. Read more online now.

    Hiding behind air spoiler 14:39:

    A man has been arrested in Birmingham after he was discovered hiding behind the air spoiler of a lorry that had travelled on motorways from the south coast, says West Midlands Police.

    Motorway police were alerted by the driver who dialled 999 at about 18:30 yesterday to report strange sounds coming from the top of his cab.

    The driver had travelled from Calais and had pulled over on the northbound carriageway of the M6 between J6 and 7 to investigate the noise.

    Woman's £1m scratchcard win 14:28: Express and Star

    A bride-to-be from Wolverhampton today told how she went weak at the knees when she realised she'd scooped £1m on a scratchcard.

    Three charged with attempted murder 14:18:

    Three men have been charged with attempted murder in connection with an outbreak of violence in Birmingham.

    Scene of the disorder

    A total of 11 people have been arrested in connection with the disorder in Sparkbrook in July which saw one man fatally stabbed and others injured, reports BBC News Online.

    News on the hour 13:56: BBC WM

    In the 14:00 news bulletin: Bosses at London Midland have told BBC WM they're still working with other transport providers to bring in a West Midlands travel pass.

    Vehicle seized with 600 chickens 13:46:

    Central motorway police unit tweets: This vehicle just seized after being driven with no insurance...600 chickens inside rear were not harmed! #noinsur

    White van being towed away
    Birmingham v Sunderland 13:32:

    Birmingham City face Premier League opposition again in the League Cup tonight as they welcome Sunderland to St Andrew's.

    Blues beat Swansea before being knocked out on penalties by Stoke in this competition last year.

    Hear full match build-up and commentary on BBC WM (not available online) from 18:00.

    Coming up on BBC One 13:17: Abigail Uden Producer, BBC Midlands Today

    We've been to the new Queen Elizabeth hospital in Birmingham where they've carried out a world first - successfully transplanting a liver which would previously have been unusable.

    Operating theatre at the new Queen Elizabeth hospital in Birmingham

    Plus we have a report about how councils can save money and support wildlife by planting wildflowers instead of formal beds.

    See more on BBC Midlands Today at 13:25.

    Walsall prostitution concerns 13:07: BBC WM

    People living in a part of Walsall say they're concerned a police crackdown on prostitution in their area isn't working.

    Residents in Pleck say there are now more working girls than before and they're afraid to leave their homes during the day. There's also reports of local women being hassled by kerb crawlers.

    Police say they carry out regular patrols and they're working to tackle the issue - but a dedicated team have been moved to other duties.

    News on the hour 12:57: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    In the news at 13:00: Patrick Verwer, from London Midland rail company, says fare dodgers are costing it up to £10m a year.

    Hear more on that story and others in the news shortly.

    Library anniversary 12:49: Matt Lee BBC News, West Midlands

    I've been to the Library of Birmingham this morning to talk to its director Brian Gambles about the upcoming anniversary of its opening.

    Library of Birmingham

    The £189m building was officially opened on 3 September and has been nominated for 11 different design and architecture awards.

    You can read about how popular the library has been in its first year on the BBC news website next week.

    Feeling warm 12:36: Charlie Slater Weather Presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    There's plenty of sunshine today in the West Midlands, with cloud building later. Here's what it should look like later this afternoon.

    Forecast for this afternoon

    Keep up to date with the latest forecast on BBC Weather.

    Reviving a liver for transplant 12:23: Giles Latcham Reporter, Midlands Today

    I'm filming transplant surgeons at the Queen Elizabeth Hospital in Birmingham who are celebrating a world first.

    They've given a patient from Walsall a liver which travelled 200 miles and took seven hours to reach them.

    That delay might well have made the liver unusable - but medics pumped blood and oxygen through it to revive it. See my report today on BBC One at 13:25 and 18:30.

    Attempted murder charges 12:09:

    Three men are due in court charged with attempted murder after a man was stabbed in the neck during disorder in Sparkbrook last month, says West Midlands Police.

    News on the hour 11:55: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    Bosses at London Midland say they're working with other transport providers to bring in an integrated travel pass in the West Midlands.

    Patrick Verwer has been in the Hotseat with Adrian Goldberg this hour- hear more in the news at 12:00 on BBC WM.

    Rail boss takes your calls 11:44: Michelle Dawes Producer, BBC WM

    The chief executive of London Midland Patrick Verwer is live on air and taking your calls.

    In the past few minutes he has pledged to put a clear sign on all of its ticket machines at stations where there are two forms of transport (ie train AND tram) that these tickets are only for train travel.

    He said different companies were still working on an integrated travel pass similar to Oyster.

    City snubbed in food guide 11:38: Birmingham Mail

    Birmingham fails to get a taste of success in the latest Good Food Guide after none of the city's restaurants made the top 50 list. Read the full story online.

    Walsall 0-3 Crystal Palace 11:28:

    Walsall were knocked out of the League Cup last night by Crystal Palace, 3-0 at the Banks's Stadium, with Dwight Gayle scoring a first-half hat-trick.

    Mathieu Manset

    After the match the Saddlers confirmed the signing of the 25-year-old French striker Mathieu Manset (pictured), who was with them on trial during the summer.

    Have your say 11:19: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service, which we write here in Birmingham.

    Our stories today 11:08: Robert Thompson Editor, Midlands Today

    It's a busy morning with quite a bit going on. Giles Latcham is working on an incredible story about a new technique that keeps a liver destined for a transplant "alive" longer. We'll be talking to a patient and surgeon.

    Elsewhere, we're meeting the head teacher of Baverstock School, which features in Panorama on BBC One this evening. We'll ask him how he's helping to turn around kids kicked out of mainstream education.

    News on the hour 10:56: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    Residents in part of Walsall say a police crackdown on prostitutes has failed.

    In the news at 11:00 on BBC WM we'll hear from the Pleck neighbourhood watch chairman, who says he's disgusted with what's happening in his area.

    Urban sketch 10:50: via Facebook

    Stirchley News posts: "Join in tomorrow with Stirchley's first ever Birmingham Urban Sketch scrawl. The event is free."

    Safeguarding children 10:38: BBC WM

    A Birmingham-based charity which looks at child protection issues says the West Midlands must take responsibility for looking after youths.

    Between 1997 and 2013 at least 1,400 children were sexually exploited in Rotherham, a report has found.

    Donald Findlater, from the Lucy Faithfull Foundation, says: "The same question could be asked of the safeguarding board and of parents across the West Midlands - what are we doing to keep our children safe?"

    Referendum will test English regions 10:21: Patrick Burns Political editor, Midlands

    It has been in place for over 400 years but, it turns out the Act of Union between England and Scotland is a much looser affair than many of us had thought. Read my full blog post.

    West Brom win on penalties 10:10:

    West Bromwich Albion needed a penalty shoot-out to get past the Football League's bottom club, Oxford, in the second round of the Capital One League Cup at The Hawthorns.

    Jason Davidson

    The Baggies went ahead with an own goal in the first half, but conceded a late equaliser, before winning the penalty shoot-out 7-6.

    News on the hour 09:55: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    A Birmingham charity says authorities in the West Midlands need to learn lessons from the sex abuse scandal in Rotherham.

    It's after a report found criminal gangs sexually abused 1,400 children over 16 years in the South Yorkshire town. Hear more in the news at 10:00 on BBC WM.

    Rail disruption ends 09:38:

    London Midland tweets: Disruption caused by earlier signalling problems at #Wolverhampton has now ended. If delayed for more than 30 min -> soda.sh/xzd

    Panorama: Last Chance Academy 09:34:

    A Birmingham school opposed to excluding disruptive students will feature in a BBC documentary tonight.

    Pupils at Baverstock Academy receiving their exam results

    Baverstock Academy does not expel disruptive pupils and will go to almost any lengths to keep them in mainstream education.

    Panorama followed students there in the run-up to exams to see if the school can honour its pledge to keep disruptive pupils in class as well as get them five GCSEs. Watch a preview of the programme online now.

    • News, sport, travel, weather for Wed 27 Aug
    • More updates from 08:00 on Thursday
    • Listen: BBC WM
    Chasing more information 09:20: Alex Homer BBC News Online

    I'm hoping to hear more from West Midlands Police soon about the illegal immigrant found above the driver's cab of a lorry on the M6 near Birmingham.

    It's not yet clear exactly where they were stashed away. I'm also hoping to find out how long the person had been there and their condition when they were found.

    Lorry driver heard noises 09:11: Express and Star

    An illegal immigrant has been found stowed away on top of a lorry cab by police after the driver heard noises. Read more online now.

    News on the hour 08:56: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    A school in Birmingham which is pioneering a new way of teaching disruptive pupils says it will go to any length to keep them in mainstream education.

    Hear more on this story in the news at 09:00 on BBC WM.

    Your questions for London Midland boss 08:43: Adrian Goldberg Presenter, BBC WM

    The managing director of train company London Midland is in the Hotseat from 11:00 taking your calls.

    Patrick Verwer

    Have you got a question you'd like to ask Patrick Verwer? Email or call 03453 00 99 56 and I'll put them to him.

    Immigrant on top of M6 lorry cab 08:30:

    Motorway police found an illegal immigrant hiding above the cab of a lorry on the M6 near Spaghetti Junction last night.

    The central motorway unit says the driver called officers after hearing strange noises.

    Wolverhampton train delays 08:19:

    London Midland tweets: Due to signalling problems at #Wolverhampton services running through this station may be delayed by up to 10 mins at short notice.

    Dry and bright today 08:10: Charlie Slater Weather Presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    After a rather chilly start, it will be a mostly dry and bright day with sunny spells.

    Towards the evening however, cloud will start to thicken in the south with winds strengthening, with a high of 20C (68F).

    Good morning 08:00: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    I'm in the BBC WM newsroom bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather updates for Birmingham and the Black Country today.

    If you'd like to comment on any of the stories we're featuring, please get in touch via email or tweet @BBCWM.



Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Child museumChild's play

    Should children be allowed to run wild in museums? BBC Culture investigates


  • Going through ice across the Northwest PassageThe Travel Show Watch

    Navigating the treacherous Northwest Passage through ice and Arctic storms

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.