Trojan Horse: Two schools to lose funding

Composite of five inadequate schools Five schools were rated inadequate by Ofsted on Monday

Related Stories

Two schools at the centre of the Trojan Horse inquiry are to lose their government funding.

Birmingham academies Park View and Nansen Primary - rated inadequate by Ofsted - will have their funding agreements terminated.

Park View Educational Trust said it may be removed from running the schools.

Oldknow Academy and Golden Hillock School, also rated inadequate, were warned they could lose funding unless concerns were addressed.

A head teacher's experience

A head teacher at one of the Trojan Horse schools said parents tried to undermine her authority and descended on the school during an Ofsted inspection.

The head teacher, who wished to remain anonymous, said she heard parents speaking to an inspector about her.

She said she came close to quitting her job on a number of occasions but everything "fell into place" when news of the Trojan Horse letter broke.

"From 2012 I felt alone," she said.

"I did not know it was happening to other heads. If I had known, I could have rationalised it but at the time I felt embarrassed.

"I started thinking 'maybe it is me, maybe I'm doing something wrong.'"

On Monday, the watchdog published 21 reports into schools allegedly targeted as part of a hardline Muslim takeover.

Five of those schools, including Park View and Oldknow, were rated inadequate.

'Islamic-themed assemblies'

Birmingham City Council said it would work with Saltley School, the only local authority school placed in special measures, and the Department for Education to install a temporary governing board.

In a letter to Park View chairman Tahir Alam, education minister Lord Nash said there were "deep concerns" about the way Park View School was run.

The letter said: "I have decided under clause 5.6 of the supplementary funding agreement for the academy to give written notice of the Secretary of State's intention to terminate that agreement."

Lord Nash criticised the trust for failing to promote "spiritual, moral, social and cultural development of pupils".

"I am deeply mindful of the need to eliminate discrimination, advance equality of opportunity and foster good relations," he said.

Flyer outside Oldknow Academy Parents at Oldknow Academy have said they are considering legal action against Ofsted

A similar letter about Nansen Primary School, also addressed to Tahir Alam, said it would have its funding arrangement terminated.

Both letters invited the trust to respond before 4 July.

A spokesman for Park View School said they would challenge the Ofsted report through the appropriate legal channels.

They said terminating the funding agreement would mean the trust could be removed from the running of the three schools.

"What happens to the schools after that would be the decision of the secretary of state, as they are already academy schools under the remit of [the] Department for Education," they said.

One parent told the BBC: "The school is very good, it keeps the girls away from the boys"

'Segregation must end'

In a letter to Dr Achmad da Costa, chair of Oldknow Academy Trust, Lord Nash said it was not meeting the requirements set out in its funding agreement.

"Therefore the Secretary of State is minded to terminate the funding agreement unless all the breaches are addressed promptly, in full, and to his satisfaction," it said.

Lord Nash set out a list of actions the trust must take before 4 July.

These included ending "less favourable" treatment of non-Muslims, ceasing segregation of boys and girls, and drawing up a plan to ensure a more "broad and balanced" curriculum.

Oldknow Academy declined to comment on the letter from Lord Nash.

A letter to Tahir Alam regarding Golden Hillock's funding arrangement set out a similar list of demands to be completed within the same timescale.

Ofsted chief Sir Michael Wilshaw said "a culture of fear and intimidation has taken grip" in Birmingham schools, while a number of head teachers had reported an "organised campaign to target certain schools in order to impose a narrow, faith-based ideology".

'Own agendas'

The report into Park View School said the academy's work to keep students safe, including from extremism, was inadequate.

It said external speakers had not been vetted properly and the school had allowed a guest with known extremist views to speak to students as part of Islamic-themed assemblies.

Darren Turner Associate head teacher of Saltley School Darren Turner said the school was "determined" to turn around

Park View and Oldknow trusts did not comment on the future but one of Saltley School's senior teachers said it hoped to boost its Ofsted rating.

Darren Turner was brought in as associate head teacher on Thursday as part of a partnership scheme with other local schools.

He said there had been "upset" among staff and pupils at Saltley's inadequate rating.

"This is all about moving forward, what happens next," he said.

"Behind these walls they've got some excellent teachers and they want to get back to doing what they are good at: teaching.

"When this school gets back to 'good' again we want to go further and become outstanding."

Parents at the schools have criticised Ofsted's reports and accused inspectors of bias.

Health professional Arshad Malik told the BBC the findings were "alien" to his child's experience at Park View.

"‎Inspectors came with loaded questions," he said.

"People are trying to use this school to push their own agendas."

He said parents would like to invite Education Secretary Michael Gove to the school for an open meeting about Ofsted's findings and to talk about what evidence was found to support them.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country



Min. Night 11 °C

BBC Local Live

    Wolves v Huddersfield 16:47:

    Wolves manager Kenny Jackett could hand Yannick Sagbo a debut when they welcome Huddersfield to Molineux this evening.

    Yannick Sagbo
    Arrested earlier this year 16:38:

    The home of Moazzam Begg was searched by police when he was arrested in February.

    Police search home in Hall Green, Birmingham

    Counter-terrorism police searched the property in Hall Green and arrested three others.

    Evans called-up for Wales 16:28:

    Wolves midfielder Lee Evans is one of six uncapped players to be picked for Wales' Euro 2016 qualifiers against Bosnia-Hercegovina and Cyprus in Cardiff.

    'Government's failures' 16:19:

    Leaving London's Belmarsh prison, Mr Begg, 46, said he had "wanted his day in court" but was "very happy".

    Moazzam Begg speaks to journalists after being released from Belmarsh Prison

    Speaking after his release, he said it was "important to point out some of the government's failures in its foreign policy and its internal policy" along with its "clear demonising of the Muslim community".

    General election 'unpredictable' 16:06: Patrick Burns Political editor, Midlands

    As the Conservatives leave Birmingham after their party conference I've written a blog taking stock of the conferences so far, pointing ahead to the Liberal Democrats in Glasgow next week and the general election in eight months' time.

    Having spent decades observing a political chess match, I now see the next general election as so unpredictable it's almost as though the chessmen are being tossed up in the air and no-one really knows how they'll land after Thursday 7 May.

    News on the hour 15:57: Rob Mayor Journalist, BBC WM

    Assistant Chief Constable Marcus Beale, from West Midlands Police, says the charges being dropped against Moazzam Begg won't effect the way the force approaches future investigations.

    Hear more on our top story in the news bulletin at 16:00 on BBC WM.

    Mids Today at 50: Dunkirk anniversary 15:52: Nick Owen Presenter, Midlands Today

    An outstanding memory for me working on the programme was going to Dunkirk in 2000 with my father Bertie on the 60th anniversary of the evacuation of which he was a part.

    Nick Owen and his father Bertie on the beach at Dunkirk

    It was his first and only return and was all very poignant.

    Orchestra HQ reopens 15:43: Tom Richardson BBC News Online

    The City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra's headquarters have reopened after a £1.8m revamp.

    Artist's impression of the finished reception area

    The orchestra's patron the Earl of Wessex unveiled the changes.

    'Poo power' for homes 15:34: Tom Richardson BBC News Online

    A UK water company has begun supplying domestic gas produced from human waste to homes. Read the full story here.

    Anaerobic digester

    Former Guantanamo Bay detainee Moazzam Begg has walked out of Belmarsh prison in south-east London after a string of terrorist charges linked to the civil war in Syria were dropped by the Crown Prosecution Service.

    'Get back to front-line policing' 15:12: Trystan Jones BBC News

    PC Peter McGinn says he's currently based in the office at Sutton Coldfield, helping with telephone inquiries and gathering information for cases. He returned to work after being injured in a hit-and-run last year.

    PC Peter McGinn

    The officer, 44, suffered leg and hip injuries and needed surgery after he was crushed against a lamppost in Birmingham.

    He says: "I'm still waiting to see if the nerve transfer to my foot is going to work. I'd like to get back to front-line policing, but whether my injuries will allow me to do that I don't know."

    News on the hour 14:58: Rob Mayor Journalist, BBC WM

    In the 15:00 bulletin, we will hear from Assistant Chief Constable Marcus Beale, from West Midlands Police, after terror charges against Moazzam Begg were dropped.

    'Long and complex' investigation 14:48:

    West Midlands Police has released a statement following the news charges against Moazzam Begg have been dropped.

    Assistant Chief Constable Marcus Beale says: "Terrorism investigations are often long and complex. This case was no exception."

    'It's been a long road' 14:36: Trystan Jones BBC News

    I've just spoken to PC Peter McGinn, the policeman who was crushed by a car and has just returned to work.

    He seems pleased to be back and says he is enjoying "the banter" after 15 months out and four operations.

    "It's still very painful now. It's been a long road… but I've had a lot of support, especially off my wife."

    Earl of Wessex to relaunch CBSO 14:19: Satnam Rana Arts reporter, BBC Midlands Today

    I'm off to see the newly 'refreshed' City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra centre later after its HQ had a £1.8m upgrade.

    The Earl of Wessex will be unveiling a plaque and I believe some school singers are due to perform.

    Mids Today at 50: The first programme 14:09: Robert Thompson Editor, Midlands Today

    All this week on BBC Midlands Today we're marking 50 years of the programme being on air.

    On 28 September 1964 Barry Lankester welcomed viewers for the first time. A leaf through the archives shows a cursory mention in that week's edition of the Radio Times.

    Radio Times page previewing first broadcast for BBC Midlands Today on 28 September 1964

    I understand, albeit grudgingly, that it was more excited about the launch of BBC Two. Read more in my blog post.

    News on the hour 13:59: Rob Mayor Journalist, BBC WM

    Assistant Chief Constable Marcus Beale, from West Midlands Police, insists the decision to drop charges against Moazzam Begg was made as soon as possible.

    Hear more in the news at 14:00 on BBC WM.

    Homeowners wanted for TV show 13:42: Stourbridge News

    A production company is looking for Black Country homeowners who want to radically redesign their home but lack the know-how.

    How does council deal with tip-offs? 13:29:

    The education secretary says the newly-appointed education commissioner for Birmingham will be looking at how the council deals with tip-offs following the Trojan Horse affair.

    Education Secretary Nicky Morgan

    Nicky Morgan says: "There was an issue in terms of heads and teachers reporting their concerns to the city council and that intelligence not being acted upon.

    "It is one of the learning points Sir Mike Tomlinson [education commissioner for Birmingham] will be looking at - when a city council receives intelligence how do they act on it?"

    Coming up 13:15: Nadine Towell Producer, BBC Midlands Today

    Moazzam Begg has terror charges dropped. Our special correspondent has been following his story over the years and joins us in the studio to analyse this latest twist

    And ultimate recycling - how Severn Trent Water is using human waste to help power our homes.

    Join us for the latest on BBC One from 13:30.

    Millwall 1-3 Birmingham 13:06:

    Blues have moved five points clear of the Championship relegation zone after a much-needed victory last night at Millwall.

    Wes Thomas
    News on the hour 12:57: Rob Mayor Journalist, BBC WM

    In the news at 13:00 we'll hear from the West Midlands counter terrorism team after seven terrorism charges were dropped against Moazzam Begg.

    Speedway revival 12:45: Nick Clitheroe Sports editor, BBC Midlands Today

    Three months after it folded, an attempt to revive the Birmingham Brummies speedway team will gather pace tonight.

    Former owner Tony Mole is holding a meeting at the Perry Barr stadium to look for investors interested in re-launching the club.

    The Brummies collapsed in July when owner Alan Phillips admitted he could no longer afford to finance the club and failed to find a new buyer.

    Historic building to be auctioned 12:31: Birmingham Post

    A historic Black Country former industrial building which dates back to the 1870s is to go under the hammer later this month.

    The day spaghetti junction opened 12:20: Midlands Today 50th anniversary

    All this week we're taking a look through some of the archive, including the heady days before congestion on Birmingham and the Black Country's roads, railways and air routes.

    Car driving on spaghetti junction in 1972

    There's some interesting footage of the Gravelly Hill Interchange - better known as spaghetti junction - opening in 1972.

    'Surprise to the defence' 12:10: Phil Mackie News Correspondent

    Although I wasn't in court today to hear news of the release of Moazzam Begg, I gather it came as a surprise to the defence.

    News on the hour 11:57: BBC WM

    In the 12:00 bulletin: The former Guantanamo Bay detainee Moazzam Begg, from Birmingham, has had seven terror charges against him dropped.

    Crush-injury PC back on duty 11:46: Birmingham Mail

    A policeman who suffered catastrophic crush injuries while tackling a fleeing burglar is back fighting crime.

    PC Pete McGinn
    Region's social workers 'most stressed' 11:36: BBC WM

    Social workers in the West Midlands are the most stressed in the country - with more than one in 10 admitting they want to leave the profession, research suggests.

    Community Care, an online resource for social workers, found more than 80% of those surveyed admitted to being under more pressure than ever before.

    Hear more on the top story on BBC WM this morning.

    Symphony HQ to reopen 11:27:

    The City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra's headquarters will be reopened later after a £1.8m revamp.

    Artist's impression of the finished reception area

    Since work began in June, the CBSO centre has been boosted with improved seating, lighting, acoustics and performance facilities.

    The orchestra's patron the Earl of Wessex is due to unveil the changes later this afternoon.

    'Going to raise many questions' 11:18:

    West Midlands Police says new material it received had "an impact on key pieces of evidence that underpinned the prosecution's case", leading to the charges against Mr Begg being dropped.

    Assistant Chief Constable Marcus Beale says: "I understand this is going to raise many questions. However, explaining what this newly revealed information is would mean discussing other aspects of the case which would be unfair and inappropriate as they are no longer going to be tested in court."

    Held in Guantanamo Bay 11:08:

    Moazzam Begg was held in the US-run military prison at Guantanamo Bay in Cuba for nearly three years from 2002 and was never charged with any offence.

    Moazzam Begg

    He is a British citizen who moved to Afghanistan with his family in 2001, before moving again to Pakistan in 2002 when the Afghanistan war started.

    Mr Begg was released in January 2005 along with three other British citizens and returned to the UK.

    News on the hour 10:57: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    We'll have more on the breaking story that former Guantanamo Bay detainee Moazzam Begg will walk free from prison later today after terrorism charges are dropped.

    Here more in the news at 11:00 on BBC WM.

    'Prosecutor offered no evidence' 10:52:

    Moazzam Begg, 45, appeared before the Old Bailey via video link from Belmarsh Prison when he was formally acquitted of all seven terror charges.

    Mr Begg spoke only to confirm his name and made no reaction as the prosecutor offered no evidence following a review of the case.

    Terrorism charges thrown out 10:49:

    Moazzam Begg appeared at the Old Bailey in July charged over allegedly attending a terrorist training camp in Syria, which he denied.

    Moazzam Begg

    He was charged with one count of attending a terrorism training camp in Syria between 9 October 2012 and 9 April 2013, and possessing documents for a purpose connected to terrorism and terrorist funding. The case was dropped today at the Old Bailey.

    Moazzam Begg 'charges dropped' 10:42:

    Former Guantanamo Bay detainee Moazzam Begg today had seven terror charges connected with the civil war in Syria dropped at the Old Bailey.

    Mr Begg, from Birmingham, is expected to be freed from Belmarsh Prison later today.

    Crash driver had 'alcohol withdrawal' fit 10:35: Birmingham Mail

    A driver who killed a young Birmingham student after suffering a seizure at the wheel may have been suffering from alcohol withdrawal, an inquest has heard.

    Have your say 10:16: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you news, sport, travel and weather updates in one place. We'd like to know what you think.

    Gas from human waste 10:07: Elizabeth Glinka Presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    Severn Trent Water has revealed it's now providing green gas made from processed human waste to more than 2.5 million homes in and around Birmingham.

    A new treatment process means the gas can be cleaned - saving the company more than £1.5m a year, which it says will benefit its customers.

    Hazardous debris removed 09:42:

    Yardley School in Tyseley is to remain closed until next week following a suspected arson attack on a neighbouring warehouse.

    Fire on Reddings Lane in Tyseley

    Head teacher Rose Hughes said "hazardous" debris had to be removed by a specialist contractor, while a large portion of the school had also been cordoned off to allow surrounding buildings to be demolished.

    Watch: Steel horse sculptures 09:29: Midlands Today 50th anniversary

    If you've travelled on the train between Wolverhampton and Birmingham you may have spotted some life-sized horse sculptures near the track.

    Steel horse sculptures resting against a factory wall.

    In 1987 British Rail part funded and commissioned a local artist to produce 12 steel horses along the railway line to "liven up the grimmest rail journey in Britain". Watch the archive footage online now.

    'Government did act swiftly' 09:14: Pete Morgan Presenter, BBC WM

    The education secretary tells BBC WM she's confident the government has got to the bottom of the Trojan Horse affair in Birmingham.

    Nicky Morgan claims the appointment of an education commissioner for Birmingham will help to improve standards at schools that were put into special measures.

    She insists the government did act swiftly enough when allegations about a hard-line Islamist agenda surfaced.

    Murder arrests after flat death 09:05:

    Two people have been arrested on suspicion of murder after a man was found dead at a Birmingham flat.

    Officers went to the property in Showell Green Lane, Sparkhill, just after 13:40 on Thursday following reports the 41-year-old had collapsed.

    A 28-year-old man and 26-year-old woman are being questioned.

    News on the hour 08:55: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    Investigations are under way to find the cause of a huge fire at a scrap metal yard in the Black Country.

    Up to 50 firefighters were called to tackle the blaze at Charles Street in Smethwick.

    Hear more on this story in the news at 09:00.

    Cameron to close conference 08:43:

    David Cameron will close the Conservative party conference in Birmingham today by pledging to increase spending on the NHS in England every year, if the Tories win next May's general election.

    David Cameron

    He will promise to protect health spending from cuts, in a repeat of the policy on which he fought the 2010 election.

    School closed until next week 08:34:

    A Birmingham school which was forced to close on Monday after a fire at a nearby industrial estate will remain shut until next week.

    Tyseley warehouse fire

    The fire at Redding Lane, Tyseley, is the third on the estate and caused hundreds of thousands of pounds worth of damage.

    Debris has fallen on to the Yardleys School site and will have be removed before it can reopen.

    Huge plume in scrap metal blaze 08:23: Express and Star

    A fire involving 200 tons of scrap metal broke out near the West Bromwich Albion ground, sending a huge plume of smoke into the sky.

    Warm and sunny 08:14:

    There will be a fair amount of cloud and many places will be dry for much of the time.

    A few warm sunny spells are likely, especially in the morning, and patchy rain will spread southeastwards in the afternoon with a high of 19C (66F). Get your local forecast.

    Lorry and car crash on M6 08:05:

    One lane's closed and there's heavy traffic on the M6 southbound between J6, for the A38(M) Aston Expressway, and J5, at the A452 (Castle Bromwich), because of an accident involving a lorry and a car.

    Congestion goes to J7, A34 (Great Barr), says BBC Travel.

    Good morning 08:00: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    I'll be bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather updates for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    If you'd like to comment on any of the updates featured today, please email or tweet @BBCWM.



Elsewhere on the BBC

  • SailingGame on

    BBC Capital discovers why certain sports seem to have a special appeal for those with deep pockets


  • European Union's anti-terrorism chief Gilles de KerchoveHARDtalk Watch

    Anti-terrorism chief Gilles de Kerchove on the threat from returning Islamic State fighters

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.