Derby fire deaths: Three guilty of Philpott children's deaths

Mick and Mairead Philpott, Paul Mosley Mick and Mairead Philpott, and Paul Mosley, will be sentenced on Wednesday

The parents who started a blaze which killed six children as they slept have been convicted of their manslaughter.

Mick and Mairead Philpott, and friend Paul Mosley, were found guilty of starting the fire in Derby to frame a former mistress in a custody battle.

The jury at Nottingham Crown Court returned unanimous decisions on Mosley and Mick Philpott while Mairead Philpott was convicted by a majority.

A senior police officer said it was the most tragic case he had worked on.

Five of the Philpott's children died in their home in Victory Road and the sixth, from a previous relationship, died in hospital.

'Violent and controlling'


TV dramatisations of a courtroom are often wide of the mark. Criminal trials are usually more forensic style analysis than gladiatorial battle.

But there were moments of pure theatre during the six week Derby house fire trial. Invariably they involved the main prosecutor, Richard Latham QC.

Often found at the Old Bailey, he was brought in by the Crown Prosecution Service before the Philpotts had even been charged with killing their children.

His past cases include the successful prosecution of the notorious Soham murderer Ian Huntley. His exchanges during cross-examination of Mick Philpott will live long in the memory.

"You were in this together weren't you," he said. Philpott tearfully replied he wasn't: "I swear on my children's resting place." Mr Latham's response: "Don't descend to that. Don't demean yourself."

Derbyshire Assistant Chief Constable Steve Cotterill said: "There are six little kids there that have not got the chance to grow up.

"Personally I have found it very upsetting. I have become extremely angry at the needless loss of life."

Five of the children died on the morning of the fire in Victory Road, and the sixth died three days later.

Jade Philpott, 10, John, nine, Jack, eight, Jesse, six, and Jayden, five, died on the morning of the fire on 11 May 2012.

Mrs Philpott's son from a previous relationship, 13-year-old Duwayne, died later in hospital.

Jurors heard that Philpott had been violent and controlling towards his former live-in mistress, Lisa Willis.

When she left, taking her children, he became "obsessed with getting Lisa and the kids back".

He started the fire in a bid to frame her for the crime and win custody of the children - and perhaps obtain a bigger house - the prosecution argued.

Prosecutor Richard Latham QC said the plan had "gone completely wrong" within two minutes because the fire was far bigger than the defendants expected.

The court heard the trio planned to get all six children into one bedroom at the back of the house where they could be rescued through a window using a pre-placed ladder.

Jurors were told that Philpott was to "act the hero and victim", rescuing the youngsters and framing Ms Willis in the process.

But they were not told that he had a violent past - he was jailed in 1978 for attempting to murder a 17-year-old ex-girlfriend.

Secret recordings of the Philpotts were made by police

He stabbed her 13 times as she lay sleeping after she ended their relationship, and also attacked her mother when she intervened.

The three defendants were found guilty after less than eight hours of deliberation.

The judge, Mrs Justice Thirlwall, said the defendants would be sentenced on Wednesday.

As the court heard the guilty verdicts, Mairead Philpott looked down at the floor and appeared upset while holding a tissue in her hands.

Before leaving the dock, Mick Philpott was heard to say: "It's not over yet."

'Six angels'

In a statement read outside the court, Mick Philpott's sister Dawn Bestwick said: "Our presence in court was to find out the truth and following today's verdict we believe justice has been done.

"This past year has been a very difficult time for our family as we have had to come to terms with what Mick and Mairead and Paul Mosley have done. We can now move on and our six angels can rest in peace."

A statement read on behalf of the Duffy family, the family of Mairead Philpott, said: "Duwayne, Jade, John, Jack, Jesse and Jayden were taken away in the cruellest way imaginable by the very people that were supposed to love and protect them.

"We, Mairead's family, cannot describe the pain we feel. Today justice has been done and we are happy with the verdict."

Samantha Shallow, of the Crown Prosecution Service, said it had been a "challenging and harrowing case to prosecute".

A serious case review is being carried out by the Derby Safeguarding Children Board into the deaths but there have been no urgent recommendations to emerge so far from the process.

The children were not subject to child protection plans or legal orders. The review is not due to be completed before the summer.

When asked if the tragedy could have been foreseen, ACC Cotterill said: "My answer is a very emphatic no. What we are dealing with is the unpredictability of Mick Philpott."

Detective Constable Maria Neads read a statement on behalf of the families

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Derby



Min. Night 1 °C

BBC Local Live

    18:00: Good evening

    BBC Local Live will be back from 08:00 on Friday with the latest news, sport, travel and weather for Derbyshire.

    17:52: Cold night ahead Sara Blizzard Weather Presenter, BBC East Midlands Today

    Dry overnight with clear spells, leading to a frost and some icy stretches by Friday morning.

    Sara Blizzard

    Turning colder overnight with a low of 1 Deg C (34 F).

    17:44: Coming up on East Midlands Today Simon Hare Reporter, BBC East Midlands Today

    I've been speaking to shocked dog owners on this Stanley Common street where poisoned dog chews were found.

    Glendon Strret in Derbyshire

    You can see my report on BBC East Midlands Today on BBC One at 18:30

    17:33: Museum tour via Facebook

    Erewash Borough Council posts: Four new history exhibitions have opened in community venues in the borough as part of Erewash Museum's popular Local Heritage, Local Lives programme.

    The new exhibitions focus on Ancient Ancestors, Long Eaton during World War One, Sport at Stanton and Lace Connections Read more online.

    17:21: Inside the Commons Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Did you see the BBC Two series Inside the Commons?

    Labour MP for Bolsover Dennis Skinner

    This week was the final part of the series. It was fascinating viewing taking a look behind the scenes of what MPs get up to and some of the traditions which still go on.

    One of the MPs who features includes the Labour MP for Bolsover Dennis Skinner, who's well known for heckling during the State Opening of Parliament.

    17:10: Street patrols

    Street patrols have been stepped up in Stanley Common after dog chews laced with rat poison were discovered in the Glendon Street area (pictured).

    Glendon Street, Stanley Common

    Councillor Barbara Harrison from Erewash Borough Council says: "This is a very serious and very worrying incident and we are grateful to the member of public for taking immediate action so that we could remove the baits before any dog was affected."

    Anyone with information is asked to contact the council by email.

    17:00: News on the hour Wesley Mallin Newsreader, BBC Derby

    Derby's new Arena will open on the 20th of March. The city council made the announcement today. Hear more in the news at 17:00.

    16:40: Duos return key Ed Dawes BBC Radio Derby

    Head Coach Steve McClaren says the availability of Chris Martin and Johnny Russell (pictured L-R) for this weekend's trip to Fulham could be key.

    Derby's Chris Martin and Johnny Russell

    The Rams are in the middle of six games in 19 days.

    16:25: Feedback

    BBC Local Live brings news, sport, travel and weather together in one place. What do you think of it?

    16:15: Arena to open in March Chris Doidge BBC Radio Derby political reporter

    I'm told Derby Arena will open on 20 March. More than three months behind the original date set in December 2014.

    Derby Arena from outside

    Take a look inside the arena on BBC News.

    15:57: News on the hour Wesley Mallin Newsreader, BBC Derby

    Derby's new Arena will open on 20 March. The multi-use velodrome was due to be ready back in December but was delayed.

    For more on this story and others join us from 16:00.

    15:54: McClaren interview

    Derby County tweets: PRE-MATCH: Steve McClaren speaks to @Ed_DawesBeeb to conclude today's press meeting at the Training Centre

    Steve McClaren speaks to Ed Dawes

    Hear the interview in full on Friday from 18:00 on BBC Radio Derby.

    15:31: Chesterfield man stabbed cat nine times in drunken frenzy Ilkeston Advertiser

    A blood-spattered drunk who stabbed his mother's cat nine times during a vicious attack in her kitchen has been banned from keeping animals.

    Chesterfield magistrates' court heard this month how Damon Kruger, 43, of Gladstone Road, Chesterfield, had been carving chicken but as his mother's cat Toby tried to get at the meat he lashed out with a five-inch knife in a drunken frenzy.

    15:17: Learning in a safe place for disabled

    More Safe Places for people with disabilities to learn is being launched by the police and crime commissioner in Derbyshire.

    You can read more about the scheme on the Derbyshire County Council website.

    15:00: News on the hour Wesley Mallin Newsreader, BBC Derby

    Coming up in the news bulletin at 15:00: BBC Radio Derby's sent a fruit basket to thank Nottingham Forest Manager Dougie Freedman.

    Fruit basket

    In the bulletin we'll hear from the greengrocer who tried to deliver it.

    14:40: Bus hits 'elderly man'

    An elderly man has died after being hit by a bus in Chesterfield yesterday.

    Derbyshire Police says it's launched an investigation after a National Express single decker coach pulled out of the Chesterfield Coach Station onto Beetwell Street and hit the man as he crossed the road.

    14:31: School scoops award Ashbourne News Telegraph

    Queen Elizabeth's Grammar School has become one of 27 schools and charities in the country to receive a £15,000 government award for the way it encourages "grit and resilience" in its pupils.

    14:12: Food basket for Forest Sally Pepper Presenter, BBC Radio Derby

    BBC Radio Derby's sent a food basket to thank Nottingham Forest Manager Dougie Freedman.

    Nottingham Forest and Derby County players

    The Reds, traditionally the Rams rivals did their bit to aid Derby County's automatic promotion push last night beating Bournemouth 2-1 at the City Ground.

    The result means Cherries remain fourth in the table six points behind Derby who are top and five points clear of Ipswich in third.

    13:58: News on the hour Wesley Mallin Newsreader, BBC Derby

    Coming up in the news at 14:00 on BBC Radio Derby: Dog walkers in Erewash are being warned to be on the look-out for poisoned chews which have been left in in the street in Stanley Common.

    13:45: Food Stars

    A Derbyshire firms is among 50 of the country's most promising food and drink entrepreneurs being recognised by the government as Food Stars, for their contribution to the UK's growing economy.

    Pudding on a plate

    Allan Hibbert owns Buxton Pudding Company says they started the company two years ago and now sell products across the country using their 100-year-old recipe.

    The government initiative is part of a drive to "inspire entrepreneurial activity across the UK".

    13:31: Council tax in Erewash likely to be frozen Ilkeston Advertiser

    Erewash Borough Council looks set to freeze its share of council tax for the sixth year running.

    Councillors at today's council executive are expected to agree that they will recommend the borough council's share of the tax should remain at the current level.

    13:15: BBC One from 13:30 Angelina Socci BBC East Midlands Today

    Coming up on BBC One this lunch time: We'll have more on dog owners being warned to be vigilant after dog chews deliberately baited with rat poison in Derbyshire.

    Plus the latest forecast with Sara Blizzard. Join us for the latest this lunch time on BBC One from 13:30.

    12:58: News on the hour Wesley Mallin Newsreader, BBC Derby

    In the news at 13:00

    Derbyshire Police is cutting down the size of it's dog unit with nearly a third of the handlers set to lose their jobs in the next couple of years.

    12:41: Buxton Folk in May Andy Potter Presenter, BBC Radio Derby

    Buxton Opera House is hosting its first ever month of folk music in the town in May.

    Buxton Opera House

    It will feature some of the best artists from across the country as well as musicians from the High Peak.

    I'll be speaking to some of the people involved on BBC Radio Derby after 13:00.

    12:28: Weather snapshot Sara Blizzard Weather Presenter, BBC East Midlands Today

    It will gradually get colder throughout the day because of a cold front which is coming in (pictured).

    Sara Blizzard

    The rain will clear throughout the afternoon.

    For the latest forecast follow @BBCWeather on Twitter. You can also watch today's forecast on Facebook.

    12:14: Dog chews tied to rat poison Dave Wade BBC Local Live

    More on BBC News about the "deadly sandwiches" made of dog chews wrapped around rat poison have been found in Derbyshire.

    The council says it's a "very serious and worrying incident". No dogs were harmed and Derbyshire Police has been informed, it says.

    11:57: News on the hour BBC Radio Derby

    Coming up in the news at 12:00: A Derbyshire firm's among 50 of the country's most promising food and drink entrepreneurs being recognised by the government as Food Stars, for their contribution to the UK's economy.

    11:42: Joseph Wright paintings via Facebook

    Visit Derby posts: Did you know you'll find the largest collection of Joseph Wright paintings on the globe at Derby Museums?; ‪#‎DerbyUK‬ ‪#‎art‬

    11:25: Have your say Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    11:13: Rat poison warning

    Dog walkers in a village near Ilkeston are being warned to vigilant after dog chews were found laced with rat poison.

    Dog chews laced with rat poison

    Erewash Borough Council's says dog chews were found with rat poison inserted inbetween and sealed by elastic bands.

    A spokeswoman says one was placed on the pavement and a second in a nearby passageway in Stanley Common.

    10:57: News on the hour Kelly Smith Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    In the news at 11:00 on BBC Radio Derby we'll have more on Derbyshire Police following the announcement that the force is going to cut jobs within its dog unit.

    10:42: Staff at Burton's Queens' Hospital still face high levels of abuse Burton Mail

    Staff working at Burton's Queen's Hospital and East Staffordshire Borough Council still face high levels of assaults and verbal abuse while at work, new figures have revealed.

    Staff at the Belvedere Road hospital site reported 53 incidences of physical abuse and 35 cases of verbal abuse last year.

    On eight occasions, council employees at East Staffordshire Borough Council faced verbal abuse.

    10:27: Bounce back from defeat Ed Dawes BBC Radio Derby

    Burton Albion manager Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink believes his team can bounce back and learn from Tuesday's 1-0 defeat at Accrington.

    Burton Albion manager Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink

    The Brewers unbeaten 13 game run came to an end, but they still top the table with the gap to 4th place nine points.

    Hasselbaink says they have to work on being hesitant in the danger area.

    10:13: Burton mural could be saved Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    A decision to remove a mural in Burton celebrating the town's history is being reconsidered after complaints by local resident.

    The images capture brewers at work with tools on Union Street.

    Burton mural

    Valerie Burton from Burton's Civic Society says the 1980s mural would be greatly missed by people.

    A spokesman for Magnet which owns the building says: "In light of recent public concern we intend to take a short period of time to consider our position on this matter, to explore ways that we can collaboratively celebrate the area's rich heritage."

    09:57: News on the hour BBC Radio Derby

    In the news at 10:00 on BBC Radio Derby we'll have more on this story about Derbyshire Police.

    A sergeant of the dog section hopes to provide a similar service despite the news that nearly a third of the handlers will be losing their job in the next couple of years.

    09:42: Planning refused for more wind turbines Kelly Smith Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    Derbyshire Dales councillors have refused permission for a wind turbine development near Carsington Water.

    The proposed Griffe Grange Wind Farm would have added five more to the seven already in or approved for the area.

    Andy Tickle of the friends of the Peak District, which opposed the proposal, says it's unlikely to be the end of the matter.

    09:25: Man dies after hit by car Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    A 43-year-old man's died after he was hit by a car in Derby city centre.

    Police say they were called to the incident on Burton Road at about 21:45 on Tuesday.

    Anyone who witnessed the incident near Charnwood Medical Centre involving a silver Vauxhall Astra is asked to call the police on 101.

    09:14: Accident closes road

    Godfrey Drive in Kirk Hallam is closed in both directions near the Oliver Road Junction due to an accident. Diversions are in operations.

    BBC Travel map

    Read about the latest delays on BBC Travel.

    08:58: News on the hour Kelly Smith Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    Our top story in the news at 09:00 on BBC Radio Derby: Derbyshire Police is cutting down the size of its dog unit.

    Shortly we'll hear from Simon Bulmer is the Sergeant overseeing the dog section.

    08:41: Five point lead Ed Dawes BBC Radio Derby Sport

    Nottingham Forest's 2-1 win over Bournemouth has secured Derby County's five point lead over the Championship play off places.

    Sky Bet Championship Table

    The Rams are top - two points ahead of Middlesbrough in 2nd with Ipswich in third.

    The chasing pack have all played 33 matches with Derby's goal difference the best in the table. See the Sky Bet Championship Table on BBC Sport.

    08:30: Strike ends Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    Firefighters have returned to work this morning following a 24-hour walkout yesterday in a dispute over pensions.

    The Fire Brigades Union says firefighters have been on strike more than 50 times since September 2013. The last strike action was in December.

    Read more about yesterday's industrial action and rally held in London on BBC News.

    08:20: Colin Bloomfield appeal latest Derby Telegraph

    posts on Facebook: The Colin Bloomfield Melanoma Appeal has raised an incredible £9,400 so far in support of BBC Radio Derby presenter's campaign. This is where it has come from:

    Colin Blomfield appeal

    You can read more about the appeal on BBC News.

    08:04: Today's forecast

    After a cloudy and mild morning with outbreaks of rain, it will become drier with sunny spells by early afternoon.

    Sara Blizzard

    Winds will gradually ease into the evening with a high of 7C (45F)

    08:00: Good morning Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    Rather wet and grey in Derby city centre this morning.

    I'm in the BBC Derby newsroom bringing you the very latest news, sport, travel and weather for Derbyshire today. Email or tweet us your stories and pictures @bbcderby.



Elsewhere on the BBC

  • BooksNew novels

    BBC Culture takes a look at ten new books to read in March


  • TomatoesClick Watch

    The smart garden that fits inside your house and provides fresh healthy food

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.