Trojan Horse: Two schools to lose funding

Composite of five inadequate schools Five schools were rated inadequate by Ofsted on Monday

Related Stories

Two schools at the centre of the Trojan Horse inquiry are to lose their government funding.

Birmingham academies Park View and Nansen Primary - rated inadequate by Ofsted - will have their funding agreements terminated.

Park View Educational Trust said it may be removed from running the schools.

Oldknow Academy and Golden Hillock School, also rated inadequate, were warned they could lose funding unless concerns were addressed.

A head teacher's experience

A head teacher at one of the Trojan Horse schools said parents tried to undermine her authority and descended on the school during an Ofsted inspection.

The head teacher, who wished to remain anonymous, said she heard parents speaking to an inspector about her.

She said she came close to quitting her job on a number of occasions but everything "fell into place" when news of the Trojan Horse letter broke.

"From 2012 I felt alone," she said.

"I did not know it was happening to other heads. If I had known, I could have rationalised it but at the time I felt embarrassed.

"I started thinking 'maybe it is me, maybe I'm doing something wrong.'"

On Monday, the watchdog published 21 reports into schools allegedly targeted as part of a hardline Muslim takeover.

Five of those schools, including Park View and Oldknow, were rated inadequate.

'Islamic-themed assemblies'

Birmingham City Council said it would work with Saltley School, the only local authority school placed in special measures, and the Department for Education to install a temporary governing board.

In a letter to Park View chairman Tahir Alam, education minister Lord Nash said there were "deep concerns" about the way Park View School was run.

The letter said: "I have decided under clause 5.6 of the supplementary funding agreement for the academy to give written notice of the Secretary of State's intention to terminate that agreement."

Lord Nash criticised the trust for failing to promote "spiritual, moral, social and cultural development of pupils".

"I am deeply mindful of the need to eliminate discrimination, advance equality of opportunity and foster good relations," he said.

Flyer outside Oldknow Academy Parents at Oldknow Academy have said they are considering legal action against Ofsted

A similar letter about Nansen Primary School, also addressed to Tahir Alam, said it would have its funding arrangement terminated.

Both letters invited the trust to respond before 4 July.

A spokesman for Park View School said they would challenge the Ofsted report through the appropriate legal channels.

They said terminating the funding agreement would mean the trust could be removed from the running of the three schools.

"What happens to the schools after that would be the decision of the secretary of state, as they are already academy schools under the remit of [the] Department for Education," they said.

One parent told the BBC: "The school is very good, it keeps the girls away from the boys"

'Segregation must end'

In a letter to Dr Achmad da Costa, chair of Oldknow Academy Trust, Lord Nash said it was not meeting the requirements set out in its funding agreement.

"Therefore the Secretary of State is minded to terminate the funding agreement unless all the breaches are addressed promptly, in full, and to his satisfaction," it said.

Lord Nash set out a list of actions the trust must take before 4 July.

These included ending "less favourable" treatment of non-Muslims, ceasing segregation of boys and girls, and drawing up a plan to ensure a more "broad and balanced" curriculum.

Oldknow Academy declined to comment on the letter from Lord Nash.

A letter to Tahir Alam regarding Golden Hillock's funding arrangement set out a similar list of demands to be completed within the same timescale.

Ofsted chief Sir Michael Wilshaw said "a culture of fear and intimidation has taken grip" in Birmingham schools, while a number of head teachers had reported an "organised campaign to target certain schools in order to impose a narrow, faith-based ideology".

'Own agendas'

The report into Park View School said the academy's work to keep students safe, including from extremism, was inadequate.

It said external speakers had not been vetted properly and the school had allowed a guest with known extremist views to speak to students as part of Islamic-themed assemblies.

Darren Turner Associate head teacher of Saltley School Darren Turner said the school was "determined" to turn around

Park View and Oldknow trusts did not comment on the future but one of Saltley School's senior teachers said it hoped to boost its Ofsted rating.

Darren Turner was brought in as associate head teacher on Thursday as part of a partnership scheme with other local schools.

He said there had been "upset" among staff and pupils at Saltley's inadequate rating.

"This is all about moving forward, what happens next," he said.

"Behind these walls they've got some excellent teachers and they want to get back to doing what they are good at: teaching.

"When this school gets back to 'good' again we want to go further and become outstanding."

Parents at the schools have criticised Ofsted's reports and accused inspectors of bias.

Health professional Arshad Malik told the BBC the findings were "alien" to his child's experience at Park View.

"‎Inspectors came with loaded questions," he said.

"People are trying to use this school to push their own agendas."

He said parents would like to invite Education Secretary Michael Gove to the school for an open meeting about Ofsted's findings and to talk about what evidence was found to support them.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country



Min. Night 1 °C

BBC Local Live

    17:13: Wheelchair user arried Noel Phillips Journalist, BBC WM

    I'm busy editing a piece which is featuring on BBC Midlands Today at 18:30.

    Troy Hitchins

    Yesterday I met Troy Hitchins. He has cerebral palsy and says he feels embarrassed after being carried down a flight of stairs in his wheelchair after a lift broke in a pub in Harbourne. He says "I didn't feel like a human being".

    The pub in question, The King's Head says its staff acted within the rules.

    16:56: News on the hour Charlotte Harriman Broadcast Journalist, BBC WM

    In the news at 17:00 on BBC WM: A report into the death of a teenager at a children's home says it could have been avoided.

    Kelly Button (pictured) was in the care of Walsall Children's Services when she set fire to her room at the home in Shropshire.

    Kelly Button

    Robert Lake who chaired the report says: "It is possible that this young lady might be still alive today... if we had worked better together."

    16:43: Villa fan 'made Nazi salute' Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    An Aston Villa supporting ambulance worker "made a Nazi salute" towards a German police officer at Anfield, a court's heard told.

    Jason Southall from Walsall denies making the salute when Liverpool FC hosted the Birmingham side in September.

    A West Midlands Ambulance Service spokesman says: "In accordance with Trust procedures, the individual has been suspended whilst an internal investigation into the incident takes place."

    Read more on this story on the Liverpool Echo website.

    16:33: Bank robber: Taxi getaway failure

    Gregory Dike (pictured) held a hunting knife to a man's neck in a branch of NatWest in Rowley Regis in April 2014.

    Gregory Dike

    Dike ran into nearby gardens after a taxi driver he'd tried to use as a getaway refused to move.

    The 38-year-old removed his boiler suit before emerging in a suit but was spotted by police officers and discovered his boiler suit, crash helmet, handcuffs, hunting knife, and two smoke bombs in a bag.

    You can watch the moment he walked into the bank on the police YouTube page.

    16:22: Feedback Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    BBC Local Live brings news, sport, travel and weather together in one place. What do you think of it?

    16:12: Bank robber jailed

    A robber who downloaded guides on "how to rob a bank" has been jailed for 11 years after carrying out raids across the country.

    Gregory Dike raiding a bank

    Gregory Dike, 38, from London carried out robberies in Leeds, Liverpool and Middlesex last year but was stopped in his tracks when he was caught fleeing from a NatWest branch in Rowley Regis.

    West Midlands Police say Dike tried to escape the robbery in a taxi he'd booked, but the driver had refused to move.

    15:55: News on the hour BBC WM

    In the news at 16:00 on BBC WM: Police are searching for a man who's believed to have stabbed a woman with a needle outside Birmingham New Street Station.

    CCTV of man police want to speak to

    It happened at 08:30am on Christmas Eve. British Transport Police say they are reviewing CCTV from the station.

    15:48: Black Country roads targeted in boy racer ban Express and Star

    Four routes will be targeted in a new clampdown against boy racers in Sandwell including a toy store car park.

    Councillors have linked with the other Black Country boroughs to succeed in gaining orders banning illegal car cruising and meetings.

    15:28: MP refused to settle libel case

    Sutton Coldfield MP Andrew Mitchell refused an offer to settle his "Plebgate" libel case just two months before he lost, court papers seen by the BBC show.

    Sutton Coldfield MP Andrew Mitchell

    The Tory MP could have saved at least £500,000 in legal costs had he accepted a deal from the Sun's publishers, News Group newspapers, last September.

    A judge said the ex-chief whip probably had called a policeman stationed at Downing Street's gates a "pleb".

    Mr Mitchell accepted using bad language but insists he had not used that word.

    15:14: Nurse found not guilty

    A nurse has been found not guilty of the manslaughter of a pensioner he was treating at a Birmingham care home.

    Iris Teale, 91, who lived in the Aston Court Nursing Home near Sutton Coldfield died after a suffering a broken leg in 2011.

    Santhosh Rajan

    Her nurse Santosh Rajan (pictured) was cleared by a jury at Birmingham Crown Court this morning.

    14:59: News on the hour Charlotte Harriman Broadcast Journalist, BBC WM

    In the news at 15:00 on BBC WM: A High Court judge has ruled that the Sutton Coldfield MP Andrew Mitchell should pay two sets of legal costs for his failed libel action over the so-called Plebgate Affair.

    14:39: Stories we're working on Abigail Uden Producer, BBC Midlands Today

    It's been a busy old day on Midlands today so far- we're on ice and snow watch in Stoke and Staffordshire where there have been a few commuting problems this morning.

    Our reporter Sarah Falkland has been looking at a serious case review which has been published into the death of a troubled teenager from Walsall who was moved around seven children's homes in 22-months before she set fire to her room and died from smoke inhalation

    And we're looking into the story about a Birmingham pub which has apologised after a disabled man was carried in his wheelchair, as their lift was broken and deemed a safety risk.

    14:27: #ThinkDontSink Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    Houndsfield Lane in Shirley is one of the most flooded roads in the UK, according to the AA.

    A flooded Houndsfield Lane in Shirley

    The the road recovery company tweets that another car has been claimed after flooding today.

    14:14: Four men in custody after gun was thrown from car Halesowen News

    A gun was thrown from a car in Dudley last night during a high speed car chase through the town.

    Four men are in police custody today (Friday) after the incident in the early hours.

    13:57: News on the hour BBC WM

    Nine different organisations have been told they could have done more to prevent the death of a teenage girl who was in the care of Walsall Council.

    You can hear more on this in our 14:00 bulletin.

    13:40: Sinclair 'hoping to play every week' BBC Sport

    Aston Villa have signed Manchester City winger Scott Sinclair on a season-long loan deal - with a view to a permanent transfer.

    The former West Brom, Chelsea and Swansea player, 25, has struggled to break into Manuel Pellegrini's side.

    Scott Sinclair

    Sinclair told Aston Villa's official website: "It's taken a few weeks but I'm happy to be here, to be in the building and to be signing for the club and ready to play some football.

    "It's nice to be able to get settled somewhere and be a part of something going forward."

    13:29: Woman dies in A38 road crash near Lichfield Lichfield Mercury

    A woman has died following a road traffic collision near Lichfield this morning.

    The crash occurred on Alrewas Road, just off the A38 in Alrewas, at 5.45am on Friday.

    13:16: BBC One this lunchtime Joanne Malin Presenter, Midlands Today

    On Midlands Today at the new time of 13:38 - how the death of a teenager from Walsall in a children's home, could've been avoided and how the latest snow is affecting the region, including the latest forecast from Shefali.

    Join us for the latest on Midlands Today on BBC One at the new later time of 13:38.

    13:00: News on the hour BBC WM

    In the news at 13:00 on BBC WM: An RAC man from Solihull says he doesn't know if he'll ever be able to go back to work after a lorry ploughed into him on the M6 last April.

    12:40: Showers possible later Sara Blizzard Weather Presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    We'll see some bright skies into the afternoon.

    Sara Blizzard

    There's also the likelihood of the odd wintry shower in places.

    For the latest forecast visit BBC Weather or follow the team on Twitter.

    12:29: Sinclair joins Villa BBC Sport

    Scott Sinclair joins Aston Villa on a season-long loan from Man City. Latest transfer news

    Scott Sinclair
    12:12: Churchill's funeral anniversary Jerry Chester BBC News Online

    Today marks the 50th anniversary of Sir Winston Churchill's funeral.

    Did you know the handles on the coffin for Winston Churchill's funeral 50 years ago were made in Birmingham?

    Coffin handles

    They were made at Newman Brothers Coffin Works in Birmingham's Jewellery Quarter.

    The museum that now occupies the former coffin works is holding a special event tonight, where recordings of Churchill's famous wartime speeches, and a film of the state funeral will be shown,

    12:00: News on the hour Jo Tidman Journalist, BBC WM

    In the news at 12:00 on BBC WM: A report into the death of a teenage girl being looked after by Walsall Council has found it was predictable that she would harm herself.

    We'll hear from Robert Lake who chaired the report, who says more could have been done.

    11:49: Serious Case Review: Recommendations Chris Blakemore News editor, BBC WM

    There are recommendations for nine different organisations including West Midlands and Shropshire as well as Walsall and Shropshire Councils and Health services.

    The report found mental health diagnosis and treatments were delayed and different organisations didn't work closely enough together.

    11:35: Health and the General Election Patrick Burns Political editor, Midlands

    A survey for the BBC this week by the polling organisation Populus suggests that the health service is now the top election issue for most voters, closely followed by the economy with immigration now in third place.


    Sunday Politics Midlands, at the later time of 12:00, examines Labour's concentration on the NHS and the Conservatives 'counter attack that "you can't have a successful election without a successful economy".

    11:18: Not allowed online

    More details on the Serious case Review by Walsall Council into the death of a 17-year-old girl.

    It emerged she barricaded herself into a room at the home and started a fire two years ago when she was prevented from staying online late at night.

    Staff and firefighters tried to rescue her, but she couldn't be saved.

    Walsall Council, which was responsible for her care, says more consideration should have been given to putting her in secure accommodation; and details numerous occasions when assaults weren't reported.

    11:00: News on the hour Jo Tidman Journalist, BBC WM

    In the news at 11:00 on BBC WM: New research suggests our internal body clock might have a far greater impact on sporting ability than previously thought.

    Scientists at Birmingham University say it might even explain the recent success of the Spanish football team.

    10:49: Heading to Wembley Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    Walsall head to Wembley on 22 March to take on Bristol City in the Johnstone's Paint Trophy final.

    Walsall FC infographic

    BBC WM will have full match commentary of the game and there will be coverage on BBC Sport via the club's page.

    The club says tickets for the match will go on sale from 6 February.

    10:37: End of the line for Land Rover Defender Birmingham Post

    It's one of the most famous vehicles in the world - but the original Land Rover is finally coming to the end of the road in its current format, after nearly 70 years.

    Queen and Prince Phillip in Ibadan, Nigeria

    The Solihull-made Defender has been used by the likes of the Queen (pictured), Winston Churchill and Angelina Jolie as Lara Croft in the Tomb Raider movies.

    10:26: Serious case review

    A report's been published by Walsall Council into the death of a 17-year-old girl at a children's home.

    The teenager barricaded herself in her room and started a fire at the Bryn Melyn care home in Bagley Marshin, Shropshire in 2012.

    The Serious Case Review has been carried out by the authorities in Walsall which were responsible for the girl's care.

    10:12: Yardley playing fields homes battle: Hundreds sign up to fight Co-op plan Birmingham Mail

    Residents have collected hundreds of signatures as they fight against plans to build more than 80 homes on playing fields.

    Fay Goodman, from the Yardley Residents' Protection Group, said around 630 people had signed a petition demanding the Central England Co-operative pull the plug on proposals to construct 82 homes off Barrows Lane, in Yardley.

    09:59: News on the hour Jo Tidman Journalist, BBC WM

    Our lead story in the news at 10:00 on BBC WM: A report into the death of a teenage girl being looked after by Walsall Council has found it was predictable that she would harm herself.

    09:42: 'Team Thumbs-Up' Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    Stephen Sutton's mum says she'll be taking part in the Great Midlands Fun Run later this year, in honour of her son who registered to do it.

    Stephen Sutton

    Jane Sutton posts on Facebook "Stephen had registered to participate in this event last year and was due to wear run number 4047. I will not only be starting the event in 2015 but will also be taking part, wearing run number 4047 in memory of Stephen and raising money for Teenage Cancer Trust."

    Entries for the fun run open on Saturday and will take place on 31 May.

    09:32: 'Acted within the rules' BBC WM

    A spokesperson for a Birmingham pub says they acted within the law when bouncers carried a wheelchair user down from an upstairs floor.

    Troy Hitchins speaking to BBC WM's Noel Phillips

    Troy Hitchins (pictured right) who has cerebral palsy was at the King's Head in Harborne on Saturday night.

    Becca Underwood from the pub says she has tried to contact Troy to apologise but they acted within the rules.

    09:14: Walsall v Bristol BBC Sport

    Bristol City will face Walsall at Wembley in the Johnstone's Paint Trophy final after beating Gillingham 5-3 on aggregate.

    Bristol City celebrate

    Last night's semi final 2nd leg finished 1-1.

    The Robins will now face Walsall in the final on Sunday 22 March.

    08:58: News on the hour Kath Stanczyszyn Reporter, BBC WM

    Our top story in the news at 09:00 on BBC WM: Cuts to NHS hospital budgets for specialist services and some operations will result in "avoidable deaths" - according to bosses at the QE hospital in Birmingham.

    In the bulletin we'll hear from Labour MP for Birmingham Edgbaston, Gisela Stuart.

    08:49: 'Relaxed' panto staged Joanne Malin Presenter, Midlands Today

    People with learning difficulties and autism are being given greater access to the arts thanks to so-called "relaxed performances".

    Birmingham Hippodrome panto

    For the second year running The Birmingham Hippodrome staged a relaxed version of it's panto where lighting and sound levels were reduced and relaxation zones set-up.

    08:34: Wheelchair user 'fire risk' Noel Phillips Journalist, BBC WM

    A disabled man says he was made to feel like a "piece of furniture" after he had to be carried out of a Birmingham pub in his wheelchair because of health and safety.

    Troy Hitchins carried downstairs out of a pub

    Troy Hitchins, 20, who has cerebral palsy was at the King's Head in Harborne on Saturday night.

    He'd been carried up the stairs by his friends because the lift was broken but was told by staff he couldn't stay as he was deemed a fire hazard.

    08:25: Hospital budget cuts BBC WM

    There's a warning from the Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham that budget cuts could lead to "avoidable" deaths.

    Inside the Queen Elizxa

    At a meeting yesterday, the hospital trust chair Jacqui Smith, said that the planned £60m worth' of savings would lead to wards closing, ending services, and making redundancies.

    08:14: On the roads BBC Travel

    There are temporary traffic lights after a manhole collapse on the A457 Sedgley Road East in Tipton.

    BBC Travel warns of delays between Dudley Road West junction and Dudley Port junction.

    08:01: Cold and breezy Sara Blizzard Weather Presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    An icy start this morning, and another cold feeling day.

    Sara Blizzard

    There will be a scattering of wintry showers, but snow mainly confined to hills, with sleet or rain at lower levels. Low of 5C (41F).

    08:00: Good morning Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    I'll be bringing you the very latest news, sport and travel updates for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    I'll also bring you regular weather updates as we've seen a number of snow showers over the past 24 hours across the West Midlands.



Elsewhere on the BBC

  • ReadingBest books

    BBC Culture takes a look at ten books you should read in February


  • A car being driven by Cruise Automation technologyClick Watch

    The tech which could allow any car with an automatic gearbox to become self-driving

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.