Trojan Horse report finds 'aggressive Islamist ethos' in schools

Five schools, including Park View Academy, were put in special measures by Ofsted last month

Related Stories

A leaked report into the so-called "Trojan Horse" plot has found evidence there was an agenda to introduce "an intolerant and aggressive Islamist ethos" into some Birmingham schools.

The report, revealed in The Guardian, was ordered by the government after claims some Muslim groups were trying to take control in some schools.

The Department for Education has said it will not comment on the leaks.

Birmingham council has released its own report, disagreeing with Mr Clarke.

Sir Albert Bore's response

Councillor Sir Albert Bore, Leader of Birmingham City Council

We must acknowledge today that Ian Kershaw's report shows we have serious governance issues in a small number of schools in east Birmingham because of serious malpractice by members of governing bodies. This has been compounded by the inability of head teachers and other governors to counter this behaviour and by the failure of the city council to intervene to instil proper governance.

The government's report was compiled by retired senior police officer Peter Clarke, the former head of the Met Police's counter-terrorism unit. It is due to be published next week.

It says he found evidence of "sustained and co-ordinated agenda to impose upon children in a number of Birmingham schools the segregationist attitudes and practices of a hardline and politicised strain of Sunni Islam".

He also found evidence of a "co-ordinated, deliberate and sustained action to introduce an intolerant and aggressive Islamist ethos into some schools in the city".

The agenda would have confined "schoolchildren within an intolerant, inward-looking monoculture that would severely inhibit their participation in the life of modern Britain," the leaked report says.

A spokesman for the DfE said: "The allegations made in relation to some schools in Birmingham are very serious and we are investigating all evidence put to us in conjunction with Ofsted and Birmingham City Council."

Russell Hobby, general secretary of the National Association of Head Teachers, said his union was disturbed by the Clarke review findings but not surprised.

They reflected concerns raised in May about improper governance and staffing and "a narrowing of entitlement for children", he said.

Trojan Horse letter The original "Trojan Horse" letter alleges the existence of a group of hardline Muslims claiming responsibility for a change in leadership at some schools

"We do not need an over-reaction. This is not a criticism of the Islamic faith, but of a narrow current within it," he said.

Birmingham's report, compiled by former head teacher Ian Kershaw, differed in its conclusions.

It said there was "no evidence of a conspiracy to promote an anti-British agenda, violent extremism or radicalisation in schools" in the east of the city.

Mr Kershaw did find "key individuals" promoting Islamic principles in schools and "noted a pattern of these individuals moving between schools".

He did not conclude whether the original "Trojan Horse" letter was a hoax, as has been claimed.

Start Quote

We do not need an over-reaction. This is not a criticism of the Islamic faith, but of a narrow current within it.”

End Quote Russell Hobby, General secretary of the National Association of Head Teachers

But he found evidence that the "five steps" outlined in the original letter as a means of destabilising school leadership were "present in a large number of the schools considered part of the investigation".

His report said evidence pointed to a group of "British male governors and teachers, predominantly of Pakistani heritage", which have formed in order to address perceived failings in some schools.

Mr Kershaw said the tactics employed by these groups were often "improper" and there was a "pattern" to their behaviour but it stopped short of a widespread plot.

'Slow to respond'

He said their motivation seemed to be an attempt to "raise standards" based on a "genuine and understandable improve education and opportunities for Muslim pupils.

"The evidence is not sufficient to lead me to construe the behaviour to be a co-ordinated plan to improperly influence the direction or management of schools serving students of predominantly Islamic faith or background," he said.

Mr Kershaw also says Birmingham City Council was "slow to respond" to allegations in the letter and accused education chiefs in the city of "poor oversight".

Peter Clarke Peter Clarke is a former deputy commissioner of the Met

He identifies a "culture within [the council] of not wanting to address difficult issues and problems with school governance" for risk of bringing accusations of racism or Islamophobia.

Speaking at a press conference earlier, Council leader Sir Albert Bore admitted the council failed to act for fear of being seen as racist or Islamophobic.

Last month, Ofsted and the Education Funding Agency published their reports and five schools were placed in special measures as a result.

The schools involved have always denied any wrongdoing.

On Tuesday, the board of trustees resigned at Park View Education Trust, which has been at the centre of claims, stating they had been the victims of a "co-ordinated and vicious" attack.

The trust has been the focus of allegations made in the anonymous Trojan Horse letter alleging the existence of a clique of hardline Muslims attempting to seize control of Birmingham schools. The origin of the letter and the intentions behind it have never been determined.

More on This Story

Related Stories

BBC Birmingham & Black Country



8 °C 7 °C

BBC Local Live

    18:00: Good evening

    Local Live updates have finished for the day. We're back at 08:00 on Thursday with more news, sport, travel and weather as usual.

    17:50: Staying cloudy Shefali Oza BBC Midlands Today Weather

    It'll stay cloudy into this evening with further outbreaks of rain overnight.

    Mist and fog patches will develop during the first half of the night, dense in places. It won't be cold, with lows of 7C (45F).

    17:42: Coming up on TV Sarah Falkland BBC Midlands Today presenter

    Police are warning that organised gangs of pickpockets are targeting shoppers at Birmingham's Christmas market. Our reporter Nicola Beckford will join us from the market.

    And Amy Cole will be live from The Magical Journey Christmas attraction on the first day since it reopened and talking to customers and organisers about how today has gone.

    Midlands Today is on BBC One at 18:30.

    17:40: Twins become fathers on same day

    Twin brothers have become fathers of baby boys born within hours of each other at the same hospital.

    The twins with their babies

    Jeromme Spence's baby, Cameron, was born at 02:04 GMT at New Cross Hospital in Wolverhampton on Monday, and Jarrell Spence's baby, Cassen, at 04:34 GMT.

    17:36: More seats to Greece

    Aegean Airlines says it will increase capacity between Birmingham Airport and Athens in summer 2015 by 8,500 seats, following the successful launch of the route in June this year.

    17:33: Pharmacy told to improve after death David Lumb BBC News, West Midlands

    A pharmacy has been told to improve its procedures after a grandfather who was given the wrong medication died.

    Edlie Masters, 83, pictured left with family, ordered paracetamol to numb pain caused by an ulcer on his foot but was given another patient's prescription.

    Edlie Masters pictured left with family members

    Solicitors representing the family said pharmacist Matthew Hurcomb contacted him after realising he had given him the wrong medication and told him there would be no adverse affects.

    Assistant coroner Heidi Connor recorded a verdict of accidental death and asked Hurcomb Chemists to put policies in place to stop it happening again.

    17:28: Terrorists 'must be found' Birmingham Mail

    The terrorists responsible for the Birmingham pub bombings must be found, David Cameron told the House of Commons.

    17:26: Villa recall Robinson Nathan Middleton BBC Radio Manchester

    Aston Villa have recalled forward Callum Robinson from Preston North End.

    The 19-year-old Robinson joined from Villa in September and had his loan extended until January last month.

    The England under-20 international scored five goals during his time at Deepdale, including a hat-trick in the FA Cup against Havant & Waterlooville.

    17:19: Feedback Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    17:16: Bridge problems hit traffic

    The lorry striking a bridge has had an impact on the traffic, with Summer Road blocked in both directions between the Machin Road and South Road junctions.

    The latest information is available from BBC Travel.

    17:14: Speedway news Mike Taylor BBC WM Sport

    Wolverhampton have selected Lewis Blackbird and Josh Bates in the Elite Draft process to allocate reserve riders for next season, which took place this lunchtime.

    Blackbird, aged 27, is a former National League champion with the Cradley Heathens and was one of the strongest reserves in this year's Elite League until suffering a serious leg injury in a crash in Denmark in August.

    Bates, who is 18, won the British Under-21 Championship title at Monmore Green last April and gained Elite League experience with Leicester this year.

    17:04: Moeen goes to century BBC Sport

    Worcestershire's Moeen Ali has chalked up his first One Day International for England against Sri Lanka. You can follow the run chase as it happens here.

    Moeen Ali
    16:56: News on the hour Rob Mayor Journalist, BBC WM

    At 17:00 we hear that a forensic pathologist has told a court fatal injuries suffered by a toddler from Birmingham were like those caused by falling from the top floor of a house.

    Listen live for more on this and other stories.

    16:40: Lorry strikes bridge

    London Midland tweets: Services are starting to get going again after being temporarily suspended after a lorry struck a bridge. Birmingham to Lichfield services were affected while the Birmingham to Redditch route continued to run.

    Commuters are being warned to expect delays and cancellations.

    16:29: 'Nothing suggests an accident' Caroline Gall BBC News

    Jurors in the trial of a man and woman accused of murdering their toddler son have heard the child suffered "heavy punches, stamps, kicks, or impact with a weapon".

    Dr Alexander Kolar said "nothing suggests an accidental cause" for the death of Levi-Blu Cassin.

    16:15: The fog descends Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    It's starting to look like a bit of a pea souper over Birmingham this afternoon.

    Fog over the Mailbox and The Cube

    Dull, damp and misty - that's what we should be expecting from the rest of today's weather.

    16:04: Behind the scenes Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    We have been given this peek of what part of The Magical Journey looks like after it reopened following some improvements made after complaints.

    What The Magical Journey looks like after improvements

    Have you been along today? What do you think? Let us know via email, Facebook or Twitter.

    15:55: News on the hour Rob Mayor Journalist, BBC WM

    Walsall Councillor Mohammed Arif has called for people not to jump to conclusions, after a couple from the borough were arrested for Syria-related terrorism offences.

    More on this and other stories in our 16:00 bulletin.

    15:32: Magical Journey refunds via Facebook

    Claire Church has aired her frustration as she claimed she had not yet been refunded money paid to visit The Magical Journey.

    She posted: "Why haven't the majority of people received their refund yet? I was due to come on Sunday with my family so do I get an automatic refund or do I have to apply by email?

    "I don't want to rebook as I've had enough of the whole situation, all I want is my money which is sat in your bank account along with many others gaining you interest! NOW SORT IT OUT!!"

    15:15: Social media monitoring 'too big' Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Monitoring online conversations from around the world is "too big a job", claims cyber-security expert Prof Mike Jackson, from Birmingham City University.

    His comments come as the BBC learned that Facebook was the firm that hosted a conversation by one of Fusilier Lee Rigby's killers five months ahead of the attack.

    Lee Rigby memorial

    "What Mr Cameron would like is for overseas internet companies to do the work of the British security services. To sift through the many millions of postings made each day and notify the UK government about any concerns," said Prof Jackson.

    15:05: News on the hour BBC WM

    The top story in our 15:00 bulletin: A married couple from Walsall have been arrested on suspicion of preparing acts of terrorism.

    14:46: New Birmingham Conservatoire plans Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Plans for the first newly-built conservatoire in the UK since 1987 have been submitted to Birmingham planners.

    The proposal is for a brand new home for Birmingham Conservatoire, part of Birmingham City University, to open its doors to students in 2017.

    How the new conservatoire could look

    Its recent graduates include singer/songwriter Laura Mvula and classical singer, theatre actor and TV presenter Rhydian Roberts.

    14:35: Magical Journey praise via Facebook

    Rebecca Spilane has given a glowing review of The Magical Journey after it reopened today.

    She wrote on the attraction's Facebook page: "Ive just come out and it was amazing. It was beautiful and magical and the staff were lovely and im very in the mood for Christmas now! Absolutely value for money! I enjoyed it let alone my 2 year old!"

    14:20: Tai missing for Wolves Mike Taylor BBC WM Sport

    Last year's World Speedway Champion Tai Woffinden has announced that he won't be riding for Wolverhampton in the Elite League next year.

    Tai Woffinden

    Woffinden says he was overwhelmed by his commitments in 2014 and had to take time out in July because of exhaustion.

    He has ridden for Wolves every year since breaking into the Elite League aged 17, but in 2015 he will ride only in the Polish and Swedish Leagues and the Grand Prix series.

    14:10: Birmingham's public transport 'shambles' Birmingham Post

    The West Midlands needs a Transport for London style regulator to co-ordinate bus, train and Metro services for the benefit of commuters, a city council watchdog committee has claimed.

    13:57: News on the hour Rob Mayor Journalist, BBC WM

    A Walsall couple - aged 20 and 19 - were picked up by counter-terror detectives at Heathrow Airport last night.

    They'd just got off a flight from Istanbul but West Midlands Police say the investigation is linked to Syria.

    More on this in our 14:00 bulletin.

    13:52: Patient 'given wrong meds' Michele Paduano BBC Midlands health correspondent

    A pharmacy has been told to improve its procedures after a grandfather who was given the wrong medication died.

    Edlie Masters

    Edlie George Masters, from Birmingham, ordered paracetamol to numb pain caused by an ulcer on his foot but was given another patient's prescription.

    A coroner recorded a verdict of accidental death and asked Hurcomb Chemists to put polices in place to stop it happening again.

    13:35: Magical Journey reopens

    The Magical Journey tweets: We are pleased to say we have reopened this morning and the first few groups have already started going through.

    13:22: Coming up on Midlands Today Ben Sidwell Reporter, BBC Midlands Today

    Fifty years ago five young men from the Black Country got together to form a band. They called themselves the N betweens but you probably won't know them as that. A few years later they changed their name to Slade.

    The N betweens with drummer Dom Powell second from left and lead guitarist Dave Hill far right

    I went back to Bilston with drummer Dom Powell, pictured second from left here, to find out where it all began. Have a guess who is on the far right of this picture too.

    Find out more on Midlands Today at 13:30 on BBC One.

    13:14: Doubling up Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Twin brothers from Wolverhampton have defied odds of 150,000 - 1 to become dads to baby boys born on the same day - in the same hospital.

    Jeromme (pictured right) and Jarrell Spence, from Fordhouses, became fathers within hours of each other at New Cross Hospital in the early hours of Monday.

    From left to right Jarrell wearing a grey top, with Cassen and Jeromme, wearing a black top, with baby Cameron

    The twins, 21, knew their partners were both having baby boys, and shared the same due date of November 26, but they didn't believe their new bundles of joy would ever arrive on the same day.

    Alex Donohue, from Ladbrokes Bookmakers, said: "This is so rare. The odds of it happening are at least 150,000 - 1."

    12:57: News on the hour Rob Mayor Journalist, BBC WM

    Police are searching two addresses in Walsall after arresting a man and a woman from the borough on suspicion of terror offences.

    More on this and other stories in our 13:00 bulletin.

    12:47: Bent loan confirmed Mike Taylor BBC WM Sport

    Darren Bent's loan move from Aston Villa to Brighton has now been confirmed. The deal runs until 29 December.

    Darren Bent

    The 30-year-old striker cost Villa £18m when he was signed in January 2011 from Sunderland. He scored nine goals in the second half of that season to help Villa pull away from relegation trouble, but gradually fell out of favour.

    He has not started a Premier League game for Villa since May 2013 and was loaned to Fulham last season.

    12:35: BREAKING NEWS

    A man and woman from Walsall have been arrested on suspicion of Syria-related terrorism offences, says West Midlands Police.

    The couple were detained by officers from the West Midlands Counter Terrorism Unit at about 22:30 yesterday at Heathrow Airport, as they got off a flight from Istanbul.

    12:19: Parents deny murdering toddler Caroline Gall BBC News

    I am at Birmingham Crown Court for the trial of Danielle Cassin and Mark Piper, who both deny murdering 22-month Levi-Blu Cassin and other charges of neglect, assault, abandoning a child, causing or allowing the death of a child, and causing unnecessary suffering or injuries to a child.

    Dr Alexander Kolar, forensic pathologist, has been detailing the injuries Levi-Blu suffered.

    Levi-Blu Cassin

    The court heard he suffered bruising to his lung, bowel and two lacerations to his liver. There was haemorrhaging around his kidneys and adrenal gland, lacerations to his small intestine and internal bleeding.

    12:09: Olsson to have surgery Mandeep Sanghera BBC Sport

    West Bromwich Albion centre-back Jonas Olsson will be out for between four and six weeks as he will undergo minor Achilles surgery.

    West Brom defender Jonas Olsson

    The 31-year-old Sweden international is scheduled to have his operation in Portugal on Friday.

    11:59: News on the hour Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    Our top local story at 12:00: A Birmingham mother with disabled twins tells us how she came face to face with a man who stole the family's motability car.

    Listen live here.

    11:50: Budget plans Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Budget proposals by Birmingham City Council for next year will be published for formal consultation in December.

    It has also planned public meetings for people to have their say on 11 December at the council house from 18:00-20:00 and on 15 December at the same time at the Lighthouse Cente in St Barnabas Church, High Street, Erdington.

    Book a place via email.

    11:40: Carjacking victim Daz Hale Presenter, BBC WM

    We've had a call from Jo. She's been the victim of a car jacking in the past few days. The car was a motability car used for her two disabled twins. Her story is actually in today's Birmingham Mail.

    Jo Collier

    Now we are here to help and we couldn't ignore what's happened. I'm talking to her on BBC WM now.

    11:35: Bears long-term deals Mike Taylor BBC WM Sport

    Warwickshire have given new long-term contracts to Boyd Rankin and Sam Hain (pictured)

    Sam Hain

    Fast bowler Rankin, 30, made his England Test debut in 2013 and has been with the county since 2008. He's signed a new three-year deal.

    Hain, 19, has agreed a new four-year contract after an outstanding first season of Championship cricket, in which he broke Ian Bell's records to become the youngest to score a first-class hundred and double-hundred for Warwickshire.

    11:24: £20m of cuts still to be found Express and Star

    More than £20million worth of cuts still have to be found at Sandwell Council - sparking a new bid to find savings.

    Tweet @bbcwm 11:11: Your reviews: The Magical Journey Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    "Everything we have done, we have done in order to create a truly magical journey for the parents and specifically the children visiting."

    How part of The Magical Journey looked on Monday

    That was how organisers explained the past three days at The Magical Journey event, during which time it was closed while workers made improvements after a wave of complaints.

    It is reopening today. Let us know what you think of it now changes have been made over email, Facebook or Twitter.

    10:55: News on the hour Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    West Bromwich West MP Adrian Bailey is promising to help a woman who says she's been driven to depression by the so-called "bedroom tax".

    Hear from him in our bulletin at 11:00.

    10:47: Mystery drone noise Solihull News

    We continue to be flooded with reports of people who have heard the Hum.

    Last week, we reported that several residents - all over Solihull - had heard the mystery drone.

    Margaret Witts, who first brought up the phenomena in our letters' page, has now been visited by Solihull Council's environmental department - who have installed recording equipment at her home.

    10:29: Have your say Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you news, sport, travel and weather updates in one place. We'd like to find out what you think.

    10:13: Christmas attraction to reopen Michelle Dawes Journalist, BBC WM

    A Christmas attraction created with the help of Laurence Llewelyn-Bowen is due to reopen later after owners decided to temporarily shut it to find solutions to complaints.

    Hundreds of people criticised the Magical Journey, at the Belfry Golf Club near Sutton Coldfield, for being overpriced and unfinished.

    Trains used for The Magical Journey tour

    The media are banned from attending the reopening, with organisers saying it would "create anxiety for visitors", but from the car park this morning the part of the attraction I could see looked quite "Narnia-esque" and very snowy.

    09:57: News on the hour Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    At 10:00 we hear from the Birmingham woman who says the impact of the so-called "bedroom tax" for her family has driven her to depression.

    Listen live here.

    09:38: Accident on M5

    Highways Agency tweets: #M5 n/bound J3-J2. 2 lanes are closed due to a multi vehicle accident. Approach with caution. Delays are building.

    09:30: Solihull power outage Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    About 190 homes are without power in the B92 area of Solihull.

    Western Power Distribution hopes to restore the supply by 11:30, according to its power cut map. Hat tip to Solihull Updates for highlighting this.

    09:14: Protest over 'umbrella' labour Birmingham Post

    Angry building workers are planning a mass demonstration outside the £200 million redevelopment of Birmingham's former BBC headquarters at Pebble Mill in protest at use of 'umbrella' labour on the site.

    08:59: News on the hour Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    Our top story: A Birmingham woman says the so-called bedroom tax has ripped her family apart and driven her to depression.

    Listen live to our 09:00 bulletin.

    08:48: Shopping parade 'like a tip' Birmingham Mail

    A Birmingham shopping parade has been left looking like a rubbish tip because council binmen have failed to collect bin bags for five weeks.

    08:35: The Magical Journey reopens Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    A Christmas attraction which closed due to complaints including smoking elves, unfinished attractions and unwrapped presents is due to reopen later.

    Lawrence at the park

    Hundreds of messages were posted on the Facebook page of The Magical Journey, which Laurence Llewelyn-Bowen helped to design, after it opened.

    A number of users complained about the price of admission - the top price for a child is £22.50 - and accused the management of misleading the public.

    08:25: Saturday night's alright in Walsall Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Sir Elton John has announced he and his band will play Walsall's Banks's Stadium on Saturday 13 June next year as part of his European tour.

    It will be the star's first ever performance in the borough.

    Sir Elton John

    Chief Executive of Walsall Football Club Stefan Gamble said: "This will be our first outdoor concert in over 20 years and will not only be a huge boost for the club, but a momentous day for the town of Walsall and the wider borough as a whole."

    08:12: Cloudy and murky Sara Blizzard Weather Presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    A rather cloudy and murky day is forecast with widespread hill fog and outbreaks of rain. The rain will generally be fairly light and patchy and it will feel quite cold under the cloud.

    The maximum temperature will be 9C (48F). The forecast for the rest of the week is here.

    08:03: M42 traffic Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Drivers are warned there is slow traffic on the M42 northbound between J4, for the A34 for Shirley, and J5, for the A41 in Solihull, because of an earlier accident. All lanes have reopened but there are still delays.

    The latest information is available from BBC Travel.

    08:00: Good morning Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    I was pleased to see a bit of rain first thing - at least then I wasn't going to need the scraper for the windscreen again.

    I'm back in the BBC WM newsroom bringing you today's news, sport, travel and weather.

    Get in touch with us during the day about our updates over email, Twitter or Facebook.



  • photo of patient zero, two year-old Emile OuamounoPatient zero

    Tracking first Ebola victim and and how virus spread

  • A young Chinese girl looks at an image of BarbieBarbie's battle

    Can the doll make it in China at the second attempt?

  • Prosperi in the 1994 MdSLost in the desert

    How I drank urine and bat blood to survive in the Sahara

  • Afghan interpetersBlacklisted

    The Afghan interpreters left by the US to the mercy of the Taliban

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • UnderwaterHidden depths

    How do you explore the bottom of the ocean? BBC Future finds out


  • The challenge is to drop a bottle of water within 100 metres of this dummyClick Watch

    The race to get water – transported by drone – to a man stuck in remote Australia

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.