Trojan Horse report finds 'aggressive Islamist ethos' in schools

Five schools, including Park View Academy, were put in special measures by Ofsted last month

Related Stories

A leaked report into the so-called "Trojan Horse" plot has found evidence there was an agenda to introduce "an intolerant and aggressive Islamist ethos" into some Birmingham schools.

The report, revealed in The Guardian, was ordered by the government after claims some Muslim groups were trying to take control in some schools.

The Department for Education has said it will not comment on the leaks.

Birmingham council has released its own report, disagreeing with Mr Clarke.

Sir Albert Bore's response

Councillor Sir Albert Bore, Leader of Birmingham City Council

We must acknowledge today that Ian Kershaw's report shows we have serious governance issues in a small number of schools in east Birmingham because of serious malpractice by members of governing bodies. This has been compounded by the inability of head teachers and other governors to counter this behaviour and by the failure of the city council to intervene to instil proper governance.

The government's report was compiled by retired senior police officer Peter Clarke, the former head of the Met Police's counter-terrorism unit. It is due to be published next week.

It says he found evidence of "sustained and co-ordinated agenda to impose upon children in a number of Birmingham schools the segregationist attitudes and practices of a hardline and politicised strain of Sunni Islam".

He also found evidence of a "co-ordinated, deliberate and sustained action to introduce an intolerant and aggressive Islamist ethos into some schools in the city".

The agenda would have confined "schoolchildren within an intolerant, inward-looking monoculture that would severely inhibit their participation in the life of modern Britain," the leaked report says.

A spokesman for the DfE said: "The allegations made in relation to some schools in Birmingham are very serious and we are investigating all evidence put to us in conjunction with Ofsted and Birmingham City Council."

Russell Hobby, general secretary of the National Association of Head Teachers, said his union was disturbed by the Clarke review findings but not surprised.

They reflected concerns raised in May about improper governance and staffing and "a narrowing of entitlement for children", he said.

Trojan Horse letter The original "Trojan Horse" letter alleges the existence of a group of hardline Muslims claiming responsibility for a change in leadership at some schools

"We do not need an over-reaction. This is not a criticism of the Islamic faith, but of a narrow current within it," he said.

Birmingham's report, compiled by former head teacher Ian Kershaw, differed in its conclusions.

It said there was "no evidence of a conspiracy to promote an anti-British agenda, violent extremism or radicalisation in schools" in the east of the city.

Mr Kershaw did find "key individuals" promoting Islamic principles in schools and "noted a pattern of these individuals moving between schools".

He did not conclude whether the original "Trojan Horse" letter was a hoax, as has been claimed.

Start Quote

We do not need an over-reaction. This is not a criticism of the Islamic faith, but of a narrow current within it.”

End Quote Russell Hobby, General secretary of the National Association of Head Teachers

But he found evidence that the "five steps" outlined in the original letter as a means of destabilising school leadership were "present in a large number of the schools considered part of the investigation".

His report said evidence pointed to a group of "British male governors and teachers, predominantly of Pakistani heritage", which have formed in order to address perceived failings in some schools.

Mr Kershaw said the tactics employed by these groups were often "improper" and there was a "pattern" to their behaviour but it stopped short of a widespread plot.

'Slow to respond'

He said their motivation seemed to be an attempt to "raise standards" based on a "genuine and understandable desire...to improve education and opportunities for Muslim pupils.

"The evidence is not sufficient to lead me to construe the behaviour to be a co-ordinated plan to improperly influence the direction or management of schools serving students of predominantly Islamic faith or background," he said.

Mr Kershaw also says Birmingham City Council was "slow to respond" to allegations in the letter and accused education chiefs in the city of "poor oversight".

Peter Clarke Peter Clarke is a former deputy commissioner of the Met

He identifies a "culture within [the council] of not wanting to address difficult issues and problems with school governance" for risk of bringing accusations of racism or Islamophobia.

Speaking at a press conference earlier, Council leader Sir Albert Bore admitted the council failed to act for fear of being seen as racist or Islamophobic.

Last month, Ofsted and the Education Funding Agency published their reports and five schools were placed in special measures as a result.

The schools involved have always denied any wrongdoing.

On Tuesday, the board of trustees resigned at Park View Education Trust, which has been at the centre of claims, stating they had been the victims of a "co-ordinated and vicious" attack.

The trust has been the focus of allegations made in the anonymous Trojan Horse letter alleging the existence of a clique of hardline Muslims attempting to seize control of Birmingham schools. The origin of the letter and the intentions behind it have never been determined.

More on This Story

Related Stories

BBC Birmingham & Black Country

Weather

Birmingham

Min. Night 14 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    NHS strike called 16:00:

    NHS workers, including nurses and midwives, are to stage a new four-hour strike in England on 24 November as part of an ongoing pay dispute.

     
  2.  
    News on the hour 15:58: Chris Blakemore News editor, BBC WM

    The Queen's been in the West Midlands Today. She officially opened the new Jaguar Land Rover Engine plant on the I54 business park near Wolverhampton.

    In the news at 16:00 we'll hear from professor David Bailey, a car industry expert from Aston University Business School. Listen live.

     
  3.  
    Yardleys School to reopen 15:53:

    Yardleys School in Birmingham, closed since a fire at a nearby warehouse, will open again on 4 November, the governors and trustees say.

    The school, in Tyseley, shut through fears of asbestos contamination after the fire at a warehouse on 29 September.

    The council had said it was safe to open earlier but the head teacher wanted to wait for confirmation from experts.

     
  4.  
    Waste of money? 15:40: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    A Real Birmingham Family statue has really divided opinion on the BBC WM Facebook page. Some say it's a waste of money and some think it's great to see real people in art.

    Claire TheHelper Gunnell posts: Two sisters taking their children for a trip out (to the park or shopping) is only one aspect of family. Depicting a Birmingham Family - How so? I don't get it. It would make a nice picture in a frame though to show unity as they are all holding hands...

    Mac McCreery adds: I went and it was great.

     
  5.  
    Ebola themed party apology 15:30: Birmingham Mail

    Birmingham Broad Street's Bar Risa comes under fire for hosting Ebola themed party, the paper reports

     
  6.  
    Clark 'loves a challenge' 15:25: Dan Pallett Sports presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    Lee Clark is the new boss at Blackpool just 10 days after being sacked at Birmingham City.

    Boy that man likes a challenge

     
  7.  
    Who paid for the statue? 15:10: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    How has the Birmingham Family bronze statue been paid for?

    Birmingham Family statue in Centenary Square

    A spokeswoman at Ikon tells me says it's been funded through private donors, the Arts Council, the Library of Birmingham and Friends of Ikon group.

    Birmingham Library's contributed £50,000 and came from the library's Capital Funding Project, a library spokesperson said.

    I'm hoping to be given a full cost breakdown shortly.

     
  8.  
    Union blast pay offer 15:04: Birmingham Mail

    The full extent of the divide between factory workers and Tata-owned management is revealed in an internal Trade Union brief to around 18,000 JLR employees ahead of a potential ballot for industrial action

     
  9.  
    News on the hour 14:55:

    The top story in our 15:00 bulletin is:

    • A statue of a real Birmingham family has been unveiled in one of the city's main squares
     
  10.  
    Rogue traders in Sandwell 14:48: via Facebook

    Sandwell Trading Standards posts: Beware if you live in Cradley folks! We've had a report of rogue traders in the area. They claimed to be from a well known local company and gave out fake cards! They offered to cut down trees, charged £1200 cash, but left all that they'd cut down at the property and all over the road and pavement.

     
  11.  
    Where's the dad? 14:33:

    Speaking about the Real Birmingham Family statue unveiled at the Library of Birmingham earlier, Angela Passey and her husband Nigel said they were "shocked" by the absence of a dad.

    Nigel and Angela Passey

    She says: "To me, that doesn't portray a family as it should be. If that indicates a family today then it's sad."

    Nigel added: "It only shows one part of a family. "The man had to have been involved at one point."

     
  12.  
    'Not my children' 14:24:

    "I don't think of [babies conceived from my sperm] as my children as I think the parent is the person who brings them up," said Jimmy, a student from Coventry.

    Jimmy was speaking to BBC News reporter Clare Lissaman as she took a look at why Birmingham was chosen to host a national sperm bank.

     
  13.  
    Royal visit 14:10:

    The Queen was welcomed by staff at Jaguar Land Rover as she visits Wolverhampton.

    Queen welcomed to Wolverhampton
     
  14.  
    News at 2pm 13:59: Chris Blakemore News editor, BBC WM

    The headlines from BBC WM include:

    • The Queen opens the new Jaguar Land Rover Engine Plant on the I54 business park near Wolverhampton
    • The Home Office insists the government won't relax its drugs policies, after a report suggesting tough penalties don't cut levels of abuse
     
  15.  
    Love it or hate it? 13:55: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    We've been asking for your thoughts on the 'Real Birmingham Family' statue. Have your say on the BBC WM Facebook page.

    Christine Mason writes: I like it, much better than some of the abstract art, very real and down to earth

    Steve Wilcox posts:: No fathers in "real Birmingham families", then ??

     
  16.  
    In pictures: Queen's visit 13:44: Express and Star

    The newspaper take a look through some of the photos it captured during the Queen's visit today while in Wolverhampton.

     
  17.  
    Listen: 'Change perceptions' 13:34:

    "We want sperm donors to be proud".

    Laura Witjens, the Chief Executive of the National Gamete Donation Trust speaks to BBC Radio Four's Today programme.

    She says: "We're going to increase the recruitment activities in Birmingham, especially around ethnic minorities. We're trying to change the perception around sperm donation."

     
  18.  
    Family reunion 13:33: Dudley News

    A Pedmore woman, put into care as a child, has met her three sisters who she did not know existed until recently.

     
  19.  
    'Very talented' 13:21:

    Speaking about the "Real Birmingham Family" statue unveiled earlier lighting designer Kate Morley said she thought sculptor Gillian Wearing "very talented".

    "You can tell instantly the statue is based on the two sisters," she said.

    "It really does look like them."

     
  20.  
    Wolves v Birmingham 13:12: BBC Sport

    Wolves and Birmingham City meet on Saturday in the first of this season's big West Midlands derbies.

    If you can't be at the game or listen to BBC WM's full match commentary, you can still follow all the action wherever you are with our special live text commentary on the BBC Birmingham website.

    Read full coverage from 11:45 where we'll be bringing you all the action as it unfolds.

     
  21.  
    News on the hour 12:59: Chris Blakemore News editor, BBC WM

    From today, two Birmingham sisters and their children will be part of Birmingham's landscape.

    In the news on BBC WM at 13:00 we'll hear from Roma, one of the sisters, who says she's honoured to be cast in bronze.

     
  22.  
    BBC One at 13:30 12:50: Peter Plisner Business correspondent, BBC Midlands Today

    This is the Queen talking to staff at the Jaguar Land Rover Centre in Wolverhampton which she has officially opened.

    The Queen in Wolverhampton

    I'll have a full report on BBC Midlands Today at 13:30.

     
  23.  
    Weather snapshot 12:39:

    Rather cloudy and mild, with rain clearing to the north.

    Weather snapshot for 6pm

    For the latest forecast visit BBC Weather.

     
  24.  
    Statue reaction 12:28:

    Simona Marchetta, 34, from Italy said she thought the statue should have been made from a lighter-coloured material.

    "Birmingham is very colourful but this statue is just one colour - black."

    Artist Gillian Wearing with sisters Roma and Emma Jones

    Rebecca Sutton, 19, said she felt it was wrong to single out just one family.

    "Everyone says Birmingham is so multicultural but that doesn't really represent this," she said.

    "With a statue you should be able to look at it and know what it's about and I'm not sure what this is trying to say."

     
  25.  
    Hospital parking 12:07: Express and Star

    Seventy extra parking spaces are planned for Cannock Hospital in preparation for taking Wolverhampton patients, the paper reports.

     
  26.  
    Depicted in bronze 11:59:

    The Jones sisters, stand with artist Gillian Wearing who depicted 'A Real Birmingham Family' in bronze.

    A Real Birmingham Family unveiled
     
  27.  
    Aqua blue 11:53: Jonny Palmer BBC WM Sport

    It's my understanding that the Queen is already on the business park. She came in by train at Wolverhampton.

    She is dressed in a smart aqua blue dress.

     
  28.  
    Statue unveiled 11:49: Tom Richardson BBC News Online

    The statue has just been unveiled to gasps of approval and a round of applause.

    A Real Birmingham Family
     
  29.  
    Queen arrives in Wolverhampton 11:45: Chris Blakemore News editor, BBC WM

    BBC WM's Jonny Palmer is live at the i54 Business Park near Wolverhampton.

    Her Majesty the Queen has arrived by train and in the next hour she officially opens JLR's new £500m engine plant. It's taken four years to build and will create 1400 jobs.

    The Queen is being shown around various parts of the park and meeting some school children too.

     
  30.  
    'Inspirational' project 11:44: Tom Richardson BBC News Online

    The Jones sisters are standing next to the statue they inspired as Brian Gamble from the Library of Birmingham tells the gathered crowd the project has been "inspirational".

    The Jones sisters at the Library of Birmingham
     
  31.  
    'Crowds gathering' 11:40: Tom Richardson BBC News Online

    I'm here the Library of Birmingham for the unveiling of Gillian Wearing's statue. Crowds are gathering for the unveiling.

    Crowds gathering to see the statue
     
  32.  
    Morning meeting 11:32: Abigail Uden Producer, BBC Midlands Today

    Just had a meeting with the graphics team about tonight's programme. We're going to lead with the Queen's visit to the i54 site so we're looking to get a map to show everyone where it is and which three local authorities have been working together to help regenerate the area.

    Still on the list to do - find out some facts about strokes - ahead of our story about the specialist unit opening at Heartlands Hospital.

    And we'll be out gathering some material later about some political manoeuvring that's going on in Dudley. It'll all be clear by 18:30.

     
  33.  
    Blackpool sign Clark 11:25:

    Former Blues manager Lee Clark has signed a one-year deal with Blackpool.

    Clark, fired by Birmingham City on 20 October, has agreed a one-year rolling contract. Read more on BBC Sport.

     
  34.  
    Ready for the Queen 11:23: Jonny Palmer BBC WM

    I'm at Jaguar Land Rover for the arrival of the Queen. Camera crews and other media are busy getting ready for the official opening. I'm here reporting live for BBC WM.

    Jaguar Land Rover Centre near Wolverhampton
     
  35.  
    Family chosen from hundreds 11:20: Tom Richardson BBC News Online

    I'm heading to the Library of Birmingham to see the unveiling of a statue by Turner Prize winner Gillian Wearing.

    Roma and Emma Jones and their sons Kyan and Shaye

    The sculpture, called Birmingham Family, depicts sisters Roma and Emma Jones and their sons Kyan and Shaye.

    They were chosen from hundreds of hopefuls to serve as the inspiration for the bronze creation.

     
  36.  
    Statue ready to be unveiled 11:12: via Facebook

    Ikon Gallery posts: Not long now until we unveil Gillian Wearing's new sculpture for Birmingham - A Real Birmingham Family.

    Family of Birmingham statue ready to be unveiled

    What will it look like? We'll have a photo after it's unveiled on BBC Local Live after 11:30.

     
  37.  
    Citizen Khan returns 11:08:

    BBC Comedy tweets: Not long to go until your favourite community leader is back on @BBCOne - new #CitizenKhan starts Friday 20:30 http://bbc.in/ZZf6tx

     
  38.  
    News on the hour 10:58: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    Coming up in the news at 11:00 on BBC WM: A row has broken out at Birmingham City Council about the amount of cash that's been spent on trade union activity.

    The authority spent £1.2m last year - this is according to a freedom of information request.

     
  39.  
    Demand for sperm 10:50:

    The number of UK-based sperm donors has been increasing since 2004. However, demand has increased even faster.

    Newly registered sperm donors chart, 2005-2013

    Denmark and the United States have become major suppliers of sperm to British women.

    The Department of Health has given £77,000 to fund a national sperm bank which will be based at Birmingham Women's Hospital.

     
  40.  
    Volunteering 10:45: via Facebook

    Eastside Projects posts: Get down to Eastside Projects this evening 6.30-8pm to find out about volunteering here and at Grand Union!

     
  41.  
    What will it look like? 10:34: Satnam Rana Arts reporter, BBC Midlands Today

    I am off to meet the Jones family who are getting ready for the grand unveiling of themselves in Bronze!

    Turner Prize winning Gillian Wearing has sculpted a new piece of art work in conjunction with the Ikon gallery to depict 'The Real Birmingham Family'.

    What will it look like? Even I've not seen it yet but it will be unveiled at 11.30 outside the Library of Birmingham in Centenary Square.

     
  42.  
    Why a sperm bank in Brum? 10:27:

    The National Sperm Bank opens in Birmingham today.

    Woman and child

    BBC News reporter Clare Lissaman took a look as to why the city was chosen to host the centre and what its founders hope to achieve.

     
  43.  
    National sperm bank opens 10:11: James Gallagher Health editor, BBC News website

    A UK national sperm bank - charged with reversing a growing shortage of donor sperm - has started work in Birmingham.

    Computer image of a sperm approaching an egg

    Fertility clinics have become increasingly dependent on imported sperm giving rise to the so-called "Viking babies" phenomenon.

    Meanwhile, data from the fertility regulator shows a 10th of IVF cycles are dependent on donated sperm or eggs.

    And a third of procedures using donated material were for same-sex couples or single women.

     
  44.  
    News on the hour 09:57: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    The world's first independent National Sperm Bank opens at Birmingham Women's Hospital later today.

    In the news at 10:00 we'll hear from the chief executive of the National Gamete Donation Trust. Listen live.

     
  45.  
    'Face of Birmingham' statue 09:52: Satnam Rana Arts reporter, BBC Midlands Today

    A life-sized statue of two Birmingham sisters and their children, will be unveiled today outside the Library in Centenary Square.

    • The Jones family

    Roma and Emma Jones are mixed race, single mothers and were chosen to represent a "real Birmingham family" by Turner prize winning artist Gillian Wearing who's cast them in bronze.

     
  46.  
    'Job security' 09:45: Michelle Dawes Journalist, BBC WM

    This £500m JLR Engine Manufacturing Centre near Wolverhampton will be officially opened by the Queen later.

    Workers from JLR centre in Wolverhampton ahead of the Queen's arrival

    I've been speaking to workers ahead of her arrival - one worker told me: "One of the reason I joined was because of the job security. The brand, the product - it has a solid foundation and we're all very proud of it."

    When asked if he was looking forward to seeing the Queen he added: "It doesn't get much bigger than this. We've all got big smiles on our faces and looking forward to it."

     
  47.  
    Uk national sperm bank opens 09:32:

    The world's first independent National Sperm Bank opens at Birmingham Women's Hospital later today.

    Birmingham National Sperm Bank

    It is hoped the new centre will help meet a national shortfall in donations.

    The centre will be paying £35 for each sperm donation.

     
  48.  
    Preparations for the Queen 09:19: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    You know something important is happening when BBC WM reporter Jonny Palmer is in a suit.

    Jonny Palmer, BBC WM reporter

    He's reporting live from Jaguar Land Rover later, as the Queen visits Wolverhampton to officially open a "state-of-the-art Engine Manufacturing Centre".

    Today's opening marks the culmination of four years work. Hear more on BBC WM throughout the day.

     
  49.  
    M6 delays 09:09:

    Delays and queuing traffic on the M6 northbound between J3, A444 (Nuneaton) and J3a M6 Toll, because of an accident involving two lorries and a van earlier on.

    All lanes have been re-opened but travel time is around 45 minutes, reports BBC Travel.

     
  50.  
    News on the hour 08:59: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    As preparations are made ahead of the Queen's arrival later we hear from Craig Osmond, the production team manager at Jaguar Land Rover.

    Hear more on this story in the news on BBC WM at 09:00.

     
  51.  
    Top headlines
     
  52.  
    'Vast majority' of local jobs 08:56:

    Wolverhampton City Council tweets: JLR executive director says new plant creating 1,400 jobs - "vast majority" from Wolverhampton area.

     
  53.  
    Watch: Poppies nearly complete 08:42:

    The final pieces of one of the world's most striking commemorative displays are being put into place in London.

    One of the poppies

    More than 800,000 ceramic poppies are being arranged around the Tower of London. Each poppy commemorates the life of a fallen British or Colonial soldier and the final one will be planted on Armistice Day next month.

    BBC Midlands Today's Liz Copper joined families from the Midlands paying their tributes to those who lost their lives in World War One.

     
  54.  
    Man charged after crash death 08:32:

    A man is charged with causing a man's death and with seriously injuring the man's grandson in a collision in Shirley.

    Emergency services were called to Bills Lane at the junction with Langcomb Road in Shirley

    Kirpal Sokhi, 19, from Hall Green is accused of causing the death of 59-year-old Stephen Beckett by dangerous driving on 17 August.

     
  55.  
    Queen to open JLR centre 08:20:

    Jaguar Land Rover's new Engine Manufacturing Centre near Wolverhampton will be officially opened by The Queen later.

    Jaguar Land Rover plant and a picture of the Queen

    It's cost £500m, will create 1,400 new jobs and is based at the i54 business park.

     
  56.  
    Patchy rain 08:13:

    A dull start with some mist and fog patches and outbreaks of patchy rain.

    The rain will clear although there'll still be one or two showers this afternoon. However, there'll also be some breaks in the cloud allowing for brighter spells.

    It'll feel milder than yesterday with highs of 17C (63F).

     
  57.  
    Good morning 08:00: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    I'll be bringing you the very latest news, sport, travel and weather updates for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    If you'd like to comment on any of the updates we're featuring today, please email or tweet @BBCWM.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • EarthWater world

    Are ‘oceans’ hiding inside Earth? BBC Future investigates

Programmes

  • Francis Rossi, co-founder of band Status QuoHARDtalk Watch

    Status Quo's Francis Rossi explains how alcohol led him to take cocaine

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.